Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To be totally fed up with dogs?

940 replies

dogtroubl · 14/04/2022 13:50

When we moved in, neighbours had an old dog that used to wander into our garden and leave poo everywhere. Couldn’t use garden with young kids due to mess and large dog.

Complained (politely), after quite a bit of unpleasantness fence finally fixed, dog died and they got 2 new dogs that were loud but contained.

Neighbours moved, new neighbours also have 2 dogs and fence is in a bad state of repair again due to the constant barking, snarling and scratching that happens every time we go outside. I always make sure I’m out there with the kids in case it breaks because they don’t sound friendly at all.

Their neighbours also have 2 dogs so the 2 sets are always setting each other off barking.

Family members also have dogs. One very old who soils everywhere and one very large, young dog who is very playful and jumps up and licks and dribbles all over you.

My daughter is terrified (the dog is easily as tall as her) and the family member always says dog will be shut away when we go over, but dog is always let or gets out soon after. I can tell my daughter’s fear of this dog irritates the family member but she’s genuinely scared after an incident when she was a toddler, plus this dog is like a horse to her and could do serious damage even with just a nip.

We’ve been to a few kids’ playgrounds over the holidays, dogs off lead and running all over the place at each one. Chasing kids in a “playful” way that scares them.

Dog poo all over footpaths and verges everywhere. Kids tread in it, I tread in it, buggy goes in it because I don’t see it until it’s too late.

I know it’s bad owners not the dogs’ fault etc but AIBU to just be totally fed up with dogs?

OP posts:
SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 13:23

vivainsomnia · 12/01/2023 13:20

I am DONE with the comparison of dogs with human children. It’s such a ridiculous argument. One is a human child. One is an animal
But your comparison is not one dog owners make. If I were to compare it would be to say: I love my kids, I love my dog, so want to do what makes both happy'. I don't ever think 'my child is a human so I'll do all I can fir them my dog is an animal so I'll do what makes the very few people scared of dogs happy'.

No dog is 100% harmless I said vast majority not 100%. No human is 100% safe, neither are buildings, cars, trees. They are all unpredictable and could do you harm, but I expect you don't avoid them all.

Ermmmm. You said the vast majority of dogs are harmless.
and I am responding by stating the fact that NO dogs are EVER completely harmless. Not one of them.
they ALL have the ability to do harm.

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 13:20

MNisMyGuiltyPleasure · 12/01/2023 13:16

Do you never take kids into (clothing) stores unless it's to buy something they need to try on? I very much doubt that. And that's your right of course. Just like it's dog owners' right to take their dogs into establishments that allow dogs.

Dogs are animals. Children are not.

vivainsomnia · 12/01/2023 13:20

I am DONE with the comparison of dogs with human children. It’s such a ridiculous argument. One is a human child. One is an animal
But your comparison is not one dog owners make. If I were to compare it would be to say: I love my kids, I love my dog, so want to do what makes both happy'. I don't ever think 'my child is a human so I'll do all I can fir them my dog is an animal so I'll do what makes the very few people scared of dogs happy'.

No dog is 100% harmless I said vast majority not 100%. No human is 100% safe, neither are buildings, cars, trees. They are all unpredictable and could do you harm, but I expect you don't avoid them all.

Lockheart · 12/01/2023 13:19

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 13:12

I am DONE with the comparison of dogs with human children. It’s such a ridiculous argument. One is a human child. One is an animal.

Humans are animals, we're not alien or divine.

MNisMyGuiltyPleasure · 12/01/2023 13:16

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 13:10

Or maybe do you can get clothes for your kids in the right size…….

Do you never take kids into (clothing) stores unless it's to buy something they need to try on? I very much doubt that. And that's your right of course. Just like it's dog owners' right to take their dogs into establishments that allow dogs.

Orangepolentacake · 12/01/2023 13:16

I love dogs and I’m fed up of them. They’re treated like fucking royalty by some people. Your family member who is annoyed at your daughter being scared is not at all reasonable and the kind of person that makes me fed up with dogs

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 13:14

vivainsomnia · 12/01/2023 13:11

And also if you can also learn that not everyone loves dogs the way you do, then also great
I didn't need to learn this. I totally accept and always have that not everyone care for dogs, even the very cute ones, although I'm still to come across such a person in life.

