Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this ‘just kids being kids’?

58 replies

Irritatedmum · 13/04/2022 21:40

DD is in year 3, all the children are 7 or 8.

They’ve all coupled up this year, lots of boyfriends and girlfriends going on. All very innocent and sweet.

But she’s started more recently to mention things, because it sounds like her little boyfriend is very popular. So girls - her friends - have been:
*trying to ‘split them up’
*telling the boy DD doesn’t like him anymore to try to get him to dump her
*one close friend told DD she likes him more so DD should ‘let her go out with him’
*told DD that ‘she doesn’t deserve him’ and that she should dump him so she can go out with him herself.

This isn’t the same girl saying it, it’s 2 or 3 different girls. The ‘doesn’t deserve him’ comment in particular has riled me - if this was a teenager I’d be bloody horrified.

Is this normal at this age?? How on earth do I deal with it? I want DD to be in a position where she has strong friendships, friends who support each other, and to me that all begins now, surely?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PinkSyCo · 14/04/2022 16:07

It's pretty common op. I remember this sort of behaviour when I was that age and I'm 52!

I’m about the same age as you and we did not behave like this at all, not even in secondary school!

dontyoubother · 14/04/2022 14:03

I have taught this age group several times. Very occasionally one will tell me someone else in the class is their boyfriend/girlfriend. I rarely notice these two kids playing together or even talking. They are very young for all this IME.

froidIci · 14/04/2022 13:59

Adults thinking they have this “line” in their heads - ie - till an arbitrary point it’s “sweet and innocent” and say boyfriends are sweet at 7, and mock weddings lovely. And then once line crossed - it’s suddenly not right.

How is a little kids to understand these arbitrary lines though? How do they know why - some sorts of weddings and having boyfriends is ok and other sorts aren’t?

Adults and parents need to be clear themselves - encourage strong healthy friendships across all sexes - but nope - mock romances and mock and playful relationships at age 7 are not okay.

froidIci · 14/04/2022 13:57

@Irritatedmum

I don’t mind the boyfriend talk at all, and the little weddings I thought were very cute! But now it’s causing trouble between the girls it’s started to worry me
Unfortunately - it is this sort of thing that makes kids confused because they don’t have any idea where the line of “cuteness” ends and something else begins. It’s not their fault. If they see carers and adults around them finding their mini-adulting cute then they carry on with it. Then suddenly one day when the slippery slope acts exactly like a slope - something goes wrong and suddenly it’s not all cute any more.

This is why - the line needs to be fairly firm. “Weddings and boyfriends aren’t things for kids to be thinking about. You’re too young for all this sweetheart.” And then rinse and repeat.

AmyandPhilipfan · 14/04/2022 11:36

When I was at primary it really depended on whether the teacher allowed boyfriend/girlfriend talk to go on as to how much of it there seemed to be. In Year 3 we had quite an old fashioned teacher who would not have tolerated anyone talking about having a boy/girlfriend. But in Year 4 I have a strong memory of the teacher letting us play ‘Postman’s Knock’ during an end of term party and locking ‘couples’ in the staff room! I even had a boyfriend that year and that didn’t happen again until I was 17! There was never any ‘you’re not good enough for him/her’ when I was at primary. Most people seemed happy for anyone in a ‘couple.’ There was a bit of nastiness if it was found out someone considered unpopular fancied someone more popular but more ‘x would never go out with y’ behind y’s back rather than directly to their face. I do remember the boy my friend liked when we were 10 ripping up the Valentine’s card she gave him which was very horrid of him but I’d never understood what she’d seen in him anyway!

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 14/04/2022 11:22

@Irritatedmum

DD is in year 3, all the children are 7 or 8.

They’ve all coupled up this year, lots of boyfriends and girlfriends going on. All very innocent and sweet.

But she’s started more recently to mention things, because it sounds like her little boyfriend is very popular. So girls - her friends - have been:
*trying to ‘split them up’
*telling the boy DD doesn’t like him anymore to try to get him to dump her
*one close friend told DD she likes him more so DD should ‘let her go out with him’
*told DD that ‘she doesn’t deserve him’ and that she should dump him so she can go out with him herself.

This isn’t the same girl saying it, it’s 2 or 3 different girls. The ‘doesn’t deserve him’ comment in particular has riled me - if this was a teenager I’d be bloody horrified.

Is this normal at this age?? How on earth do I deal with it? I want DD to be in a position where she has strong friendships, friends who support each other, and to me that all begins now, surely?

I would say it's entirely normal, my eldest fell out with her friend because they chose the same color. They've been friends since nursery so nearly a decade. This unspoken passive feud has been going on for over 12 months.

Kids fall out, we're just about to let her have a phone, I've warned her of the dangers of nattering and bullying via phones.
We had explicit bullying of my stepdaughter who's mid 20's now, but teenagers were physically abusing her, even calling the house.

All because she was pretty and a girl's boyfriend fancied her.
It's all nonsense but these things can spiral between the different groups.

Threetulips · 14/04/2022 10:55

I'm suggesting that she asks the school to intervene to discourage all of the boyfriend/girlfriend nonsense altogether

I agree. But it’s hard if the parents don’t back the teachers as OP clearly thought it was sweet and inicent.

MooseBreath · 14/04/2022 10:51

I'd like to clarify that I don't think it's appropriate for 7-9 year-olds to watch Love Island!

But when a child has a 15-year-old sister, it is possible that it's on in the living room and the child would see it. There are also some parents who don't care what their children watch. We had a reception-aged child who was obsessed with Deadpool and frequently quoted it.

ThisUserIsNamed · 14/04/2022 10:43

It is completely inappropriate behaviour. These children will be copying what they see adults do, be it at home or television. The language used shows this is not an innocent game of house. A 7/8 year olds games ought to be climbing trees as their pirate ship, taking their dolls to the dotors etc, not fighting over boys. I would do something like the big life journal to help improve your DDs self esteem. Boys are not a prize to be won, she is. And there is plenty of time for that. Read plenty of books about women who are celebrated for their achievements. So many girls are valued on their appearance, see older girls and women valued by the passing words of Boys and men.

Does your DD have access to Internet unsupervised, snap chat,ma TV in her room or anything elsr? It may be something she is seeing or It may just be how other children have formed the 'games'. Make sure your DD isn't directly being exposed to anything she shouldn't be.

Try and use this Easter break to reset, to play, Read and connect. Tell her she is too young for these games, for now there are more important things to do, like paint, play pirates/fairies/whatever her jam is and learn.

AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 10:40

@Threetulips

and I would be having a word with the school to ask if they could help to address it

Why ‘Hi teacher I think it’s sweet DD has a boyfriend and all her friends are being mean and jealous’

Don’t you think teachers spend enough time dealing with these kids falling out because parents actively encourage it? Then what happens is the boy dumps one girls and dates another causing more upset - and round it goes

Stop thinking it’s sweet and tell her she can’t have a boyfriend til she’s 30! That will take the pressure off her because before you were agreeing with it.

No, I am not suggesting that the OP asks the teachers to deal with the other kids being "mean and jealous" about the dd's so-called boyfriend. I'm suggesting that she asks the school to intervene to discourage all of the boyfriend/girlfriend nonsense altogether.

I'm sure that teachers do indeed spend lots of time dealing with this crap, which is exactly why the school needs to intervene and nip it in the bud. Boyfriend/girlfriend talk isn't inevitable at this age. There will always be stupid parents who encourage it, so the school has to set the tone and discourage this kind of role play because the kids clearly aren't old enough to cope with it, as the OP's post clearly demonstrates. That's what my dd's school did, and I'm grateful to them for taking such a sensible approach.

Snowballtorch · 14/04/2022 10:24

I know this is not necessarily uncommon, but I don't think it is normal behaviour at this age either. In your shoes I would be speaking with the school to make them aware of the impact on your DD and to ask them to address the issue.

There was nothing of the sort at our DD's school, until a new girl joined the class in Y5 and then it became a big problem, with issues just as you describe. It caused much upset and divided friendship groups. The school were aware and did what they could, but by Y5 their influence was limited because much of it was conducted on WhatsApp outside of school (another issue in itself). In our case the girl who was instigating it had quite a difficult home life and had been exposed to far too much for her age. Whilst very sad for the girl, I was very concerned about what my DD was being exposed to as a result.

Our DD was badly impacted early on and then removed herself as much as she could, but at the cost of feeling like an outsider. We were very relieved when the girl went to a different secondary school and fortunately, there has been nothing like it in our DD's new school.

Y3 is very young to be dealing with this sort of thing and I hope the school are able to nip it in the bud.

ThePants999 · 14/04/2022 10:23

Blimey. When I was in primary school, in the early 90s, none of this happened, not until secondary school.

Threetulips · 14/04/2022 10:22

and I would be having a word with the school to ask if they could help to address it

Why ‘Hi teacher I think it’s sweet DD has a boyfriend and all her friends are being mean and jealous’

Don’t you think teachers spend enough time dealing with these kids falling out because parents actively encourage it? Then what happens is the boy dumps one girls and dates another causing more upset - and round it goes

Stop thinking it’s sweet and tell her she can’t have a boyfriend til she’s 30! That will take the pressure off her because before you were agreeing with it.

ringoutthebells · 14/04/2022 10:22

'I think lots of parents unwittingly encourage this kind of thing because they find it cute or funny, but the kids just aren't old enough to deal with it.'

