Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just when you think this government can't get any worse - now they are going to send asylum seekers to Rwanda

639 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 08:25

I didn't vote for this shower. The problem with people arriving (if they make it) in small boats needs addressing but AIBU that sending them on a one way trip to Rwanda isn't the answer?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Unphased · 19/04/2022 13:53

BewareTheLibrarians
I think you would be very surprised outside your little bubble

SleeplessInEngland · 19/04/2022 13:47

It's strange that 'economic migrant' has become a dirty term. Willing to work and be taxed? Good! The UK is kidding itself if it thinks it doesn't need you...

BewareTheLibrarians · 19/04/2022 13:44

Sorry just re the “why don’t they stay in closer countries” question. The vast majority of asylum seekers do.

“World-wide around 85% of all refugees live in developing regions , not in wealthy industrialised countries, and 73% of refugees displaced abroad live in countries neighbouring their countries of origin.”

www.unhcr.org/uk/asylum-in-the-uk.html

But that’s been covered before on these threads, hasn’t it?

BewareTheLibrarians · 19/04/2022 13:40

@Unphased

BewareTheLibrarians I would imagine a very large percentage of the U.K. think it’s money wasted, especially at the moment
Haha, no. Not by a long shot. The voices like yours are loud but not a majority.
BewareTheLibrarians · 19/04/2022 13:39

@Unphased I work with asylum seekers so I’m well aware of what work and training they do when their claims are agreed. Are you?

You seem a bit unaware that the reason that some asylum seekers go on to be doctors, engineers, high skilled jobs, is because that’s what they were doing before their country went to shit with civil wars etc. or are you one of those who thinks that all people from the Middle East and Africa are unskilled and uncivilised?

And for anger perspective, in my last cohort I had a group go on to be HVAC engineers, plumbers and electricians, including those who’d had no access to education due to wars and poverty. They worked so hard to get to where they are. They earn more money than I do, therefore pay more taxes than I do. Being young and fit, they’re more likely to be net contributors to our economy, although I probably shouldn’t tell you that in case you start demanding to ship our disabled and elderly to Rwanda instead.

Btw, our population density is much lower than Rwanda’s. UK = 281 per km2, Rwanda = 525 per km2.

Parker231 · 19/04/2022 13:34

@Unphased

Parker231 Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Kuwait, Pakistan, plenty of countries around them, why risk coming all the way here?
Not exactly safe countries with a good human rights record!
SleeplessInEngland · 19/04/2022 13:32

"Yes of course, I forgot that all migrants go on to be doctors, etc, yes they have kids and the population grows so we need more people to service the people that are here, what would you say is the max population a tiny island like ours can sub stain?"

Actually the UK has a massive shortage of unskilled workers. If you're trying to make this an economic argument instead of an ideological one at least get the basics right.

Unphased · 19/04/2022 13:31

BewareTheLibrarians
I would imagine a very large percentage of the U.K. think it’s money wasted, especially at the moment

Unphased · 19/04/2022 13:30

Parker231
Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Kuwait, Pakistan, plenty of countries around them, why risk coming all the way here?

Unphased · 19/04/2022 13:26

Parker231
If they didn’t try to come here, there would be know problem

Unphased · 19/04/2022 13:25

BewareTheLibrarians
Yes of course, I forgot that all migrants go on to be doctors, etc, yes they have kids and the population grows so we need more people to service the people that are here, what would you say is the max population a tiny island like ours can sub stain?

Parker231 · 19/04/2022 13:19

@Unphased

BewareTheLibrarians If they didn’t come, no money would be wasted on them, it could be used for more good in this country,
Where do you think the Syrians and Afghans should go when escaping the troubles in their own countries? Money isn’t being wasted on them - the U.K. government system is poor and takes way too long but the majority have the rights to stay in the U.K.
BewareTheLibrarians · 19/04/2022 13:18

“Wasted”?? Jesus Christ just stop it. These are humans you are talking about. Humans that go on to be doctors, nurses, fill skilled labour gaps, have families, have kids. Humans that pay taxes in the UK.

“Wasted” is a sick comment and I’m shocked that you think it’s ok to say.

lameasahorse · 19/04/2022 13:17

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

BewareTheLibrarians · 19/04/2022 13:15

At some point are people going to realise that:

• the amount of dangerous crossings is because of the government and their refusal to set up safe routes and resettlement schemes? They’re choosing not to control the number of people arriving in boats. Why?

• People feeling like some places in Kent are being “overwhelmed” by asylum seekers is because of the government and their refusal to set up safe routes?

