Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

LGBTQIA+ Meetings for young people, aged 14 to 25

64 replies

HereForTheGloss · 13/04/2022 19:32

A local Community Interest Company is advertising a weekly LGBTQIA+ meeting for young people aged 14 to 25.

I am responsible for a young person that has expressed an interest in attending but I have a concern about the age range and am not that happy about a 'young for their age' 14 year old, or any 14 year old actually, mixing with 25 year olds when the focus of these sessions (I assume) is on sexuality and gender identity. The only information I can find about the sessions online is that sessions act as a gateway for members to meet others from the same community, they also teach attendees the importance of LGBTQ+ history.

This is all new to us and the age range feels off to me. I'd be more comfortable if the meeting was for age 13 to 16 year olds for example.

I emailed the organisation to ask about the format and content of the meetings and the supervision and safeguarding procedures in place. I basically want to know who has eyes and ears on these children during the meetings to make sure they're not being groomed by the adult attendees at the meetings.

I got a response which did not answer any of my questions. The response was that they're "a professional organisation with all policies and procedures in place. I understand your concerns around 14 year olds mixing with 25 year olds but as a qualified teacher I risk assessed and made a decision based on the need for the group after receiving calls from parents who wanted their 14 year olds to be able to attend. As a mum and nan I treat the people in our care with the same respect that I treat my own. The group is always facilitated by one volunteer with lived experience and a qualified professional".

I can't find any policies, procedures or risk assessment info on the website. The CIC has been set up by 2 people and they and several of the volunteers have a bio on the website in which they detail their own mental health issues, how they were victims of child abuse, alcoholism, gender questioning from a young age, etc, but nothing about any relevant qualifications they have, or courses or training they've undertaken, or DBS checks.

Would they be required to have all this stuff in place and should they show me a copy of their risk assessments and policies if I ask to see them? Do I have the right to ask if everyone working there is DBS checked and ask for proof?

Tell me honestly am I just being ridiculously over protective? As I said if I knew it was a group of 13 to 16 year olds I'd feel much more comfortable as I'd see them more as peers, I'm not comfortable with a 14 year old hanging out and chatting about sexuality and sex with 25 year olds.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Itwasntmeright · 16/04/2022 15:02

Lesbian here

No, completely inappropriate. 14-year-old children should not be in a group with 25-year-old adults. Posters who disagree, go and look for another social group with this age range, I bet you won’t find one, and if you do I’ll bet you under 16s have to be accompanied by an adult.

They should be showing you their safeguarding policies, the fact that they haven’t suggests that they don’t have any. I would suggest reporting, but I suspect because it’s LGBTQI whatever, nobody will care.

All this groomy shit is being done in our name. Not in my name.

Boxowine · 16/04/2022 14:42

@BiscuitLover3678

You say No. It's Asexual! With an exclamation point. But Aro's are included in the LGBTQIA+ sphere and recognized as a sexual identity. They even have a flag for Pride. It's not entirely clear to me or anyone else that adult male Aro's are not included in this proposed group.

It's a legitimate concern, not because the straights are bigoted or liars but because we look at what information is put out and take the time to actually pay attention to what we have been told.

And what I am being told is that adult males who engage in physical sex but without experiencing romantic feelings are a legitimate subset of the LGBTQIA+ community and should neither be erased nor disparaged.

So what value is there in having a 25 year old Aro man met up with a 14 who is exploring their sexual identity?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/04/2022 21:23

Excellent post, IsabelaMadrigal, though I'd add that just because someone says they're "a teacher" doesn't necessarily mean they are one in the usually understood sense
The group I mentioned tried that with me too, and when pushed the answer was "Well, I deliver courses so I am a sort of teacher, ha ha"

They got told that their activity wouldn't be happening, and the abuse was something to behold, though luckily I'm old and ugly enough for it to have gone straight over my head

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/04/2022 21:15

I got a response which did not answer any of my questions
I can't find any policies, procedures or risk assessment info on the website

Both potential huge red flags, I'm afraid, and FWIW similar has happened to me within a community activity I run

At the very least you need full proof of:
Actual training and qualifications
Professional registration and with which governing body
DBS checks
How the course was developed and in consultation with whom
Policies, including guidelines and risk assessments

Just for asking you'll almost certainly be deemed a bigot and worse, but for anyone with sense the list above would be a minimum

LittleWhingingWoman · 14/04/2022 20:39

@nosyupnorth

Your replies are going to be a load of homophobic drivel by people who clearly think gay = groomer and I suspect you will cheer to have the biases that are obvious in your OP confirmed but YABU.

If it's a local group the community might not be big enough to run seperate age group meetings, especially not if it's a newish group. Their response to your concerns might be unpolished but that doesn't mean it's nefarious. If you're that worried inquire about going along for support at least for the first meeting to get a sense of the group.

