Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just when you think this government can't get any worse - now they are going to send asylum seekers to Rwanda

639 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 08:25

I didn't vote for this shower. The problem with people arriving (if they make it) in small boats needs addressing but AIBU that sending them on a one way trip to Rwanda isn't the answer?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Soffit · 14/04/2022 13:08

@Alexa I’m not sure what you think you know that is any more valid than other contributors but any brainwashed social justice zombie could rock up with that arrogant sound byte. The world needs less middle class, suburban, saviours indoctrinated into believing that they are making a positive difference when the evidence shows otherwise.

707smile · 14/04/2022 13:07

@Dogmum40

As long as it’s safe for the vulnerable I can’t see an issue, if they are genuine they will be offered the right to stay, if they are coming to the uk with bad intentions then they get refused entry!

Surely this is a better alternative to people coming in illegally on boats who have paid vast sums to traffickers! If they genuinely need help this could be a better solution all round as if they are genuine they should find the legal route of entering

If you wanted a better quality of life and wanted to move to the UK, would you think that Rwanda would be an adequate alternative?
theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 13:06

@Hospedia that is exactly correct, and I have personally worked with people who have successfully resisted being deported to this very country (and surrounding countries) because of the poor level of health care there, including the fact that they will not be able to access their essential medication there, so their human rights will be breached. The human rights and immigration lawyers will be all over it.

This. is. not. going. to. work.

SushiShopSearch · 14/04/2022 13:05

I can't see an issue. If people are fleeing for their lives and looking for safety then they need to be processed for asylum. You know our country is absolutely full.

Ukranians are completely different. They have fled to the nearest country and are applying for visas from there.

This will stop people dying en route to the UK. They did the same in Australia and the hundreds of people drowning en route stopped as they were processed in PNG.

707smile · 14/04/2022 13:04

It's pretty horrifying isn't it! Nothing they do surprises me any longer though.

Intheinterestsoffairness · 14/04/2022 13:03

There are surely better solutions for asylum seekers and/or migrants than this. We travel regularly through Caen. Large groups of young men hang around the traffic lights and roundabouts near to the Ouistreham ferry, waiting for vehicles to slow so they can jump on - lorries and motorhomes specifically. No-one with a motorhome stays near the ferry overnight, the risk of stowaways is too high.

The part that puzzles me is why aren't they being picked up by the French authorities? They are in France illegally at that point, but it seems a blind eye is being turned judging by how many people you can see. Wouldn't it be better to work with the French and come to an arrangement in terms of the UK and the rest of Europe accepting a certain percentage of the asylum seekers France takes in near the ferries?

AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 13:02

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

So do we think this scheme will just turn out to be unworkable? Who will the Tories blame when they have to ditch it?
I don't think they have ever had any intention of implementing it. It's just a distraction technique.
theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 13:01

I understand it to mean that people will be shipped off and THEN their asylum claims will be processed. So a mixture of those people who will fail to qualify and those people who will qualify will all head for Rwanda. The "virtuous" will come back to the UK at some point, the rest will stay in Randa and have long, happy and prosperous lives in a very poor country where they never wanted to be and where the locals depise and envy them. Sound like a plan.

Alexandra2001 · 14/04/2022 13:01

@HRTQueen

Well it’s a vote winner

I don’t understand how Europe collectively have not been able to manage this issue better

What would you do if you think the solution is so easily found?

But of course it isn't, the only thing that works (in limiting economic migration) is boosting the economies of the countries they come from but we don't want to do that, so cut foreign aid.

Forcibly deporting people to a far away country is more akin to something Putin or Xi would do.

We should seeking return agreements with the EU and with the countries of origin but of course that requires negotiating with the EU, something BJ has proven utterly incapable of doing as everything with him has to be a competition.

One thing i would say its a great pity this policy wasn't in force in the 60s, then Patel would never be here.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 13:01

So do we think this scheme will just turn out to be unworkable?
Who will the Tories blame when they have to ditch it?

OP posts:
Hospedia · 14/04/2022 12:59

Instant human rights issue, therefore, by sending people to Rwanda, so they'll have to make an exception for all asylum seekers claiming to be gay, bisexual or trans

Rwanda doesn't have anything stove basic healthcare facilities either so anyone with ongoing health needs could argue being sent there would potentially kill them.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 12:58

@theDudesmummy

People tend to go where they have relatives if they can. The UK is a big country (population-wise) and has (greatly to its benefit) a lot of people from other countries living in it. This increases the chances that people are going to have a relative in the UK. Not everyone tries to come to the UK. There are plenty wanting to settle in Germany, Scandinavia, etc wherever their relatives live.

The narrative that its about the UK benefits system in some way is a right-wing trope and utterly wrong.