As pointed above, I fully accept that someone might not care for my dog, I don't need their gratification at all and I respect their feelings.

I however have an issue with those who would i.pose that ALL dogs should be on lead all the time because of a very small minority of people who don't like dogs and the even smaller minority of dogs who cause trouble.

I am 100% as cross with those who don't pick up poo (drives me very angry) and those who indeed minimise their dogs bad behaviour). But MOST dogs owners are responsible and the very vast majority of dogs are totally harmless.

No dog is 100% harmless.

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 13:13

vivainsomnia · 12/01/2023 13:11

And also if you can also learn that not everyone loves dogs the way you do, then also great
I didn't need to learn this. I totally accept and always have that not everyone care for dogs, even the very cute ones, although I'm still to come across such a person in life.

As pointed above, I fully accept that someone might not care for my dog, I don't need their gratification at all and I respect their feelings.

I however have an issue with those who would i.pose that ALL dogs should be on lead all the time because of a very small minority of people who don't like dogs and the even smaller minority of dogs who cause trouble.

I am 100% as cross with those who don't pick up poo (drives me very angry) and those who indeed minimise their dogs bad behaviour). But MOST dogs owners are responsible and the very vast majority of dogs are totally harmless.

Right, and I totally didn’t need to be reminded that some people love dogs.
everyone already knows that!
hence the whole point to this thread.

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 13:12

MNisMyGuiltyPleasure · 12/01/2023 13:08

For the same reason why you may need to bring a child into a clothing store - because you may not be able to leave them at home or with someone else.

I am DONE with the comparison of dogs with human children. It’s such a ridiculous argument. One is a human child. One is an animal.

vivainsomnia · 12/01/2023 13:11

And also if you can also learn that not everyone loves dogs the way you do, then also great
I didn't need to learn this. I totally accept and always have that not everyone care for dogs, even the very cute ones, although I'm still to come across such a person in life.

As pointed above, I fully accept that someone might not care for my dog, I don't need their gratification at all and I respect their feelings.

I however have an issue with those who would i.pose that ALL dogs should be on lead all the time because of a very small minority of people who don't like dogs and the even smaller minority of dogs who cause trouble.

I am 100% as cross with those who don't pick up poo (drives me very angry) and those who indeed minimise their dogs bad behaviour). But MOST dogs owners are responsible and the very vast majority of dogs are totally harmless.

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 13:11

MNisMyGuiltyPleasure · 12/01/2023 13:08

For the same reason why you may need to bring a child into a clothing store - because you may not be able to leave them at home or with someone else.

So*

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 13:10

MNisMyGuiltyPleasure · 12/01/2023 13:08

For the same reason why you may need to bring a child into a clothing store - because you may not be able to leave them at home or with someone else.

Or maybe do you can get clothes for your kids in the right size…….

MNisMyGuiltyPleasure · 12/01/2023 13:08

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 12:27

Unless it’s a dog which is used as an aid eg for a person with impaired vision, then WHY on earth would a person even need to bring a dog into a clothing store?! Or for any store at all.

For the same reason why you may need to bring a child into a clothing store - because you may not be able to leave them at home or with someone else.

TeaKlaxon · 12/01/2023 12:58

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 12:27

Unless it’s a dog which is used as an aid eg for a person with impaired vision, then WHY on earth would a person even need to bring a dog into a clothing store?! Or for any store at all.

Convenience.

If I'm out for dog walk or lunch and my dog is with me, it's really convenient if I don't have to drop my dog some and return to town if I need to pick something up from a shop.

I actively choose to frequent shops that are dog friendly precisely for that reason - if I need a pint of milk, it's so much easier to pick it up on the way back from walking the dog than to have to go out twice. And if shops recognise that and choose to appeal to the custom of people like me, they should be free to do so.

