Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just when you think this government can't get any worse - now they are going to send asylum seekers to Rwanda

639 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/04/2022 08:25

I didn't vote for this shower. The problem with people arriving (if they make it) in small boats needs addressing but AIBU that sending them on a one way trip to Rwanda isn't the answer?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Justanotherlurker · 14/04/2022 22:29

Laughable the Tories are promoting this as helping migrants!

Offer a better alternative.

We currently spend circa £2 billion a year housing migrants, that's an awful lot of nurses for the failing NHS, the simplistic route is to just increase taxes on 'the rich', MN had a massive blow out over Corbyn saying those earing above 75K a year was rich...

We could pretend there is no housing crisis whilst we are struggling to build for a native increase in population, estimated 300k imigrants a year (which is vastley understimated), whilst we are on a build rate of 200k a year houses.

An easy feel good factor is pretending there is a simple situation to a very complex sitution based on 'anti racist' and saying that there is sufficient brownfield sites or vacant housing but that doesn't correlate to the costs of putting migrants up in hotels, and nimbyism.

This is where the left need to come up with a suitable alternative instead of just calling it evil and or racist, a lot of people are not realising that the 'critical thinking' meme is being played against them

The calling out 'racist' has lost its meaning, this is the watershead moment of the left needing to offer proper alternatives

Fr0thandBubble · 14/04/2022 22:25

I think it’s a very good thing. We can’t have half the world moving here. The vast majority of people arriving in boats are economic migrants - why else would they arrive with no papers or ID? They throw them in the sea on the way over. And don’t forget they’re coming from France, an entirely safe country.

I despair of all the bleeding heart liberals on her. We can’t take in everyone.

watcherintherye · 14/04/2022 22:22

As the volunteer at a refugee camp outside Dunkirk so eloquently put it:
Rwanda?……..Vraiment?!!

bjjgirl · 14/04/2022 22:13

I am in disbelief -

Why are we treating Afghan refugees so differently to Ukrainian refugees?

It is not the answer to the people smugglers, it is cruel and degrading.

It is shameful

StoneofDestiny · 14/04/2022 21:59

Laughable the Tories are promoting this as helping migrants!

Let's send Pritti Patel, Johnson and Sunak off to Rwanda on a one way ticket - we don't need racists, liars and lawbreakers here.

HRTQueen · 14/04/2022 21:56

I never said I didn’t care

I have on here and other threads said he should step down/or I believe he won’t do the right thing and step down

It’s not enough there are bigger issues going on. Unfortunately if this had come out earlier and it wasn’t so drawn out we might have had a different reaction. There is a crises in Europe that dominates politics at the moment not our PM lying to parliament

It’s also Easter break from Parliament another convenience

Is it the right time to have a new PM ? No but then should he stay on as PM I don’t think so but I’m not a supporter of his and never have been and the Tories have to weigh up have we got someone to step in well the favourite to that isn’t going to happen now. A leadership contest would seem indulgent and likely to backfire

Look at the polls they are not shifting in the way you would hope probably as many who support him know he lies him being a maverick not really following the rules is part of his appeal

We also have local elections in a few weeks

Fulmine · 14/04/2022 21:12

@HRTQueen

Fulmine I think it’s more to do with the elections on a few weeks time than distraction from party gate and if the plan works even for a fraction of people that good for the the next election if not then another scheme shall be decided on - it’s the doing something that counts immigration particularly of young man is a hot topic look across the border at France

Party gate ship has sailed now we have the report coming out next week but he has been fined few MP’s have called for his resignation it’s old news

It certainly isn't old news. There are more fines to come, including in particular the one for him attending his aide's leaving do, and all of that will make it ever more obvious that his excuses about not realising this was against the rules just won't wash. That in turn leads to major questions about his misleading Parliament which will be the subject of a debate next week. You may not care about that, but it's a very serious offence for any MP, let alone a Prime Minister. A number of Conservative MPs have made it very clear that they are appalled and that if he doesn't go now it's just a matter of time.
Sometimeswinning · 14/04/2022 20:44

The UK is a cesspit of racist arseholes

No country actually likes illegal immigrants though. Its becoming a problem which needs addressing and sorting. No one has actually got an answer.

When you see education and health care failing all around you, you do end up thinking where are my priorities? It isn't with adults escaping their home country etc. I feel compassion. But I have other things which mean more to me.

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/04/2022 20:40

Just in case anyone thinks the Home Office is capable of handling this scheme if it did go ahead, let’s take a look at all these situations where the Home Office was found to be acting unlawfully with its treatment of asylum seekers and refugees on its own ground.

Home Office plan for removing migrants unlawful, court rules
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-54632985.amp

www.matthewgold.co.uk/high-court-rules-home-secretary-acted-unlawfully-in-accommodating-asylum-seekers-in-inadequate-napier-barracks/

Home Office admits unlawful secret policy to seize all migrants’ mobile phones
www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/migrant-phones-channel-home-office-b2002036.html?amp

Home Office acted unlawfully in detaining unaccompanied young people for age assessments
insights.doughtystreet.co.uk/post/102hgm1/home-office-acted-unlawfully-in-detaining-unaccompanied-young-people-for-age-asse

Blossomtoes · 14/04/2022 20:32

Yes, they have set out their stall. And that’s excellent because we know where we are with them. Johnson will change his mind at the merest hint that there might be a vote to two in it.

HRTQueen · 14/04/2022 20:31

Where have I said that I support this policy? I have said it needs to be addressed. All European countries have brushed this aside and a few really are left dealing with the worst of the issue. Also we need to look at what is happening in France do you think Macron if he wins is going to not use these desperate people as pawns to appease the far right. He has already been doing this and this will become more of a problem for the UK

I have suggested that Labour need to come up with their policy or announce they are working on one and put that forward not just cries of how awful it is. That’s Labour’s policy at the moment to be critical of the government without putting forward their plans. Talk about preach to the converted they need to step up to win the next election

Blossom that’s why Tories are successful is because they will change with public opinion. I want a centre (won’t happen) or centre left party in but they need to improve on winning votes

mrshoho · 14/04/2022 20:28

@Blossomtoes

Don’t you think this government has given us enough crowd pleasing U turns *@HRTQueen*? I don’t really want a government that changes with the wind to garner votes.
but likewise Labour have set out their stall. I can't vote for them because of their blatant stance on women's rights. I won't vote Conservative either because of their social and economic policies.
user1471453601 · 14/04/2022 20:21

@HRTQueen, I'm really sorry to have to post this. My sorrow is because I totally agree that vulnerable women need safe spaces. I couldn't agree more.

But if you really think it's ok to ships other vulnerable people off to a country with a bad human rights history, well I despair.

I can hold more than one non contradictory view in my head.

I want vulnerable people to be safe, whether those vulnerable people are asylum seekers or women.

Blossomtoes · 14/04/2022 20:18

Don’t you think this government has given us enough crowd pleasing U turns @HRTQueen? I don’t really want a government that changes with the wind to garner votes.

HRTQueen · 14/04/2022 20:11

It’s what many want to hear from Starmer and other senior Labour mp’s

No one thinks Boris Johnson is a closet feminist

again it’s something Labour can fix they can act on but haven’t

Why are Labour dragging their heels so much. Do you think Tony Blair and Gordon Brown wouldn’t have been all over the issue. Their focus was on voters not on internal party arguments and policies that suit a few on the left of the party or friends of Labour

Blossomtoes · 14/04/2022 20:10

The "But Boris knows what a woman is" brigade never seem to look at the actual effects of the Tories' policies (or they're too rich to care)

That’s the crux of it. It’s a middle class woman’s luxury.

Theimpossiblegirl · 14/04/2022 20:09

How anyone can still vote for these heartless self serving Tory tossers is beyond me.

Sbbhnfc · 14/04/2022 20:05

But 'Boris' said something good about women, once, despite treating wonen like shit all his life, so Mumsnet will be voting Tory no matter what over atrocities they commit.

Yep. Anyone who thinks Boris and his mates are really friends to women needs their cognitive dissonance settings adjusting. The "But Boris knows what a woman is" brigade never seem to look at the actual effects of the Tories' policies (or they're too rich to care).

HRTQueen · 14/04/2022 20:00

I really don’t think it will. Those who are angry will still be angry many just don’t care that much and when stories get dragged out (as this has for months) it’s loses the impact it first had. Was you shocked he was fined ? I wasn’t

The focus is votes

Labour need to come out with a policy that they would put in place or announce they are working at putting a together an option not just cries of this is awful/wrong those that disagree know this already but it’s an issue that has to be addressed

If Macron wins he will absolutely have to appease the far right this in turn can make the issue foe the UK more difficult to manage

The most desperate are pawns in politics (not new)

SleeplessInEngland · 14/04/2022 19:56

France has major racial issues - just look at Le Pen’s success. Shouldn’t surprise anyone a Middle Eastern wouldn’t want to hang around.

Crikeyalmighty · 14/04/2022 19:54

@daimbarsatemydogsbone. I agree with your post, we actually need to get down to the root cause of why they are coming here when already clearly in France or Belgium. (Usually France) — a relative of mine was high up on the police side of border force and said one big problem was gangs of blokes from Essex and Kent and south London enticing people to do this for large sums of cash by claiming it was ‘easy’ to get houses and benefits and work’ - none of which is true. A few of these gangs sadly are immigrants already here —-but far more so are white home grown scumbags. We need to be actively finding out who these dinghy crossers have been paying and get rid of the enablers- personally I think a 1 way ticket to Rwanda for the enablers would be perfect. The estimated cost if put into ‘full production’ Is 1.4 billion a year— for that we could be keeping them in the Ritz as Chris Bryant stated. The lack of social housing etc that others mention has nothing to do with refugees allowed to stay — the numbers are actually not that high. It is because demand has risen due to unaffordable private rented and owner occupier in relation to earnings and right to buy — a terrible option— I know at least 4 people who fiddled that system buying for relatives and then selling on at huge profits within a couple of years and a total lack of building anything on social rent market that family sized!!! Thing is though logical and practical and ethical solutions don’t appeal to the rabid Daily Express/Mail contingent who are obsessed that this countries ills are all due to that Polish plumber or the young Syrian family and not due to a complete lack of control of the government actually governing and not just constantly covering their backs to keep UKippers on side — and I’m not some rabid hard left winger- very much a centrist — but this bunch of Johnson sycophants are just a nasty bunch of ambitious shits pandering to the lowest bar.

SleeplessInEngland · 14/04/2022 19:48

@HRTQueen

You really think he is going over the fines ?

He would have by now if that was to happen he certainly isn’t going to do the right thing and resign

There is a crises in Europe which has worked in his favour

No, he won’t go - his MPs are cowards. But it will make people angry again, take up the news cycle and diminish whatever else they’re trying to get people to focus on. But they’ve decided to weather it, and they’ll pay for that.
feckingknackered · 14/04/2022 19:45

@lemongreentea

Tory votes will be delighted.

The UK is a cesspit of racist arseholes.

My thoughts exactly!!
CMZ2018 · 14/04/2022 19:43

Happy days

HRTQueen · 14/04/2022 19:42

You really think he is going over the fines ?

He would have by now if that was to happen he certainly isn’t going to do the right thing and resign

There is a crises in Europe which has worked in his favour