Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - my neighbour's flower bed is my dog's toilet

357 replies

SevenWaystoLeave · 14/04/2022 12:36

I routinely let my dog wander unsupervised around the neighbourhood and he's taken to going into my neighbour's garden, digging up their flower bed and taking a massive stinking dump there. It's his favourite spot to go. This has become a daily occurrence, but I can't stop him, he's an animal and needs his freedom, and I'm not going to clean up after him either because they can't technically prove it's my dog, and not someone else's free-roaming unsupervised dog.

...Yes this would be really fucking unreasonable wouldn't it and people would be quite rightly calling the authories on me and I'd get fined and a control order slapped on my dog. So why why why the ever living fuck is it considered okay and normal when cat owners do this?!? It's absolutely disgusting and I am so so sick of cleaning cat shit out my garden on a daily basis. AIBU?

OP posts:
Beekindbeehumble · 14/04/2022 13:03

When my new neighbours arrived with 4 cats I realised I had to net any areas I wanted new plants to establish. Neighbour stood talking to me by our boundary, saw one of their cars use my flower bed as a toilet and ignored it. Leaving me to pick up their cat’s mess from my garden.

1ittlegreen · 14/04/2022 13:03

I stick small twigs and canes in my beds and they don't touch them. They need a wide area to scratch the earth so if you put them in the ground about 30cm apart they will go somewhere else.

10HailMarys · 14/04/2022 13:01

Well, i mean, dogs are allowed in pubs and on trains etc. cats aren't.

Dogs are allowed in some pubs - it's up to the publican to say yes or no, just as it would be if someone wanted to bring in a cat. Some pubs and shops have resident cats - my local bookshop has a cat. He's really lovely and very affectionate so I always give him lots of fuss, but I haven't asked him whose garden he poos in Grin

You can generally take cats on trains too - would just have to be under control, so in a carrier or on a lead/harness, same as a dog.

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 14/04/2022 13:00

I hate bl... cats and their craps in my garden (on top of plants) or on the lawn.
Thank goodness our dog hates them too and chases them off.

worriedatthistime · 14/04/2022 12:59

@yourestandingonmyneck they might not bark but they scream and howl at night and fight that makes a racket
Some irresponsible owners leave their dog crap , difference is they can get fined
If people want cats reported when knocked over then they need to accept they are treated as dogs and owners responsible

SevenWaystoLeave · 14/04/2022 12:59

Sprinkle flower bed liberally and regularly with pepper or chilli powder to deter regular offender(s).

Thus making the garden unpleasant and hazardous for my own pets and family - why should I have to do this because other people won't control their pets?

Wear gloves to do your gardening.

Ask neighbours to please walk their cats on a lead and pick up their poo.

Absolutely what they should be doing, that or keeping their little darlings indoors, but apparently cat owners love it when their pets shit all over the neighbourhood and then get flattened by cars, and suggesting they take any measures at all to prevent this is a terrible violation of their cat's human rights.

Erect tarpaulins over your garden in case birds shit in it. Ditto mice and rats when passing through.

Cats aren't wild animals, they are pets people choose to own then don't take any responsibility for. If you can't see the difference there, I can't help you. And there's no wild animal that shits in my garden with the same level of frequency, nor do they ruin the plants in the process.

OP posts:
Thehundredthnamechange · 14/04/2022 12:58

I'm annoyed at myself for accidentally clicking 'YANBU' when I very much think that you are.

worriedatthistime · 14/04/2022 12:57

@rosesarebluey there are such things in existence

catwomando · 14/04/2022 12:57

I've got 2 cats who both pop in my garden and also now we have a badger, who also poos in the garden.

It's shit city here, but to be expected.

Cats can't be controlled so you just have to get on with it I'm afraid.

Cats are not dogs.

darlingdodo · 14/04/2022 12:57

Love our cats. But it's DH and I dealing with the crap because they're indoor cats. Not fond of dealing with other cat's crap in our garden.

There seems to be an increasing amount of dog crap around too - at least it's not in our garden.

WimpyKidYouNot · 14/04/2022 12:56

“AIBU to be annoyed I stepped into a pile of squirrel, bird, mice, rat [insert other small animal] poo in my garden.”

Except no one’s ever seen a thread on that - just cats Wink

worriedatthistime · 14/04/2022 12:55

@TheLightSideOfTheMoon bingo , so many cats don't and if its a flower bed what activity are you likely to be doing
My neighbour had stones our front and cats used as a litter tray and they tried all sorts , eventually they concreted the small area over and the cat still shits there

AryaStarkWolf · 14/04/2022 12:55

I do chase them off when I see them. Thing is, my dog is a sighthound, he has a high chase drive, he could actually kill a cat if he got hold of one, which I really don't want to happen - which is yet another reason I don't want other people's cats in my garden. So the result is I have to restrict and supervise my own dog's access to my own garden because of other people's cats coming onto my property (and of course if he did harm a cat I'd be the bad guy, because god forbid a cat owner ever take responsibility for the safety of their own pet).