Do you ban you child from mixing with heterosexual adults? Almost certainly no. So it is pure homophobia that you think talking to LGBTQ adults would be inherently inappropriate. I would bet that the adults in that group have no interest in discussion sexual or adult details with a 14 year old any more than you want your 14 year old in that discussion, honestly there is higher risk from having group comprised solely of teens in which older teens may not recognise what is age appropriate for the whole group.

Absolute nonsense.
IsabelaMadrigal · 14/04/2022 20:32

Just because someone is a teacher doesn't automatically make them a safeguarding guru.

With pgce's and other teaching courses you'd be lucky to get even a day of safeguarding.

We then get yearly training, but it understandably focuses on the big stuff, so you'd be unlikely to dig down into things like clubs.

Most teachers however, get our safeguarding knowledge from more experienced teachers and staff, which we in turn use and identify. A good teacher never assumes they 'know' safeguarding because the very nature of it is a many headed hydra. New technology and the determination of predators to access children means you never become 'the guru'.

So I'd advise this teacher to listen to safeguarding concerns that are brought to you instead of brushing them off. You need to be constantly checking your practice.

I'd also advise them to be especially careful with out of school clubs as if (when) something happens you will be fully responsible and have no team or union to back you up.

Children are too important to 'learn from mistakes'. Quit being arrogant and listen.

FairyLightPups · 14/04/2022 20:06

LGBTQ+ groups for young people are really important but as someone that works with young people I'd be splitting that group into:.

~ 14-15
~ 16-19
~ 20-25

Large mixes can be useful in small doses but ultimately it's a huge safeguarding concern and I say that for any youth group.

Belkell · 14/04/2022 20:03

nosy might want to ask themselves why it is OK for LGB teens to have a lower standard of safeguarding that those who don’t identify as such.

Singling out the gay kids for a blatantly poorer standard of service that the straight kids. Smells like discrimination to me. Accidental, and well meaning perhaps. But still.

Gay people aren’t any more likely to have nefarious intent than anyone else. But they aren’t arent less likely either. Youth groups draw the dodgy types in like moths to a flame. And anyone can say they are LBGTQIA++. It isn’t like there’s an entrance exam.

12yearsinazkaban · 14/04/2022 19:33

Mr and my 14-16yo group used to hang around with a 25 year old. He was a nonse and had a relationship with a girl 10 years younger than him. when they broke up he asked me to be his girlfriend and I was so Confused I said yes, thankfully as soon as I left I never saw him again.

I also met with one of his friends I would like at 16
... he was 40s! both would have jumped at this group....

Neverreturntoathread · 14/04/2022 18:10

I wouldn’t let my child go to that, no. There should be a child’s group and a separate adult group. Straight or gay, it isn’t appropriate for children to be chatting about sex with adults unless for the purposes of sex education in a very strict safeguarding situation eg tracher at school.

I think this group sounds kinda creepy.

Find a different support group there are loads.

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 14/04/2022 17:45

@nosyupnorth

Your replies are going to be a load of homophobic drivel by people who clearly think gay = groomer and I suspect you will cheer to have the biases that are obvious in your OP confirmed but YABU.

If it's a local group the community might not be big enough to run seperate age group meetings, especially not if it's a newish group. Their response to your concerns might be unpolished but that doesn't mean it's nefarious. If you're that worried inquire about going along for support at least for the first meeting to get a sense of the group.

Do you ban you child from mixing with heterosexual adults? Almost certainly no. So it is pure homophobia that you think talking to LGBTQ adults would be inherently inappropriate. I would bet that the adults in that group have no interest in discussion sexual or adult details with a 14 year old any more than you want your 14 year old in that discussion, honestly there is higher risk from having group comprised solely of teens in which older teens may not recognise what is age appropriate for the whole group.

Bollocks. I'm bisexual and this is wildly inappropriate.

ResisterRex · 14/04/2022 17:42

Good update OP. Adults can't just have access to minors. There are no special reasons or groups.

LondonOx · 14/04/2022 17:38

Sorry posted too soon! That last paragraph should have read:

I completely understand why you need to exercise caution in safeguarding the welcome of the young person in your care, but thought it was worth sharing the value that I personally found in connecting with other, older gay women so I would encourage you to think about how you might be able to facilitate this.

LondonOx · 14/04/2022 17:37

It was incredibly beneficial to me as a young gay teenager to meet and talk to older people from within the community who were able to provide mentorship, a sense of belonging and reassurance that the things that I wanted out of life (e.g. a long term committed relationship, children) were possible for me.

I actually think the group is more likely to be appropriate as a forum for the young person understanding more about their sexuality with a wider age range. In my experience, groups with a narrower age range e.g. 13-16 just turned into a match making event.

I completely understand why you need to exercise caution in safeguarding the welcome of the young person in your care, but thought it was worth sharing the value that I personally found in connecting with other, older gay women.

TheGrinchsDog · 14/04/2022 17:25

Good update Op!

However I agree with the PP that 16-25 age range isn't much of an improvement. I'd be a lot more comfortable with 18-25 personally and under 18's as groups.

I don't think her responses to you were all that great tbh. You had reasonable questions around the child safeguarding for the group and as a teacher and the person responsible for setting it up I think it's her duty to make sure all the I's are dotted and T's are crossed when it comes to safeguarding. Being able to give a concise and understandable outline of that to parents is an important part of that.

I wouldn't feel reassured by her responses anyway. Hopefully if she is reading this she won't get upset, hopefully instead she will take on board what has been said and next time someone asks be better equipped and able to answer them in a reassuring way.

HermioneWeasley · 14/04/2022 15:04

Hello owner of the group.

I’m delighted to hear that the repeated references to 4 year olds turn out to be a typo. I’m not convinced that 16-25 is much better, but at least it’s not an illegal child grooming club eh?!

Just a teeny reminder that paedophiles have relentlessly tried to use the rainbow umbrella to gain sympathy, respectability and access to children. Anyone involved in LGBT youth activities needs to be on high alert and offer these children the highest standards of safeguarding.

HereForTheGloss · 14/04/2022 14:56

Sorry, that wasn’t that quick or concise Grin

OP posts:
HereForTheGloss · 14/04/2022 14:52

Quick update - so the owner has seen this thread.

I had emailed again today and asked whether copies of policies and procedures were available as I couldn’t find them on their website, and whether group facilitators were DBS checked. I got an email reply which didn’t answer the questions, but said she’d be happy to have a talk on the phone.

As I said she’s seen this thread and I thought her tone was (maybe understandably?) quite defensive. During the conversation she asked me to remove this thread, but then later asked me to update it. I said if she though I’d misrepresented anything she could come and post on the thread herself but she declined.

She clarified that the group isn’t for 14-25 year olds, that’s a mistake in the advertising, she just hasn’t got round to updating the social media flyer yet.

For clarity, the social media flyer that has been circulated for months says the group is for 16 to 25 year olds, it’s only in the last week the age has been lowered to 14.

So the ad that was posted 2 days ago stating that the group is for ages 14-25’s is incorrect.

She agreed that 14 year old children meeting with 25 year old adults to discuss their sexuality was inappropriate, I pointed out that seemed to me at odds with her email reply I understand your concerns around 14-year olds mixing with 25-year olds; however, as a qualified teacher, I risk assessed and made a decision based on the current age range, and need for the group. She said she was rushed sending out the email as she’s so busy and hadn’t articulated her response properly. I’m pleased she clarified and agreed.

I kinda struggled to get a word in edgeways tbh Grin. I don’t for a minute think the group was set up with nefarious purpose in mind but it has just been not well thought through.

I’ve spoken to a friend who is a teacher and sent her a screenshot of the advert. If that advert continues to be circulated as it stands she is going to have a chat with the safeguarding person at school when they’re back but she pointed out that there is little if any regulation around these type of voluntary groups.

I have had a chat to the young person and explained that currently I’m not comfortable with them attending and why, but I will speak to some people as soon as the Easter hols are over and find an appropriate group. I don’t mind ferrying them around so if we end up having to travel into one of the 2 nearest cities to us if there are some good groups there, that’s not a problem and I’m totally on board with them accessing some peer support in this area.

OP posts:
BiscuitLover3678 · 14/04/2022 07:55

[quote Soontobe60]@BiscuitLover3678

I would hope that all children are asexual up to a certain point in their development! The alternative is to be ‘sexual’ - see the dictionary definition below.

asexual
/eɪˈsɛkʃʊəl/
adjective: asexual
1.
not involving sexual activity, feelings, or associations; non-sexual.
"he led an asexual life"
2.
BIOLOGY
(of reproduction) not involving the fusion of gametes.
"each polyp is capable of budding new polyps though asexual reproduction in spring"
noun
noun: asexual; plural noun: asexuals
a person who has no sexual feelings or desires, or who is not sexually attracted to anyone.[/quote]
I agree that asexual is something I wouldn’t expect to be assumed until adulthood.

But being asexual in general is a bit different. I’m sure you can look it up if you actually want to learn about it.

H1ghway · 14/04/2022 07:55

Of course we should be having groups for the LGBT demographic. Gay teens are excluded from finding meaningful relationships and often have nowhere to socialise as they are very much the minority. It is incredibly hard to connect with others like them. It can lead to safe guarding risks with online behaviour and MH issues.