True, but we have minimal enforcement once people are here, and plenty of opportunities to work off the books. Don't get me wrong - I'm not demonising people for wanting a better life - but another part of the pull to be here is the lack of any likelihood of being caught once you melt into the general population.
OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 12:57

It’smale economic migrants.

Not refugees.

Have I misunderstood?

I thought that the idea was to ship male asylum seekers off to Rwanda so that their asylum claims could be processed there instead of here.

But you seem to be saying that we will be processing asylum claims here in the UK and allowing the genuine refugees to stay, so that it is only the economic migrants who will be shipped off to Rwanda.

Or perhaps it is you that has misunderstood.

theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 12:54

@OctopusSay that's a whole nother issue. But the overall principal is that people are going to say whatever they need to say to avoid going to Rwnada (assuming this scheme is real which I still don't really believe). They will "identify" as gay, trans,mentally ill, as they will be able to successfully prove that these characteristics mean that their human rights will be specifically violated by their being set to Rwanda. For some it will be true. For some it will not. It will make a mockery of the whole (ridiculous, unethical) system.

Tippexy · 14/04/2022 12:53

@cansu

So vulnerable people will be sent to a place with a terrible record of human rights abuses. Yes that sounds a really good idea. Ffs this is awful. You could not make it up.
It’s male economic migrants.

Not refugees.

AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 12:53

Surely that's the very reasontodiscuss these things with all sorts. Then you can edicate us. Thank you.

Well, I agree that there would be a value in debating things if people who knew nothing would actually admit that. The problem is when people start spouting misinformation as fact, as others may believe what they are saying.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 12:50

@Soffit

The ideological infection is not just a British problem, it has also been propagated all over the Third World.

The entire history of the world has been entirely reframed as the history of emancipation so nobody will blame the migrants for breaking through every border and barrier they want and relaying their heroic escape tales in 'safe spaces' to hyper-psychologized British aid workers where 'there's no moral judgment' and 'everyone's victimhood is valid'.
It is a foolproof way of destroying a civilization from within.

?
OP posts:
HRTQueen · 14/04/2022 12:50

OctopusSay

How long have Greece said they need support and Italy

It’s not a new issue it was an issue while we were still in the EU. It’s an issue that no one really want to tackle head on. The Syrian crises was different as is the Ukraine crises

Not every European country is in the EU but all can support each other (and I would include Turkey) but it’s an issue that they hope will go away and half dealt with

theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 12:49

This from the Guardian feed: "Patel says people resettled in Rwanda will be given support for up to five years, covering training, accommodation and healthcare, so they can resettle and thrive".

So you are going to settle a group of people in an extremely poor country (most people under $2 a day) and provide them with all kinds of support that the local people there can't access? Like free accomodation and European standard healthcare? I wonder what the local people will make of the group? I can't see them being thrilled, well some criminals may be thrilled at the propect of exploiting such people. But are they really going just integrate into Rwandan society? What a stupid stupid stupid idea. Even for the Tories this is a new level of shit.

SleeplessInEngland · 14/04/2022 12:44

@HRTQueen

No it’s not on here blossom

But MN is never the place to gauge what the majority think or vote for

It won't be in the 'real world' either when the boats keep coming. Everyone in favour of this seems to conveniently ignore that part.
OctopusSay · 14/04/2022 12:43

@theDudesmummy

Yes, the LGBT issue is not going to have been missed. Why would someone who has a poor chance of being allowed to stay in the UK and a high chance of being sent to Rwanda not just claim to be gay or trans? There would be a huge incentive to do so, because their lawyers would then be able to argue that their human rights will not be protected in Rwanda. This would then affect the statistics and create suspicion of genuinely gay and trans people fleeing persecution. This has NOT been thought through and it is a moral and legal complete mess.
You can identify as whatever you choose unless you've arrived in a boat?
HRTQueen · 14/04/2022 12:41

No it’s not on here blossom

But MN is never the place to gauge what the majority think or vote for

theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 12:40

Yes, the LGBT issue is not going to have been missed. Why would someone who has a poor chance of being allowed to stay in the UK and a high chance of being sent to Rwanda not just claim to be gay or trans? There would be a huge incentive to do so, because their lawyers would then be able to argue that their human rights will not be protected in Rwanda. This would then affect the statistics and create suspicion of genuinely gay and trans people fleeing persecution. This has NOT been thought through and it is a moral and legal complete mess.

OctopusSay · 14/04/2022 12:39

@AlexaShutUp

It's worrying when the people who are debating these topics don't even have a basic understanding of the terms that they are using. We will never have a humane policy towards those fleeing war and persecution if people remain ignorant of the basic facts.
Surely that's the very reason to discuss these things with all sorts. Then you can edicate us. Thank you.
BattenbergdowntheHatches · 14/04/2022 12:38

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn