Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the prospective father does not need to go to every IVF appointment?

186 replies

TheOccupier · 12/04/2022 22:48

Someone who indirectly works for me has recently let me know his wife is having IVF treatment. For the last couple of months, he's been absent frequently, often failing to answer emails, working from home if he's online at all, and not doing site visits which are an important and necessary part of his role. I am unhappy about this.

I am technically his client, not his employer - he's a long-term agency worker by choice (he is senior-level, with fairly unique skills and a lot of responsibility). He has spoken to his agency director about the situation and apparently they have signed off on it. Nobody has proactively communicated with me. I am not based at the office he is meant to work from so I rarely see him in person and wasn't even aware that he'd switched to WFH - I noticed a lot of out of office messages but put these down to site visits. I only found out about the IVF last week when I put him on the spot by asking for the date when he was last at a particular site that he's meant to visit weekly (because there's been an issue there that he should have picked up) and it turned out it's been over 2 months. He then told me what's going on.

So:
a) AIBU to be annoyed about him neglecting his work responsibilities and think IVF is not an acceptable justification?

b) AIBU to believe that the husband/partner does not actually need to attend the majority of IVF appointments and that my agency worker is being unreasonable in acting as though he's the one trying to get pregnant, especially as this is affecting his performance at work?

I am aware that IVF involves a lot of appointments and many of these will be at very short notice. However, the only people I know well who have done IVF have been women using it to become single mothers by choice, and therefore they have just got on with it and done most appointments on their own, other than when they needed physical support/driving home etc. I can't believe most prospective fathers go to ALL the appointments and get away with it at work - especially given that even women don't have any legal right to time off for IVF up until implantation!

If I'm not being unreasonable, how should I handle this? The guy would be difficult to replace, plus I really like him on a personal level, but his poor performance is now causing problems for me and others.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
5zeds · 19/04/2022 17:40

He might want paternity leave need time off for sick children and has shown he will just take it and not bother to tell you.

BigFatLiar · 19/04/2022 10:30

@KosherDill

He's taking the piss. You should ask for him to be replaced before your business suffers more.
Yep, he might want paternity leave and need to take time off to look after sick children.
LondonladyTTC · 19/04/2022 06:02

When I had IVF my partner only came to the appointments he needed to be at (3 of them) due to having to work and both of us not wanting to cause disruption (I didn't even tell my work I was going through it). However, it can be emotionally draining so both of us were likely distracted for the month and trying to support each other emotionally. No idea if either of our employers noticed, I doubt they did as main deliverables completed.
Everyone copes with things differently and I would definitely be sympathetic of anyone TTC for a very long time (upset of this for my was I think even more distracting than the IVF!) and the treatment itself particularly since it's short term. It's good he felt comfortable enough to tell his employer, and it's great he is being so supportive to his wife.

KosherDill · 19/04/2022 05:22

He's taking the piss. You should ask for him to be replaced before your business suffers more.

Passanotherjaffacake · 19/04/2022 04:36

My husband came to them all for our first, we were both invested in having a child.

Second baby he could only come to certain appointments with covid so I went alone to the majority. He felt quite left out of that cycle.

Prior to covid restrictions it was absolutely normal to see couples at the clinic. Partners should be encouraged to be invested in their children from the off, in my view.

Plus he might be handling the medicine doses etc. feels complex the first time you get to grips with it all.

tillytown · 19/04/2022 04:14

YANBU. There are very few appointments he needs to attend. My husband didn’t go to a single appointment aside from giving his semen due to Covid. It was fine, he wouldn’t have gone to many any way, possibly egg collection day (to drive me home). If the issue is the females fertility then he doesn’t need to be there
It doesn't matter if he needs to be there or not, he wants to go and his work is allowing him to go. Just because you don't think your husband would have gone with you doesn't mean every other man wouldn't want to support their partner.

Ylvamoon · 19/04/2022 02:37

At the end of the day, it seems that communication between yourselves and the agency (staff) or your other sites isn't that gerat.

How can it be that you were not notified by anyone about missed site visits?

