Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just when you think this government can't get any worse - now they are going to send asylum seekers to Rwanda

639 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 08:25

I didn't vote for this shower. The problem with people arriving (if they make it) in small boats needs addressing but AIBU that sending them on a one way trip to Rwanda isn't the answer?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 14:33

@MrsEdnaWelthorpe that's not the part of the system I work in really, I work with serious offenders in secure psychiatric units, they are in general not sending for their families if they have any, while they are in hospital. So I don't really know from personal experience how long it takes once someone is established in the UK after having succesfully claimed asylum to get visas for family members. Money will be a factor of course. I have several family members who got residence through me (I am British) and it was very very expensive.

SleeplessInEngland · 14/04/2022 14:33

@EmpressCixi

It’s only for those illegally crossing the Channel. It’s not for all refugees. I think it is better than drowning due to the traffickers. It will save lives in the long run. This will deter people from paying thousands to get in a flimsy dinghy and try and make it across open sea. And it’s not definitely a one way ticket as they’ll be in a safe accommodation (the pictures look quite nice actually) where they can apply for a visa and then come legally....which the Ukrainians are managing to do despite the horrors they are fleeing. If the Ukrainians can do legal refugee visa applications, then why can’t these others? And what’s wrong with housing them in sunny, warm. Africa while their applications are processed? Surely it’s better than a sports Centre in snowy Poland or Romania?
Crossing the channel to claim asylum isn't illegal, because the staus of that claim can only be determined by due process.
Getoff · 14/04/2022 14:30

I do think there's a high chance this won't work. If I had to guess, most likely outcome is that something bad will happen to some refugees in Rwanda, there will be a UK witch-hunt by media and the half of the population who did not vote for the government, who don't need any rational reason to blame the government for anything, and the government will be forced to back away from the only solution they've managed to think of. So the policy will fail not because it's technically flawed, but because it becomes emotionally/politically untenable.

EmpressCixi · 14/04/2022 14:28

Also 'healthy young men' are least likely to drain the NHS, but can provide the physical labour (we are so shy to do) and possibly build that housing and pick that fruit we need so much.

That’s pretty racist to say that’s what immigrants are good for and also that British are work shy.

EmpressCixi · 14/04/2022 14:26

It’s only for those illegally crossing the Channel. It’s not for all refugees. I think it is better than drowning due to the traffickers. It will save lives in the long run. This will deter people from paying thousands to get in a flimsy dinghy and try and make it across open sea. And it’s not definitely a one way ticket as they’ll be in a safe accommodation (the pictures look quite nice actually) where they can apply for a visa and then come legally....which the Ukrainians are managing to do despite the horrors they are fleeing. If the Ukrainians can do legal refugee visa applications, then why can’t these others? And what’s wrong with housing them in sunny, warm. Africa while their applications are processed? Surely it’s better than a sports Centre in snowy Poland or Romania?

Getoff · 14/04/2022 14:25

BTW, I agree it's horrible. I don't have a better idea though, so I'm not criticising anyone.

Getoff · 14/04/2022 14:23

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

I didn't vote for this shower. The problem with people arriving (if they make it) in small boats needs addressing but AIBU that sending them on a one way trip to Rwanda isn't the answer?
Do you have a better idea?

There's no way around the fact that if we want to have an immigration policy, we will have to do something that anyone with any empathy for those whose hopes and dreams are being crushed will find horrible.

Those are literally the choices, don't have an immigration policy, or do something horrible.

Fair enough to say that there are different levels and kinds of horrible, but I challenge you to come up with something better. Remember that the point of this policy is not to put lots of people in Rwanda, it's to stop them travelling to the UK in the first place. Once it's working, if it works, almost no-one will be being sent to Rwanda, because they won't be traveling to the UK in the first place.

SleeplessInEngland · 14/04/2022 14:19

Snap polling has come in from YouGov:

Overall voters:

Support: 35%
Oppose: 42%
Don't Know: 23%

Among tory voters:

Support: 59%
Oppose: 22%
Don't Know: 19%

That 59% figure isn't as high as I thought it be for what amounts to a no-holds-barred policy like this. Maybe voters are wary from other failed dingy promises.

notanotheroneagain · 14/04/2022 14:18

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Watch and wait for the private companies who expect to make money out of this scheme. providing "services", building facilities in Rwanda, whatever. And guess what, they will be linked to Tories making profits

Absolutely - and that will be the second "purpose" on the list, just after creating a nice diverting headline

After what we've seen during Covid it frankly amazes me that folk would expect anything else

Bet Reese Mogg, already has his finance and all his contracts for cronies in order already.
notanotheroneagain · 14/04/2022 14:17

Problem is that it's not even making any financial sense.

Australia spent 400M processing under 240 applicants. We have a budget of 120M. Then we say we have 600 per day. So just how many are we supposed to process with this.

Also 'healthy young men' are least likely to drain the NHS, but can provide the physical labour (we are so shy to do) and possibly build that housing and pick that fruit we need so much.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/04/2022 14:16

Watch and wait for the private companies who expect to make money out of this scheme. providing "services", building facilities in Rwanda, whatever. And guess what, they will be linked to Tories making profits

Absolutely - and that will be the second "purpose" on the list, just after creating a nice diverting headline

After what we've seen during Covid it frankly amazes me that folk would expect anything else

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 14/04/2022 14:14

@theDudesmummy

Where do you think the women and children are? Many are waiting desperately in dangerous places or refugee camps for their man to overcome incredible physical and mental hardships to get somewhere safe, get a job and then send for them legally.
As you work in the system, could you say how long it generally takes for them to be able to bring their families to the UK?
Blossomtoes · 14/04/2022 14:09

I imagine that there would be major legal challenges to such a policy

I expect the Good Law Project is already building a case.

AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 14:07

The thing is, if it applies to economic migrants only, they will have to go through the whole asylum process first, which often takes years. Lots of people will disappear in that time anyway, and even if they don't, the plan doesn't deliver any benefits for the UK taxpayer.

I don't think that can be the plan, as there is literally no point, so I assume that the idea is for home office officials to do some kind of dodgy half-arsed "initial assessment" of whether they think that someone is likely to have a valid asylum claim or not, without all of the usual legal protections that would be in place. Then those who are unlucky enough to be deemed economic migrants will get shipped off to Rwanda while their asylum cases are being processed properly via the legal route. Undoubtedly, that would mean that some genuine refugees were amongst those shipped off to Rwanda, but I guess they will simply be regarded as collateral damage. The unlucky ones sacrificed for a greater cause.Hmm

I imagine that there would be major legal challenges to such a policy. I'm not sure how it would all play out in practice.

theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 14:04

Everyone, even Patel, knows it couldn't work, though. It's not supposed to. It's just a very nasty stinking dead cat.

theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 14:02

I can't believe I am as one with Farage. I need to sit down.

Blossomtoes · 14/04/2022 13:58

The policy is going to apply to male economic migrants only

Not according to the Home Office minister interviewed on R4 at 1pm. They also interviewed Nigel Farage who said it won’t work and is a pointless waste of money. My jaw dropped. I thought he’d love it.

AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 13:58

I'm not getting snippy, @Tippexy. I'm asking how it's going to work and what the point of this policy will be if it only applies to people who have already been deemed to have no right to remain in the UK. Why not just deport them to their home country instead of spending millions of pounds off taxpayers money on sending them to Rwanda. What would this achieve, exactly?

Parker231 · 14/04/2022 13:58

Women are also included in this deportation

Tippexy · 14/04/2022 13:51

@AlexaShutUp

Yes, you have misunderstood (along with plenty others on the thread, to be fair!).

OK, @Tippexy. If I have misunderstood, please enlighten me as to how this is going to work.

From what you're claiming, it seems that we are going to process asylum claims here in the UK so that we can differentiate between genuine refugees and economic migrants. It generally takes months or even years to process asylum claims, so everyone will remain here in the UK while this is underway.

We will then allow the genuine refugees to stay, while those who are refused asylum will be deemed to be economic migrants and shipped off to Rwanda. For what purpose, exactly?

Wouldn't it make more sense to just deport them back to their countries of origin? Of course, that isn't always straightforward and many will go underground when their asylum claim has been refused, but I can't see that sending them to Rwanda will make any difference to that.

If we are only sending economic migrants to Rwanda and no refugees, please explain to me why we would do this and how it's all going to work.

There’s no point getting snippy with me! As usual, the left wing frothing on MN starts before anyone has actually read and absorbed the facts.

The policy is going to apply to male economic migrants only. That’s not “what I’m claiming.” It’s what is actually being reported. Read a news article, take it from the source rather than from a MN thread.

From The Times:

Migrants who arrive in the UK will be assessed initially by Home Office officials to determine whether they are economic migrants or genuine asylum seekers who have fled persecution in their home countries. It is not yet known how long this process will take or how they will judge whether an individual is an economic migrant.

Nine in ten of the 28,526 migrants who crossed the Channel in small boats last year were male, according to official statistics. Seven in ten were single.

BorisJohnsonsHair · 14/04/2022 13:51

@Babdoc

It is all very well to condemn the plan to send them to Rwanda, but what is your alternative? The UK does not have sufficient housing for our own population. Waiting lists for council accommodation are soaring, houses are unaffordable, and we are one of the most densely populated countries in Europe. Migrant numbers would involve building a new city every year. And that doesn’t include provision for their future children. So what do you suggest, OP?
The reason we don't have enough housing us because the Tories sold it all off in the 80s and there has been no significant investment in it since.

What are the migrant numbers? Do you include Ukrainians in this (because clearly Ukrainians are "proper" refugees, unlike the Syrians or Afghanis)?

This country is also one of the richest in the world, has hundreds of thousands of homes that no one lives in ( 238,306 in 2020) - the problems here are all about lack of Government investment and policy. Again, Conservatives. Who seem to be moving further and further to the right in a daily basis.

Grantanow · 14/04/2022 13:51

Utterly despicable. Is there anything Johnson wouldn't do to distract people from his lying? And Patel is equally appalling for promoting this wretched idea of sending refugees to a tin pot despot's country with a one way ticket. It's pandering to the far right of course. What has our country come to that we have a Prime Minister of such low integrity and morals? The Party must get rid of him and his crony Cabinet.

Trainbear · 14/04/2022 13:48

@cansu

So vulnerable people will be sent to a place with a terrible record of human rights abuses. Yes that sounds a really good idea. Ffs this is awful. You could not make it up.
The genocide was Frances fault apparently..
SleeplessInEngland · 14/04/2022 13:46

@NameInUseAlreadyAgain

So why not stay in France then. Why come to UK if get shipped to Rwanda.
A lot of mixed messages on this thread. Rwanda has gone from being 'warm and safe' to being a preventative punishment.
Soffit · 14/04/2022 13:45

Oh that old chestnut Hmm But I’m of immigrant stock and I am talking about other Caucasian people Grin