Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just when you think this government can't get any worse - now they are going to send asylum seekers to Rwanda

639 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 08:25

I didn't vote for this shower. The problem with people arriving (if they make it) in small boats needs addressing but AIBU that sending them on a one way trip to Rwanda isn't the answer?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Soffit · 14/04/2022 16:05

[quote EmpressCixi]@notanotheroneagain
What has race anything to do with this.

The definition of race includes different nationalities, so by virtue of calling British work shy and non British refugees as good for fruit picking, yes that’s a racist comment.[/quote]
Race and nationality are nothing to do with one another but I expect you do not realize that Wink

theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 15:53

This is what immigration minister Lord Harrington said on LBC on 5 April

Refugees Minister Lord Harrington declares there is 'no possibility' refugees will be sent to Rwanda, despite reports

EmpressCixi · 14/04/2022 15:52

@AlexaShutUp

Yes, *@EmpressCixi*, the resettlement programme is a much better way of allowing people to come into the UK safely and legally. However, the current programme only meets a tiny fraction of that need. If you're arguing to dramatically increase the number of refugees helped by that route so that people no longer feel compelled to make those perilous journeys, then I am absolutely in support of that. In the meantime, I am concerned about the people who feel that they have no other options.
Yes, the UNHCR Resettlement scheme needs to be drastically expanded. Yes, also highly concerned about refugees left in such hopeless optionless situations. Just think it’s worth trying if it saves even a dozen lives from drowning in the open sea.
theDudesmummy · 14/04/2022 15:50

The Daily Mirror has said that actually, once people have been sent to Rwanda they will not have the option of applying for asylum in the UK. And that they will be sent within 5 days of arrival in the UK, so whether nopt they are eligle for asylum will be decided in 5 days. And that LGBT refugees will also be sent to Rwanda. This is not legal. WTF are they doing?

GoodJanetBadJanet · 14/04/2022 15:49

But 'Boris' said something good about women, once, despite treating wonen like shit all his life, so Mumsnet will be voting Tory no matter what over atrocities they commit.
Yes this, it's seriously worrying.
FFS can we not get rid already, I hate how intolerant and further right we're all shifting and people are either ignorant or don't give a shit Sad

Inkyblue123 · 14/04/2022 15:49

I can understand their desire to use a similar system to Australia. I’m not sure about Rwanda though, seems an odd choice. Unfortunately some small boat migrants are criminals and terrorists , and the system we have now certainly doesn’t work. How would you protect the borders? For those people who object - what would you do instead? It’s easy to criticise, but what alternative measures would you use?

EmpressCixi · 14/04/2022 15:46

@BewareTheLibrarians
Yes, I think you are right in thinking that while it’s technically illegal, asylum seekers can’t actually be prosecuted for arriving that way. This is because they are rightly viewed as the victims of the traffickers and forced to break the law.

So perhaps time to lobby the government to open/reopen safe routes of travel for asylum seekers. It would cut down on the deaths in the channel, but for some reason the government doesn’t seem interested in that part.
I agree and there was discussion about the government negotiating opening a processing centre in Calais but it died on the vine. You’d think they’d at least have a floating ferry that could dock, prices refugees and then set sail. Or a pop up at an airport. Perhaps they fear fraudulent applications. The government can be paranoid.....

AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 15:43

Yes, @EmpressCixi, the resettlement programme is a much better way of allowing people to come into the UK safely and legally. However, the current programme only meets a tiny fraction of that need. If you're arguing to dramatically increase the number of refugees helped by that route so that people no longer feel compelled to make those perilous journeys, then I am absolutely in support of that. In the meantime, I am concerned about the people who feel that they have no other options.

EmpressCixi · 14/04/2022 15:42

@Freckles1978
I agree, the refugees don’t have a choice. They are either forced modern day slaves or deceived by predatory traffickers into thinking its the only option.

We have to stop these traffickers somehow, I’m open to any other solution too.

