Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have such a visceral reaction to being called by my name?

465 replies

Nameproblemsagain · 13/04/2022 16:30

I probably am BU about this, but when my parents named me they gave me a totally different name to the one I’ve always been named and while on a logical sort of level I know this wasn’t the intent, it’s always felt a bit like a cruel joke.

Went into the bank today and was greeted by the wrong name. It just really fills me with annoyance.

I know people will say to change it but I’ve never been sure that this doesn’t create more problems than it solves. Plus, I think actually doing this would make me angry too!

So hit me - AIBU?

OP posts:
Nameproblemsagain · 13/04/2022 22:29

In all truth and honesty I wouldn’t say that changing my surname wasn’t a big deal. It wasn’t the hardest thing in the world, obviously, but it wasn’t no work at all either. But that is by the by: the thread has fixated on changing my name even though I’ve said (politely - thanks for above for acknowledging that!) that I’d prefer not to do that for a variety of reasons!

OP posts:
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 13/04/2022 22:29

@Nameproblemsagain

Thanks for the responses. The problem is if I changed names formally I’d have to keep explaining that then which makes it a bigger deal than it is.

Surely the bank didn't call you by the wrong name. They called you by your name

See it’s comments like this that are the problem. I’ve had teachers say to me that it’s my name and insist on calling me it, situations in healthcare etc. It’s not my name and never has been.

You've got two options, really, haven't you? Change your name legally. Or issue everyone in banks, healthcare, teaching, and every other institution with a crystal ball, so that they can magically sense that the name you use on documents is not what you want to be called.

Which do you think will be easier?

DropYourSword · 13/04/2022 22:27

I think the issue with this thread is that your actusl issue is trying to resolve the feelings you have with your parents giving you this 'joke' name.
Unfortunately the way you've explained your issue means everyone is focusing on the actual name and how easy it would be to change it, rather than the deeper issue you're experiencing.

If you changed your surname when you got married you would have seen it isn't a particularly big deal to change your name, and that a concern about job applications etc is fairly misplaced.

I don't think it's some posters fault that they've misunderstood your concern if they haven't read all your replies. But fuck me, there are some desperately rude people here.

Badnessinthefolds · 13/04/2022 22:23

You're being utterly ridiculous.

Thousands of people in the UK go by their middle name. Thousands.

No one cares.

I've had loads of job applications land on my desk where a name change has been declared and the reason is "always been known by middle name."

No one cares. It isnt a discussion. At all.

@BeforeGodAndAllTheFish except OP cares... And it's her name. It's really not about what anyone else thinks.

She's said repeatedly that she doesn't want to change her name because it won't take away the feeling she has about it.

The feeling of being reminded when she's called the wrong name will be replaced by a similar feeling when she fills in a form with the name change.

Maybe it would solve it for you- or thousands of other people- but that's not really the point here.

@Nameproblemsagain you have my sympathy for a difficult situation and the variety of responses in this thread. I think you've remained polite throughout.

I wonder if Relationships might have given you a different response than aibu? As pp have said, this is an emotional thing and those can't always be easily resolved or judged as un/reasonable because feelings aren't rational

Glamora · 13/04/2022 22:07

@Nameproblemsagain

It really isn’t bullshit. When we apply for jobs we have to write down if we’ve ever changed our name and why. In the overwhelming majority of cases it’s just going to be ‘got married / divorced.’
But how many jobs do you apply for?
SoupDragon · 13/04/2022 22:07

If you have to given an explanation then, like a PP said, you only need to say "always known by my middle name". Nothing more is required

shakeitoffshakeacocktail · 13/04/2022 22:05

Oooh I really want to share my joke name now!!!

Done entirely on purpose as a nod to the Beatles and drug usage (hopefully) not this specific drug

Song
Lucy in the sky with diamonds

My initials at birth were LSD

I always thought it was a good icebreaker 😄
I'm NOT a drug user

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 13/04/2022 22:04

@amoobaa

She wouldnt have been called the wrong name at most of her examples if she just legally changed it when she became an adult and updated all her records.

Going for her C section, they never even would have known her old name.

It's on her for dragging it around with her for no damn reason.

BreatheAndFocus · 13/04/2022 22:04

My DB has always used his middle name not his first name. In fact, he was named with the expectation his middle name would be his ‘real’ name. This was because our parents thought the two names they’d chosen worked best in that order. It’s never caused any problems and no one has called him the wrong name.

I presume this is because of the way it’s been recorded - ie making it clear it’s the middle name that’s the name to be used. On less official documents my DB doesn’t even put his first name. His bank calls him by his ‘real’ name too - because he’s clearly got it recorded in a way that makes this obvious eg, his bank card.

Could you not slowly go through all places your name is recorded and amend it in such a way to remove the chance someone will mistakenly call you it? And for places where you don’t have to put your full name, just omit it altogether.

