Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just when you think this government can't get any worse - now they are going to send asylum seekers to Rwanda

639 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 08:25

I didn't vote for this shower. The problem with people arriving (if they make it) in small boats needs addressing but AIBU that sending them on a one way trip to Rwanda isn't the answer?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2022 10:44

If you think we dont have room, Rwanda definitely doesnt @ParsleySageRosemary.

ParsleySageRosemary · 16/04/2022 07:08

This is so weird and I don’t know how much it’s going to cost the country - does anyone? Why Rwanda, a country that was committing genocide not that long ago, apart from the point that the U.K. can obviously bully them into something now but couldn’t stop the genocide then?

It does raise the point again that we simply haven’t got the room to support all these displaced human populations. There are millions on the move, between war and climate change.

Merrymouse · 16/04/2022 06:58

@FelicityFlops

Has anyone considered that a lot of this movement is actually human trafficking/organised/financial crime? By removing the asylum seekers from UK soil, they are being protected from further exploitation and possibly being given options and opportunities that would not be available had they remained on UK soil? It will be interesting to see if this move results in a significant reduction in refugees/asylum seekers. Obviously a better final destination might have been desirable & the cost is ridiculous.
How does moving people to Rwanda protect people from further exploitation? The Tories who have defended this on the radio have not demonstrated any interest in or knowledge of Rwanda or even the detail of the scheme.
theDudesmummy · 16/04/2022 06:55

@MangyInseam this, from my reading of it, is not intended to be a camp where people are accommodated while their applications are processed. It is a permanent one way ticket (to one of the poorest and most densely populated countries on earth). Anyway, the amount of people and organisations now coming out and saying it cannot work is quite remarkable. It was never intended to work. Just some Save Big Dog crap plus a nice bit of jackbootery for the DM readers ahead of the local elections.

Merrymouse · 16/04/2022 06:51

@mrshoho

Judging by the 44% YABU votes there are many people who believe this awful plan to be acceptable.
And workable, which similarly surprising/worrying.
MangyInseam · 16/04/2022 01:37

This seems to me like a complicated plan that won't be very effective. Rwanda seems like an odd choice, not close to where the people are coming from. Maybe someone earlier in the thread mentioned why it was chosen but at face value it seems odd.

However, the concept is already widely accepted for processing large numbers of refugees, because the method of just having people find their way to wherever they can doesn't really work either.
There are already many many camps like this where people wait to have their applications to all kinds of different countries processed. Usually they are as close as possible to where the people are fleeing from. It does also often involve background ckecks

I'm not sure I buy the argument that refugees from Ukraine or any other place should be treated differently than others, just because their situation is in the news at the moment. And it's also the case that when there are large numbers, it becomes a real administrative problem to try and find places for all without overwhelming services, which is a real possibility. I've worked in an organization that supports refugees local to me for a while in a volunteer type capacity, and we've actually stopped accepting applications for now because there is no housing where we are - many people are living in shelters or tents already. While the international refugee system is in concept a deeply humanitarian idea, in execution it probably isn't an answer to the problems of displacement of masses of people.

Fulmine · 15/04/2022 23:38

It's now coming out that, most unusually, this policy has been signed off by Patel on a ministerial direction, which means that the Permanent Secretary felt he couldn't sign it.

Fulmine · 15/04/2022 18:00

Denmark made a deal to do this a year ago, but hasn't actually sent anyone. Probably for all the reasons that we won't be sending anyone, either.

SpinningMeSoftly · 15/04/2022 17:52

Aren't the Danes planning to do the same thing? They seem a pretty well adjusted society

Well if they are, they ain't now.

Newnamefor2022 · 15/04/2022 17:49

@VestaTilley

It’s abominable. Even for them, a new low.
Aren't the Danes planning to do the same thing? They seem a pretty well adjusted society.
TooBigForMyBoots · 15/04/2022 17:46

Don’t be taken in…

But they will be taken in because, just like the eminem/Rhianna song, they love the way this government lies.

DesidaCrick · 15/04/2022 17:39

@theDudesmummy

It is quite "world-beating" to come up with a plan which is simultaneously expensive, immoral, illegal and completely unworkable, I will give them that. Lessons will be learned. Pockets will be lined.
This…

It won’t work. There will be legal challenges. It’s just a distraction from party gate. Don’t be taken in…

theDudesmummy · 15/04/2022 17:29

It is quite "world-beating" to come up with a plan which is simultaneously expensive, immoral, illegal and completely unworkable, I will give them that. Lessons will be learned. Pockets will be lined.