Agree with this.

froidIci · 14/04/2022 09:52

See - we don’t consider any of this “innocent and sweet” because the slope - as you evidently are seeing - is slippery.

DS in year 1 and has had his share of these things already but we have told him firmly that he’s far too young for all this and when Ella said she wanted to marry him - he said “my parents said we are too young for all this leave me alone”. Will try same with DD who is younger.

Me and spouse come from v different continents and cultures and both agree that none of this is innocent and sweet at this stage. It’s a slippery slope and they could really do without the distraction

kimfox · 14/04/2022 09:51

I have 3 DC, youngest currently Y5 and we never had any of this but reading this I'm quite shocked that perhaps it is "normal". I mean there's been the occasional x is y'all girlfriend / boyfriend but not like this with everyone getting involved & playing at relationships in such an in depth way. Mind is a bit boggled tbh.

Irritatedmum · 14/04/2022 09:48

I’d be absolutely horrified if any of the kids are watching Love Island. I’ve never seen it and never want to, but I know it’s definitely not appropriate for children. That hadn’t even occurred to me.

OP posts:
Suprima · 14/04/2022 09:39

This is really common to have them playing out boyfriend/girlfriends, even from Year 2! I just tell the children in my class that they are too young for boyfriends and girlfriends and it does fizzle out pretty quickly.

The only thing that concerns me is the language being used here. I would be really concerned that the girls are watching things like MAFS, Love Island and soaps to pick this up. I would speak to the teacher and see if a circle time could be done, and they also may be able to have a 1:1 chat with the ones acting the most teenage to work out why.

AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 09:35

You are endorsing the idea that there are real boyfriends which is a mistake I think.

I agree. They don't need exclusive "boyfriend"/"girlfriend" relationships at this age, it's much better to help them understand that they're all just "friends". And that they can have as many friends as they like.

littlebird2 · 14/04/2022 09:33

My dd is only in reception and this sort of thing terrifies me. It's not happening yet obviously. I went to an all girls school so never experienced the boyfriend thing until 16+. I think it's mad children take about this so young.
I would definitely speak with the teacher.

Santaslittlemelter · 14/04/2022 09:29

@Irritatedmum

To my DD having a boyfriend is just the most innocent thing really - sort of the boy she is most friendly with at that moment if you see what I mean. So it didn’t bother me until now. All this other talk is coming from other girls, or even maybe just one of the girls and they’re all learning it.
Yes but you can still put boundaries in place for her. She’s essentially role playing an adult thing no matter how ‘innocent’ that comes across. I think it would be a good idea to start backing her off the idea of boyfriends. And tell her clearly that just because you like a boy doesn’t mean he is a boyfriend, he’s a friend. And that she won’t have boyfriends till she is about 15 or older. And when she says her boyfriend be clear, it’s a game where they are pretending about boyfriends and girlfriends and if it’s turning nasty, she doesn’t need to play this game anymore and should extract herself.

You are endorsing the idea that there are real boyfriends which is a mistake I think.

AlexaShutUp · 14/04/2022 09:24

There was a bit of this in dd's school in reception. The school actively discouraged it and it stopped. There was nothing further really until dd was in Year 6. I don't think it's healthy tbh, and I would be having a word with the school to ask if they could help to address it. The idea of kids falling out over boyfriends/girlfriends at 8 is awful.

I think lots of parents unwittingly encourage this kind of thing because they find it cute or funny, but the kids just aren't old enough to deal with it.

Parentcarerandcrazy · 14/04/2022 09:13

@MooseBreath

Having been a teacher, this is normal depending on the class. Some girls are a "mature" 7-9 and think of themselves as teenagers. Those children in particular often are interested in makeup and fashion, but not always. A lot also have older siblings and watch things like Love Island.
Jesus! Love Island is NOT appropriate for even a 9yo. I honestly would be speaking to school about that. I know people have different parenting styles but that is honestly just awful. Is there a watered down version for before the watershed? I live in a rural area and to some extent I think the kids round here don't grow up as quick as urban kids but is that sort of thing standard?
Parentcarerandcrazy · 14/04/2022 09:05

My 7yo DD has had 'boyfriends' since Reception - as in, she will say 'X is my boyfriend now' and they might colour in pictures for each other 😅
My 6yo DS has a long-term girlfriend 🤣 they say they are in love and she sometimes kisses him on the hand! Its still completely sweet and innocent and never been through any kind of rocky periods or drama.
The stuff your child is being told is not appropriate for their age group though, I would be having a word with school.

SnowyPetals · 14/04/2022 09:00

Both my DC went to a mixed primary school. Even by the time they left at the end of Y6 there was none of this going on. I think they are too young and not normal in my experience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread