Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being annoyed by friend judging name choices

109 replies

87beck · 13/04/2022 11:50

Our second son was born a few weeks ago and we decided to name him Jack

My friend met him for the first time yesterday and decided to inform me that her DH has commented that if they ever have a boy, jack would've been the last name on their list as it's associated with bad behaved boys etc and it's just not "a cool name" & also said that my first boys name isn't cool and why do we go for such simplistic names ..?

It might just be the postpartum hormones but I'm soooo angry she decided to share this with me .. wtf !
I Didn't say anything but my DH said next time he will see them he will mention the unnecessary comment.
I would never judge anyone's name choices so I'm super angry that behind close doors they bitch about my boys names 🥲 not in a rush to meet up with her again

OP posts:
XelaM · 13/04/2022 14:49

Jack is a great classic name and much better than the more "unique" names people give their kids these days

MyEasterEggs · 13/04/2022 14:44

Bitter. Jealous. Unkind. None of the traits I’d want in a “friend”. What an asshat. If she has an ounce of sense she’ll be feeling awkward about that needless comment. Jack is a beautiful name!

tearinghairout · 13/04/2022 14:36

What a horrible and unnecessary comment. It's extremely poor form to make a comment like that. We all have weird prejudices about names and may well share them before the baby's arrival, but to say this now is very rude and childish. I would agree that there is something going on, jealousy maybe.

ExplodingCarrots · 13/04/2022 14:31

Does she have children OP? She sounds awfully bitter and possibly jealous and this is her way of punishing you . No friend would say something like this unless something is going on with them.

Sidisawetlettuce · 13/04/2022 14:31

@Womeninblack

Just leave it. It was a careless comment and she probably said it without thinking. No need to make it a big thing
It wasn't careless. It was spiteful.
ExConstance · 13/04/2022 14:27

I have a Jack DS1, he went to Oxford and has a very high up job (unlike me) When he was born it was quite an unusual name.

EV117 · 13/04/2022 14:27

She sounds like a dick.

MrsWinters · 13/04/2022 14:26

I always judge peoples name choices, but I do it behind their backs.
From the anonymity of the internet I’ll give you the truth. Jack is a lovely name.

ellenpartridge · 13/04/2022 14:25

Your "friend" is being a cow. She's been really rude for no reason and I wonder if she's somehow jealous or bitter for some reason as this isn't normal behaviour at all!

Also agree there's nothing at all wrong with Jack. Perfectly nice normal classic name. Probably much nicer than her "cool" names

Oysterbabe · 13/04/2022 14:24

It's a lovely name imo. My grandfather was Jack, my adult nephew is called Jack and my friend has a new baby Jack. It's classic and timeless.

Graphista · 13/04/2022 14:22

Rude cow!

Ignore!

She clearly has issues that are nothing you've caused.

Jack is a perfectly good, solid name. But even if the name was Agamemnon or whatever you don't comment on peoples name choices for their kids!

I'm one of a LOT of cousins and the names of our dc range from the simple to the sublime and ridiculous! Makes no difference to what the children are like! That's down to parenting

There are some of the parents with perfectly normal straightforward names for their dc and the dc are unusual in their hobbies, interests etc and some other children have less common names and the dc are quite conservative quiet kids

My brother and his 1st wife chose what was then a fairly unusual name for their son (it's since become very common actually funnily enough), my mum said nothing to them but asked me if it was a "real name" Grin

She's not a bad person she just hadn't heard it before and thought it a little odd. She adores him and is very proud of him as she is all her grandchildren.

I chose what I thought was a not too common name for dd - then thr following bloody year due to a fall celeb having the name it exploded! So when she started nursery there were loads with the same name! You can't predict these things.

Ourlady · 13/04/2022 14:21

Your friend is a nasty cow. I would be keeping my distance from her. She is no friend!

DisforDarkChocolate · 13/04/2022 14:09

I love Jack. Excellent name.

You're friend is an arse.

Silversprinkles · 13/04/2022 14:04

Jack is a classic strong name, been top 10 for ages for a reason - it's a solid name that works with all ages/jobs etc and isn't a "trend". And the behaviour/name thing is (a) completely absurd anyway and (b) certainly not true for the Jacks I know who are great kids.

But even if you had named your boy Hoopla-Doopla-DingDong, when you meet a post partum Mum and new baby the ONLY thing to say is how lovely her new baby is and the name suits them/is great. Any discussion if ever, is before birth if and only IF they've asked for your advice/opinion. Not after birth and name announced. They've been named, it's not going to change, and if you say something rude it will never be forgotten.

Your friend is rude and hurtful. I would think long and hard about meeting up again.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 13/04/2022 14:02

Her boyfriend is absolutely ridiculous.

My uncle Jack was an absolute gentleman my nephew Jack is at University on a placement studying biological and chemical sciences.

I don't think much of your friend sharing the information, we all hear stupid things regularly to then pass on the stupidity makes her a definite knob.

Congratulations on the birth of your beautiful boy. 🎊 👏

Arucanafeather · 13/04/2022 14:01

@Llamapolice

That is rude. It's a golden etiquette rule of my mum's to never comment negatively on a baby's name or appearance! Saying that if she's not usually like that I'd just leave it now.
I live by that rule too. I was on my knees emotionally after having our second and when I showed him to a friend who’d come to stay when he was a couple of weeks old and asked if they through he looked like his sibling, she replied “he looked like ET”. It was such a shock and made me realise she often said bitchy things to me over the years. Totally changed how I felt about our friendship and it’s never recovered.
MargaritasOnMe · 13/04/2022 13:55

She's horrible. I'm a teacher and really like the name Jack. It's not a 'naughty' name at all. In fact, I'd have liked it for ds1 but DH has quite a few relatives with the name so we felt we couldn't use it. Anyway, just ignore her! And congratulations!

greenlynx · 13/04/2022 13:53

I don’t think that it’s out of date name, I think it’s classic name and a really nice one.
She was very rude to comment on your choice of names at all and even more to bitch behind your back with her DH and then telling you about it. I wouldn’t meet up with her anymore, she clearly doesn’t like you.
By the way, so they don’t have a son, do they? I wonder if they are jealous, especially her DH.

Bootothegoose · 13/04/2022 13:50

@Whose

Christ, I thought you were going to say you'd named your son Sprinkle or something. Nothing wrong with Jack, it's a great name. Your friend is rude and clearly would have preferred Sprinkle, or Sunset or Sapling or something. Ignore.
Sprinkle made me snort. Honestly not as bad as some of the names I've heard from extended family and friends.

Baby BJ was a corker as was little Chaos. I shit you not - Chaos.

Whose · 13/04/2022 13:46

Christ, I thought you were going to say you'd named your son Sprinkle or something.
Nothing wrong with Jack, it's a great name. Your friend is rude and clearly would have preferred Sprinkle, or Sunset or Sapling or something.
Ignore.

Bootothegoose · 13/04/2022 13:45

@LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus

My MIL said our daughter's nickname was embarrassing to say! She has a very popular girls name but goes by a diminutive that is common for boys - along the lines of Olivia - Ollie or Stephanie - Stevie. It was years ago now but I've never forgotten it!

Also your username is fantastic!

DarkCorner · 13/04/2022 13:40

What?! That's such a horribly mean and rude thing to say about a new baby's name! Is she always like that?

Fwiw, Jack is a lovely timeless classic name and definitely "cool" and not "naughty" to me.

ElsieMc · 13/04/2022 13:35

What on earth is wrong with Jack? I hope my dd will pick this as a middle name for a son at some time as it was my dad's name. We all have rather awful sixties/seventies names in the family - Elsie is my favourite aunt's name.

I am guilty of commenting on my dd's daughter's name but I was invited to. It is somewhat unusual! Can't say I have ever come round to it, but it's not my choice - I've already had mine. What an insensitive so called friend you have. You find out who your friends are when you are a little bit down or hormones raging op. Phase her out, you only have time for people who make you feel good now.

LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus · 13/04/2022 13:34

And Jack is a nice name, I've never known a horrible Jack.

Irridescantshimmmer · 13/04/2022 13:34

YANBU
With a friend like that, who needs enemies.

Grossly insensitive, even more so because you have just given birth.

I think you deserve an apology because their comments have caused offence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread