Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have such a visceral reaction to being called by my name?

465 replies

Nameproblemsagain · 13/04/2022 16:30

I probably am BU about this, but when my parents named me they gave me a totally different name to the one I’ve always been named and while on a logical sort of level I know this wasn’t the intent, it’s always felt a bit like a cruel joke.

Went into the bank today and was greeted by the wrong name. It just really fills me with annoyance.

I know people will say to change it but I’ve never been sure that this doesn’t create more problems than it solves. Plus, I think actually doing this would make me angry too!

So hit me - AIBU?

OP posts:
Cocomarine · 13/04/2022 18:43

I do think you need to look at the big picture though. I share a name you don’t want to share, really.
Pretty close example: let’s say I’m called Myra Smith.
Through my 70s childhood, my brother called my Hindley.
All the time.
Like, “oy, Hindley - mum says tea’s ready.”
Literally called me nothing but for years.

My brother is a total fucking arsehole - that was only one part of him. Black eye was bad too.

So it isn’t just about being called Hindley - it’s a much bigger picture.

Do you have a bigger picture with your parents?

Hesma · 13/04/2022 18:43

You’re being a prat and totally U. If it’s that big a deal change it

Moodycow78 · 13/04/2022 18:41

It's not unreasonable that it annoys you I suppose but it is very very unreasonable to refuse to change it and complain when it's used 🙄

Butchyrestingface · 13/04/2022 18:40

@Nameproblemsagain

If it was just something like Susan Jane, Susan after an aunt but called Jane because that’s the name they liked that’s fair enough *@Butchyrestingface* but the circumstances of mine were a bit different and were supposed to be a funny joke.

I don’t think it was intended to be cruel but setting me up as a joke from birth probably wasn’t the best start!

If your parents have given you a really objectionable name that would have caused teasing or bullying, I'm sorry. I think that is really self-indulgent, selfish and shows little care for their offspring.

But... (always the but), I think in that case I'd have lanced the boil at the first available opportunity rather than let it fester unnecessarily. In the unlikely event that you're ever asked to explain the reason for the name change on an official document (as I say, I can't remember this happening to me), you could just put "named changed in childhood/never been called original name".

MissChanandlerBong80 · 13/04/2022 18:40

I can certainly understand the annoyance with your parents for giving you a first name they had no intention of calling you as a joke. For a start, naming your child is no time for comedy.

Notonthestairs · 13/04/2022 18:39

This is obviously an issue between you and your parents.

The name issue can easily be remedied - by resisting taking action you are perpetuating something which upsets you. It doesn't make a lot of sense unless the actual issue is not simply the name but your associations around it.

Chaoslatte · 13/04/2022 18:39

My dad and MIL both go by their middle name, it’s pretty common. But they don’t get annoyed when people call them by their first names. I agree with Pp suggestion that you might want to seek therapy. Clearly there are deeper issues here with your parents.

Cocomarine · 13/04/2022 18:39

One thing’s for sure - your name’s not Elsa.

Cocomarine · 13/04/2022 18:39

Well make a choice.

  • confront your parents for giving you a Ben Dover type name for laughs, over something as serious as a name. That’s valid. Even if it’s actually Ben James Dover and they used James. It’s actually a shitty thing for them to have done (unless it was actually sweet but twee, not actually laughable)
  • before or after have a wee bit of therapy
  • accept the name now that your married name nullifies the joke. Ben James Smith and MOVE ON.
  • accept the past but change it now

or:

  • stop around like a petulant child with no agency, refusing to change it or take steps (therapy…) to deal with it.

Your husband sounds like a fucking prize, teasing you about it when it’s so upsetting for you 🙄

notsureaboutTAAT · 13/04/2022 18:39

@Nameproblemsagain what is the joke then your name and surname combination or they called you something wayyyyyynout there like Mouse ?

SadButTheTruth · 13/04/2022 18:37

I honestly don’t think people are biting your head off - why do you think that? There’s irritation because you keep fobbing off any idea offered to fix your problems. I think people have offered practical solutions and also advised emotional support but you just want to be angry.

TheGrinchsDog · 13/04/2022 18:37

I kind of understand where you are coming from OP, sort of-ish.

Unfortunately, while your feelings are valid, you are going to have to make peace with either keeping the name for official purposes or changing it somehow. Maybe therapy to talk it out with someone who knows what they're doing would be more helpful than posting here.

It's not great your parents gave you a 'joke' name on your BC, but as you say they didn't do it with cruelty in mind. I can understand (ish) the feeling that it's unfair that you have to change it, but would that not be a short term annoyance compared to the long term annoyance of keeping your given BC name? Sometimes stuff like this happens and it's a bit shit or unfair, but sometimes we still have to just grab a shovel you know?

