Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just when you think this government can't get any worse - now they are going to send asylum seekers to Rwanda

639 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 08:25

I didn't vote for this shower. The problem with people arriving (if they make it) in small boats needs addressing but AIBU that sending them on a one way trip to Rwanda isn't the answer?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
HRTQueen · 14/04/2022 12:38

Set out plans and look at the reaction …

OctopusSay · 14/04/2022 12:37

@theDudesmummy

People tend to go where they have relatives if they can. The UK is a big country (population-wise) and has (greatly to its benefit) a lot of people from other countries living in it. This increases the chances that people are going to have a relative in the UK. Not everyone tries to come to the UK. There are plenty wanting to settle in Germany, Scandinavia, etc wherever their relatives live.

The narrative that its about the UK benefits system in some way is a right-wing trope and utterly wrong.

I don't think it's about benefits either, they hope to work and support themselves, eventually and I understand the family reasons etc for preferring to be here, but I don't understand why that preference is worth dying for.
Blossomtoes · 14/04/2022 12:37

@HRTQueen

Well it’s a vote winner

I don’t understand how Europe collectively have not been able to manage this issue better

Is it? I wouldn’t be too sure about that.
HRTQueen · 14/04/2022 12:36

Tories have been looking to the next election form the day after the last election

This is why they win …. If it backfires (which I don’t think it will with many of their supporters) they will pull the plug in this and also has time to be stopped in other ways

Labour need to learn from this set our plans look forward the reaction and learn

AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 12:35

It's worrying when the people who are debating these topics don't even have a basic understanding of the terms that they are using. We will never have a humane policy towards those fleeing war and persecution if people remain ignorant of the basic facts.

OctopusSay · 14/04/2022 12:35

@HRTQueen

Well it’s a vote winner

I don’t understand how Europe collectively have not been able to manage this issue better

Maybe because the UK made it clear we didn't want to be part of any European solution?
theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 12:34

People tend to go where they have relatives if they can. The UK is a big country (population-wise) and has (greatly to its benefit) a lot of people from other countries living in it. This increases the chances that people are going to have a relative in the UK. Not everyone tries to come to the UK. There are plenty wanting to settle in Germany, Scandinavia, etc wherever their relatives live.

The narrative that its about the UK benefits system in some way is a right-wing trope and utterly wrong.

SleeplessInEngland · 14/04/2022 12:33

"Well it’s a vote winner"

Nah. An election's two years away and the boats will keep coming.

FrenchMustard · 14/04/2022 12:33

I also had to check the date today. They have lost the plot....how on earth do they think this will save peoples lives? It isn't going to curb human trafficking, the traffickers still get their money and they don't give a flying fuck what happens to the people being trafficked.

I thought they had reached a new low when they said it was ok to shoot dinghies in the channel, but this is something else.

Dont even get me started on how they have the money for this and yet they will do absolutely jack shit about the cost of living crisis they created.

HRTQueen · 14/04/2022 12:33

Well it’s a vote winner

I don’t understand how Europe collectively have not been able to manage this issue better

SleeplessInEngland · 14/04/2022 12:32

@Soffit

The ideological infection is not just a British problem, it has also been propagated all over the Third World.

The entire history of the world has been entirely reframed as the history of emancipation so nobody will blame the migrants for breaking through every border and barrier they want and relaying their heroic escape tales in 'safe spaces' to hyper-psychologized British aid workers where 'there's no moral judgment' and 'everyone's victimhood is valid'.
It is a foolproof way of destroying a civilization from within.

I feel like you're just one post away from bringing up The Great Reset theory.
Fulmine · 14/04/2022 12:30

@Choopi

Only because we have chosen to give them visas before they arrive. If we did the same for other refugees, then they wouldn't be asylum seekers either. The principal is the same.

Of course. Temporary visas could be offered to Afghans and Syrians too. I think a lot people would be in favour in this. A year or 2 in the UK then off you go back home.