We need more LGBT groups. If we did maybe they wouldn’t all be squashed into 1. I doubt very much it’s set up to groom.My son’s was 11-19( up to 25 if a disability). He was groomed online on one of the streaming sites open to all sexualities and which many teens access in their own rooms. He was never groomed at his group which involved paperwork to join and had adults supervising.

I think split age group is best as gay men/ teens can feel shit enough as it is without being classed as a groomer due to being in the same room as younger gay boys/men. Personally I think under 16s should be the ones to have a separate group.

Soontobe60 · 14/04/2022 07:23

@BiscuitLover3678

I would hope that all children are asexual up to a certain point in their development! The alternative is to be ‘sexual’ - see the dictionary definition below.

asexual
/eɪˈsɛkʃʊəl/
adjective: asexual
1.
not involving sexual activity, feelings, or associations; non-sexual.
"he led an asexual life"
2.
BIOLOGY
(of reproduction) not involving the fusion of gametes.
"each polyp is capable of budding new polyps though asexual reproduction in spring"
noun
noun: asexual; plural noun: asexuals
a person who has no sexual feelings or desires, or who is not sexually attracted to anyone.

Soontobe60 · 14/04/2022 07:19

@nosyupnorth

Your replies are going to be a load of homophobic drivel by people who clearly think gay = groomer and I suspect you will cheer to have the biases that are obvious in your OP confirmed but YABU.

If it's a local group the community might not be big enough to run seperate age group meetings, especially not if it's a newish group. Their response to your concerns might be unpolished but that doesn't mean it's nefarious. If you're that worried inquire about going along for support at least for the first meeting to get a sense of the group.

Do you ban you child from mixing with heterosexual adults? Almost certainly no. So it is pure homophobia that you think talking to LGBTQ adults would be inherently inappropriate. I would bet that the adults in that group have no interest in discussion sexual or adult details with a 14 year old any more than you want your 14 year old in that discussion, honestly there is higher risk from having group comprised solely of teens in which older teens may not recognise what is age appropriate for the whole group.

It’s not homophobia, it’s basic safeguarding. Children attend all sorts of groups - sports clubs, cubs, brownies, guides, youth clubs etc. they are all categorised by age. For a reason!

I’m not entirely sure that we should be having groups that are for a specific demographic - it sounds exclusionary to me. How would people react if there was a group set up solely for straight people? White people? Able-bodied people? Shouldn’t the aim in society to be that groups set up for a particular purpose - eg Guides, are inclusive of all girls within the age limits set by the group? Whether gay, straight, disabled etc?
LGBTQI+++ is a massive demographic. Including ‘I’ in that group seems a complete nonsense. It’s the only letter that stands for a physical disorder - intersex is a very outdated term too. It’s DSD. It’s not a sexual orientation, or an ideology. Having it in that letter string is like having D (for Down) in there. It makes no sense!
Q is seen by many many gay people as a massive homophobic insult.
LGB are sexual orientations
T is a gender identity
+++ is just daft.

So no, questioning the appropriateness of such a group covering the ages that this group covers isn’t homophobic. It’s common sense safeguarding and applies to any type of group where this age range is catered for. Parents know that when they send their children to school every single member of staff has undergone rigorous safeguarding checks and training. As teachers, we accept that we have to do this. We don’t think that our employers or the parents believe we’re all paedophiles!

BiscuitLover3678 · 14/04/2022 06:58

@Boxowine

What does the "A" stand for? I thought it was "Aromantic". Am I correct that this means people who have sexual intercourse but do not engage romantically? What value is there in proctoring a meeting with a 25 year old male Aro and a 14 girl exploring her sexual identity?

When did these Aro men become a protected class?

No it’s asexual! Or ace.

I can see how this might be useful as it’s young people talking to adults who have gone through something similar and can actually be supportive. A lot of the teens will be still going through it.

It depends how it is all talking place. I agree that just general mixing and a 25 year old taking numbers of teenagers is horrendous. Is that what this is though?

ResisterRex · 14/04/2022 06:16

Your replies are going to be a load of homophobic drivel by people who clearly think gay = groomer and I suspect you will cheer to have the biases that are obvious in your OP confirmed but YABU

And

Sounds like the age has been lowered for particular children. If you have concerns then you should go along to the first one to see what’s what.

Absolute garbage. All children deserve the same protections and levels of safeguarding. No adults get to mix with children because it's a particular subject. The CIC arrangement and the topic is a distraction. The issue is adults accessing children.

The organiser needs to be reported to their employer.

Thehundredthnamechange · 14/04/2022 06:00

"Your replies are going to be a load of homophobic drivel by people who clearly think gay = groomer and I suspect you will cheer to have the biases that are obvious in your OP confirmed but YABU"

What utter nonsense. A support group for heterosexual teenage girls and heterosexual adult males would be absolutely unacceptable and probably wouldn't even be allowed to run at all, especially if the focus was on sexuality.