Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have such a visceral reaction to being called by my name?

465 replies

Nameproblemsagain · 13/04/2022 16:30

I probably am BU about this, but when my parents named me they gave me a totally different name to the one I’ve always been named and while on a logical sort of level I know this wasn’t the intent, it’s always felt a bit like a cruel joke.

Went into the bank today and was greeted by the wrong name. It just really fills me with annoyance.

I know people will say to change it but I’ve never been sure that this doesn’t create more problems than it solves. Plus, I think actually doing this would make me angry too!

So hit me - AIBU?

OP posts:
HELLITHURT · 14/04/2022 06:52

My SIS is in the same position, never has an issue.

All very dramatic!

QuinkWashable · 14/04/2022 06:33

Incidentally you can’t legally change children’s names in the UK unless done officially with the consent of everybody with PR or a court order.

Oh, yes, I had full permission from his dad. I actually think that the deed poll isn't technically enough until you're 16 either, that it should be officially recorded in the gazette or whatever - but the passport office issued his passport without issue, and he's had visas in multiple countries since, so it doesn't seem to be an issue anyway.

In the UK we're very free-for-all for names unlike a child I met who had 3 official names due to being Greek (ie a name written in greek characters), born in France (ie. needing a greek name, in anglicised characters), with a dad from a country that used Cyrillic (so a second passport, with his greek name, now in Cyrillic). The mum was tearing her hair out filling in forms with that!

Butchyrestingface · 14/04/2022 06:29

It really isn’t bullshit. When we apply for jobs we have to write down if we’ve ever changed our name and why

Who is ‘we’? I HAVE changed my name and don’t recall ever having had to explain why in nearly 30 years. Others on the thread have said the same.

Even if you do have to give a reason, what’s so hard about writing “have never been known by this name?”

No, changing your name WON’T magically get rid of the feelings associated with your parents thoughtlessness, but it will at least prevent you being confronted by them whenever you meet strangers in formal situations.

Some people seem to LIKE being victims. It’s comfortable. Taking control would involve stepping out of that role and so they don’t do it. Which is frustrating to watch/read, and probably why you’ve had the responses you’ve had. Counselling would let you explore why you won’t take one simple, straightforward step to help yourself.

JeffThePilot · 14/04/2022 05:04

@QuinkWashable

So yes it might be my name in a legal sense but since I’ve never been called it

In the UK you can call yourself whatever you like and that is your legal name. If you have never used the one on your birth certificate, then it is simply not your legal name, it's just the name on your birth certificate.

And getting a passport in a new name is easy, you don't even need your deedpoll to be put in the register, you literally pay the UK deed poll service 35 quid (this is for peace of mind, you don't officially even need to do that), and send that deedpoll, along with your birth certificate, and yes, an explanation that you have changed your name and would like your passport in the new one (and that's all!). I know this, I did it for my son.

Driving license is similarly easy, just explain that you want to use the name you want to use. Honestly.

Incidentally you can’t legally change children’s names in the UK unless done officially with the consent of everybody with PR or a court order.

But yes, for adults it’s a simple process.

aurynne · 14/04/2022 04:43

OP, with all due respect, you are CHOOSING to be enraged and upset time and time again by an issue which would be easily solved, and you keep looking for excuses not to solve it, hence guaranteeing a life of upset and frustration. It does sound like you just enjoy the drama.

You have two options:

a) You DON'T legally change your name and put up with people using your legal name. People cannot read you mind to know you're not known by that name, and honestly, won't care about your naming circumstances either.

b) You DO legally change your name. You may have to go through a bit of red tape, but that will prevent the situation in a).

Your choice, really.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 14/04/2022 01:06

PigletJohn

Not wanting to out you, but I'm assuming your previous name was Jon Hamm - and you changed it as you kept getting your post mixed up with that of the American actor? Grin

PigletJohn · 14/04/2022 00:20

If you decide you want to change your name, it is not difficult and it is not unending hassle.

I made an alteration to mine, and notified the tax and NI offices, and the doctor. Hardly anybody else has any records going back to before I changed it.

