Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still be upset my dad smacked me as a child

238 replies

WonderingSally · 14/04/2022 21:42

I've always wondered how normal my childhood was. I was born in 1988, and can remember often being smacked as a child. Thinking about it I was a good kid, I got straight As, never got in trouble, head girl at school etc. But probably at least every 2/3 weeks I ended up with a smack for often stupid reasons - I don't remember most, but one that sticks out was drying my hair for too long, that kind of level of naughtiness. Always for things I'd done wrong around the house.

AIBU to think this wasn't normal even in the 90s? Or did smacking just happen in those days? I've always wondered what happened in other households but too scared to ask incase I find out my dad is definitely a dick

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 15/04/2022 19:41

"My parents hit me when they were stressed, my dad banged our heads together, but we are a great family with so much love and respect!"

What family is this, the Corleones? Jesus wept. And to think I'm getting mawkish rebukes about blame, regrets and how I shouldn't be judgemental because I think parents who expect a child to handle being hit can damn well handle hearing that they fucked up.

dumdumduuuummmmm · 15/04/2022 17:32

@lovelymama

I’m older than you, I was born in 1980. I have a very close, loving family and had a great childhood but we were smacked. Not for random things, which sound very petty in your case. We were very poor, mum and dad must have been so stressed about money as I am 1 of 4 children. I think when they were stressed was when we got a smack. I remember my dad getting mine and my sister’s heads and banging them together. That bloody hurt!

Our relationship with our parents has always been strong and I adore my parents as we have such respect for each other. In your case, is there a strong upside to your dad? Do you only have those bad memories or are there lots of amazing things that you remember too?

I can't believe what I'm reading. You were hit when your parents were feeling stressed. You were their emotional punch bag. Please stop telling yourself and the world that it was your fault. You are actually admitting that the snacking happened when they were feeling stressed. They released their stress onto you
dumdumduuuummmmm · 15/04/2022 17:30

@typingcake

I was born in 1980 and I was smacked as a child through to my teen years. Stuff like slapped on the legs, smacked hard in succession on my backside, once dad was drunk and I did something to annoy him and he slapped me hard on the face and another time my mum dragged me outside by my hair. We were not regularly abused just when we had done something bad, mostly fighting with each other. One thing tho - Dad never hit me or my sisters any other time and he never hit mum. Bit my god they threw stuff and screamed at each other.
Honey you were abused. Your father hit you when he was drunk. Please stop trying to make this seem ok and your fault.
Organictangerine · 15/04/2022 17:27

@crispsarny

YABU 36% ffs
I don’t think it’s ‘YABU because smacking is fine and good parenting’

It’s more ‘YABU to be specifically upset about something which, at the time it happened in, was sadly a very routine part of parenting and you weren’t maliciously singled out’

crispsarny · 15/04/2022 17:22

YABU 36% ffs

crispsarny · 15/04/2022 17:21

@SpiderVersed

I think dwelling on it many years later isn’t particularly healthy.

I was occasionally smacked, my brother far more often. Have never done it myself and my anecdata is that my brother and I fought physically all the time and my children never fought physically.

It’s not a case of dwelling on it, abuse can cause lasting damage, it fundamentally alters a childs brain development. For me It can feel like I never left the childhood home, still trapped with my abusers. I am doing intensive work to undone the fucked up damage & trauma that my shit bag family meted out to me. So much fucking ignorance in this thread.
MeridasMum · 15/04/2022 16:15

70s baby here.

I was smacked regularly by both parents, F did it more that M, however my mother now denies it. Her story is: she smacked me once in my life and felt so bad about doing it, she couldn't ever forgive herself.
She rewrites history a lot.

She also used to grab me by the hair and PULL so hard when I was a young adult still living at home. She only stopped when I started doing it back to her.

When I was 19, I went on holiday with my boyfriend (now husband) and my father didn't like it so he smacked me repeated on the bare bottom. I was scared and humiliated.
I have NEVER been able to get over that.

My eldest DD is 25 and I am incredibly ashamed to say I smacked her as a young child. It was all I knew how to do. It's another thing I have difficulty coming to terms with. I have apologised and asked her forgiveness which she gave but I hate myself for it.

AngieBolen · 15/04/2022 16:14

In 2001 i took my DS to the GP because of his behaviour. The GP asked if I'd tried smacking him, and was a bit eye rolly when I said no, and that I didn't want to. Both my DM and FiL advised DS needed a good hard smack. Obviously they were wrong, but no so long ago smacking was very normal. I don't think it was about physically hurting the child, more about asserting some sort of dominance.

crackingreward · 15/04/2022 16:02

But there are so many posts on here from mum's tearing their hair out because they are at their wits end with their kids behavior. I was smacked as a kid and I grew up into a happy, balanced adult

Those children whose mums are tearing their hair out will probably also grow into happy, balanced adults.

RoseGoldEagle · 15/04/2022 15:50

Born in early 80s, only remember being smacked once. Just on the hand, I was probably 6 or 7, I think I’d thrown something across the room in a rage. I can still so clearly remember the shock of it and how upset I was. I think my Mum would probably have been horrified she’d done it, as it wasn’t the norm, but I don’t remember that. I just remember that feeling so well, and there’s no way I’d ever smack one of mine.

Goldbar · 15/04/2022 15:46

@Anythingbutsnow

..... But there are so many posts on here from mum's tearing their hair out because they are at their wits end with their kids behavior. I was smacked as a kid and I grew up into a happy, balanced adult. To me, it seemed like a quick, efficient method to teach right from wrong. I don't smack my kids now as I'm aware it's not acceptable, but my god the long drawn out process of naughty steps, no screen time etc etc do my head in!
But hitting is wrong. One of the first lessons we teach our children, right from when they are little babies just toddling about in baby group, is that being violent towards others is wrong. It's the one 'offence' that had my DC removed from any group for a few minutes for the first time, and then if it happened again, we'd leave. And that was from when they were just 15/16 months.

How is it acceptable for an adult to hit, then, and not a child? For most parents, hitting and other violence is the worst thing their children could do... they might tolerate a bit of boisterousness or not listening, or messing around at table, but I don't know any parents who will condone their children hitting others and not intervene.

C152 · 15/04/2022 15:32

I think smacking was seen as a normal way of reprimanding a child - it didn't have to be for anything particularly 'bad'.

Chanandlerbong1 · 15/04/2022 15:23

Born in late 80s. I can only remember once getting a smacked bottom. Probably for something silly like stealing sweets.
I was never smacked again after this - perhaps my dad felt guilty about it.
My dad was regularly physically abused by his own father and at school by teachers. I guess that one time he smacked me he felt intense guilt and decided he would never do it again.
After that I can only remember being shouted at for being naughty.

Rosegardenpinks · 15/04/2022 15:08

I can't get my head around it being seen as acceptable years ago. I don't understand how a parent ever felt ok about physically hurting a child they love and who is dependent on them. I also find it a bit jarring to hear adults who would never dream of hitting their own child say my parents did xyz and we have a great relationship. I realise trying to understand others relationships is very difficult but that feels odd to me.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 15/04/2022 15:02

I was born in late 80s and experienced smacking throughout my childhood. Usually I was put over my Dad’s knee with pants pulled down and spanked on the bottom with a hand but sometimes with a stick my Dad kept for the purpose. I would also sometimes be hit with household objects like a chopping board, spoon etc over the head or on the back of the legs by both parents. I don’t remember how frequent it was but it was a common reaction to doing anything ‘naughty’ which could include accidents like spilling a drink or things like putting elbows on the table during dinner. I do still feel upset about it now as I don’t feel like this was normal in the 90s and most of my friends weren’t punished in this way.

Ivyonafence · 15/04/2022 15:02

@zingally that's so sad, I'm really sorry Thanks

MotherOfChaos28 · 15/04/2022 14:57

DH born the same year as you and I was the year after. Both of us were smacked. I couldn’t imagine ever raising a hand to my kids and our parents have never smacked their grandchildren. I’m so pleased we’re moving past this as a form of discipline because I think it’s barbaric.

ChristmasFluff · 15/04/2022 14:52

There's something wrong with anyone who thinks it's ok to hit someone smaller than them, who they have power over - and who they say they love.

Whether it was 'normal' for the time or not is irrelevant on a personal level

Thank fuck we are evolving away from being the type of society that thinks hitting kids is ok.

Llamasally · 15/04/2022 14:52

I don’t know what it says about smacking but probably more memorable is DF calling me a stupid bitch, really aggressively, virtually spat it at me, when I was about 8.

Llamasally · 15/04/2022 14:47

80s child and was smacked a lot, by my mum, who had a short temper. Red handprints across the backs of my legs often. It wasn’t so much the smacking that I think was most damaging though, I think it was the total inconsistency of what it was for. Sometimes basically over nothing. I think she did it to relieve her own frustrations mostly, so I had no clear boundaries or knowing where I stood, I lost respect completely and was a nightmare teenager.

My DH who is the same age was never smacked and had a huge respect for his parents.

zingally · 15/04/2022 14:47

Just wanted to add, that 99.9% of the time, he was a loving, fun, silly dad. But he had a side, for sure.

maddy68 · 15/04/2022 14:46

I was also smacked. I think it was the done thing then. I have to say to say I probably needed it and no I don't have any long term psychological issues from it. It was just standard parenting then

zingally · 15/04/2022 14:44

I was born in 84 and was smacked maybe every 2 to 3 months? My mum was the "smack once and done" sort, but my dad would really go for it. It would be multiple hard smacks on the bum, with his hand, or mums slipper. Really painful, and I've never forgotten, or I'd say, completely forgiven. I know my older sister got the belt at least twice, but I never did. But I also know it irreparably damaged her relationship with him. She never forgave him.

Once, when I was in my mid-20s, dad threatened to slap me over something, can't even remember what, but I said something like, "If you even try that, I will walk out of here, and I swear to god, you'll never see me again." It completely took the wind out of his sails, and I think that's the first time he saw me as a full adult.

Years later I discovered he's suffered physical and sexual abuse at his private boys school as a young teen, and growing up he'd been starved of a lot of positive attention. The parenting he got was benign neglect at best. Clothed, fed and watered, but that's about it. Knowing all this went a long way to explaining some of his behaviours towards my sister and I as children.

SpiderVersed · 15/04/2022 14:43

I think dwelling on it many years later isn’t particularly healthy.

I was occasionally smacked, my brother far more often. Have never done it myself and my anecdata is that my brother and I fought physically all the time and my children never fought physically.

Mangogogogo · 15/04/2022 14:40

I’m not a smacker but I remember running away from my dad laughing my head off when he was trying to smack me, maybe 4or 5 times in my childhood and he never caught me!

I don’t smack my children ever but I appreciate I’m quite lax with my kids compared to others. The concerns I have is that smacking is replaced with verbal abuse. A smack is shit, don’t get me wrong but the anger that could have been a tap is more often than not now replaced with some kind of vile put down or disgusting abusive words. I see this in my job and I do wonder what’s best? (Obviously parents controlling themselves is best but that ain’t gunna happen overall is it?)