Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ukraine attention bias

37 replies

Easymeasy · 14/04/2022 07:06

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-61101732

I'm glad this has been publicly said and a proper discussion needs to be had.
The amount of excuses (even on here) as to the reason people were climbing over themselves to offer empathy, support and money to Ukrainians compared to other countries.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DdraigGoch · 14/04/2022 11:32

While there's an element of "these people look like us, that could have been me", it's a lot more complicated than that.

  • Ukrainians have more access to electronic communications than refugees from past conflicts did. That means that we are better informed than ever.
  • The conflict involves a hostile superpower with nuclear weapons. Russia poses a threat to us all, unlike Gaddafi or Assad whose threat didn't really extend beyond their respective countries' borders.
  • The Ukrainian leader is very charismatic. Did the victims of any other conflicts have someone like that speaking up for them?
picklemewalnuts · 14/04/2022 11:14

And we were very welcoming to the Vietnamese boat people, donkey's years ago when we were more overtly racist, so it's not uncomplicated racism.

Alexandria12 · 14/04/2022 11:10

Fact is we aren't actually offering the Ukrainian refugees much in the way of support at all, not in comparison to the numbers fleeing. So any discussion about whether or not we are doing more because they are white is irrelevant because we are doing bugger all for them aside from making sympathetic noises.

*The UK government has announced that about 16,400 people have arrived in the UK from Ukraine under the two visa schemes the Home Office has set up to handle refugees.

The UNHCR estimates the number of people who have fled Ukraine for abroad since Russia’s latest invasion began on 24 February is 4,697,964*

The UK have helped with weapons, which is good, but fundamentally more about our own self interests than anything else.

MorrisZapp · 14/04/2022 09:19

@StarlingsInTheRoof

I am sure there is white bias yes. However there are also other factors. Most of the ongoing wars across the world are civil wars. Many of them involving people we don't agree with fighting people we don't agree with. In Ukrane an ex global super power invaded a democracy headed by a president who has turned out to be exceptionally good at leading a media campaign. We have a clear line of "the goodies" and "the baddies" to throw support behind.

The majority of world rulers grew up during the cold War and will have clear memories of red threat, so don't want that returning. Assad is clearly less of a threat to us than a country with a big red nuclear button. The refugees from Ukrane have been predominantly women and children, whereas young men tend to be the escapees from other war zones mentioned. So yes, I am sure whiteness plays a significant part, but it is far from the whole story.

Makes total sense. Thank you.
TraceyLacey · 14/04/2022 09:01

Social media is playing a huge part in making Ukraine visible - citizens are live streaming on Tiktok, soldiers are updating on Telegram, the President has daily Facebook broadcasts. Their lives are part of our lives, we aren't waiting for or relying on the BBC to tell us what is happening on the news.

StarlingsInTheRoof · 14/04/2022 08:59

I am sure there is white bias yes. However there are also other factors. Most of the ongoing wars across the world are civil wars. Many of them involving people we don't agree with fighting people we don't agree with. In Ukrane an ex global super power invaded a democracy headed by a president who has turned out to be exceptionally good at leading a media campaign. We have a clear line of "the goodies" and "the baddies" to throw support behind.

The majority of world rulers grew up during the cold War and will have clear memories of red threat, so don't want that returning. Assad is clearly less of a threat to us than a country with a big red nuclear button. The refugees from Ukrane have been predominantly women and children, whereas young men tend to be the escapees from other war zones mentioned. So yes, I am sure whiteness plays a significant part, but it is far from the whole story.

Alexandria12 · 14/04/2022 08:49

There have been an insane number of refugees that have come from Ukraine in just a few weeks. Over 4 million I think so far more than the whole conflict in the Balkans, which happened over years. People were worried about that too at the time but this is far more scary as it involves Russia.

Also our government has done almost nothing about accepting refugees . The uk have taken tiny numbers so I don't see how other than rhetoric we have done more to help refugees than in any other conflict.

I have an opinion about this. Some people don't care about Ukraine and don't want to help. They don't want to see the suffering in the news and would rather stick their heads in the sand. That makes them feel bad but rather than admit the truth to themselves they have thought of some weird logic that makes the people who care about Ukraine racist.

howtomoveforwards · 14/04/2022 08:46

That the war in Ukraine should be important to us, more so than our involvement in other wars in recent years around the world, is evident and I don’t think this is bias just the stark reality of what we are facing globally.

That we are somehow have more empathy for white, mainly women and children refugees is an uncomfortable truth we should face head on, accept as reality and start to educate on the bias, realities, myths etc whilst refugees are at the forefront of our minds and we can clearly see those biases.

Kendodd · 14/04/2022 08:38

And besides, I don't think you can accuse the Tory government of welcoming Ukraine refugees, as far as I can see they're trying to erect every barrier they can get away with to discourage them for trying to come here. Its absolutely shameful.

Kendodd · 14/04/2022 08:34

Where are all the other black African countries falling over themselves to help their brothers and sisters in war torn African countries? Or Saudi Arablia and other Arab countries helping Syria?
Most refugees do stay local and are housed in neighbouring countries. Take your point about Saudi Arabia, but it in itself is a hideous regime, I wouldn't want to be a refugee there.

Cyw2018 · 14/04/2022 08:31

I disagree.

We need the Ukraine to hammer the Russian army, or else we are all doomed.

To do this we need to support the Ukrainian military with weapons (which the government are doing), and to make sure the soldiers know that their families are being cared for so they can keep fighting hard.

This is a strategic tactic, which is what war is about.