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 12:27

TeaKlaxon · 12/01/2023 12:21

I'm not sure why you think someone who chooses to work in a Pet Shop should have to 'put up with' dogs, but someone who chooses to work in another dog-friendly workplace should not.

If you want to work in a clothes shop and don't want to be around dogs, then work in one of the many that do not allow dogs. But if a clothes shop chooses to allow dogs, they are and should be entirely entitled to do so.

And of course no employee can avoid being near dogs entirely in the workplace, unless they want to exclude service dogs.

Unless it’s a dog which is used as an aid eg for a person with impaired vision, then WHY on earth would a person even need to bring a dog into a clothing store?! Or for any store at all.

TeaKlaxon · 12/01/2023 12:21

lieselotte · 12/01/2023 12:06

But many posters here go further - they complain about other people's pet dogs in their own home (none of their business) or complain that dogs exist in public spaces at all (e.g. pubs, cafes, shops) or complain that dogs are permitted off lead in parks even when they are under control. Those complaints are not reasonable

I agree with the first one.

The second one is reasonable because all of those places are workplaces. I should not have to put up with dogs because eg I work in a clothes shop. Different if I choose to work in a pet shop. As dogs are even being allowed in offices now, people are finding their choices of employment being reduced.

And the third one is open to discussion. Personally I don't think any off-lead dog is under control unless it is very highly trained eg a police dog. However, most dogs sniff around and mind their own business. If yours is one of the ones that doesn't, it should be on a short lead at all times.

here are MANY adults who are afraid of strange dogs. Some of them are even dog owners themselves. But are AFRAID of dogs they don’t know.

Indeed. And even if you are of the dog owner ilk who thinks everyone should love your fur baby, maybe you can accept that your dog shouldn't bother other dogs or animals, even if you don't care about other humans.

I'm not sure why you think someone who chooses to work in a Pet Shop should have to 'put up with' dogs, but someone who chooses to work in another dog-friendly workplace should not.

If you want to work in a clothes shop and don't want to be around dogs, then work in one of the many that do not allow dogs. But if a clothes shop chooses to allow dogs, they are and should be entirely entitled to do so.

And of course no employee can avoid being near dogs entirely in the workplace, unless they want to exclude service dogs.

TeaKlaxon · 12/01/2023 12:19

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 12:00

What is reasonable to you, may be unreasonable to someone else.
Peoples opinions are formed by their own personal experiences.
Ultimately some people cannot tolerate dogs for many valid reasons.
others literally consider dogs as their family - also for valid reason.

Of course people can disagree with what's reasonable and what's not. But that's sort of the point of discussion.

I consider those who are obnoxious about other people's dogs in their own homes, those who object to dogs being allowed in venues that have chosen to allow them, and those who object to dogs being off lead in parks even if they are under control to be unreasonable.

No one here is arguing that the other things - not picking up poo or allowing dogs to harass or attack others - are reasonable, so that's really not even a debate.

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 12:15

lieselotte · 12/01/2023 12:06

But many posters here go further - they complain about other people's pet dogs in their own home (none of their business) or complain that dogs exist in public spaces at all (e.g. pubs, cafes, shops) or complain that dogs are permitted off lead in parks even when they are under control. Those complaints are not reasonable

I agree with the first one.

The second one is reasonable because all of those places are workplaces. I should not have to put up with dogs because eg I work in a clothes shop. Different if I choose to work in a pet shop. As dogs are even being allowed in offices now, people are finding their choices of employment being reduced.

And the third one is open to discussion. Personally I don't think any off-lead dog is under control unless it is very highly trained eg a police dog. However, most dogs sniff around and mind their own business. If yours is one of the ones that doesn't, it should be on a short lead at all times.

here are MANY adults who are afraid of strange dogs. Some of them are even dog owners themselves. But are AFRAID of dogs they don’t know.

Indeed. And even if you are of the dog owner ilk who thinks everyone should love your fur baby, maybe you can accept that your dog shouldn't bother other dogs or animals, even if you don't care about other humans.

All of this. 💯

lieselotte · 12/01/2023 12:06

But many posters here go further - they complain about other people's pet dogs in their own home (none of their business) or complain that dogs exist in public spaces at all (e.g. pubs, cafes, shops) or complain that dogs are permitted off lead in parks even when they are under control. Those complaints are not reasonable

I agree with the first one.

The second one is reasonable because all of those places are workplaces. I should not have to put up with dogs because eg I work in a clothes shop. Different if I choose to work in a pet shop. As dogs are even being allowed in offices now, people are finding their choices of employment being reduced.

And the third one is open to discussion. Personally I don't think any off-lead dog is under control unless it is very highly trained eg a police dog. However, most dogs sniff around and mind their own business. If yours is one of the ones that doesn't, it should be on a short lead at all times.

here are MANY adults who are afraid of strange dogs. Some of them are even dog owners themselves. But are AFRAID of dogs they don’t know.

Indeed. And even if you are of the dog owner ilk who thinks everyone should love your fur baby, maybe you can accept that your dog shouldn't bother other dogs or animals, even if you don't care about other humans.

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 12:06

BeatrixPottery · 11/01/2023 22:06

@AGoodDayForSomebodyElseToDie where do you live I literally live a stones throw from one beach and 10 minutes walk from another, been here 2 years, run on the beach 4 times a week. Walk past the other few times a week, never once seen a discarded nappy. Plenty of dog 💩tho!

It’s absolutely disgusting and inexcusable! It’s all over the place isn’t it. Just horrendous.

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 12:02

AGoodDayForSomebodyElseToDie · 12/01/2023 11:26

I'm afraid you're only demonstrating your lack of understanding of nuance and rational argument.

And you're incorrect on all counts, ftr.

🙄Ok cool

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 12:00

TeaKlaxon · 12/01/2023 11:47

Literally no one here thinks everyone loves dogs. You're making that up.

The issue is what are the reasonable expectations of those who don't love dogs.

Is it reasonable to expect that dog poo is picked up? Of course. Is it reasonable that dogs are not permitted to harass other people? Of course.

But many posters here go further - they complain about other people's pet dogs in their own home (none of their business) or complain that dogs exist in public spaces at all (e.g. pubs, cafes, shops) or complain that dogs are permitted off lead in parks even when they are under control. Those complaints are not reasonable.

What is reasonable to you, may be unreasonable to someone else.
Peoples opinions are formed by their own personal experiences.
Ultimately some people cannot tolerate dogs for many valid reasons.
others literally consider dogs as their family - also for valid reason.

TeaKlaxon · 12/01/2023 11:47

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 11:35

please show me where I insisted it was crazy to think differently to me …….
And also if you can also learn that not everyone loves dogs the way you do, then also great.

Literally no one here thinks everyone loves dogs. You're making that up.

The issue is what are the reasonable expectations of those who don't love dogs.

Is it reasonable to expect that dog poo is picked up? Of course. Is it reasonable that dogs are not permitted to harass other people? Of course.

But many posters here go further - they complain about other people's pet dogs in their own home (none of their business) or complain that dogs exist in public spaces at all (e.g. pubs, cafes, shops) or complain that dogs are permitted off lead in parks even when they are under control. Those complaints are not reasonable.

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 11:35

vivainsomnia · 12/01/2023 11:22

That’s absolutely your prerogative.
we are all different and all have valid feelings about subjects

But that's not what your posts imply. You insisted that it was crazy to think differently to you.

If you can now see that indeed, people can love dogs and not just consider them as smelly disgusting wild animals, then that's great.

please show me where I insisted it was crazy to think differently to me …….
And also if you can also learn that not everyone loves dogs the way you do, then also great.

AGoodDayForSomebodyElseToDie · 12/01/2023 11:26

SummerPeach · 12/01/2023 07:31

Your arguments are the ones which are totally irrational and ridiculous.
you probably have three dogs and refer to all of them as fur babies.
You probably let them off the lead and pay little attention to where they are and who they’re bothering.
Have a good day, bye.

I'm afraid you're only demonstrating your lack of understanding of nuance and rational argument.

And you're incorrect on all counts, ftr.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.