Anybody else, I just tell my "new" name. If I start a new job, I tell them my name, and it matches the tax and NI forms.

If anybody wants to see my birth certificate, I provide it with a covering letter (I used to have some spare copies printed, but now I keep it on the computer and print when required.. Which is very very rare.

Topseyt · 13/04/2022 23:32

Parents should take the responsibility of naming their children seriously and not saddle their children with "joke" names. It is shortsighted, stupid and disrespectful to the people they will grow into.

I'm glad my parents weren't into doing that sort of thing. The worst they did was decide that I would be known by my middle name and to this day I really can't understand why. Why couldn't they have put the name I was to be known by first on my birth certificate. They have never been able to explain it either (I have asked).

I've had to explain fairly often why I am known by my middle name. I don't think my reaction to this is as visceral as OP's, but I do feel frustrated by it. It is tedious.

I've seriously considered using deed poll to officially drop the first name that I never use. I can't quite decide to take the plunge though. My parents didn't choose a joke name, they did choose carefully and gave names that they loved. Deciding to change that isn't a decision I would take lightly.

I understand some of OP's frustration. I suspect that the real issue is hurt at the joke name. I would personally find that hard to forgive.

Nefelibata86 · 13/04/2022 23:21

Some of these responses are pretty harsh. A name is a big part of identity for goodness sake, one of the first we get and pretty much the first thing we learn about someone when we meet. Try to have some imagination or empathy for what it’s like to be saddled with one for whatever reason has associated baggage with it.
I dislike my name for various reasons, partly because it doesn’t suit me and my parents were definitely thinking of themselves when they named me and not of how it would be to have that name and the image of the person it may conjure which while being a lazy stereotype has still been tricky to navigate at times and just does not fit with me or my identity.

Being called by it is jarring. I’ve experienced trauma in my life and have a high adverse childhood experience score. It doesn’t make how I feel on a bodily level about my name any less as others have suggested and in doing so have belittled the OPs experiences as unimportant.

Runnerduck34 · 13/04/2022 23:19

Blame your parents not the bank staff who naturally called you by your legal name. why on earth didn't your parents register you under the name they wanted to use?! I can see why you're cross with them.
I'm sorry , but the only way to avoid this is to legally change your name to the unofficial one you are known by.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 13/04/2022 23:17

@Nameproblemsagain

In all truth and honesty I wouldn’t say that changing my surname wasn’t a big deal. It wasn’t the hardest thing in the world, obviously, but it wasn’t no work at all either. But that is by the by: the thread has fixated on changing my name even though I’ve said (politely - thanks for above for acknowledging that!) that I’d prefer not to do that for a variety of reasons!
You've already changed your name, though, or rather your parents have. You might not want to go through the rigamarole of a deed poll, but why don't you just drop your first name and use the middle one, to avoid irritation, given that that is how you are known anyway?

You're called Eleanor Rigby or Jane Austen, or whatever it is, but you've always been known as Sarah. In most contexts, you can just call yourself Sarah Rigby. Legally, your name is whatever you are known by. DH has a foreign name that no one can pronounce, so he is known by a British name that bears no relation to his actual name - say, his actual name is Tharupiyum but he is known as Harry. Harry is not on his birth certificate but it has become the name he is known by, Apart from his passport and our marriage certificate, he is Harry on everything else, perfectly legally.

I get what you are saying about changing your name officially not erasing the original irritation with your parents. OTOH, why keep rubbing your own face in it, by using Eleanor on forms etc when, in 99% of situations, you could just call yourself Sarah?

NotADressPerson · 13/04/2022 23:06

Why don't you want to change your name op?

Puffalicious · 13/04/2022 23:05

I just find it strange that you're traumatised by your name that you've never really been called, that was given to you by people that love and care for you (as you stated). There are many, many MNers who are traumatised by terrible, awful childhood experiences. In this context your perceived trauma seems utterly ridiculous.

Let it go.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/04/2022 23:02

I might have misunderstood, but I'm gathering that it wasn't just a normal name that sounds funny with a surname, like Theresa Green or Eileen Dover, but that the first name is not really a name - just a word chosen and used as a name to make it sound funny. The kind of thing you might joke about calling your child but (most people) would never actually do.

So you keep getting something like this (or worry about it happening, even if it doesn't):

Hi, I'm Lisa Higgins

But it says here 'M. L. Higgins'

Yes, I go by my middle name

Ah, well we need your full name, so what's your first name?

Merry. I'm Merry Lisa Higgins.

Ooh, that's unusual, I've never heard of somebody called Merry before. Did your parents have a reason for calling you that?

Yes, my maiden name was Christmas, so my parents called me Merry: Merry Christmas.

What? Why would they do that?!

I think they found it funny.

Oh.

And then there's the awkward silence - thoughts that might be going through their head such as:
Why would you actually do that?
Were her parents really stupid?
Did they not like her?
Is she making it up, just for attention?

And this throws you into the spotlight, makes you feel judged, makes you start to wonder the same about your parents - did they not like me, did they just see me as little more than a joke to give them a giggle and not care about me going through life like that?

But at the same time, it IS still the official name that you were given and it feels odd officially jettisoning it; like doing so would bring all the ill-feeling for your parents out in the open - when they are/were nice, kind parents in all other respects, apart from saddling you with a ridiculous name. Considering officially changing it feels almost like you have to throw away a part of your identity and yourself - even though it's not your commonly used identity, it does still relate to you. Because giving a child a name is such a major thing, you would feel like changing it was a betrayal of them and a huge slap in the face to them, when they just wanted you to have an interesting name.

All the time when, if they'd just called you Lisa Claire, even on occasions when you do have to give your maiden name, it's just:

What was your maiden name?

Christmas - Lisa Claire Christmas.

Ooh, that's a nice festive name!

I think I might see where you're coming from now, OP - and it's a deep-rooted issue that saying "Just change it and stop moaning, so simple" doesn't really address at all. I may be way off, but I think I sort of get it Flowers

Itsmemaggie · 13/04/2022 22:49

I do agree with the poster who says that you’re choosing to hold on to this - I’m sure you have your reasons for that, it would be healthier to accept and move on but life isn’t always that simple.

Hatinafield · 13/04/2022 22:48

I’m assuming it’s something like Mr and Mrs Houston called their daughter Whitney Jane?

I’m not going to try and convince you to change your name. But I do find it really interesting that you’d rather stay in this situation which causes you so much angst rather than avail yourself of the straightforward legal fix available to you. Any idea why that is?

Itsmemaggie · 13/04/2022 22:46

To be fair to the posters getting frustrated at you not wanting to change your name when it seems like an obvious solution, your initial posts do sound angry and emotional. You’ve clearly calmed down a bit.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 13/04/2022 22:44

This thread is so confusing and infuriating all at the same time! 😂
If that's your legal name and you hate it that much, change it.
If not, you'll have to just learn to live with it.
Of course banks are going to deal with you as your legal name.
One they have to, two they're not mind readers.
Not sure what posters on here can advise if you're adamant it's too much hassle to change?

Now I am married the first name has lost its “humour” so it’s just a bit strange.
I'm intrigued though lol
You keep saying they found it funny.
It's a joke.
Now wondering what it could be
Annette Curtain?
Theresa Green?!
Lydia Bin?!
Grin

Phewthemutinyworked · 13/04/2022 22:43

I have a very generic traditional name but have always referred to my shortened throughout my whole life …I actually get really angry and annoyed if I am referred to original name ! So I do understand your annoyance…names are so personal and defining.

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 13/04/2022 22:42

But you would never have to explain it.

You change it. You update all your records. No one asks why.

Very very occasionally, you may need to put it on a job application but that's what... maybe once every 5 years?

You would never have to explain it.

Right now, you do. You need to give your legal name and then you need to ask people to call you by your middle name and then you need to remind people. Then you still encounter every day situations like the bank where they dont know at all.

It never ends. You need to explain it every time. You feel under attack every time a name is needed.

And that's the problem. The constant battle. The constant reminder. The inconvenience.

All of that goes away when you change it and spend a day dealing with paperwork to update everything.

No one is going to ask you why. You wont encounter these conversations ever again. It's just done with.

You get the name you want. The name you feel is yours. And you dont need to discuss it again.

You get to move on.

You've got a bad taste in your mouth and you're choosing to hold it there and constantly swallow it back. Just spit it out.

Glamora · 13/04/2022 22:40

@Nameproblemsagain

I won’t have to explain why I have changed my name because I won’t be changing my name. I have a number of reasons for this and I have been clear and consistent about this on the thread.

As someone has said above it’s more the emotional reaction. It has been useful to talk about.

You're having an emotional reaction to something you can fix but chose not to.

It's like me breaking my leg, and not getting it put in plaster because I won't be able to wear my high heels. So what if it hurts, and will cause me long term damage, I want to wear my high heels and complain about the pain and deformity.

nocoolnamesleft · 13/04/2022 22:39

Is this really about the name at all? Or is it about your relationship with your parents? You said (I paraphrase) that they made a joke out of your name. And you said in another place that when your surname changed the joke didn't make sense. Is this something that seems clever for a nanosecond whilst drunk, that no decent person would actually call their child? Like Olive Groves, Dwayne Pipes etc? Because if so, then yes, in your position I would be mightily pissed off that my parents had done that to me, making a joke of my name and my future. And changing the name wouldn't eradicate the anger and the hurt. But it might possibly trigger you less often.

Nameproblemsagain · 13/04/2022 22:32

I won’t have to explain why I have changed my name because I won’t be changing my name. I have a number of reasons for this and I have been clear and consistent about this on the thread.

As someone has said above it’s more the emotional reaction. It has been useful to talk about.

OP posts:
amoobaa · 13/04/2022 22:30

[quote BeforeGodAndAllTheFish]@amoobaa

She wouldnt have been called the wrong name at most of her examples if she just legally changed it when she became an adult and updated all her records.

Going for her C section, they never even would have known her old name.

It's on her for dragging it around with her for no damn reason.[/quote]
Yes, it’s entirely true that she wouldn’t have been called the wrong name if she had changed it.

But I think that’s missing the point.

Perhaps it’s not the name itself that causes so much emotion, but the fact her parents chose it for her as a thoughtless joke.

Is it on her for dragging the name around?

Or is it on her parents for giving her that name to begin with?

If you want to point your finger at someone, why point it at the victim?

Yes time has moved on… Yes she’s an adult now… Obviously it’s her responsibility to fix the problem (that they created) but she has every right to express her feelings about it.

If I poked you in the eye, and you expressed pain… wouldn’t you hope bystanders would say, “ouch, that looked painful… Amoobaa was out of order doing that to you” rather than, “oh do shut up and get over it… all you need to do is put some ice on it”

Yes, if you were still banging on about your eye decades later, everyone would be fed up.

But what if I poked you in the eye on the day you were born and it impacted your for the rest of your life AND you never expressed your hurt? Then one day you decided to say how much it affected you and people told you to shut up and just put some ice in it?

No… the reasonable response would be, “I’m so sorry Amoobaa poked you in the eye when you were so defenceless and vulnerable. I can see why you’d be hurt. I’m afraid you’re responsible for your eye care now and unfortunately you’re going to have to take responsibility for Amoobaa’s actions, but I recognise that must feel really unfair and I’m sorry to hear about what she did to your eye.”

Fandangofran · 13/04/2022 22:30

Even if you DO have to explain why you've changed your name when applying for a job - (which I don't understand at all, it's never happened to me since I did my deed poll) surely that's less hassle and less likely to provoke questions than not changing your name and.

  1. Applying for a job in your (official) name, getting the Job and then saying "oh but that's not my name, my name is actually actually (preferred) name"
  1. Applying for job in (preferred) name and then having the awkward question from payroll/HR of why doesn't your name match the (official) name linked to your NI number/tax records.

Surely either of those are going raise more questions and look more dodgy than just changing your name by deed poll in the first place and having everything match.