TooBigForMyBoots · 15/04/2022 17:13

Israel sent their refugees to Rwanda, it didn't work so they stopped as people were pretty much handed to the traffickers.

This is a waste of money and a waste of time by our waste of space government.

MarshaBradyo · 15/04/2022 17:10

@theDudesmummy

Let's not bring that whole "transphobia" thing into this thread, that is not a "left v right" issue whereas this fascist refugee plan definitely is...
Yes it’s a shame it’s being used in this way

Mn is one of the few spaces where women can discuss their rights without attacks. Although we still get some.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 15/04/2022 17:08

Theres a strong and vocal right wing authoritarian contingent on MN
Completely agree so I'm sadly not surprised by the results either.
Been here years and it never used to be like this, I'd have said it was more left wing when first started MNetting, past few years have become more and more extreme, it's pretty scary really in my opinion.

theDudesmummy · 15/04/2022 17:03

Let's not bring that whole "transphobia" thing into this thread, that is not a "left v right" issue whereas this fascist refugee plan definitely is...

MarshaBradyo · 15/04/2022 16:42

Theres a strong and vocal right wing authoritarian contingent on MN, came for the transphobia and stayed for the racism

No I don’t think so. There’s many who care about women’s rights who are attacked in this way, but I don’t agree.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 15/04/2022 16:39

@mrshoho

Judging by the 44% YABU votes there are many people who believe this awful plan to be acceptable.
Theres a strong and vocal right wing authoritarian contingent on MN, came for the transphobia and stayed for the racism
BewareTheLibrarians · 15/04/2022 16:13

@MarriedThreeChildren
I’m not 100% sure I understand what you’re saying (which is probably due to my brain, not how you’ve written it Blush) Is the problem the technical definition of the term asylum seeker, or the fact that they’re not considered as in need if a safe route is given closer to their country?

This is from Amnesty International on the kind of safe route scheme I’m thinking of:

“Accordingly, as regards people seeking asylum, Amnesty International UK calls upon the Government to both:
• make safe and legal routes available (to reduce exploitation, abuse, loss of life and other harms; and to reduce opportunity for smugglers and traffickers); and
• respect and protect the rights of all women, men and children seeking asylum to do so (including in the UK and including by such other routes as they may need to take).”

MarriedThreeChildren · 15/04/2022 15:53

@BewareTheLibrarians

No, I agree *@woodhill* The government could set up safe routes to the UK (it’s their refusal to do this that has increased dangerous boat crossing and strain on Kent) but they won’t.

That way they can play off people arriving in boats as out of their control, and pander to their right wing base by appearing to be “strong on immigration”.

Ultimately though by refusing to set up safe routes to the UK they’re unwittingly increasing uncontrolled immigration.

What can we do? Let your mp know you think this scheme is abhorrent, and ask your mp to push for safe routes to the UK to reduce dangerous boat crossings.

Sorry @BewareTheLibrarians but I’d you set up safe routes for people to come to the U.K., then they are NOT a asylum seekers.

The whole thing about seeking asylums is that you arrive in that country illegally, that you can only claim asylum once you are in the country.

What you are describing is not helping asylum seekers. It’s supporting people leave dangerous places but that’s not getting asylum.
And tbh it also assumes the system isn’t completely bonkers and crazy complicated (like what they’ve done for CHILDREN coming from Ukraine).

littledrummergirl · 15/04/2022 15:08

Will those who have travelled from Rwanda and are waiting for a decision have to return there while they wait?
This seems a little um strange, especially if the meme above about 100% of Rwanda claims in 2020 were successful.

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/04/2022 14:59

No, I agree @woodhill The government could set up safe routes to the UK (it’s their refusal to do this that has increased dangerous boat crossing and strain on Kent) but they won’t.

That way they can play off people arriving in boats as out of their control, and pander to their right wing base by appearing to be “strong on immigration”.

Ultimately though by refusing to set up safe routes to the UK they’re unwittingly increasing uncontrolled immigration.

What can we do? Let your mp know you think this scheme is abhorrent, and ask your mp to push for safe routes to the UK to reduce dangerous boat crossings.

woodhill · 15/04/2022 14:55

What would make it better though, I don't think the situation can continue like this

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/04/2022 14:53

@woodhill As I replied to that post,

Unfortunately the human trafficking doesn’t start in Calais, it starts where the asylum seekers are coming from. Libya for eg, where a lot of asylum seekers will cross to Europe from, is a hotbed of slavery, taking advantage of the desperation people have to get to safety. This scheme sadly won’t do anything to combat that.