We don't need to help people from Syria or Ethiopia, it would nice to help them, and as a country we do to a limited extent, because it is a morally good thing to do. However with the Ukraine we need to do this because we can not risk Russia gaining confidence and momentum, and the war extending further into Europe.

picklemewalnuts · 14/04/2022 08:31

The war in Yugoslavia and now in the Ukraine have a huge 'people like us' factor. Scenes from those cities before the war are indistinguishable from scenes here. I was in Yugoslavia a year before it all kicked off. It felt like all the other cities I travelled through on my interrailing ticket.

For a country that looked and felt indistinguishable from mine to be at war, bombed out, destroyed, was terrifying and has left me aware that there is no particular reason it couldn't happen here.

Ukraine has a similar feel, from what I can see. The landscape, the people, the cities, all look like 'home'.

Yemen and Syria and Ethiopia do not look like home. It doesn't have the same visceral impact. It's terrible, and the siege of that port was desperately sad, but it's slightly removed.

MorrisZapp · 14/04/2022 08:30

Disagree. Anyone able to watch the scenes from Ukraine and call it fashionable has lost all sense of how humanity works.

Kendodd · 14/04/2022 08:30

I don't know about those conflicts but I do remember multiple thread on here about how to help and house, in our own homes, refugees from Syria and Afghanistan. There were plenty of posters on those thread accusing people of only wanting to help brown people and not giving a shit about white people here in the UK if they were homeless, not offering spare rooms to them. I used to get quite pissed off with posters on the Ukraine threads calling racism saying people didn't give a shit about brown refugees or offer there homes to them because they did and there were loads of thread talking about exactly that. To me it rather suggests it's the people name calling over the Ukraine refugee crisis are the ones who actually don't give a shit about refugees because where were they during all those Syria and Afghanistan threads? Why didn't they see them, were they of no interest and scrolled past? Its many of the same names on those threads as the Ukraine threads.

None of the above is to pretend white bias doesn't exist though.

DrDetriment · 14/04/2022 08:24

Yes there is more focus on Ukraine and there is nothing wrong with that. It's a European country, not that far from us. If Putin wins he could threaten the rest of Europe. The refugees are culturally similar to us. Where are all the other black African countries falling over themselves to help their brothers and sisters in war torn African countries? Or Saudi Arablia and other Arab countries helping Syria? Thought not. It's all down to the west and our fault for being 'racist' if we don't send billions in aid to them and open our gates to millions of refugees across the world.

Alexandra2001 · 14/04/2022 08:18

There was in the 90s and 00s a war in Europe, closer to UK than Ukraine, and which produced over 2.5m displaced people

Ex Yugoslavia didn't produce a super power conflict.

There was no popular rallying cry to take them in then, and they were just as white and European as this 2.5 million. But they weren't fashionable

Rubbish, Yes there was, plenty came to the UK and all across Europe, there are ex refugees who have gone into the House of Lords/Commons, the surgeon who did my hip op was from Bosnia.

But the race/distance points hold good. The war in Rwanda, which overlapped, got even less attention

Whose fault is that? the right wing media we all read and in any case, it did, huge outcry on why UN did so little.

Ponoka7 · 14/04/2022 08:17

@Thriwit
"Western governments are not giving any kind of aid out of any sense of goodness, but out of political need."

It isn't just about governments, it's about individuals/general public/media. I can remember the headlines against Somalian/Rwandan refugees. Even our Prime Minister used the term migrants a few times in Parliament, instead of refugees.

Ponoka7 · 14/04/2022 08:13

@Alexandra2001, I agree about the difference in the impact of the wars on us. However we aren't talking about the war, we are talking about refugees. There's a massive difference in attitude towards the different coloured refugees.

I know her faults, but this has been spoken about on Kay Burley's news shows from early on. She's had different guests discussing it.

Africa is quite important, but we know that they will always have to trade with us, so we don't care who gets killed in the process. It suits us for Africa to be in constant crisis/poverty.

Many experts think that Putin won't use Nuclear weapons, we've jumped on a bandwagon declaring that he will.

Kendodd · 14/04/2022 08:12

I don't disagree with the white people bias, just generally in life, not just this. This line though

But Tigray province in Ethiopia, Yemen, Afghanistan or Syria are not receiving the same attention, he said.

I wonder if those countries are getting more attention in their neighbouring countries than Ukraine is? Although the Ukraine war could (is?) expected to affect the world food supply and price so even there, perhaps not?

Thriwit · 14/04/2022 08:11

When that says “the world does not give equal attention to emergencies affecting black and white people”, does he actually mean “the West does not…”? What is the attention he wants? Humanitarian aid? Military aid? Political intervention?
Western governments are not giving any kind of aid out of any sense of goodness, but out of political need.

lljkk · 14/04/2022 08:10

Bosnia only has a population of 3.2 million now, it just isn't as big a place as Ukraine (44 million). The ex-Yugoslav conflict was in news constantly for years and did spawn a lot of refugees across Europe & world. Europe offered instant admission to Bosnians at the time.

After Russia directly attacked Ukraine in a huge offensive, would they consider attacking other European countries with the same amount of force? It's not same situation as the civil wars in Syria, Yemen or Lebanon (which were all over news at times). This isn't a story just about displaced people.

Personally I'm trying harder to avoid Ukraine news than I ever tried to avoid the other country conflict news. Even though others are sadder, Ukraine is bound to be bigger, it means more.

JellyfishandShells · 14/04/2022 08:06

Disagree - it’s ridiculous whatabouterry. It was, and continues to be , a sudden and shocking event that is of huge concern to us and should be at the forefront of our minds.

Flammkuchen · 14/04/2022 08:03

Sorry, but I am more concerned about a war in Europe than further away countries. Especially when it would be easy for us to get involved and then for Putin to launch a nuclear strike.

lemongreentea · 14/04/2022 07:59

Completely agree.

SunshinePie · 14/04/2022 07:58

I think it’s because this war could end up involving nuclear…that will affect the whole world.

Swipe left for the next trending thread