Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just when you think this government can't get any worse - now they are going to send asylum seekers to Rwanda

639 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 08:25

I didn't vote for this shower. The problem with people arriving (if they make it) in small boats needs addressing but AIBU that sending them on a one way trip to Rwanda isn't the answer?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
woodhill · 15/04/2022 14:48

@FelicityFlops

Has anyone considered that a lot of this movement is actually human trafficking/organised/financial crime? By removing the asylum seekers from UK soil, they are being protected from further exploitation and possibly being given options and opportunities that would not be available had they remained on UK soil? It will be interesting to see if this move results in a significant reduction in refugees/asylum seekers. Obviously a better final destination might have been desirable & the cost is ridiculous.
Yes that is a good point

Anything to stop the people trafficking which is what is obviously needed

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/04/2022 14:39

@Trainbear Here’s a link to a UK study on migrants and crime rates, which found “The foreign-born share of the population is unrelated to violent crime according to the most recent research findings.”

migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/immigration-and-crime-evidence-for-the-uk-and-other-countries/

Germany had a bigger problem and this article also touches on the reasons - basically if you mistreat and isolate your asylum seeker population and make them unwelcome/know their claims will fail, the crime rate becomes higher. If asylum seekers can be placed with their family, and/or allowed to work or otherwise integrate, the crime rates are lower.

www.reuters.com/article/us-europe-migrants-germany-crime-idUSKBN1ES16J

Basically, treat people like humans is the message there.

As young men (of any nationality) are more likely to commit crimes, increasing the population of young men in any country can be a risk, which is why it’s so important to make sure asylum seekers are properly integrated into communities and learn the cultural norms they need to live by. I personally am very direct and strict when explaining to young men/teenagers I work with that yes, girls here dress differently but that doesn’t mean you can stare or touch, and also explain (appropriately) consent and women’s rights, as I do with my own sons, and what happens if you don’t respect that. Doing that protects both the asylum seekers and the people they interact with.

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/04/2022 13:48

@Trainbear yes that is absolute bollocks (based on studies in Europe and USA - although I’m not sure they officially referred to it as bollocks Smile)

I will find the actual data later, but when asylum seekers do commit crimes it tends to be visa related such as overstaying or working before their claim is processed.

There are extreme outliers too, such as the stabbing at a hotel where asylum seekers were held, where ptsd and mental health problems have been left untreated and exacerbated by living conditions and claims left unprocessed for far too long.

Blossomtoes · 15/04/2022 13:44

No mention of national government:

What you shouldn't do

Produce publicity on matters which are politically controversial
Make references to individual politicians or groups in press releases
Arrange proactive media or events involving candidates
Issue photographs which include candidates
Supply council photographs or other materials to councillors or political group staff unless you have verified that they will not be used for campaigning purposes
Continue hosting third party blogs or e-communications
Help with national political visits, as this would involve using public money to support a particular candidate or party. These should be organised by political parties with no cost or resource implications for the council.

Trainbear · 15/04/2022 13:40

Discussing this with a friend. They said about the high number of crimes committed by asylum seekers/failed asylum seekers, refugees in the UK. I cannot see these figures anywhere to check or see if she is wrong. Does anyone have a link to a verified independent source of information?

MarshaBradyo · 15/04/2022 13:39

Never mind it breaches the electoral rules too

I had a look as interested, as had not heard of this but I don’t think it does.

‘On 5 May 2022, local elections are taking place in across Scotland and Wales, in London, and some English authorities.
For UK and devolved government departments the pre-election period for local elections is not fixed to any particular date. The general convention is that special care should be taken in the three weeks preceding the elections. In 2022, that will be 14 April to 5 May.’

‘ commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn05262/

theDudesmummy · 15/04/2022 13:34

This is an interesting angle which I had not thought of, re how this "plan" would make things more dangerous if it were to actually happen

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/apr/14/rwanda-asylum-seeker-plan-is-just-a-senseless-soundbite

theDudesmummy · 15/04/2022 12:49

What will push through is the money. The rest will be a complete mess.

Blossomtoes · 15/04/2022 12:47

Never mind it breaches the electoral rules too

I’m not sure it does, I think purdah only applies to government in general elections, it’s applied locally for local ones.

I can’t see it happening either @Puzzledandpissedoff. They can’t even sort out the red tape for the refugees they’re welcoming with open arms.

MarriedThreeChildren · 15/04/2022 12:44

@mrshoho

I'm worried that by regarding this as a mere distraction it will push through. The headline today is that they will be ready to commence within weeks. I think it's a big mistake.
I agree.

Whether it’s a distraction or not, it needs to be addressed.
And I wouldn’t address it as a moral issue as such (even though IT IS a immoral) but as a cost issue (billion of pounds every year) , with total lack of efficiency (Israel tried that and it didn’t work).
I have enough to see this government spending our taxes on crap and nothing in what will make a real difference to the population whilst walking all over their manifesto pledge.
Enough!