Walkingalot · 13/04/2022 22:02

I've changed my surname a few times through marriage and by deed-pol - 5. I've never been asked why. It really is that easy, as other pp have said. For something that bothers you so much, surely it would be worth the effort. IF anyone asks, just say you've always been known as .*** so finally making it legal. End of story.
I'm assuming your name was something like Penny (Anne) Farthing and you got married and are now Penny (Anne) Smith but your parents always called you Anne. Incredibly childish of them but what can you do!

Lougle · 13/04/2022 22:02

My Dad is Scottish and often if the given name is x, the used name is y. He seamlessly switches between x and y depending on context. It makes it slightly awkward at times for me because I deal with lots of his affairs and I have to take a minute to think about whether he would be x or y in that context.

My DD has LDs. We gave her quite an old fashioned long name that shortened into a name that is a popular contraction of three or four different first names. The contraction can be spelt -y or -ie. Hers is -ie and she gets really cross if someone spells it -y.

Two of her first coherent sentences (speech and language disorder) were 'My name is -ie. There's no 'y' in '

Lifesonebigparty · 13/04/2022 22:02

You don't sound angry. You sound fed up and exhausted with it all and I don't blame you.

I don't think it's as simple as changing your name. This is so much more than that. Do you think you'd benefit from talking to a counsellor? And if your parents are still around, can you tell them how it has affected your whole life because it has impacted your whole life.

Topsyturveymam · 13/04/2022 22:02

I changed my name to my mums maiden name by deed poll when I was 18 years, due to a disappearing father (I had his name on my birth certificate).

I’ve had to put my former surname on some forms but never been asked why I changed my name. I think some have assumed marriage, but the reason is no-one else’s business.

I know you feel fed up with being given the name on your birth certificate in the first place … but you don’t have to carry the name if you don’t want too.
Deed poll, get a new passport and ta dar! Done!

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 13/04/2022 22:01

You're being utterly ridiculous.

Thousands of people in the UK go by their middle name. Thousands.

No one cares.

I've had loads of job applications land on my desk where a name change has been declared and the reason is "always been known by middle name."

No one cares. It isnt a discussion. At all.

Once you change it at the bank, it is done. They wont call you by your old name again. It's done.

You're one of those people who just enjoys misery. You're creating your own drama and misery and wont take 5 minutes to put a simple solution in motion.

People change their names every day, for all sorts of reasons.

No on cares.

Either change it or stop moaning when strangers use your legal name.

amoobaa · 13/04/2022 21:58

@Nameproblemsagain I think you’ve remained very composed, considering how many people simply aren’t listening to you and seem unable to think about your experience from an emotional perspective rather than a practical one.

You could easily change your name by deed poll but that won’t magically fix the feelings you have about what your parents have done.

To all the people dismissing OP’s feelings, you can’t seriously believe that a parent’s choice of name for their child carries so little significance?

Think of all the times people pour their heart and soul into name choices. Because they care so much.

OP, I think it’s really sad that your parents have chosen a name that is a joke and their only explanation when questioned is that they found it funny.

Read up on transference (in psychoanalytic theory) you might find it interesting that the overwhelming majority of posters here are responding to you with frustration, annoyance and anger… when you have done nothing wrong apart from share your feelings. Not only that, but you would be completely justified in feeling frustrated, annoyed and angry yourself.

But these are devastating and painful feelings. I can understand why you wouldn’t want to go there and I imagine you realise this (because you mentioned that this issue is much deeper for you than a bit of legal paperwork).

Perhaps All these posters are doing you a favour. Perhaps they are all feeling and expressing the feelings that you don’t want to feel or express.

Perhaps the unexpressed feelings, the understandable anger towards your parents (whom you can love and be furious with simultaneously) go something along the lines of, ‘what the actual fuckety fucking fuck are you playing at!?’

Why did they treat your name like a joke?

Why do they show no interest in your feelings about it, when it continues to follow you and taint so many significant moments in your life and times you feel most vulnerable- your jobs, your c-section and all the other times/ things you mentioned.

Posters here are basically holding a big mirror up to you and reflecting back your own feelings.

Maybe you’d be better off if you owned some of these feelings OP?

I bet you’d have got a different, more empathic, kinder response if you’d said:

I know I can easily change my name by deed poll but I’m just so fucking angry/ hurt (insert your emotions here) that my parents chose a joke name for me. Didn’t I mean more to them than that? I know it’s ultimately my responsibility to deal with it (and all the unwanted memories and feelings it’s left me with) BUT that doesn’t change how unfair it feels. I wish they hadn’t done this to me, it’s made me feel so shit. In my day to day life I hide my feelings and I just want a place to express then here.

Maybe it’s time to get angry?

Feelings are not logical and they can’t really be judged. They just are. And they tell us a great deal about ourselves if we pay attention to them.

For what it’s worth, I think you’re entirely reasonable and I welcome your feelings, whatever they are.

Maybe once you feel heard and respected, you’ll be able to think about changing your name (as the icing on the cake, not the solution to your hurt).

I know it’s not fair, but ultimately you are now responsible for something that you neither deserved nor asked for. In fact, it’s entirely the fault of your parents… but you alone have to pick up the piece and decide if you want to move forwards or stay stuck.

