Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just when you think this government can't get any worse - now they are going to send asylum seekers to Rwanda

639 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 08:25

I didn't vote for this shower. The problem with people arriving (if they make it) in small boats needs addressing but AIBU that sending them on a one way trip to Rwanda isn't the answer?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Parker231 · 15/04/2022 08:36

Next weeks PMQ’s are going to be entertaining. Kier Starmer is brilliant at using his questions so effectively against Boris. With this latest disaster and Partygate, Boris is going to be totally useless.
The Rwanda idea is there just to appeal to the more racist Brexit voters as a ploy to cover up all the Tory disasters over the last couple of years

Alexandra2001 · 15/04/2022 08:28

Sky is reporting the hostels haven't even been built nor has the private firm that owns the sites, agreed to sell or lease.... the pictures we all have seen are of an ex holiday complex.. one off.

World Service saying locals very angry as their economy is poor and they have no real functioning health service or education system, so all these people will place huge strain on local services.

Alexandra2001 · 15/04/2022 08:25

@AnnesBrokenSlatenes I think you find that Labour have put forward plenty of ideas on migration... so increase foreign so their economies flourish, create more legal ways to come here, reform labour market so that illegal working is much harder, assist EU countries that take far more refugees and work to be able to return refugees.

Of course had Boris not campaigned to leave the EU, we could return economic migrants... why do you think we now have so much illegal migration from the EU now?

Sure we didn't often do that pre brexit but we could have, it was our decision not too.

As for Dead Cat, the tory press always ensure they focus on the latest BJ announcement, its difficult to counter.

Merrymouse · 15/04/2022 08:21

Some information on Rwanda.

Kagame has been in power for 22 years and won his last election (2017) with 98% of the vote.

Same sex marriages are not recognised.

If Boris Johnson can’t recognise why that should raise questions about whether this is a good place to send asylum seekers for processing, I have some wall paper to sell him.

And that’s before you get into the logistics of how this actually operates.

Merrymouse · 15/04/2022 08:11

Indeed you make the point yourself that the ones coming here are choosing to do so because they have family here.

Of course refugees want to go to a place where they have family. Wouldn’t you?

Doris86 · 15/04/2022 08:04

@BewareTheLibrarians I’m well aware that most migrants stay in mainland Europe rather than come to the UK. My point being that the 8% that do cross the channel are coming here by choice, so the argument that they are trying to get to safety in the UK does not stand up.

Indeed you make the point yourself that the ones coming here are choosing to do so because they have family here.

Trainbear · 15/04/2022 07:31

And still the deliberate misunderstanding of asylum seeker, refugee, economic refugee is not clarified.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 15/04/2022 03:02

What a considered contribution to the debate. That will definitely help refugees.

Clumsyvolcano · 15/04/2022 02:59

A racist in power makes for a racist population…

AnnesBrokenSlate · 15/04/2022 02:41

Part of the reason he's able to throw this dead cat on the table is because the other parties are too busy making themselves unelectable or ignoring all the issues with the current asylum system.

Of course, Rwanda is a ridiculous idea but now everyone will froth about it and no other party will feel the need to present a working solution to the refugee crisis. The current crop of Tories are a bunch of grubby, money-grabbing charlatans.

But spare me the other parties' angst when they completely refuse to engage with the issues around asylum, refugees, illegal wars, aid budgets being redirected to defence and everything else that is contributing to the awful situations that create migrant issues.

ChimbarasiKotapaxi · 15/04/2022 02:25

It stinks

lameasahorse · 15/04/2022 02:22

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lameasahorse · 15/04/2022 02:21

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Robinni · 15/04/2022 02:20

@BewareTheLibrarians the whole thing seemed quite sophisticated, and it appeared to me that the set up was get in by any means necessary (boats were discussed, although not his particular route), go under the radar or overstay your welcome. Be facilitated initially by people you know from home who have settled status. Then find a U.K. woman who can get a roof over your head and work cash in hand until you decide to marry her and stay or go back home.

He had come from a nice family, had education, and there was nothing to flee from. He just wanted to go through this “right of passage” as he saw it and to make money. That struck me as wrong.

It’s thwarting the people who actually do need help to my mind, so it needs to be stopped. I still don’t feel comfortable about Rwanda though….

Robinni · 15/04/2022 01:48

[quote BewareTheLibrarians]@Robinni Designer clothes on less than £40 a week? They must have been brilliant at budgeting!

Unless you’re saying they entered as asylum seekers, slipped under the radar and worked cash in hand, unable to rent (they ask for proof of residency now) and obviously not eligible for benefits or a council house? That is obviously a major problem that the UKBA seems occasionally slightly arsed at sorting out. Overstaying without necessity and/or staying illegally is pretty shit, especially as they have a safe home to go to.

He’s super lucky though to make it to the UK safely given how dangerous the journey is. Did he not have problems going home of his own accord on his documents which wouldn’t have shown entry to the UK?[/quote]
@BewareTheLibrarians I don’t know all the ins and outs of it but he and his friend amongst others either came over on holiday or had a years work visa.

The guy I was briefly involved with married a U.K. woman and that enabled him to stay and to leave without penalty.

The one who was deported was found out after a decade of cash in hand work, his partner had tried to apply for tax credits using his details. She went after him and married him. He’s now back.

I got the feeling I was targeted as I had my own home and so I didn’t get any further involved. I was very young at the time.