MarriedThreeChildren · 15/04/2022 12:41

@mrshoho

Judging by the 44% YABU votes there are many people who believe this awful plan to be acceptable.
There is a reason why BJ and Patel brought that now, just before the MY elections… same with the trans agenda.

Never mind it breaches the electoral rules too.

Or it’s not manageable - I mean they find find BILLIONS of pounds to send a few thousands of people in a foreign country but they can’t do the same for the NHS? How?!?

It’s about those awful immigrants arriving in dinghies that are swamping our shores!!!! We are being invaded!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/04/2022 12:27

I'm worried that by regarding this as a mere distraction it will push through

I find that's the benefit of following more than just the latest shrieking headline
Even if they really do push ahead with it there's no way this incompetent government will be able to organise things within weeks, so there'll be plenty of time to act if there's any evidence it's actually being done

I strongly suspect, though, that the furthest it'll get is some funding being found, which will instantly be grabbed by the cronies

mrshoho · 15/04/2022 12:13

Judging by the 44% YABU votes there are many people who believe this awful plan to be acceptable.

mrshoho · 15/04/2022 12:10

I'm worried that by regarding this as a mere distraction it will push through. The headline today is that they will be ready to commence within weeks. I think it's a big mistake.

badspella · 15/04/2022 12:05

As others have said, this is a distraction from 'Partygate' and a potential sweetener for people who may want to see 'action' being taken on 'illegal immigration'.

However, even as a distraction, the racism and inhumanity of the people who propose this is apparent. Certain 'migrants' will be sent to Rwanda. Others fleeing from war will be offered sanctuary. To put is another way, brown or black people fleeing from war and atrocity, will be sent to a place infamous for past genocide, current human rights violations and people trafficking. White European people fleeing from war will be invited into our homes.
How will the government distinguish between the man from Afghanistan who is fleeing for his life, and the man from Afghanistan who is fleeing for a better life?
I know this is not a Tory-bashing thread, and I do have a great deal of respect for Conservatives, but this government (whatever it is) completely mismanaged the Coronavirus situation, leading to a large number of preventable deaths (especially among the disabled); they lied completely about Brexit (a 'done deal' still very undone) and they broke the laws with little more than a petty fine.
Boris is hiding behind a situation of atrocity, by playing some kind of (ineffective) superhero, whilst showing he cares very little about people who do not serve his purpose. This proposal is racist to the core.

theDudesmummy · 15/04/2022 10:57

A numpty minister called Pursglove calls Rwanda a "progressive country". Well yes, it is, in the sense that it has progressed and improved since being the site of a huge genocide, sure.

theDudesmummy · 15/04/2022 10:49

And this

Just when you think this government can't get any worse - now they are going to send asylum seekers to Rwanda
weleasewoderick23 · 15/04/2022 10:45

@longwayoff

The only thing missing from this policy stolen from 1930s Germany is somebody sporting a small mustache.
Too true. The nazi's wanted to send Jews to Madagascar to get rid of the "problem". Look at how that ended ......
BewareTheLibrarians · 15/04/2022 10:43

Ahaha 🤡Sad

Just when you think this government can't get any worse - now they are going to send asylum seekers to Rwanda
BewareTheLibrarians · 15/04/2022 10:37

@mrziggycoco

Single male economic migrants only.
Nope. The Home Office documents state it will be men, women and families. It’s thought only unaccompanied children will be allowed to stay in the Uk.
theDudesmummy · 15/04/2022 10:36

@BeinBedEarly maybe read the thread? Main reason is joining family. And contrary to opinion propaganda most migrants/refugees don't try to get to the UK, they go to other places.

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/04/2022 10:35

@BeinBedEarly that’s already been answered on this thread, see my response to Zerrin a few posts upthread.

theDudesmummy · 15/04/2022 10:34

@cushioncovers surely you can see that is a ridiculous question?

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/04/2022 10:33

@FelicityFlops

Has anyone considered that a lot of this movement is actually human trafficking/organised/financial crime? By removing the asylum seekers from UK soil, they are being protected from further exploitation and possibly being given options and opportunities that would not be available had they remained on UK soil? It will be interesting to see if this move results in a significant reduction in refugees/asylum seekers. Obviously a better final destination might have been desirable & the cost is ridiculous.
Unfortunately the human trafficking doesn’t start in Calais, it starts where the asylum seekers are coming from. Libya for eg, where a lot of asylum seekers will cross to Europe from, is a hotbed of slavery, taking advantage of the desperation people have to get to safety. This scheme sadly won’t do anything to combat that.
BeinBedEarly · 15/04/2022 10:33

Why can’t these asylum seekers seek asylum in France? What is it about this country that makes them travel through Europe and pay huge sums to gangs to get to us?