You sounds lovely and I hope you find a way to get unstuck Flowers

Mydogmylife · 13/04/2022 21:57

@Nameproblemsagain

The problem isn’t really solved though.

As I’ve said I still have to refer to it on job apps etc and I need to explain why I changed it and tbh I don’t particularly want to get into it.

I do understand some people think that this is purely about the name and it isn’t.

I'm sorry, I'm not getting the part why you have to refer to your name change /explain it and you really don't!!!! Just get it changed , then get some help for your issues re the name
palmplantcirca1980s · 13/04/2022 21:55

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Wrongkindofovercoat · 13/04/2022 21:53

Another who was given a 'first' name which I have never been called, not only that, but the 'first' name was one that people often got wrong. Cue a bit of a panic when I wouldn't wake up following surgery because they were calling my name, one I had never been called and also pronouncing the one I had been called wrongly !

Hariboqueen1 · 13/04/2022 21:51

I understand you op. You need to get your name changed. Yea it will be a pain in the arse for a few years but in the future it will be fine and so distant. I think you should go through with it. I dont think it will be as hassle as you think, people change surnames all the time when getting married. If I was you I would go through the hassle now and some hassle for a few years, and every year it will crop up even less than the last. When you are 80 you wont have heard or had to think of the name for decades.

AMBE123 · 13/04/2022 21:44

I was adopted. On adoption my parents changed my name to a name that always jarred with me, and then called me a nickname (basically the 2 initial letters) anyway. My adopted name never fitted me and I never liked it. I tolerated the nickname out of respect but didn't like it, I am a person and I have a name, not just letters! Eventually I changed my first name by deed poll to a name of my choice. As others have said, it costs about £20. Then you send the deed poll off with your driving licence and passport applications to get them changed to new name. Voila, you then have official photo ID of your new name to use everywhere else. You take that to GP etc and get them to change the name on your health records.

On job applications, you just give your new name. If asked to show ID you show photo ID. If you have to fill out security forms eg for criminal records checks you will be asked if you were ever known by another name and you declare it there.

It really is as simple as people are saying, I promise you.

Names are important, they are part of us. Change your name to legally be what you have always been called if you prefer that name.

TheGrinchsDog · 13/04/2022 21:44

Changing it formally won’t solve that no matter how annoyed people get about it. I’m genuinely sorry if that’s frustrated people but that’s how it is.

But changing it would solve part of the problem.

People are getting frustrated because you are so stuck in this way of thinking that you can't see that by changing your name it would probably help you enormously in the future.

People have given you really good advice about the disclosure forms for work, which I agree with PP won't need filled out very often surely?

People have given you really good advice about therapy and your parents.

You aren't taking any of it on board. It makes for hard reading and I'm sad for you OP, I've been that person and you don't poo-poo good suggestions and turn away from help because it's fun. This is clearly a bigger problem than you are able to let yourself see Flowers I really hope you get some help with this.

ldontWanna · 13/04/2022 21:42

@Gardeningcreature

I think this needs to be a warning to all parents: Stop calling your children ridiculous names. You need to register your baby as the name you intend to call your child. I'm not taking about Stephen/Steve or Josephine/Josie. I'm taking about registering your child as Fanny Maggie Moo and then referring to them as Laura. It's ridiculous. I know of adults who are called say Martin John Jones but their parents have always intended calling them Johnny. When asked why they did this it's always "Oh John or Johnny Jones doesn't sound as good!" Well why on earth register them as Martin? Seriously it's stupid. I feel the same about surnames. Unmarried parents, mum has a lovely surname, dad has a name that will be ridiculed. Add to this the name they have chosen for their child sounds silly when coupled with dad's surname and what do they do? Lumber the child with the shit surname.
I gave DD her dad's surname precisely so she wouldn't be stuck with the/my shit (and also very weird/wrong sounding with her first name) surname.Grin
BoredZelda · 13/04/2022 21:39

You have the choice of changing it, or re-framing your attitude to it. Only you can decide which to do.

Or do nothing and just seethe about it for the rest of your life.

RosiePosieDozy · 13/04/2022 21:38

I feel for you. Naming a child is a massive thing and something that stays with a person forever. To have an almost joke name is unacceptable IMO. Your parents were nasty to do this. Whether it was intended nastiness or not, it's a lot to deal with.

Gardeningcreature · 13/04/2022 21:33

I think this needs to be a warning to all parents:
Stop calling your children ridiculous names.
You need to register your baby as the name you intend to call your child. I'm not taking about Stephen/Steve or Josephine/Josie. I'm taking about registering your child as Fanny Maggie Moo and then referring to them as Laura.
It's ridiculous.
I know of adults who are called say Martin John Jones but their parents have always intended calling them Johnny. When asked why they did this it's always "Oh John or Johnny Jones doesn't sound as good!" Well why on earth register them as Martin? Seriously it's stupid.
I feel the same about surnames.
Unmarried parents, mum has a lovely surname, dad has a name that will be ridiculed. Add to this the name they have chosen for their child sounds silly when coupled with dad's surname and what do they do? Lumber the child with the shit surname.