Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think 8am to 6pm at nursery/school+wraparound is just too much

571 replies

magicsoosh · 13/04/2022 03:57

Apparently Mon-Fri 8am to 6pm childcare is normal.. AIBU to think that's a lot? That's more hours than most full time jobs

OP posts:
codeVeronica · 13/04/2022 13:59

[quote FairyCatMother]@SockFluffInTheBath There are many things in life that some people might do, that others couldn't or wouldn't, including being a SAHM, or not putting your child in a nursery for 10+ hours a day. These decisions and views are equally valid, and are motivated by good intentions. My relative has just spent £4000 on a once in a lifetime flight in a WW2 Spitfire. Mine and DH's savings barely amount to £4000, and I have a fear of flying, but I don't feel any resentment towards my relative for being able to afford this experience. The same goes for those who can/'t afford to be SAHMs, there will always be 'haves' and 'have nots', but expressing unjust anger and resentment towards those who hold different views is unnecessary.[/quote]
People resent being judged for working when they have no choice. Your relative chose to buy the plane, many can't choose to be stay at home parents (although let's face it, 99% of the time it's the mother who is expected to stay at home) because they simply can't afford it. And then they have to put up with people like you and the OP telling them they are damaging their children.

Profanisaurasrex · 13/04/2022 13:53

Yeah it’s a lot.
My kids both absolutely loved nursery and therefore I didn’t feel bad about it. To them it was normal as it was what they knew.

FairyCatMother · 13/04/2022 13:49

@SockFluffInTheBath There are many things in life that some people might do, that others couldn't or wouldn't, including being a SAHM, or not putting your child in a nursery for 10+ hours a day. These decisions and views are equally valid, and are motivated by good intentions. My relative has just spent £4000 on a once in a lifetime flight in a WW2 Spitfire. Mine and DH's savings barely amount to £4000, and I have a fear of flying, but I don't feel any resentment towards my relative for being able to afford this experience. The same goes for those who can/'t afford to be SAHMs, there will always be 'haves' and 'have nots', but expressing unjust anger and resentment towards those who hold different views is unnecessary.

babyjellyfish · 13/04/2022 13:41

Unless you have a magical teleportation device enabling you to travel instantly through time and space from your childcare setting to your 9-5 job (which is not even long hours, by the way), you're going to need childcare for an hour either side of your actual working hours, OP.

My son goes to the childminder from 8-6:30 five days a week and has done since he was about 7 months old. He doesn't seem traumatised.

Glittertwins · 13/04/2022 13:41

@magicsoosh

I posted at 3am while feeding my baby...
Come back when your baby is old enough to drop the middle of the night feeds and stop being so pissy about those that need to work.
TheKeatingFive · 13/04/2022 13:38

Some of those who do become SAHMs can be very naïve about the financial and security implications of the choice.

It's often much more than a few years of cutting back and going without luxuries. It can have very long term implications on your career progression, family security, individual independence and funding your retirement.

Of course it doesn't apply to all SAHMs. Some think it through very carefully and make provision where they can. Some are so rich that it doesn't matter. But for me personally, no way would i take the chance. My ability to provide for myself and my children is too important to me.

SockFluffInTheBath · 13/04/2022 13:38

@FairyCatMother

Why do these threads always cause so much anger and resentment? OP is freely expressing a valid viewpoint, for babies and young children to be away from their parents/primary caregivers for 10 hours a day + is not at all ideal. The anger caused by stating this opinion would suggest that many are aware of this, but for whatever reason are unwilling to admit it.
Because there’s no way of saying it that doesn’t sound preachy or judgey. Do you think MNers put their children in wraparound care for fun? Really? So how is it constructive, useful or kind to voice it? It’s not a nice ‘thinking aloud’ thread it’s a ‘how could you possibly, I never would’ looking down the thread.
luckylavender · 13/04/2022 13:38

@magicsoosh

I posted at 3am while feeding my baby...
Women need to make choices for their own families. They don't need judgey sanctimonious feedback. Life is hard enough.
Hankunamatata · 13/04/2022 13:37

Come back when your a fulltime working parent with no other childcare options Biscuit

nameisnotimportant · 13/04/2022 13:34

It is a long day but children are incredibly resilient and it becomes their normal. My kids only go three days a week but they are there from 7am to 6pm. They ask to go on the days that they aren't there. It's not like they are being dropped in an environment where they are being neglected. My kids get attention, love, socialisation, education, plenty of play time and decent meals. I feel incredibly lucky that I can send my children to a safe place that they love, while I pursue my career.

FairyCatMother · 13/04/2022 13:33

Why do these threads always cause so much anger and resentment? OP is freely expressing a valid viewpoint, for babies and young children to be away from their parents/primary caregivers for 10 hours a day + is not at all ideal. The anger caused by stating this opinion would suggest that many are aware of this, but for whatever reason are unwilling to admit it.

AllOfUsAreDead · 13/04/2022 13:31

Yes op you're quite right, it's far too much. NONE of the people you've ever known, spoke to or worked with were in that many hours of childcare from nursery, the only ones that did are currently rocking in corners on psych wards.

