Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

You don’t tell your most successful child you were a ‘useless’ parent because of other siblings

62 replies

BigGreenSofa · 12/04/2022 22:54

So my MIL loves to tell us how we should share our success with her/DBIL/DSIL ie: people will lots of money spread it about the family as opposed to keeping it for themselves. Unfortunately for her, a of the financial backing we have came from inheritance I got (which we used to springboard further) but will mean neither she nor his siblings will ever have right to any of it.

Tonight she started laying it on really thick to DH that she was a useless parent because DBIL doesn’t ‘earn enough’ (he has a very reasonable job but no, will not ever be able to match our situation) and DSIL won’t succeed in his chosen career (he won’t - he’s not pushy enough). As it goes DBIL (who doesn’t now earn enough) was always the golden child. DH was always written off as not being as bright if able in comparison. And is still now on occasion.

Aibu to be pissed off MIL has started this line especially as DH feels he has to tell her she was a brilliant parent (when she wasn’t having written him off) because it’s a nice thing to go and this entire thing plays into his need for her to approve of him, that he isn’t part of her problem.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
diddl · 13/04/2022 09:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

MarriedThreeChildren · 13/04/2022 08:59

@diddl

So she was a bad parent to your husband but he lies & tells her she wasn't?

That would annoy me.

Could he find a way of just not engaging in those conversations?

Lol

You realise you are talking about a child-mother relationhsip there?
That he probably has spent his life smoothing things over and making her feel better.
It’s not as easy as saying ‘well he is lying so he should stop’. If it was that easy you wouldn’t have the Stately Homes threads going on, regular threads form posters with manipulative parents etc…

This is hard stuff to acknowledge your Laurent’s are shit, manipulative and don’t treat you the same than your siblings.
Detangling yourself from a lifetime of reactions/smoothing over/ignoring, all done as a preservation mechanisms as a child, is also hard.

MarriedThreeChildren · 13/04/2022 08:55

@BigGreenSofa it seems some people have struggle understanding english. Probably too late and not awake enough Wink

Your post is quite clear tbh.
You’ve inherited money. You and your DH took RISK with that money and made it work into something even more profitable.
Kudos to you. Both to have taken the risk and to have made it work. Nit everyone does.

I’m getting the feeling that the request to share the money is coming from MIL more than BIL and SIL. The wailing, thé ‘oh I can’t have been a good enough mum’ etc… is guilt tripping. She is using guilt and making her own ds feel bad to push you to do something you don’t really want to do.

She is wrong, I think you know that. From your posts, I suspect your DH does too but is feeling bad about it.
Just a few things there

  • it’s not your DH’s responsibility to ensure his mum is happy. If she feels she didn’t do a good enough job with BIL, then SHE has to deal with it. Giving money to him (and SIL) would only be a plaster solution and she would end up still feeling oh so bad for them.
  • being manipulative isn’t a nice trait. And it’s ok for your DH to stand up to that.

However, by experience, it’s extremely hard to do! So my advice (seeing the golden child stuff going on too) is for him to go and see a psychotherapist and talk it through. He needs to work on his boundaries and being able to ‘see’ when his dmum is just being a prick vs real issues/feelings etc…
But seing the jealousy going on in the family, I wouldn’t be surprised if he ends feeling he needs ot go low contact or NC :(

diddl · 13/04/2022 08:54

So she was a bad parent to your husband but he lies & tells her she wasn't?

That would annoy me.

Could he find a way of just not engaging in those conversations?

BringMeTea · 13/04/2022 08:52

Are you Mrs Rishi?

Nothappyatwork · 13/04/2022 08:46

The thing is money sharing within families actually works really really well, the very well of people I know they don’t borrow money off banks if they need a new car they ask the parents, when they want to buy a house they all club together, never get a mortgage. And the whole family prospers as a result of this. You literally save hundreds of thousands of pounds.

And then Mumsnet decides that that’s not the best way to live your life 🤣

bettysboob · 13/04/2022 08:45

Sounds to me like your MIL doesn’t like the fact that you have been given the opportunity to make a life for yourself based on what you want to do, not what you have to do - unlike her other children - and because this happened through inheritance, this won’t change (unless the other DC end up also marrying into money). That’s not your problem.

Herejustforthisone · 13/04/2022 08:37

I don’t really understand why you felt compelled to join in the criticism of your husband’s siblings here. It does not make you sound nice.

CharSiu · 13/04/2022 08:37

Op has said she is not in the UK, sharing money especially to support parents is expected in some cultures.

I do not see her post as a brag, it has two issues.

The MIL feelings about her parenting and wanting assurances which sticks in the throat a bit because she had a clear favourite amongst her children but does her DH effectively lie to soothe the Mother.

The fact that the MIL clearly wants the op and her DH to share their money with siblings.

I see the Mothers wailings as manipulative in all this.

Of course you do not share your money op unless you both specifically want to. I assisted a sibling at one point because her DH had cancer his business went down and she had worked for him so their income stream disappeared almost over night. But that was my choice with no manipulation or expectation.

