Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think all school holidays should be universal within England?

32 replies

CakeBossBaby · 14/04/2022 08:47

I currently have children at 3 different schools. My daughter broke up on 4th April and returns this Tuesday.
My son only broke up yesterday and has next week off until 25th. My 3rd child has yet again different holidays! Its like this every term.

How are we supposed to have days out or God forbid a week away somewhere when holidays aren't coordinating and we cannot get a full week where all kids are off apart from Summer when prices are extortionate.

Why do schools all within 2 miles of each other have su h drastically different holiday schedules?

Shouldn't holidays just be set days for all schools within England?

Does anyone know why schools hoose heir own dates?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NeverDropYourMooncup · 14/04/2022 14:37

@greenteafiend

I actually think dates should be staggered by region (but roughly standardized within each region). This might reduce the number of days when far-flung cousins can get together, but it would really reduce price gouging. The difference in dates between England and Scotland is already a factor enabling people to get some cheaper deals.
I think that in reality, all that would mean is the higher price being charged over a longer period.

There will always be people messed up by living and working over boundaries for that - if they're the same everywhere though, I think that creates greater pressure on leave requests, however - everybody with kids will need the same two weeks off, rather than some being two weeks before Easter, some either side and some two weeks starting from Maundy Thursday.

So, on balance, although it is a PITA to have different dates, I do think it helps a greater number of people to stagger it. And, of course, private schools do pretty much as they wish and academies because half the SLT have kids at private schools, but I guess the theory is there that those parents can afford to access lengthy fulltime childcare?

greenteafiend · 14/04/2022 14:23

Prices won't go down if holidays were staggered. Just the 'off peak' rates will increase to match the 'peak' ones.

Nonsense. Scots and English already enjoy "cheaper" holidays on each other's turf due to holiday dates being different in Scotland and England.

Right now, we're facing difficulties with international travel, higher fuel prices and so on that will make holidays abroad harder, not to mention the environmental guilt over flying. Yet holidays in the UK often end up being very expensive in part due to the price gouging effect--and with the cost of living going up, people are going to really struggle to afford those prices now. And yet after COVID we are all simply desperate to enjoy holidays of some sort! Something's got to give. Staggering holidays to help reduce the cost of UK holidays would make sense.

Staggering between regions would make it harder for families in different parts of the country to get together but there would be SOME overlap. People who send their kids to two schools over boundary lines might be a bit screwed, but how common is that?

Greyornavy · 14/04/2022 13:56

Harder to get childcare though.

notanothertakeaway · 14/04/2022 13:47

@Greyornavy

YANBU

It is a complete pain for teachers with children with different holidays too.

Teachers would likely still be off for the majority of their children's school holidays, unlike non teachers
Waxonwaxoff0 · 14/04/2022 11:56

Nah, I prefer it when they're different. DS often has later holidays than the rest of the country (last Christmas he was off until the 10th Jan) so I often get better holiday deals. Grin

reluctantbrit · 14/04/2022 11:51

@sweeneytoddsrazor

Quite a few years ago I stumbled across a programme about a holiday site, cant remember which one and the manager was saying if they had to rely on school holiday bookings they would go out of business. Out of school holiday time 3/4 of the booked accommodation was people taking advantage of the newspaper £25 holidays and the only money the site made was what was spent in the bar etc. That was just about enough to keep them going. Staggered holidays would be a good thing for them.
I agree. I am from Germany where the holiday season runs from mid June to mid-September as the states (apart from two) rotate each year.

So, all hotels, camping, self-catering properties have a larger season than just the 6 weeks of holidays in their area.

Only drawback is that if you go from Northern Germany to Bavaria in July for example the Bavarian children are still in school and there is nothing special going on. On the other hand, attractions are normally less busy.

OverTheRubicon · 14/04/2022 11:46

@sweeneytoddsrazor

Quite a few years ago I stumbled across a programme about a holiday site, cant remember which one and the manager was saying if they had to rely on school holiday bookings they would go out of business. Out of school holiday time 3/4 of the booked accommodation was people taking advantage of the newspaper £25 holidays and the only money the site made was what was spent in the bar etc. That was just about enough to keep them going. Staggered holidays would be a good thing for them.
Totally agree. It's so hard for tourism destinations - but also for lower income families, the price rises needed to cover the triple whammy of fine for term time absence, Brexit, then covid have made any holidays so expensive that even simple ones are out of reach for many.
sweeneytoddsrazor · 14/04/2022 11:43

Quite a few years ago I stumbled across a programme about a holiday site, cant remember which one and the manager was saying if they had to rely on school holiday bookings they would go out of business. Out of school holiday time 3/4 of the booked accommodation was people taking advantage of the newspaper £25 holidays and the only money the site made was what was spent in the bar etc. That was just about enough to keep them going.
Staggered holidays would be a good thing for them.

OverTheRubicon · 14/04/2022 11:43

@Greyornavy

YANBU

It is a complete pain for teachers with children with different holidays too.

You do realise that most parents in the UK - often on lower annual pay than teachers - get 4-5 weeks holiday, while their children get 13 weeks? I appreciate it's an annoyance, but if other parents can manage this much extra cover, don't think this is worth losing the benefits of not having every family in the UK trying to visit family/go on holiday in the same narrow windows.
Owl55 · 14/04/2022 11:27

Write to your local council as they usually set the holiday dates but academies can choose their own within limits and schools choose their inset days

reluctantbrit · 14/04/2022 11:27

Staggering can help but I think schools in the same LA should have identical holidays, academy or not. It just helps with families who have children in different schools.

We have a academy trust covering both primary and secondary and they coordinate their holidays and most Inset days, making it easier for parents.

Nidan2Sandan · 14/04/2022 11:24

I hear you! I have 3 schools all within a 5 minute drive of each other and all have different school holidays.

Come september I will have a child in each of these schools Confused

Greyornavy · 14/04/2022 11:23

YANBU

It is a complete pain for teachers with children with different holidays too.

x2boys · 14/04/2022 11:19

I have two children at two different schools, as mu youngest is disabled and goes to a special school, both schools are in the same LEA so holidays are roughly the same ,when ds1 was at primary school they used to get just over a week at Easter and two weeks in the end of May and June half term which always differed to ds2 holidays
My boys have both been off for two weeks and go back on Tuesday next week.

OverTheRubicon · 14/04/2022 11:02

Prices won't go down if holidays were staggered. Just the 'off peak' rates will increase to match the 'peak' ones.

That's demonstrably not true. For starters, look at how prices rose dramatically when the fines for term time absence came in. If you're running a family focussed destination or activity, and have 13 weeks of the year to book family holiday makers, you need to charge them far more to break even than if you can spread it over 18 or more weeks due to staggered breaks. The trains will also be far more crowded, and the roads busier and more dangerous.

This isn't about wealthier MNers wanting cheaper Centre Parc stays or ski trips, it's about larger numbers of everyday families wanting a camping space that doesn't cost the same as they used to pay for a static caravan, people not having to hit the roads during the massive train delays happening this Easter bank holiday, or those living in tourist destinations struggling with increased poverty during the very long off season.

Blondeshavemorefun · 14/04/2022 10:20

3 diff schools is unusual

Terms seem to vary over county

So I’m in kent and dd finished fri 1 April and back tue 19

Friends in herts finished week later so fri 8 and go back 25 so actually have whole Easter week off which makes more sense to me

Assume 2 schools yours go to are like that

What’s the third holiday dates

Abraxan · 14/04/2022 09:24

@greenteafiend

I actually think dates should be staggered by region (but roughly standardized within each region). This might reduce the number of days when far-flung cousins can get together, but it would really reduce price gouging. The difference in dates between England and Scotland is already a factor enabling people to get some cheaper deals.
Prices won't go down if holidays were staggered. Just the 'off peak' rates will increase to match the 'peak' ones.

So it's more likely that no one will benefit, and those without children or not working in the school sector will just suffer as a result too.

Staggered holidays make it difficult for people who live near to regional/les boundaries. I know of a number of teaching staff who already have different holidays to their children. It makes life. Ore difficult for extended families, including blended families as well as cousins, etc, too.

poorbuthappy · 14/04/2022 09:16

I have 3 kids in Wales ( 2 different boroughs) plus a DH who's a teacher in England. Every year I have to do the cross reference to make sure any plans fit in with everyone. When the kids were younger there was a lot of different holidays but with the event of the academy we seem to have aligned. I'm hoping all my kids are out of education by the time the Welsh Government attempt to fuck it all up (again).

DDivaStar · 14/04/2022 09:12

I feel your frustration, we have family living away who often have different holidays to us.

But I'd say its also fairly unusual to have 3 children all in different schools.

TheMoth · 14/04/2022 09:04

Borders need to link together too. I teach in one country and my kids go to school in another. If Wales go ahead with their stupid idea of shorter summer holidays and random weeks tagged on elsewhere, it will turn into an absolute nightmare.

Ponoka7 · 14/04/2022 09:02

It does often get proposed, but as said it's unworkable for Faith schools. If the school's come under different LEA's, then the holiday dates wil be different. Places would be swamped if all the children were off together.

CakeBossBaby · 14/04/2022 08:58

@notanothertakeaway

I sympathise with you, but surely, overall, it's better if school holidays are staggered, to avoid everyone trying to take holidays at the same time, which would lead to even higher prices

We're in Scotland. Northumberland in july is full of Scots, as our summer term ends around 30 June

I didn't even think of that Blush
OP posts:
OverTheRubicon · 14/04/2022 08:57

Terrible idea for anyone who wants to go away (holidays but also just travelling to see family), and for locations reliant on tourism.

With so many holidays already aligned, and stricter rules about holidays during term time, even cheaper breaks are now out of reach of many families, and the trains, buses and roads are completely overwhelmed at holiday times.

Better to stagger them more, really.

drspouse · 14/04/2022 08:56

Catholic schools often want different holidays to celebrate Holy Week in school as well.

OctopusSay · 14/04/2022 08:53

Local authorities do have fixed dates, but academies can set their own.

It's swings and roundabouts. Parents whose children are all at the same academy (which must be more usual than 3 different schools?) like the different holidays and it means they can get cheaper holidays/don't have to fight with colleagues for the time off.