If someone has had to leave their home and their country for fear of persecution, how would that be guaranteed to change within a couple of years?
AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 12:28

@pussycatunpickingcrossesagain

I honestly had to go into the kitchen and check the date on the calendar...it's not the 1st. 🤯
No, but the PM does have a very good reason for wanting to get people talking about something different.
Fulmine · 14/04/2022 12:28

@SleeplessInEngland

Interestingly, the government's own website advises that if you're LGBT you shouldn't travel to Rwanda. So that's good.
That'll be fun. Instant human rights issue, therefore, by sending people to Rwanda, so they'll have to make an exception for all asylum seekers claiming to be gay, bisexual or trans. That'll give the Daily Mail seizures.
Soffit · 14/04/2022 12:27

The ideological infection is not just a British problem, it has also been propagated all over the Third World.

The entire history of the world has been entirely reframed as the history of emancipation so nobody will blame the migrants for breaking through every border and barrier they want and relaying their heroic escape tales in 'safe spaces' to hyper-psychologized British aid workers where 'there's no moral judgment' and 'everyone's victimhood is valid'.
It is a foolproof way of destroying a civilization from within.

pussycatunpickingcrossesagain · 14/04/2022 12:27

I honestly had to go into the kitchen and check the date on the calendar...it's not the 1st. 🤯

OctopusSay · 14/04/2022 12:26

Yes, but most of them haven't arrived in France. They're only there because of their attempts to get to UK

Again, I understand that as a preference, but not why it should be so strong as to risk life for it.

theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 12:24

I dont know much about living in France, the benefits and suppoprt systems there etc, but I do know that it is widely accepted that the general politicak and social environment is to the right of the UK (well, at the moment, UK is trying to catch up clearly) and racism is rife. So I am sure that plays a part in people's decisions. Also the greater usefulness of learning English rather than French.

People also always underestimate risks and think they will be one of the (majority) who "make it" across.

Soffit · 14/04/2022 12:24

Our whole system is skewed against any immigration scheme (viable or otherwise) from properly getting off the ground. Until the 'oppression Olympics' is directly addressed, then the migrants can be confidently assured that they will win the game without trying.

OctopusSay · 14/04/2022 12:23

And they're only in camps in Calais because they're trying to get to UK. There are other options.

I mean the whole thing is hideous, I just can't understand the argument that they have no choice about taking such risks in the channel.

Fulmine · 14/04/2022 12:23

@Georgeskitchen

If anyone has actually read the article properly it tells you that this is not women and children but single men coming across illegally in boats, mostly economic migrants who if applying legally wouldn't qualify. I don't see a problem with this as many other countries in the world adopt this approach. So as much as some of you would love to believe that this country doesn't rescue the vulnerable fleeing war zones, actually, they do
Being a single male doesn't automatically make anyone an illegal migrant. There's nothing saying how exactly they can come up with a reliable way of weeding out those who are coming illegally from those who are coming legally - other than allowing a full review and appeal system before they contemplate sending anyone to Rwanda. And if you do that, it makes the whole scheme utterly pointless anyway.
AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 12:22

@OctopusSay, you are wrong, I'm afraid. I have worked in this area.

Asylum seekers are still waiting for their claims to be evaluated. If they are granted asylum, they then get refugee status.

Toddlerteaplease · 14/04/2022 12:21

I suppose for the genuine people it's better than risking your like in a tiny boat. But other than that it seems a pretty stupid idea.

MarriedThreeChildren · 14/04/2022 12:21

The whole point of asylums seekers is that
1- they do t have a visa
2- they will come into the country illegally.
3- they are escaping war or death (eg being homosexual in Afghanistan)

That’s what an asylum seeker is. That’s the definition and they have a special status under international law. Saying that those people should have a visa before coming is simply laughable.

OctopusSay · 14/04/2022 12:20

[quote theDudesmummy]@OctopusSay many of them have relatives in the UK. So it could be the difference between living an undignified homeless existence in a camp in Calais or sleeping on your cousins's sofa in Birmingham. I know which I would choose.[/quote]
Yes, as I said, I understand why they'd prefer to come here, but their situation, once in Europe, is surely no longer one of sheer total desperation where facing death in the Channel is their only option?