Crudger · 13/04/2022 08:29

I can understand the OP perfectly. To the people being snippy about not understanding her posts- this says more about your level of comprehension than her language skills (in her second language).

OP financial success IS largely what people mean by success no matter how ‘lucky’ you have been (sorry for the loss of whoever you inherited the money from ). Almost all financial success is down to luck one way or another- a good education, good looks, a talent etc and then you turn it into success by using it wisely and working hard. Ignore the jealousy on this thread and from your MIL.

Fundays12 · 13/04/2022 08:25

It’s not about who is most successful. The reality is it’s your money and regardless of how you got it (I.e inheritance, hard work etc) you do not have to share it with anymore. My sister is better off financially than me but I would never ask her for anything or expect her to share her money. I am glad her, my brother in law and nieces and nephews have a nice standard of living and hope that continues.

2DogsOnMySofa · 13/04/2022 08:21

Sit down with your dh and come up with a few choice sentences so he can shut her down.

You shouldn't measure success in monetary terms

BIL is happy, surely that's all that counts

Money can't buy happiness

5128gap · 13/04/2022 08:17

@saraclara

I've read all OP's posts again and can't find any bragging at all. She's been straightforward in saying that her wealth was an inheritance and not down to her efforts. She certainly hasn't implied that she's better than anyone else.

The question is quite straightforward. MIL thinks she should share with the in-laws (no reason why she should) and is trying to guilt her son into it. And yes, that's unreasonable.

The turn that the responses have taken is very odd.

OP is allowing her MIL to think that she and her H are wealthy because they have done better in life than the siblings. Based on this, the MIL appears concerned that she parented her children differently leading to their different outcomes in life. Its an unusual but perhaps understandable concern for mother, who may question whether she parented them equally. The OP could if she wished, clear up the confusion by simply being honest, yet she seems to prefer to foster the belief that their success is due to some exceptionalism rather than good fortune, and therefore they are 'better'. As for sharing the wealth, I suppose that depends on the OPs stance on whether its fair to benefit from wealth you haven't earned or not. So theoretically she should be all for it.
milderchilly · 13/04/2022 08:14

You all sound the same bla bla bla

SpaceFarce · 13/04/2022 08:08

Mostly I’m just surprised that people can make enough sense of the OP to pass comment. Agree you all sound awful though.

Ukholidaysaregreat · 13/04/2022 08:08

I don't think you should engage with the MIL at all on this topic. I think she sounds manipulative and I would question whether she would pressure the other siblings to share their money given the family dynamics. I wouldn't bother reassuring her either and I would talk this through with your husband so he can recognise the behaviour.

saraclara · 13/04/2022 08:06

I've read all OP's posts again and can't find any bragging at all. She's been straightforward in saying that her wealth was an inheritance and not down to her efforts. She certainly hasn't implied that she's better than anyone else.

The question is quite straightforward. MIL thinks she should share with the in-laws (no reason why she should) and is trying to guilt her son into it. And yes, that's unreasonable.

The turn that the responses have taken is very odd.

Ohnonevermind · 13/04/2022 08:05

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SilverBirchWithout · 13/04/2022 08:02

It does sound like you have similar attitudes as your MIL about success and money. I’m not quite sure what you want from her or DH? Congratulations about inheriting money and enabling your DH to have ‘better’ choices?

Dentistlakes · 13/04/2022 08:00

Money breeds money. When you have it, it’s easy to make more. You were lucky to gain money through inheritance, so I don’t necessarily think that makes you more successful.

Your MIL had no right to expect you to share your money with other family members. They need to make their own way, even though it will be harder for them, but not impossible.

Londoncallingme · 13/04/2022 07:59

@XelaM

Oops don't know why it posted twice
Because it’s so true. No point to this thread - so you inherited some money, so what? Nothing to do with success.
5128gap · 13/04/2022 07:56

You could try being honest and tell her that your 'success' is not down to your or your H's achievements, but the good fortune of you inheriting someone else's money; so therefore your H is no different from his siblings. At the moment she is under the false impression you have wealth due to your own efforts, and can't understand why her parenting resulted in one 'successful child' only. Which is a bit daft, but people can be odd. Tell the truth and clear up the confusion then change the subject if it comes up again.

HabitsDieHard · 13/04/2022 07:54

Your MIL sounds manipulative to me, and your post was perfectly easy to understand.

Nothappyatwork · 13/04/2022 07:50

So basically you didn’t earn the money that has now propelled you into a position where you think you’re better than everybody else within the family i.e. successful and youre moaning because the mother-in-law feels that she’s not done the best job with all of her children let’s be honest and she’d like some reassurance that that’s not the case from your husband because he’s the only one with any level of visible success ?

I feel sorry for the mother-in-law.

Ideally we would all be robots who need no reassurance whatsoever but for some reason it appears she does and you are wrong to withhold that if it makes an old lady feel a bit better.

SpaceshiptoMars · 13/04/2022 07:27

It may be cultural - some cultures expect a successful son to float the rest of his family with the rising tide. But equally, OPs inheritance might be tied up in trusts and the money restricted to spending on education, health etc.