Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family ask what size for the kids then ignore it everytime grrrr

62 replies

notsureaboutTAAT · 14/04/2022 15:09

Then seem to get annoyed when said item is unworn or I get children to try it on and it doesn't fit. My children are giants. The toddler is chunky too, the older one has slimmed out as he's grown. Why ask me what size and then ignore me ? This is various different family members from both sides. I am happy for people to buy clothes for the DC not fussy on styles.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
liveforsummer · 15/04/2022 12:37

My ex does this. When dc were smaller they were both pretty small for their age yet he'd but the correct age so it was drowning them/falling down/looked awful and scruffy. About a year ago they both stretched massively - dd12 is now 5'4'' and now they (his partner does most of the buying) only then decided to start buying smaller. Bought dd a 9-10 outfit the other week. She's now wearing small adult clothes. Bizarre!

ColdHappyBap · 15/04/2022 11:46

It’s taken a while but we’ve finally got family to stop trying to buy clothes, unless I have specifically selected them. Eldest is tall (not overweight, no vanity sizing, just tall) so always needed at least one year above her age, if not two. Both kids are autistic and have massive sensory issues around clothes. Family would buy things and I would just know they’d never get worn even if they did fit. I end up returning half of what I buy because it turns out there’s a seam that feels weird.

It was hard for the grandmothers on both sides as they both love clothes, one is very stylish and one just likes cute slogans and stuff. But they got there. I would find it so annoying if they’d just ignored us like some families here have.

minniep · 15/04/2022 11:31

We have this but we always get stuff that's too big as mine are all small for their age. Then it's either forgotten about as it's stashed away or only fits when it's the wrong season or has a character on it that the child no longer likes

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 15/04/2022 11:24

Just say "dont buy them clothes, they are very fussy" Job done.

CruCru · 15/04/2022 11:19

Are they doing it to make a point? I often see people on MN saying that children’s clothes now have vanity sizing and how many aged 7 (say) children wearing age 7 clothes are overweight. I mean, it’s not good if they are but I can’t otherwise imagine why an adult would be told to buy age 12 then carry on buying age 9.

Theunamedcat · 15/04/2022 10:52

Drop it in a charity bin on the way back

Survivingmy3yearold · 15/04/2022 10:51

@PinkArt unfortunately she's a tad batty and it's her way of contributing. She would potentially even be slightly offended that we weren't interested. To be honest, even if I "forgot" them, she'd probably just keep hold of them until we see her again in several months time and bring them down with a load more. The annoying thing is, some of it might have been useable if she'd popped it in the post when she got it, but she's had this stuff since way before Christmas, but by the time she passes stuff on DD has grown into the next size. DP has said most of it won't fit but she's said to take it back with us and pass it on to others or donate it somewhere near to us

Foody8410 · 15/04/2022 10:07

My sons grandparents always buy him clothes that are his age. Thats age 11-12 at the moment. He has always been small & we tell them every time. He is in age 7-8 clothing!! They've just given us two t shirts for easter or him that go down to his knees!

PinkArt · 15/04/2022 10:02

@Survivingmy3yearold, are you able to make it equally clear back that they just don't fit though and you therefore have no use or need for them? 'Forgetting' does look like it could be an easier fix short term though.
This thread makes me twitchy as I was the very tall kid who hated clothes presents as they were always way too small, despite my parents telling people my sister and I really did need trousers for several years older than our ages. It was just the gift of disappointment!

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/04/2022 09:00

I had a family member who did similar. Not with clothes but would ask what the kids wanted. To which i would always stress please don't worry as I knew they were busy and didn't have alot of money and didn't want them worrying about buying a present. Just send a card or give them a phone call. I've always taught my kids that not everyone will always be able to afford presents and that's not whats important.

But they'd always insist and say they wanted to get them X off the list of what we were considering. So we'd double check it was OK. Check they dodnt want to just chip in a fiver and we'd say ot was from all of us ( if it was something on the big/pricey side) to which we'd be assured it was all in hand.

Only to be given something completely different , or clearly something being thrown out by someone else or tat from some selling page.

Like why. Whats the point. Just say, we'd not care the kids would have just been happy to see you.

FromOurHatsToOurFeet · 15/04/2022 08:27

Back in the day MIL used to get great pleasure from buying clothes in the wrong sizes that the kids would hate from Woolworths. Luckily Woolies would let you exchange. I used to know the manager by name! DH said to just let her shop, that was the bit she enjoyed.

CMOTDibbler · 15/04/2022 08:24

Late MIL was a beggar for this. She didn't see DS for 6 weeks after he was born (he was early, but they'd booked to go to their overseas holiday home for 8 weeks over his due date), and came back with newborn size clothes even though she was told that he a) didn't need any baby clothes at that point as others had bought them b) was 11lb by the time they saw him so well out of newborn. Later she'd buy cute toddler shoes when away to bring back, even though dh told her how difficult his feet were to fit as, just the same as dh, he had very wide and high feet and we'd try soo many shoes in specialist shops to get anything.
But not a surprise really as she never bought dh anything that fitted anyway, even when given specifics

Survivingmy3yearold · 15/04/2022 08:16

@PinkArt

So I had to pack her clothes anyway and now have 2 sacks of no good clothing to take home and drop at the charity shop Nope *@Survivingmy3yearold*! Your MIL has two bags to keep at her house and to drop at the charity shop. Why on earth would you take them with you? She's seen they don't fit, you want to break this pattern, it seems a no brainer to leave them behind.
@PinkArt it's been made very clear by her that they are now our clothes and if they don't fit then we need to pass them on. To be honest I may just "forget" to take them. She thinks I have hundreds of friends who are all desperate for baby clothes but anyone I know who has children already has older children/cousins who all pass on clothes so really wouldn't want them. As annoying as it is, I can see that she gets immense pleasure from doing it as there will be no other grandchildren. I just wish she checked on sizes before buying!
lljkk · 15/04/2022 08:10

I had an opposite problem... items bought too big. Nobody asked about their sizes, anyway.

Small kids & the items bought would be out of season for size of my child, then not fit when baby/toddler was the right size.

Often older DC were fussy & simply didn't like those items.

Or the items would even go out of fashion, be too childish, by the time they fit !

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/04/2022 08:02

My DM used to do this, even though I told her dds were ‘standard’ size, so to buy by their age on the label.

We were once visiting the U.K. in the depths of winter from a much warmer country, and DPs were meeting us so I asked her to buy them winter coats - ages 3 and 6.
She bought 6 and 9! (‘I thought they’d be skimpy’ 😂.) They absolutely swamped them. We had to stop on the way from the airport and change them.

Camomila · 15/04/2022 07:56

FIL does the opposite, everytime he comes back from the Philippines he brings back giant clothes. The DC and DH are pretty average size so DS2 gets clothes that fit DS1, DS1 (age 6), gets t-shirts that fit me, and DH gets L or XL shirts when he's a S/M.

(I keep getting rosaries, am not sure what I am meant to do with all the spare ones)

DuchyCazalet · 15/04/2022 07:42

DM used to do this. It was a control thing. She'd buy something too big and give the gift with the receipt. Then expect me to trapse in to the shops to change the item. She'd badger me about it. I started handing her things back and saying she could change them, I wasn't spending my time off doing it. Think she also liked to be able to moan that she bought stuff for the kids but never saw them wearing it.
Weaponised gifting is part of her MO

Theunamedcat · 15/04/2022 07:24

@PlasticineMeg

Can I also add my own rant in…

Family (in laws mostly): What chocolate do the kids like for when I buy them an Easter egg?
Me: Honestly please don’t, they get one from school each and one from my 90yo granny but we don’t like them to have more because it’s far too much chocolate, just donate the money or buy a book.
Family: Hmm

Also advent calenders one year the kids had five each plus the ones I had already bought the conversation went have you got the advent calendars yet they are a pound in tescos? Yes I've got them already (buys them one each) ok thanks but they already have on? Well now they have two!....they were on offer so we bought a couple more ummm thanks but they won't get eaten?....we decided to buy some for our house as well.....(me) WTF?
MyCatIsAJerk · 15/04/2022 01:54

My sister does this to ME!!!

I am very small 7.5 stone and she gifts me large/xlarge tops, etc.
I’m sure she does it as an insult but it’s just comical. And dumb.

Ericaequites · 15/04/2022 01:27

My grandmother made me lots of clothes until I was a teenager, but also used a tape measure wisely.
I was tiny, so it was hard to find me clothes as a child. My Brownie and school uniform had to be special ordered. I didn’t receive many clothes as gifts.

Wtfdoipick · 15/04/2022 01:23

I have a 10 year old who is just over 5ft tall. Age 10 clothes do not fit her, everyone knows she is incredibly tall and yet I still get age 10 clothes as gifts for her.

Chely · 15/04/2022 01:15

People do this with our kids too.
A size bigger is fine, they grow in to them. It's when they buy 1-2 sizes too small that I find annoying, gift receipts great but I hate the faff of returning stuff.

Poopootatty · 15/04/2022 01:14

@PlasticineMeg ha I hear you!

Also DH doesn’t want our DD to have loads of chocolate. She’s got a v sweet tooth and would just eat all she has in one sitting. I agree with him and not keen either. Yet he will not upset his parents and tell them not to get chocolate. He’d rather that our four year old is given it but try and restrict what she is allowed to eat. It really pisses me off. She’s 4, they are adults, surely they can handle getting a colouring book or something instead of chocolate?!

Poopootatty · 15/04/2022 01:08

I thought it was just my MIL who did this!

Our DD is very slim but taller than average. We all know this and MIL spends plenty of time with her but even after discussing her clothes size, she’ll come back with a size too small because the next size up “looked too big”. At Christmas I couldn’t even do up the dress she gave. It went straight to a younger cousin! On her birthday last month I handed the latest outfit back and said politely that it was lovely but it would be too small and could she swap it. MIL is lovely but she has a total blind spot when it comes to DD’s size!

PlasticineMeg · 15/04/2022 01:07

Can I also add my own rant in…

Family (in laws mostly): What chocolate do the kids like for when I buy them an Easter egg?
Me: Honestly please don’t, they get one from school each and one from my 90yo granny but we don’t like them to have more because it’s far too much chocolate, just donate the money or buy a book.
Family: Hmm