Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go out / send DS to nursery when potty training?

38 replies

Llamasally · 14/04/2022 10:49

We are on day 4, he’s nearly 3, it’s a bit hit and miss but he’s getting more on the loo/potty than not and making steady progress in the right direction.

Nursery said if he’s having more than 1-2 accidents a day then he’s definitely not ready. He’s having more than this and in on Tuesday next week. Surely people still go out, function, go to nursery etc while the process of learning is happening? Obviously with plenty of spare clothes, something to sit on when out in case of an accident etc?? I don’t understand this thinking but FTM and this is all new to me and very anxiety inducing!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
yellowwellingtons · 14/04/2022 15:49

I'd keep going with it over the weekend, you might see massive improvements by Monday/Tuesday.
Nursery should be supporting you on this if you think he's ready.
We've just potty trained DD and were similar to you having accidents for the first few days, we're now two weeks in and she's been dry for the last 4 days.
Have you tried any kind of incentive to try and get him to go on his own accord?
We started a sticker chart with DD and every time she went on the potty, even if she had an accident then managed to finish it on the potty, she gets to put a sticker on her chart, it's worked really well for us. A friend of ours used chocolate buttons.

Heythere13 · 14/04/2022 15:37

It’s about the child’s stance

He’s not going unless prompted

The switch has not clicked yet

Rebecca1305 · 14/04/2022 13:04

Night time dryness happened by itself at 2 & 8 months so don’t listen to anyone saying boys aren’t night dry untill 4-5 .. that came from my health visitor Confused

@Heythere13

Why isn’t he ready Confused he’s been using the potty and toilet ? If he wasn’t ready he would refuse to sit on it ? Going back to pull ups is just confusing for the child you just need to go for it and accept accidents happen.

Heythere13 · 14/04/2022 13:00

It won’t confuse him because he wasn’t ever ready so he was probably confused re what the heck you have been doing!

Go back to pull ups and wait for his cue. It should come very shortly given age

Rebecca1305 · 14/04/2022 12:59

Weird , sounds like he’s ready to me ? I started on my sons second birthday as he just sat on the potty one day and weed- it took about a month to be reliable lots of accidents at first , left him naked on the bottom half. Lots of time in the garden, letting them wet themselves gets them used to feeling of being wet which nappy’s don’t allow. I took mine out in the first week on short outings , I put a towel in the trolley and a car seat protector in the seat. You’d think nursery would support you ? They all have accidents at nursery anyway there too busy playing. There’s never a good time to potty train this is why people keep putting it off till there 4, there will always be accidents with it - doesn’t mean there not ready!

welshladywhois40 · 14/04/2022 12:40

We potty trained over a long weekend. Started Friday and sent him to nursery on Tuesday with plenty of clothes. By the Monday accidents were better. The first week I was on pins about how he would cope at nursery and he managed fine with just a few accidents.

My nursery were really supportative. Even the day they had to tell me he decided to pull his pants down and fee in front of everyone in the playroom.

TulipsGarden · 14/04/2022 12:02

@Tillsforthrills I guess all nurseries are different. Ours encouraged us to start potty training as they believed he was ready, and said he only needed the long weekend off and they would deal with it from then on.

They don't have holidays, it's open all year except one week at Christmas. And I don't have enough annual leave to take weeks off, obviously.

I know my friend's child's pre-school asks that children are potty trained before starting, but that's a completely different set-up, only open term time and she only pays for lunchtime cover.

Flickflak · 14/04/2022 11:55

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Goldbar · 14/04/2022 11:54

Like @StepBackPlease, we left DC in pull ups at nursery and for days out for around a month or two after DC was in pants at home. At nursery, DC was busy and outdoors most of the time, and couldn't necessarily get a staff member's attention in time. For days out likewise, we couldn't always be sure of being near a toilet (and lots were closed due to Covid). It didn't confuse DC at all and was much less stressful for us all.

Profanisaurasrex · 14/04/2022 11:39

I didn’t mention in my previous post, that our nursery are fully supportive of doing potty training alongside us and will change clothes etc as needed. But it was just my view that DC needed to be ready before I felt comfortable asking nursery to do it with us.

Also, don’t feel that he needs to do it just because he’s nearly 3. We tried recently with DS who is 3 this month and it was clear he wasn’t ready so we’ll try again in about 3 months or so.

minniep · 14/04/2022 11:33

Honestly it sounds like he just isn't ready yet. When they are ready it just clicks

Hugasauras · 14/04/2022 11:30

Very glad for our nursery reading these replies! Kids tend to be ready when they're ready, and that doesn't always coincide with holidays (plus our nursery is open year-round so there are no nursery holidays bar two weeks at Christmas). No one at our nursery has kept their child off for potty training!

Tillsforthrills · 14/04/2022 11:27

@TulipsGarden

My experience of private nurseries and childminders is that the first few weeks of potty training is a parental responsibility, after which they continue the training depending on readiness.

I’m slightly confused as to why you think a private nursery has to take on this parental duty, it’s also much better for the child.

Hence why it’s usually done during a holiday period.

Whatsmyname100 · 14/04/2022 11:26

4 times a day, then he's definitely not ready. I only started ds at 3.5yo and he was more than ready. He had one accident in 2 weeks. We only did night training after 4 and from the very first night he was trained. You definitely need to wait till he was ready. By 3.5yo I found my ds walking to the toilet at home by himself wanting to try. Nursery is right in this instance I'm afraid.

StepBackPlease · 14/04/2022 11:25

Hi Op, my DD was in pull ups at nursery for around a month before we finally felt she was ready, despite being in pants at home. She was just under 3 by the time she was completely dry in the day and is now 3.5 and only dry at night last week.

It didn't confuse her at all, she was able to understand pull ups were for nursery and knickers were for home, but she could wear her big girl pants for nursery once she was doing all her wees in the toilet.

It's one thing for them to use a potty or toilet when prompted, but the staff at nursery won't have time to be dealing with 4 accidents a day. I would persevere at home and send him into nursery with pull ups for now, and keep reminding/praising him when he tells you he needs to go.

We used smarties as an incentive for a while, and she negotiated a very complicated tariff of different amounts of smarties for poos and wees Grin.

Sounds like he'll get the hang of it soon, but don't let anyone pressurise you by saying 'oh he should be potty trained be now'. They do it when they're ready. I had MIL and DM going on for months about DD still being in pull ups, but when we eventually did go for it she was done in a week.

TulipsGarden · 14/04/2022 11:24

@Llamasally

Thanks for all the replies. He’s going when prompted and doing well with that, but only a handful of times of his own accord. The accidents are coming to tell me he has done a wee, with wet pants. Yesterday was four times like this. I’m asking or putting him on the potty pretty frequently. Maybe he isn’t really ready then based on these experiences…
For mine the going by himself took a week. For my best mate with her first, 12 days. With her second, three days. It's so variable but if sounds like he's getting the hang of it.
Sally872 · 14/04/2022 11:21

Regular reminders and accidents are fairly normal first few days. If he is improving carry on but success for us was all about going regularly as I reminded then recognising the sign the need to go themselves. Handfuls of times of own accord sounds OK, perhaps more frequent reminders though.

Llamasally · 14/04/2022 11:16

Will it just confuse him now though, if he’s not ready and we go back to pull ups?

OP posts:
Llamasally · 14/04/2022 11:15

@TulipsGarden it’s a private day nursery. I’ve taken this week as annual leave to try and PT

OP posts:
Llamasally · 14/04/2022 11:14

Thanks for all the replies. He’s going when prompted and doing well with that, but only a handful of times of his own accord. The accidents are coming to tell me he has done a wee, with wet pants. Yesterday was four times like this. I’m asking or putting him on the potty pretty frequently. Maybe he isn’t really ready then based on these experiences…

OP posts:
TulipsGarden · 14/04/2022 11:11

Is this a day nursery or pre-school? If it's a private day nursery for working parents they can hardly take weeks off to potty train.

Ours just ask you to do a few days at home - we did a long weekend - and then send them in with lots of changes of clothes. Mine is about five weeks in now and still not great with wees. They don't mind at all (or at least they say they don't, and have said not to put him back in nappies as he's getting there).

girlmom21 · 14/04/2022 11:07

Is he having accidents or just going without thinking? They're not the same with potty training.

Mum2Terrors · 14/04/2022 11:06

My DS was 3 and half when we re attempted potty training. Every attempt prior he wasn't showing interest. Over the summer I put him in pant with his potty near by. Every half hour I ask if he wanted to go. The first couple of days it was accident after accident but by the end of the week he got the hang of it. Then it was very rare he had an accident. I chose to stay at home the week we was potty training as it made it easier. He was in his safe place so he didn't get embarrassed about his accident as I didn't want him to be put off using the potty. When it came to going out, I always put him in a potty training pull up just in case of an accident. Took him to the toilet when we could and rewarded him if he kept the pull up dry.

Every child is different and sometimes they are just not ready. If he is having frequent accidents and not getting the hang of it, he may not be ready just yet.

Hugasauras · 14/04/2022 11:05

Tuesday is a long way away in potty-training terms though! You'll probably find things are much better at home by then.

Hugasauras · 14/04/2022 11:04

DD had way more than 1-2 accidents at nursery when she first went back, think she had about 5 first day! But they said that was totally normal as nursery is a v different environment to home and they almost need to re-learn it with all the distractions and different set-up.

Ours doesn't ask you to keep kids off for potty training. You send them in with tons of spare clothes and they support what you're doing at home. They didn't specify a number of accidents that was acceptable as the difference between home and nursery is so big.

The first week or two DD had quite a few accidents at nursery but was almost totally dry at home. Then it just clicked and that was that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread