Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just when you think this government can't get any worse - now they are going to send asylum seekers to Rwanda

639 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 08:25

I didn't vote for this shower. The problem with people arriving (if they make it) in small boats needs addressing but AIBU that sending them on a one way trip to Rwanda isn't the answer?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Soffit · 14/04/2022 12:20

@MarriedThreeChildren

Do you remember 5 years ago when the tories were all supporting LePen in the French elections and going on how great they were and had the same ideas than them etc…? Did no one then realised that LePen is the far right and therefore it means that Tories are now a far right party?

Are you all just realising that?

Fwiw the idea of sending people to Rwanda is not new. Patel tried a few different countries before. Maybe she found one now that would agree for money, who knows.
Why sending people to Rwanda is less acceptable then sending to Cyprus, whatever isolated island in the Atlantic etc… I’m nit sure though. The aim and the result is the same.

Not really. Racism in France is on a completely different level. Our left is probably equivalent to their moderate right. There is a reason why the migrants are passionately against it.
DowningStreetParty · 14/04/2022 12:20

It’s a completely bizarre and vastly more expensive way of dealing with the issues and it looks like a huge cynical distraction ploy from our shameful lawbreaking PM Boris Johnson. Who should have resigned yesterday.

Fulmine · 14/04/2022 12:19

@Unphased

Fulmine Yes, set up in Rwanda
How exactly does an appeal system set up in Rwanda work, then, @Unphased? Shall we massively increase legal aid so that appellants' lawyers can access them in Rwanda and go there for appeal hearings? Are we going to send Immigration Judges over to Rwanda? If or when the appeals go in the appellants' favour, how do we enforce them if, for instance, Rwanda doesn't get around to sending them back to the UK?
theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 12:18

@OctopusSay many of them have relatives in the UK. So it could be the difference between living an undignified homeless existence in a camp in Calais or sleeping on your cousins's sofa in Birmingham. I know which I would choose.

MarriedThreeChildren · 14/04/2022 12:18

Do you remember 5 years ago when the tories were all supporting LePen in the French elections and going on how great they were and had the same ideas than them etc…?
Did no one then realised that LePen is the far right and therefore it means that Tories are now a far right party?

Are you all just realising that?

Fwiw the idea of sending people to Rwanda is not new. Patel tried a few different countries before. Maybe she found one now that would agree for money, who knows.
Why sending people to Rwanda is less acceptable then sending to Cyprus, whatever isolated island in the Atlantic etc… I’m nit sure though. The aim and the result is the same.

Choopi · 14/04/2022 12:17

Only because we have chosen to give them visas before they arrive. If we did the same for other refugees, then they wouldn't be asylum seekers either. The principal is the same.

Of course. Temporary visas could be offered to Afghans and Syrians too. I think a lot people would be in favour in this. A year or 2 in the UK then off you go back home.

OctopusSay · 14/04/2022 12:17

@AlexaShutUp

They aren't asylum seekers.

Only because we have chosen to give them visas before they arrive. If we did the same for other refugees, then they wouldn't be asylum seekers either. The principal is the same.

It's not. Asylum seekers are escaping political persecution.

Refugees are usually escaping war.

Neither will typically have a visa.

GatoradeMeBitch · 14/04/2022 12:17

They've signed the agreement. I imagine both political sides will be keen to get it going. It has an unpleasant colonial whiff about it though, delegating our issues to an African country. It's very clearly a threat, not something organized with anyone's welfare in mind. But DM readers will be thrilled that we're sending some people with dark skin off to Africa - it literally sounds like a plan made up by bigots in a pub.

And we haven't been told anything about the Rwanda side. Unsuccessful applicants - apparently all men - will be urged to begin a new life there. What do people from Rwanda think about this?

I think if this happens it's going to make us look shameful as a country.

theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 12:15

One of my roles for many years has been working with mentally disordered offenders, many of whom are "illegals" ie have no residence status. It is extremely common (and rightly so) for the human rights/immigration lawyers be able to resist deportation on mental health grounds, if the country the patient is to be deported to has a lesser mental health care system and/or medication vital to the person's health are not available here (or are only available for sums which are outside the person's means). Rwanda is one such country. Many asylum seekers have mental health problems. The lawyers will fight this scheme all the way (if it is a real thing, which I seriously doubt) and it will be untenable.

Unless the UK is intending to set up a health care service in Rwanda which rivals NHS services and has the same very expensive medications available? I don't think so.

SleeplessInEngland · 14/04/2022 12:14

@Soffit

I don't know about English lessons but they would be better off training Tom Daley style in multi-sports: rowing (across the Channel) /swimming (just in case you fall off the dinghy) /cycling (well, you never know!) / ultramarathon (sprint into Kent before Border Force catch you and send you to Rwanda). Of course, the majority of takers will be young male economic migrants but there will be a hell of a lot more of them than before.
Sounds exhausting. If someone's willing to go through all that then good luck to 'em.
AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 12:14

They aren't asylum seekers.

Only because we have chosen to give them visas before they arrive. If we did the same for other refugees, then they wouldn't be asylum seekers either. The principal is the same.

Fulmine · 14/04/2022 12:14

@Babdoc

It is all very well to condemn the plan to send them to Rwanda, but what is your alternative? The UK does not have sufficient housing for our own population. Waiting lists for council accommodation are soaring, houses are unaffordable, and we are one of the most densely populated countries in Europe. Migrant numbers would involve building a new city every year. And that doesn’t include provision for their future children. So what do you suggest, OP?
Not actually true. We do have sufficient housing for own population, the problem is that our housing system is incredibly inefficient.
Flapjacker48 · 14/04/2022 12:13

The Tories are clever - there is some hand-wringing on places like MN and Twitter about this, but they know the vast majority of voters do want immigration reduced, especially illegal immigration. Watch Labour struggle to say anything coherent about this without it descending into verbose, vague statements compare this to:

"Boris and the Tories want to reduce immigration and care about women - they have my vote!"

However true/practical this it will appeal to the electorate.

Choopi · 14/04/2022 12:11

@AlexaShutUp

Is that not just where most asylum seekers come from right now though? I'm not sure there are many asylum seekers coming from white-majority countries are there?

Ukraine?

They aren't asylum seekers.
Soffit · 14/04/2022 12:11

I don't know about English lessons but they would be better off training Tom Daley style in multi-sports:
rowing (across the Channel) /swimming (just in case you fall off the dinghy) /cycling (well, you never know!) / ultramarathon (sprint into Kent before Border Force catch you and send you to Rwanda).
Of course, the majority of takers will be young male economic migrants but there will be a hell of a lot more of them than before.

OctopusSay · 14/04/2022 12:10

Ukrainians aren't asylum seekers. There's a very careful distinction.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/04/2022 12:10

What should people do then when our leader publicly details the intended plan?

Simple - treat it like all the other attention-seeking nonsense he spouts, but keep an eye on anything that really matters to see what comes next

9 times out of 10 nothing will happen once the headline's been relished and possibly a few backhanders doled out, and in the few cases where anything really does start up, that's the time to start getting enraged

OctopusSay · 14/04/2022 12:09

@Hospedia

There's also the fact the people with viable options do not tend to get on unsafe, overloaded boats with a high risk of drowning during the crossing. They're desperate people who see it as the least shitty option of several shitty options. This scheme isn't going to deter them.
I have to admit I don't fully understand this position. Yes, of course re crossing the Med, but it doesn't make sense for crossing the Channel.

I understand of course, why they'd prefer to be in UK, where they'll often know people and have some of the language, but why is it still worth such dire risk to life once they're safe in France or elsewhere in Europe?

AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 12:07

Is that not just where most asylum seekers come from right now though? I'm not sure there are many asylum seekers coming from white-majority countries are there?

Ukraine?

Parker231 · 14/04/2022 12:06

@SleeplessInEngland

Interestingly, the government's own website advises that if you're LGBT you shouldn't travel to Rwanda. So that's good.
According to Boris, Rwanda is one of the safest countries in the world!
AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 12:06

@theDudesmummy

I don't believe this is actually going to happen. It's a disgusting cynical dogwhisle to the far right, to noth deflect from Big Dog's myriad problems and shore up the right wing vote, because that is the only vote they are going to get going forward.

I am very very glad I left.

Agree. They have no intention of actually implementing this.
OctopusSay · 14/04/2022 12:05

Apparently (according to the article) more than 28000 people crossed the channel this was last year and this facility will be able to deal with up to 100 at a time, 500 pa and cost £120m. Is that pa? To set up? Forever?

So even if it was a great idea, it will barely scratch the surface anyway. And how will it be a deterent if the chances of going to Rwanda are far lower than not going to Rwanda?

Choopi · 14/04/2022 12:05

@MythicalBiologicalFennel

Australia does have a similar system. From where I am it looks like a way of shoving refugees somewhere out of sight basically hoping they will either die or go away. Read on the BBC that only people from "countries like Syria or Afghanistan" will be sent to Rwanda. Does this mean that white, non-muslim refugees will be treated differently then?
Is that not just where most asylum seekers come from right now though? I'm not sure there are many asylum seekers coming from white-majority countries are there?
theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 12:04

I don't believe this is actually going to happen. It's a disgusting cynical dogwhisle to the far right, to noth deflect from Big Dog's myriad problems and shore up the right wing vote, because that is the only vote they are going to get going forward.

I am very very glad I left.

Parker231 · 14/04/2022 12:04

Saw this on Twitter

Three points on Rwanda policy.

  1. Last year Australia spent £461m to process 239 asylum seekers offshore
  2. The UK is spending £120m
  3. 600 people crossed the Channel on Wednesday

So either this is a stunt, to deter and ease political pressure or a lot more money will be needed