• Money being “wasted” on housing asylum seekers is because of the government and their inability to process asylum claims on time?

• the shortage of housing, gps, community services, refuges and the rise in food banks, child poverty is all because of the government and their commitment to austerity?

Demonising a group of people in a shit situation (asylum seekers) does nothing to fix any of that.

Or is it just easier to pick on people who don’t look like you?

Unphased · 19/04/2022 13:10

BewareTheLibrarians
If they didn’t come, no money would be wasted on them, it could be used for more good in this country,

BewareTheLibrarians · 19/04/2022 13:06

@Unphased If you think they’re just economic migrants, then why are over 70% of asylum claims accepted (and more on appeal)? Are you saying the government are doing a shit job of that too? Better vote in a new one then!

I take it you’ve missed all the analysis that shows sending asylum seekers to Rwanda is going to be more expensive than the current situation? That Priti Patel had to override her parliamentary secretary as the Rwanda plan wasn’t cost efficient?

Plus the fact that so much money has to be spent on accommodation because the government takes too long too assess asylum claims? They should be completed in 6 months, but cases are now waiting over 18 months. That’s your money being wasted because of government inefficiency.

Unphased · 19/04/2022 12:59

Merrymouse
Let’s get them all out to Rwanda, where they can all apply for asylum, then decisions can be made backed up by any evidence, freeing up are hotels and bedsits at the cost of 4 million a day and rising

Unphased · 19/04/2022 12:55

lameasahorse
There you are again, presuming every migrant is fleeing a war torn area, not just an economic migrant

lameasahorse · 19/04/2022 12:40

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Merrymouse · 19/04/2022 12:37

The genuine asylum seekers will have papers etc

I’m interested to know what you think life is like if you are in a position where you need to claim asylum in another country.

Merrymouse · 19/04/2022 12:34

@Unphased

I think a lot of people on here, need to know the difference between genuine asylum seekers and just economic migrants, I’m sorry but which ever you look at it, it can’t be acceptable for people to just land here on boats, ( security, health, economic risk )
And you can easily tell the difference by….?
BewareTheLibrarians · 19/04/2022 12:33

@Unphased I’m quite confused by your answer, especially where you ask “how many more do you want us to have?” Where on earth did you see that in my post, or did you just assume?

Did you read the part where I said safe routes can control numbers, ie reduce them if the government want? Because I didn’t say anywhere that I want us to have more. The government is forcing boat crossings therefore uncontrolled, higher numbers.

Also, no, genuine asylum seekers don’t “always” have papers. They might not have passports or ID in their own country. And if they do, the people traffickers often steal their documents to make sure they’re paid. They don’t give them back, not being the most moral bunch.

As for your last point, it might ease your panic to look at how many family reunion cases go through. It’s not as much as you seem to fear.

Unphased · 19/04/2022 12:25

BewareTheLibrarians
We are already one off the mostly densely populated countries in Europe, how many more do you want us to have?
The genuine asylum seekers will have papers etc, it’s the ones that have nothing after burn or destroying proof of nationality or age,
It’s all well and good going down the family route, but it’s amazing how many members of one family there is

BewareTheLibrarians · 19/04/2022 12:18

@Unphased People just landing here on boats is something that this government could reduce a lot more (and a lot more cheaply) by setting up safe routes and resettlement schemes to the UK. That would be the fabled “controlling our borders” that this government promised to do, as resettlement schemes could have set numbers and allow the spread of asylum seekers around the country, rather than overwhelming Kent. Why are people who voted for this government letting them get away with breaking this promise?

By shutting down all safe routes into the UK, this government is doing nothing to stop uncontrolled and dangerous boat crossings - which also line the pockets of the people traffickers.

Are people aware that, apart from UNHCR resettlement schemes which only take a very small number, and family reunion schemes which again take a small number, there are NO safe, legal routes for asylum seekers to come to the UK?

If you really want your brain melting, have a look at this, from the Government:

“There are no safe and legal routes for people seeking asylum. The immigration rules make no provision for any person to come (or apply to come) to the UK for the purpose of making an asylum claim.
While there is no provision in the rules for permitting a person to come to the UK for the purpose of seeking asylum, Home Office policy is explicit that no claim for asylum in the UK will be considered unless made by a person who is already in the UK.”

www.amnesty.org.uk/files/2021-01/Amnesty%20International%20UK%20-%20Safe%20and%20Legal%20Routes%20Briefing_0.pdf

I mean, it’s 🤡.

You can’t claim asylum outside the UK. You can’t come to the UK to claim asylum. But you can only claim asylum in the UK.