Do you work in a field that would ask you to disclose prior names? Otherwise it shouldn't come up for work surely?

You say you tried to change it a while back and for whatever reason you were rejected. Maybe you could go to citizens advice and get some help with the forms? Did they give a reason it was rejected?

notsureaboutTAAT · 13/04/2022 18:36

My dad is the oldest boy and so named after his dad, never called it as that would be confusing. Always called another name which is not on his birth certificate. He has a British passport in his alternative name so I have no idea how unless he deed polled or things were more lax back then, it as I've seen his birth certificate ( he's mid 70s)

The hassle is only the same hassle as changing your name after marrying.

SisterRuth · 13/04/2022 18:36

I changed my name to my middle name, dropped my first name altogether. Did it when I was 28. Didn't even do it by deed poll, just wrote to a few organisations (bank etc) & when I came to renew passport, wrote an explanation in the box provided. Passport came back in new name. Piece of cake. Have never had to explain this to anyone. Don't understand what you're moaning on about.

Nameproblemsagain · 13/04/2022 18:36

@OctopusSay this is what I’ve had all my life, being told I’m using the wrong name, I don’t know what my name is, why did they call me if I wasn’t going to be known as .

OP posts:
Nameproblemsagain · 13/04/2022 18:35

If it was just something like Susan Jane, Susan after an aunt but called Jane because that’s the name they liked that’s fair enough @Butchyrestingface but the circumstances of mine were a bit different and were supposed to be a funny joke.

I don’t think it was intended to be cruel but setting me up as a joke from birth probably wasn’t the best start!

OP posts:
me4real · 13/04/2022 18:35

I know everyone thinks snapping my head off and telling me to get my name changed solves everything, but it’s not just about my name. It’s also about my feelings about it.

Then you just change it and you won't ever have to have the feelings again @Nameproblemsagain . I did it and it's so much nicer.

Or if you just want to talk about your feelings (which you can stop having to experience from now on through a simple action) you could see a therapist.

I don’t think I want to change it.

Then therapy is the best option for you. Maybe after some therapy you might decide to take control of your life and that might include changing it (if that's what you decide.)

somehow feels like yet another thing I have to do which I have to do because my parents did it to me. Maybe that makes no sense, but I just really feel I shouldn’t have to.

I get what I mean but it seems a bit like cutting off your nose to spite your face, being stubboorn for the sake of it, but is your choice of course.

I don't have a driving license or passport BTW. I did it just with my birth certificate and some bills as proof of address or something. Then I changed it with the DWP and council etc. Most places are quite laid back about it.

OctopusSay · 13/04/2022 18:35

@Nameproblemsagain

Thanks for the responses. The problem is if I changed names formally I’d have to keep explaining that then which makes it a bigger deal than it is.

Surely the bank didn't call you by the wrong name. They called you by your name

See it’s comments like this that are the problem. I’ve had teachers say to me that it’s my name and insist on calling me it, situations in healthcare etc. It’s not my name and never has been.

So what name is on your passport, driving licence, exam certificates? Teachers etc are using your name. It's you that isn't.
TeaStory · 13/04/2022 18:35

You are assuming I haven’t had a similar experience…

yogafairy · 13/04/2022 18:34

I had this! Except I didn't know I had a different name until I needed to get my birth certificate for a passport. All through school I was called one name but my birth cert says a very different name. (This was in then seventies so not like now) I did change my name though as the birth cert one sounds so odd to me!

Nameproblemsagain · 13/04/2022 18:34

@Hellocatshome

For many of the above examples I couldn’t have changed my name because I wasn’t 18.

The problem is the thread has become about posters thinking biting my head off in as withering and sarcastic a way possible ‘solves’ the problem and it doesn’t, it goes far deeper than that.

OP posts:
Butchyrestingface · 13/04/2022 18:33

As I have said, I recognise this doesn’t make sense to anybody else, I really do, but it somehow feels like yet another thing I have to do which I have to do because my parents did it to me.

I think that's why PPs have suggested posters.

This thread is awash with people who've been in the same situation and taken the easy and painless step of changing their name by deed poll. They don't feel it was something their parents "did" to them.

Some form of counselling would allow you to explore your feelings around the issue.

Beees · 13/04/2022 18:33

I don’t think I want to change it.

Well then honestly you're just going to have to put up with people calling you the name and get angry everytime which truthfully just sounds like you're being a martyr and not changing it so you can continue to complain and resent it.

It would take you 10 minutes to change it and you'd rarely have to give it a second thought again for the rest of your life. Life is going to be very long if you get cross every time someone uses your name.

Aquamarine1029 · 13/04/2022 18:32

You are the maker of your own misery.

MurmuratingStarling · 13/04/2022 18:32

I don't get it. Confused

Swipe left for the next trending thread