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/04/2022 15:39

[quote EmpressCixi]@BewareTheLibrarians
I agree refugees are not illegal immigrants.
But this is different from being a legal refugee making an illegal crossing of the channel. You can be a legal refugee but still break the law.[/quote]
Ah I see what you mean. Blush Although am I right in thinking that while it’s technically illegal, asylum seekers can’t actually be prosecuted for arriving that way? The Home Office tried recently, and the court of appeal slapped them down quite quickly.

So perhaps time to lobby the government to open/reopen safe routes of travel for asylum seekers. It would cut down on the deaths in the channel, but for some reason the government doesn’t seem interested in that part.

They do seem very interested in the part where they potentially get to make themselves very rich by setting up offshore processing centres ala covid PPE scandal.

Freckles1978 · 14/04/2022 15:36

@AlexaShutUp

Refugees can and do travel by commercial plane or boat or train or Chunnel to the U.K. with travel documentation and upon arrival present themselves to border control as an asylum claimant. Over 44k people claimed asylum last year and most of them came to the U.K. one of these ways and not by paying a homicidal human trafficker to stick them on a dinghy or the back of a lorry.

OK, so that's great if you are able to obtain a different kind of visa that enables you to travel to the UK via another means, e.g. if you qualify for a tourist visa etc. You can then travel to the country safely and claim asylum once you get here. What are you supposed to do if you aren't eligible for another kind of visa that would enable you to do this?

Do you think people choose to pay people traffickers extortionate sums of money to make a perilous journey in a dinghy if they had the option of just getting on a plane instead? Why do you think they would do that?

I've worked in this area for over 20 years. Many people do obtain visas some with their own passport and visa, others through the use of an agent with a fraudulent passport and visa.

I don't think this will stop the small boat crossings. IME the people who board these boats do not do this out of choice. They are often beaten and put on the boat or forced at gunpoint when they refuse.

EmpressCixi · 14/04/2022 15:36

Asylum claims will only be considered once someone has arrived in the UK.
Unless applying via the UNHCR Resettlement scheme from a third country.

They either have to do that by deception or by travelling "illegally".
I don’t agree with this. Most refugees are honest about their status.

Alexandra2001 · 14/04/2022 15:35

EU of course not the UK...

Alexandra2001 · 14/04/2022 15:35

@EmpressCixi UK operates very draconian laws on who is eligible to claim legally or not and tight quotas, hence the huge issues with those fleeing Ukraine not being able to come here.

But as the french said, sort out your Labour market, provide legal ways to come to the UK and the issue will largely go away IF the issue is to prevent criminality and drownings but it it isn't, its about the appeasing the xenophobic British public.

No surprise that out of 28 countries we not only demanded a referendum, we went and left the UK, against our best interests, purely because we don't like foreigners.... unless they man our ferries, wipe our arses and do airport check ins, then they can stay... for a while or until we don't need them.

Freckles1978 · 14/04/2022 15:30

To the previous poster who asked about bringing family over.

No one can apply for Family Reunion until they have been granted refugee status. You cannot qualify for Family Reunion if you are refused asylum and granted another form of leave to remain. The length of time it takes to decide an asylum claim varies as does the length of time to go through the appeals process.

EmpressCixi · 14/04/2022 15:26

@BewareTheLibrarians
I agree refugees are not illegal immigrants.
But this is different from being a legal refugee making an illegal crossing of the channel. You can be a legal refugee but still break the law.

EmpressCixi · 14/04/2022 15:21

What are you supposed to do if you aren't eligible for another kind of visa that would enable you to do this? There is the UNHCR Resettlement scheme which allows refugees to apply from outside the U.K. for asylum.

Do you think people choose to pay people traffickers extortionate sums of money to make a perilous journey in a dinghy if they had the option of just getting on a plane instead? They may not know they have the option, the human traffickers are very very good at lying and convincing refugees that their way is the only way in.

Why do you think they would do that? See above.

Do you have a better solution? The Rwanda scheme will be part of the UNHCR Resettlement scheme...

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/04/2022 15:20

@EmpressCixi Copy-pasting my reply from a few posts above again:

More perspective here, useful for those posters who keep saying asylum seekers are coming to the UK illegally. (Writer is David Simmonds, Conservative MP for Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner and chair of the APPG on Migration.)

“We must also be mindful of our tone and language in this debate. The people that are crossing the Channel are not ‘illegal immigrants’. Those crossing the Channel are allowed under our laws to seek refuge in the United Kingdom. It is only once they reach our shores that they have their asylum claims processed. If they are successful, they are deemed as refugees, and it is only if they are unsuccessful that they are deemed to have no legal status to be in our country.”

AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 15:20

They’re paying the trafficker to avoid due process

How are they avoiding due process?

People who fly in to the country on a tourist visa or similar, and then claim asylum once they get here, face the same process as people who come in on a dinghy.

If the people who are arriving in ways that you deem to be "legal" were honest about their intentions to claim asylum on arrival, the reality is that they wouldn't be allowed to travel.

Asylum claims will only be considered once someone has arrived in the UK. They either have to do that by deception or by travelling "illegally". While it would be infinitely better if someone could rock up to a British Embassy in their home country and claim asylum there, that isn't how the process currently works.

EmpressCixi · 14/04/2022 15:15

@SleeplessInEngland

"It’s not “by whatever means” ....yes the refugees themselves are not illegal, but their means of travel can be illegal. The channel crossings in the dinghies arranged by human traffickers ARE in fact illegal."

Nope. The illegality comes if they arrive and try to avoid due process, usually set up by the trafficker. But an asylum seeker in a boat on the channel? Not illegal.

They’re paying the trafficker to avoid due process ergo, they are crossing illegally. Cant believe you are seriously arguing that human traffickers are operating a legal immigration service across the channel and thus implying all the deaths by drowning are acceptable?
AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 15:13

Refugees can and do travel by commercial plane or boat or train or Chunnel to the U.K. with travel documentation and upon arrival present themselves to border control as an asylum claimant. Over 44k people claimed asylum last year and most of them came to the U.K. one of these ways and not by paying a homicidal human trafficker to stick them on a dinghy or the back of a lorry.

OK, so that's great if you are able to obtain a different kind of visa that enables you to travel to the UK via another means, e.g. if you qualify for a tourist visa etc. You can then travel to the country safely and claim asylum once you get here. What are you supposed to do if you aren't eligible for another kind of visa that would enable you to do this?

Do you think people choose to pay people traffickers extortionate sums of money to make a perilous journey in a dinghy if they had the option of just getting on a plane instead? Why do you think they would do that?

EmpressCixi · 14/04/2022 15:12

There is also the UNHCR Resettlement scheme where refugees in other countries can also be given protection in the UK via resettlement schemes. The UK works with the UN Refugee Agency (the UNHCR) to arrange for the transfer of refugees from an asylum country to the UK, with the aim of ultimately granting them permanent residence.

SleeplessInEngland · 14/04/2022 15:11

"It’s not “by whatever means” ....yes the refugees themselves are not illegal, but their means of travel can be illegal. The channel crossings in the dinghies arranged by human traffickers ARE in fact illegal."

Nope. The illegality comes if they arrive and try to avoid due process, usually set up by the trafficker. But an asylum seeker in a boat on the channel? Not illegal.

Chewchewaboogie · 14/04/2022 15:09

Are any of you who object to economic migrants( only).
Not refugees..going down this route actaully living in the areas with an influx of the economic migrants at all? Do you understand any of the feelings of some the locals. ? Or do you live in leafy rich suburbs? I am.not agree but i do think this requires thought. Its like how we got brexit amd the tories in.. the people who such things affect are npt heard until in desperation they vote tory..? They need.to be heard and then empathised with somehow and things at.least addressed somehow( extra funding innsuch areas etc?? I dont know,,)unless u want a tory vote.. until then they may feel.unheard and takenthe only route they feel.open to them. Anger , hatred amd labellimg of such voters doesnt work . My relative is .political commenter and said denial of peoples real experience does not work .. it leads to polorisation ie things like this being on the cards.

AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 15:09

So true, @BewareTheLibrarians.

Sigh.