AKASammyScrounge · 15/04/2022 01:45

@luxxlisbon

This is perhaps one of the most mental things to come out of this government, and that is saying a lot.

I have no idea why they thought this is would go down well??

People didn't speak about party-gate once they heard about Rwanda. Perhaps Rwanda is a distraction. He is also astute enough to touch on people's fears of being overwhelmed by migrants. Illegal migrant numbers are projected to reach 1,000 a day soon.
BewareTheLibrarians · 15/04/2022 00:52

@Zerrin13 Except all but 8% don’t do that (it’s the post directly above yours).

The 8% that do, the vast majority have family or other ties to the UK. Some may only speak English, not French or Italian and feel the risk is worth it to be able to earn money. For survival/family, not designer clothes.

And horrible shit happens on these journeys. Parents separated from children is not as rare as it should be. If you were that parent and heard your child might be in the Uk, would you just put your feet up in France and say, nah he’ll be fine?

If you had distant cousins in the Uk and no-one in Europe would you stay? I remember one of the boys I worked with talking about how he made the decision, if he was worried about his safety doing the crossing from France to the Uk. He said “I didn’t care. I was alone. I was already dead.”

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/04/2022 00:36

@Robinni Designer clothes on less than £40 a week? They must have been brilliant at budgeting!

Unless you’re saying they entered as asylum seekers, slipped under the radar and worked cash in hand, unable to rent (they ask for proof of residency now) and obviously not eligible for benefits or a council house? That is obviously a major problem that the UKBA seems occasionally slightly arsed at sorting out. Overstaying without necessity and/or staying illegally is pretty shit, especially as they have a safe home to go to.

He’s super lucky though to make it to the UK safely given how dangerous the journey is. Did he not have problems going home of his own accord on his documents which wouldn’t have shown entry to the UK?

GiantHaystacks2021 · 15/04/2022 00:29

YANBU.

It's disgraceful.

Robinni · 15/04/2022 00:24

I’m not sure about Rwanda as a location…but there needs to be some sort of a deterrent and something done so that people who genuinely need refuge get it and those who are illegal economic migrants are shipped back.

I once had a Bf from an African country (I won’t name which one) he explained to me coming to the U.K. was like a right of passage. “You come make some money, go home with all your designer clothes and then invest in your community”.

He was a lovely man, however I felt this stance was wrong. He did go home of his own accord eventually, his friend was deported.

Zerrin13 · 15/04/2022 00:02

Ask yourselves a question. You have no choice but to seek refuge in another country. You are escaping a war, you are frightened for your life and the lives of your family, you are prepared to pay criminals a huge sum of money to get you to safety. You arrive in a safe country that offers you shelter. What do you do next? You get on a dinghy and risk being drowned to get to the UK.

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/04/2022 23:06

@Doris86 @AngeloMysterioso and whoever else is asking this question. It’s understandable that social media/mainstream media has done a job in making the public believe that all asylum seekers are coming to the UK rather than staying in continental Europe, but it’s not true.

UNHCR info here:

In the year ending September 2021, Germany received the highest number of asylum applicants (127,730) in the EU+, followed by France (96,510). When compared with the EU+, the UK received the 4th largest number of applicants (44, 190 – including main applicants and dependents). This equates to 8% of the total asylum applicants across the EU+ and UK combined over that period, or the 18th largest intake when measured per head of population.
Germany, France, Spain and Italy accounted for around 70% of all first-time applicants in the EU-27. These figures include all asylum applicants, not just main applicants (i.e. including children and other dependents). World-wide around 85% of all refugees live in developing regions , not in wealthy industrialised countries, and 73% of refugees displaced abroad live in countries neighbouring their countries of origin.

Do you think we should take zero asylum seekers just because we’re a few miles over to the west? What’s the logic? You think other European counties should shoulder all the burden and we shouldn’t, because the North Sea exists?

Receiving 8% of total asylum applicants should not necessitate this level of hysteria.

Parker231 · 14/04/2022 22:37

Many do stay in other European countries - far more than arrive in the U.K. those arriving in the U.K. often choose it as they have family and friends living here.

Doris86 · 14/04/2022 22:35

@AngeloMysterioso

Playing devil’s advocate here- could they really be described as “fleeing” if they’ve travelled through 3 or 4 perfectly safe countries before getting on the boat in Calais? As far as I’m aware there’s no war taking place in France. Or Italy. Or many of the other places they’ve passed through and chosen not to remain in.
Totally agree. They have passed through many safe countries, before reaching the point of crossing the channel to the UK. For whatever, they’ve made the choice they want to come to the UK, rather than needing to, to reach safety.
Parker231 · 14/04/2022 22:35

@Fr0thandBubble

I think it’s a very good thing. We can’t have half the world moving here. The vast majority of people arriving in boats are economic migrants - why else would they arrive with no papers or ID? They throw them in the sea on the way over. And don’t forget they’re coming from France, an entirely safe country.

I despair of all the bleeding heart liberals on her. We can’t take in everyone.

The majority arriving in the U.K. are those escaping wars in countries such as Syria and Afghanistan - ie left behind following actions taken by the West. c75% arriving by boat are subsequently granted the right to remain in the U.K.. After escaping from a war, risking their lives to get to the U.K., what life will they have if they are then sent off to Rwanda? Hardly a safe country to make your life in.
Thankfully I think this latest ridiculous idea by Boris will fail hopelessly due to human rights issues and lack of funding.