Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

LGBTQIA+ Meetings for young people, aged 14 to 25

64 replies

HereForTheGloss · 13/04/2022 19:32

A local Community Interest Company is advertising a weekly LGBTQIA+ meeting for young people aged 14 to 25.

I am responsible for a young person that has expressed an interest in attending but I have a concern about the age range and am not that happy about a 'young for their age' 14 year old, or any 14 year old actually, mixing with 25 year olds when the focus of these sessions (I assume) is on sexuality and gender identity. The only information I can find about the sessions online is that sessions act as a gateway for members to meet others from the same community, they also teach attendees the importance of LGBTQ+ history.

This is all new to us and the age range feels off to me. I'd be more comfortable if the meeting was for age 13 to 16 year olds for example.

I emailed the organisation to ask about the format and content of the meetings and the supervision and safeguarding procedures in place. I basically want to know who has eyes and ears on these children during the meetings to make sure they're not being groomed by the adult attendees at the meetings.

I got a response which did not answer any of my questions. The response was that they're "a professional organisation with all policies and procedures in place. I understand your concerns around 14 year olds mixing with 25 year olds but as a qualified teacher I risk assessed and made a decision based on the need for the group after receiving calls from parents who wanted their 14 year olds to be able to attend. As a mum and nan I treat the people in our care with the same respect that I treat my own. The group is always facilitated by one volunteer with lived experience and a qualified professional".

I can't find any policies, procedures or risk assessment info on the website. The CIC has been set up by 2 people and they and several of the volunteers have a bio on the website in which they detail their own mental health issues, how they were victims of child abuse, alcoholism, gender questioning from a young age, etc, but nothing about any relevant qualifications they have, or courses or training they've undertaken, or DBS checks.

Would they be required to have all this stuff in place and should they show me a copy of their risk assessments and policies if I ask to see them? Do I have the right to ask if everyone working there is DBS checked and ask for proof?

Tell me honestly am I just being ridiculously over protective? As I said if I knew it was a group of 13 to 16 year olds I'd feel much more comfortable as I'd see them more as peers, I'm not comfortable with a 14 year old hanging out and chatting about sexuality and sex with 25 year olds.

OP posts:
Thehundredthnamechange · 14/04/2022 05:57

This is massively inappropriate. A 14 year old child and a 25 year old adult should not be mixing like this. The child should be with other children and the adults with other adults. Massive safeguarding risk, not only because of the age difference but also because of the fact that the group is associated with sexuality?

QueenCamilla · 14/04/2022 04:11

I would be equally worried about the volunteers... Massive safeguarding risk.

BritinDelco · 14/04/2022 03:17

As a 15yo I joined one of these groups (20 years ago) it was invaluable in helping me find a safe space to explore the "unnatural " feelings I was having, and find other people like me.
Not all parents/carers are so accepting of their child's preferences as you are, I had to do this in secret. It helped me come out to my parents 5 years later.
While I understand safeguarding concerns at opposite ends of the age range, give this organisation a chance. Its a wonderful thing that organisations like the one you describe exist in the UK. I know several of my Lebanese/Emirati/Indian friends would have been very grateful for its existence

Boxowine · 14/04/2022 01:44

What does the "A" stand for? I thought it was "Aromantic". Am I correct that this means people who have sexual intercourse but do not engage romantically? What value is there in proctoring a meeting with a 25 year old male Aro and a 14 girl exploring her sexual identity?

When did these Aro men become a protected class?

FOJN · 13/04/2022 22:37

Your replies are going to be a load of homophobic drivel by people who clearly think gay = groomer and I suspect you will cheer to have the biases that are obvious in your OP confirmed but YABU.

This is nonsense. Do you think people would be OK with that age range if it was a group of straight people talking about sexuality? Exactly the same safeguarding concerns would arise.

It does no one any favours to accuse people of homophobia when they raise safeguarding concerns.

ArcheryAnnie · 13/04/2022 22:25

@nosyupnorth you clearly missed my post. Can confirm I'm a bender and think this group isn't appropriate.

(And no, I wouldn't think a support group for heterosexuals - where the only thing they have in common is their heterosexuality - should have an age range that lumps children with grown adults, either.)

KittenKong · 13/04/2022 22:02

Those age ranges are too wide - what clubs do kids go to with adults? Unless they are going say rock climbing or playing chess .

Lowhum · 13/04/2022 21:56

There is an LGBT charity in Wales that runs an 11-18 year group. I don’t know what discussions are had but it is labelled a support group.

SantanaBinLorry · 13/04/2022 21:51

Are you in N'Wales OP?

My sons school gave me some info about a group to contact in our area. Thankfully (and luckily for them, coz i would have kicked off big time!) I looked at their web page before hading details to my son.
The group was same age range 14-25, the next arranged 'meeting' was a zoom meeting for them all to watch and discuss Its a Sin together.
My son had only just turned 13 - the school did get an earfull about that!

It felt dodgy to me, for all the reasons stated above. The school didnt seem to have an issue with the organisation (or hadnt really thought about it til it was raised)
I certainly wont be directing my kid there even when they are old enough to.
These kind of voluntary orgs need some closer inspection. This is the only group available in our town, I dread to think how many kids have been advised to attend? It's creepy as fuck.

NoToLandfill · 13/04/2022 21:37

I think your gut instinct is telling you to keep the teenager in your care AWAY from this group. Listen to your instincts. This has grooming written all over it.

KittenKong · 13/04/2022 21:29

Any 25 year old wanting to jag out with 14 year olds… I’d be very wary.

Kids at school who can’t vote/drink/have sex/smoke - and 25 year old adult with a job/mortgage/spouse etc etc etc. they have nothing in common.

YouCantTourniquetTheTaint · 13/04/2022 21:24

Wow that sounds like a recipe for disaster. I'm bisexual and at 24, I was more into going out, than joining a group with a bunch of children.

A LGBT group for teens, great fabulous. A group for young adults, yeah great. Mixing 14-24 year olds? No, not appropriate at all, 14 year olds do not have anywhere near the maturity nor life experience of those in their early 20s.

Sounds like something a groomer has come up with tbh. And I'd question anyone age 18+ going to it.

MangyInseam · 13/04/2022 21:12

[quote BiscuitLover3678]@MangyInseam I have never seen them included before. What a shame they were! I agree it seems unrelated.[/quote]
I believe it's now unusual in the UK, Stonewall tried to shoehorn them in but stopped when asked. It's quite common to see in North America though.

veronicagoldberg · 13/04/2022 21:05

Sounds groomy.

TheGrinchsDog · 13/04/2022 20:49

@nosyupnorth

Your replies are going to be a load of homophobic drivel by people who clearly think gay = groomer and I suspect you will cheer to have the biases that are obvious in your OP confirmed but YABU.

If it's a local group the community might not be big enough to run seperate age group meetings, especially not if it's a newish group. Their response to your concerns might be unpolished but that doesn't mean it's nefarious. If you're that worried inquire about going along for support at least for the first meeting to get a sense of the group.

Do you ban you child from mixing with heterosexual adults? Almost certainly no. So it is pure homophobia that you think talking to LGBTQ adults would be inherently inappropriate. I would bet that the adults in that group have no interest in discussion sexual or adult details with a 14 year old any more than you want your 14 year old in that discussion, honestly there is higher risk from having group comprised solely of teens in which older teens may not recognise what is age appropriate for the whole group.

Um no, DFOD I'm Bi and I'm sure there are other posters who aren't heterosexual going to agree with me.

No I wouldn't want a 14yo in a group of heterosexual people where the reason for the group was their shared sexuality!

There are reasons - good, valid, not homophobic at all thank you very fucking much! - why you separate groups by age. When it's to do with sex and sexuality the same rule applies.

Gay does not = pervert.

However lax safeguarding where children and young teens (and adult women - sorry!) are concerned does = pervs trying to get access to their chosen prey. Same goes, as we all know, for positions of power etc etc.

HereForTheGloss · 13/04/2022 20:48

@nosyupnorth I have facilitated young people in my care to attend various groups - bereavement support, mental health support, support for carers groups, a variety of extra curricular sporting, dance and social activity groups - I've never known any group I've had involvement in thus far to have such a wide age range mixing together, and I'm guessing there's reason for that.

@vinoandbrie its not the Proud Trust, it's a local independent Community Interest Company.

I'm sure their intentions are only well meaning. I can't see from looking online that they are bound by any rules or regulations so maybe technically/officially they're doing nothing wrong, but I don't have a great feeling about their awareness of possible risks, especially after their email reply.

OP posts:
Margotshypotheticaldog · 13/04/2022 20:39

@nosyupnorth do you have kids?

Margotshypotheticaldog · 13/04/2022 20:38

I would bet that the adults in that group have no interest in discussion sexual or adult details with a 14 year old
Would you? would you bet your child on that?

vinoandbrie · 13/04/2022 20:36

This absolutely screams red flags. Vulnerable children in the younger age range would be at risk in terms of safeguarding. It’s not the Proud Trust is it?

Porcupineintherough · 13/04/2022 20:34

If sex is the issue then the group should run from ages 16-25. Which is fine except then there is the possibility that there arent enough children to run an under 16s group.

AchillesPoirot · 13/04/2022 20:30

I wouldn’t be happy with a 14 year old in a support group of any kind with adults.

nosyupnorth · 13/04/2022 20:27

Your replies are going to be a load of homophobic drivel by people who clearly think gay = groomer and I suspect you will cheer to have the biases that are obvious in your OP confirmed but YABU.

If it's a local group the community might not be big enough to run seperate age group meetings, especially not if it's a newish group. Their response to your concerns might be unpolished but that doesn't mean it's nefarious. If you're that worried inquire about going along for support at least for the first meeting to get a sense of the group.

Do you ban you child from mixing with heterosexual adults? Almost certainly no. So it is pure homophobia that you think talking to LGBTQ adults would be inherently inappropriate. I would bet that the adults in that group have no interest in discussion sexual or adult details with a 14 year old any more than you want your 14 year old in that discussion, honestly there is higher risk from having group comprised solely of teens in which older teens may not recognise what is age appropriate for the whole group.

Barbie222 · 13/04/2022 20:25

Very worrying from a safeguarding pov. Under 18 and over 18 meets should definitely be facilitated separately, unless every over 18 who goes along is crb checked, or every under 18 has a parent or carer. How can that work?

SolasAnla · 13/04/2022 20:21

Why would a 24 year old want to attend a social gathering with a 14 year old? What life experience do they share? What's the basis of any friendship?

Fine, if the 24 year old was mentoring or it was an activity like sport, hiking or learning a language etc.

But the 24 year old is a fully grown adult worried about a career path, earning to pay rent etc.

The 14 year old is still figuring out how to negotiate with their parents over their mid-week curfew.

There is too much of a power imbalance in any friendships.

BiscuitLover3678 · 13/04/2022 20:21

@MangyInseam I have never seen them included before. What a shame they were! I agree it seems unrelated.

Swipe left for the next trending thread