You need to quit your job right now op and don't even THINK about working until they toddle off to university. God forbid if you do otherwise, they'll probably just fall over and forget how to do anything. Even if you are struggling for money, you do not work again.

dottydodah · 13/04/2022 13:30

I was at Nursery as a child .Later on went to friends house or DGP after School .Not ideal but DM had to work, as DF died and she was a widow with a little girl to provide for .In an ideal world we would have choices .I worked as a Nursery School teacher .My Nursery was a good one and the children were well cared for ,After lunch naps, and quiet time provided. Many more parents need to work these days.Food ,Energy bills and so on to pay for . One person at home FT these days is rare and puts a lot of pressure on a marriage.If you dont want to put your Baby in FT care ,dont, Its not illegal! Stop trying to pile a heap of shit on working mums by guilt tripping them like this

emeraldcity2000 · 13/04/2022 13:28

Mine are in full time childcare (grandparents do 1 day for the baby). I probably could afford to give up work. Different lifestyle but certainly possible. I don't feel guilty though. Both kids are happy, engaged and well looked after. The nursery care is exceptional and school childminder is great too. Both my kids get a huge amount from the stimulation of other children and professional childcare and both are bright and high energy so it suits them. If I picked them up early they wouldn't want to chill out at home anyway... not all children are alike - if they struggled I would probably try to reduce my hours. They are also well loved and secure, we spend a lot of quality time together as a family at weekends and holidays.
Fwiw my mum was a sahm. I was always jealous of the kids who went to childminders!

grapewines · 13/04/2022 13:26

What do you want working parents to do exactly?

I don't even have children, but you're being goady. Just stop.

glinner4prez · 13/04/2022 13:19

Of course it's too much but what the fuck do you expect? Parents have to work! Quite frankly my working week is often 'too much' for me but guess what? Money doesn't make itself. If you're smug about being a SAHP then you do you hon, but don't forget about all the risks associated with that too. I'm not prepared to be screwed financially if my relationship ends or DH dies.

Classicblunder · 13/04/2022 13:10

It is a long day and we do our best to reduce it - both do 4 days compressed hours and stagger hours so that we can pick up by 5 - but I do also think some people romanticise the alternatives

Great if you have fit, healthy and enthusiastic grandparents able to do childcare but I have known several children basically just parked in front of the TV for hours by grandparents who aren't able to take them out easily - one of my cousins did this with their kids, the grandparents were elderly and just not able to do much, one day a week might have been fine but those kids got very little stimulation.

Similarly, I have met SAHMs at playgroups who are just so fed up with their kids that they are ignoring them completely.

In comparison, a high quality nursery may be better.

I am not saying all grandparents/SAHMs are useless but just that it's not always the best option either

Echobelly · 13/04/2022 13:09

It's a full time job plus a commute, certainly in London - I needed 8-6 for both my kids to get into town, work 9-5 and get back.

FairyCatMother · 13/04/2022 13:07

I meant to add that DH works in an NHS band 4 admin role, so take home pay is approx £1650 a month, so apparently far less than the average family income. After mortgage and bills etc it leaves virtually nothing for saving or trips out very often, and we have another DC on the way, but I feel so much happier spending the precious time with DS.

Thehop · 13/04/2022 13:06

I’ve just finished working in a nursery to become a childminder.

Those children are educated, loved, played with and muttered ALL DAY. Nobody says “wait a minute I’ve got to answer an email” “I’ll play after I’ve done the washing” it’s a bloody brilliant day/week if you choose provision properly.

FairyCatMother · 13/04/2022 13:03

IMO it is far too much and one of several reasons why DH and I have decided for me to remain a SAHM. Money is tighter now that our household income has halved, but we feel it is so much better for our DS, who is with me doing various activities every day and can still see his grandmother a few times a week too. My own childhood experiences echo those of a previous post, whereby I was looked after by a child-minder virtually full-time until the age of seven, which I really disliked. I'll never forget how sad I used to feel after school, when all of my friends were being collected by their parents/grandparents, most of whom either worked part-time or not at all, and the only person to greet me was a scowling red face who clearly enjoyed childminding more for the income. When my mother eventually decided to pack in her career to raise me full-time, life seemed so much more pleasant and happier, which is exactly what I want for my own DC.

yaboreme · 13/04/2022 12:58

It is a long day I agree.

My son has been in childcare since 15 months... 07:30-5-5:30 I don't have any support and I need my job otherwise me and said child don't have a house, food or clothes...

It isn't some sort of abuse, simply a means to an end. It would be nice to have grandparents and family to help but we don't. Just me and DH. I'd love to have the security of being at home and not having to work but I don't.

I hope my son will one day understand that I didn't 'dump' him at nursery, I did it for us as nothing comes for free unfortunately.

Volhhg · 13/04/2022 12:45

Yes it is too long. But what else can people do, this is how society is in this country both parents have to work. Hopefully the staff make it a comfortable and stress free environment for the children and it won't feel like a working day. I know that the people I know who do this as a job are very kind and patient people who go far beyond the pittance they're paid for being nursery/childcare jobs.

jellybe · 13/04/2022 12:42

Is this your first baby? If you don't want them going to long nursery days don't send them it isn't the law but I assume you already know that and are now have a PFB moment cause how could your darling manage being away from you for so long Hmm
Well guess what some of us don't have that option as flexi working isn't a thing in many many jobs i.e. midwifery (you know those lovely people who helped you bring you baby into the world)

So unless you have an actual point jog on with your judgmental post and remember not everyone has a choice if they want to be able to feed/ cloth their kids as well as pay the bills.

Comedycook · 13/04/2022 12:34

I'm not judging but I know my DC would have been absolutely exhausted if they had gone to school and been in wraparound care from 8-6 every day of the week. By the time you get home, you barely have two hours before it's time for bed. It is far from ideal but if people have to work, then theres no choice.

However, my sil would do this...her dh earns loads and she has a property portfolio. I thought she was absolutely mad putting her school age DC in full time wrap around care and spending her life dashing round when financially she didn't have to work.

Still, it has absolutely no impact on my life so obviously I wouldn't say anything.