You shouldn't, he probably wouldn't catch a cat anyway and it would deter them from coming into the garden

ShirleyBadass · 14/04/2022 12:55

My neighbour frequently lets me know when my cat poos in her garden. However, having spent the last 5 years picking her cat poo out of mine, I don't feel she can really complain as we're quite even!

Just wish I could repay the favour to the dog walker who has taken to letting their dog poo on my front lawn every few days....

10HailMarys · 14/04/2022 12:55

Birds, foxes and other wildlife do this too.

Yes, they do - but that is absolutely not the point. I have a fox that regularly comes into my garden. It has actually never crapped in the garden as far as I know, but it has scratched up the lawn before now, looking for grubs, so it does occasionally cause a bit of inconvenience. However, the big difference here is that I get pleasure from seeing a fox in my garden, and in fact I have deliberately left a little hole in my fence so it can come in, so I have made a choice to accept occasional inconvenience because I enjoy seeing the fox so much. That is my decision about my property. Someone else's cat coming in is not my decision about my property, and I'm getting zero benefit from it to balance out the constant shit. So no, it's not remotely the same.

As for other wildlife - I have squirrels and the occasional hedgehog in my garden and a lot of birds. They produce tiny little poos that don't smell of anything and they don't dig holes in my flower beds to do it.

It will take a while if your garden is now a part of their routine but keep a supersoaker water pistol to and you’ll soon make it so they change their routine and avoid your garden

So, I'm supposed to sit at my window 24 hours a day with a loaded supersoaker waiting for someone else's pet to do its routine shit every day until it gets the message? Not terribly practical, that. Again, very much the person who doesn't own a cat who's being inconvenienced by the cat-owner's choices, isn't it?

Scabetty · 14/04/2022 12:54

One of mine shits on our grass Angry and one comes in to use the litter tray. Stray cats shit in my flower beds as do foxes. Annoying as it is I have other things boil my piss Grin

Candleabra · 14/04/2022 12:54

I use to chop bit off my pyracanthas hedge and lay them in the flower beds to deter persistent cats. they’re so spiky, it stops them squatting

TheNoonBell · 14/04/2022 12:54

My cats poo in my own flower beds which is highly annoying. The neighbours both sides have dogs so are safe.

worriedatthistime · 14/04/2022 12:54

@IncompleteSenten yet people say that can't be done and you proved it can

yourestandingonmyneck · 14/04/2022 12:54

Well, i mean, dogs are allowed in pubs and on trains etc. cats aren't.

You may find cat shit in your garden. I'm forever stepping over dog shit on the pavement on my way to work.

You can't legally just knock a dog down and leave it for dead. You can with a cat.

Some dogs bark and make a hell of a racket wakening neighbours up in the early hours of the morning. Cats generally don't.

Some dogs maul young children to death. Cats don't.

They are just entirely different species of animals and behave accordingly 🤷‍♀️ I'm not sure trying to draw comparisons like that is a helpful way to think of it.

rosesarebluey · 14/04/2022 12:52

@wanttomarryamillionaire

I agree op. I don't get why cat owners think its ok for them to let their pets wander wherever they please shitting and killing small animals and birds as they go. They should be responsible and cat proof their gardens.
How can you cat proof a garden? Cats will always get out of it.
quickscribble · 14/04/2022 12:52

@NobleYeats1

I agree. Even worse for me was being out gardening when pregnant and unearthing cat poo ending up terrifying me about toxoplasmosis. It’s disgusting and dangerous for kids too. I’ve started going for the cat with a water gun when it comes onto our property now.
I had this happen to me too, got soil in scratches up my arms and was so worried.
SevenWaystoLeave · 14/04/2022 12:52

@Trulyweird1

YANBU, but cat owners will be on to tell you that cats have a ‘right to roam’ etc. Only thing that seems to work for me is covering the flower beds in Defenders cat-off. That and sending my dogs out to the garden when the little crapper thinks it wants to pay us a visit. It tends to skirt round our property these days .
I do chase them off when I see them. Thing is, my dog is a sighthound, he has a high chase drive, he could actually kill a cat if he got hold of one, which I really don't want to happen - which is yet another reason I don't want other people's cats in my garden. So the result is I have to restrict and supervise my own dog's access to my own garden because of other people's cats coming onto my property (and of course if he did harm a cat I'd be the bad guy, because god forbid a cat owner ever take responsibility for the safety of their own pet).
OP posts:
AryaStarkWolf · 14/04/2022 12:52

@mumsie8

Don't know where the fallacy that cats don't shit in their own garden comes from. I can assure you they do. My boy poohs quite happily in the purposely dug area of earth in our garden. He also shits in my flower beds but that's a work in progress i tell my neighbour to let me know if he goes in theirs and also to scare him off with water. Other than that he also has a litter tray, which he uses and so far to date my neighbour has never alerted me to the fact my free roaming cat has shat on her lawn.
My cat is the complete opposite, he won't shit anywhere other than his litter box. (and yes I know for sure, he's mainly an indoor cat but has an outside enclosure and he comes in the garden when I'm there as well)