I would work on the relationship and active communication with the agency and your
own staff.

You will find that this problem will resolve itself!

user1471481356 · 19/04/2022 01:51

YANBU. There are very few appointments he needs to attend. My husband didn’t go to a single appointment aside from giving his semen due to Covid. It was fine, he wouldn’t have gone to many any way, possibly egg collection day (to drive me home). If the issue is the females fertility then he doesn’t need to be there.

alltheteeshirts · 19/04/2022 01:00

Forget about the IVF. It's not relevant.

You are paying for a service - is he providing that service? Is it delayed, shit, or both?

IVF can be a difficult emotional journey. So can parenthood.

If he's not performing well now, you need to raise it, as it's not going to get any better without intervention. As you're the client and not the employer, it's not your responsibility to explore why he's underperforming, but the people you pay should be sorting him out and/or providing you with a refund.

5zeds · 19/04/2022 00:43

You do not need you dp with you at every appointment for ivf EVEN if he has fertility problems. Some people like it but it certainly isn’t necessary or the sign of a more loving partner or more invested aspiring father.

IsabelHerna · 18/04/2022 23:19

You're just not educated on the matter.

Yes, both men and women are needed in ivf appointments, because not all cases are the same. For example, there is such a thing like male infertility... It's not always the female's problem, or about single women in their 40s trying to create a family (I am one of them).

I actually work from home, and do site visits when needed and go for some meetings. Talking about IVF, infertility and fertiity treatments is not easy, and it's something very personal. I've told HR about it when I decided to move along with IVF, but I would feel violated if I learned they spoke about it to my clients... It's a personal medical issue. If you have the relationship with him that he feels comfortable to share this with you, mentioning something to you could be good, but "putting people on the spot", is really not the way to go.

HR, my coworkers, superiors, and also the team I manage have been really supportive of me, and it does help me stay productive and stable.

LolaSparkle · 14/04/2022 10:12

Agree with @housemaus completely!!

You need to address the issue with the agency and manage his performance via the appropriate channels but his reason for absence shouldn't be an influencing factor here.

I had my husband at every appointment, and to be honest I'd have struggled to get through it without him.

The simple fact is, his agency agreed to his request (which is a totally acceptable one!) so your issue really is with them.

People go through things in life which are difficult to deal with. And whilst physically the impact here is on women, you shouldn't underestimate the mental impact this can have on men. Going through it can be difficult for both involved, not just women. Would you be saying the same thing if his reason for absence/poor performance was a result of a close family bereavement?
Whilst they're both different scenarios, both take a mental toll.

My advice would be take it up with the agency and find a compromise that's meets as much of your needs as possible for your business, but also the needs of your colleague which shows support. If like you say, he'd be difficult to replace then you'd be cutting your nose off to spite your face as he won't be going through the IVF journey forever and when it's over, he'll remember how you treated him. You may need to make a temporary adjustment.

And finally, get yourself some training on compassion and maybe do some research on what's involved with the IVF journey and how difficult it is.

52andblue · 14/04/2022 09:43

@XjustagirlX

Having read your update about him specifically stating ivf means he isn’t going to client sites. That implies to me that he is staying away due to COVID. Imagine going through ivf to be told it’s cancelled as he caught COVID at a client site! It’s just not worth the risk.
Yes. I had 3 x ivf around 20 years ago. During x2, my H caught the herpes cold sore virus & reacted really badly( literally hundreds of lesions on his face, bedridden, lost 1 stone in a week). It meant he produced NO sperm for the cycle we'd already started & we could not afford another. Rare, but IVF can have many more complications & ramifications than you could ever possibly imagine until you are 'in it'. (I also got OHSS).

That said, the Company supplying his services need to ensure another worker can fulfil their to you obligations during this time (which could be ongoing). They have a contract with you they are not fulfilling.

NobleYears · 14/04/2022 09:37

@Bitconfusedhmm I don’t think there is any projection going on on this thread. Op literally started a thread saying the man doesn’t need to go to ivf appointments and how she knows single women who got in with it by themselves. Obviously women who need their husbands support or women whose husbands have male factor or those who are currently doing ivf and understand the high cost of catching covid mid cycle are going to respond. There is already so little support for women/men dealing with what is a medical issue and understanding op ignorance of what ivf entails means people are replying to her.

Dahl1a · 13/04/2022 23:08

My Dh came to every single appointment. I was terrified and incredibly anxious. We found the process so hard we needed counselling which we had at the clinic. He did all the injections so needed to be there each time anyway to get all the info, considering the money we were spending it was crucial as part of the decision making process. His fertility was investigated too.

It’s hideous to go through. I became v ill and ended up in HD after contracting OHSS. If my Dh hadn’t been so involved at the clinic he wouldn’t have identified it and got me to hospital so quick.

Bitconfusedhmm · 13/04/2022 22:53

Massive projection going on on this thread

Also, still trying to get over @Lily2075’s assertion that ivf treatment is ‘just as much the man’s treatment as the woman’s’ Confused

user1471592953 · 13/04/2022 21:26

My DH and I worked on the basis that he came to every appointment that could bring bad news so we could support each other.

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 13/04/2022 21:13

@TheOccupier

How did it go today with the agency director? Did you find a solution?

thenewduchessoflapland · 13/04/2022 18:20

So he's a sub-contractor and he's not fulfilling the role your business requires?

DelurkingLawyer · 13/04/2022 18:08

I think by mentioning the IVF he has managed, probably inadvertently, to confuse the issue in your mind.

You or your employer are the client and you have a contractual relationship with the agency to provide certain services. The scope of the services and the expected standards are presumably set out somewhere (such as numbers of site visits, whether the agency staff are obliged to work in person in your office etc). If the agency doesn’t perform those contractual obligations you have a claim again them which you should pursue in the first instance as a complaint.

Entirely separately this chap has an employment relationship with the agency. He may well be entitled to adjustments or leave or whatever from them. He may have no such entitlement and they may have decided because they wish to be a good employer to let him have time off. That’s between him and the agency. It has nothing to do with you.

Where the agency has fallen down is that the arrangement they have reached with their employee has no bearing on the services that they continue to be obliged to provide to you. They are still obliged to provide those services and if they can’t do so via him they have to do so by some other means. Let’s say the obligation is to visit site A once a week. They can’t just say, oh well our employee can’t do that for health reasons therefore we won’t do it for TheOccupier’s company. They have to clear it with you which it seems they haven’t done.

So take it up with the agency and tell them to provide what they have contracted to provide.

The employee may well not realise the agency has not had this conversation with you and so he has told you he is going through IVF when he realised you didn’t know the background. He may also not draw much of a distinction between you and his employer because on the ground as far as he is concerned he is working at your office. Seems reasonable enough, but it’s confused the issue.

BungleandGeorge · 13/04/2022 16:31

I don’t think there’s any legal obligation to let him have time off but that’s for the agency to decide. They need to provide the service paid for and no way should you settle for less. It sounds like you’re getting very little out of the contract, surely he should still be working the majority of the time

TheSnufflet · 13/04/2022 16:17

YABVU with regards to the IVF treatment, and it's nothing to do with the emotional support aspect. Depending on what their issue is, he may need something like TESE/surgical sperm extraction which is a much bigger deal for the man and does have significant downtime. Also, the man does need to attend for bloods to be taken before the cycle is allowed to start. My clinic wanted both me and my husband to self-isolate for two weeks before egg retrieval, aka 'the bit with the cup', so it sounds as if that may be why he is not doing site visits. If he caught COVID during a site visit, they would be out thousands of pounds and have an entire cycle's worth of drugs wasted (also, if he were to pass it on asymptomatically to staff at the clinic, there could be the disastrous outcome of potentially dozens of patients getting their cycles cancelled - they're not fucking about for funsies).

However, YANBU in terms of expecting work to be done that is not being carried out - it sounds as if there has been a breakdown in communication with the agency and that's the bit that needs sorting.

Cherrysoup · 13/04/2022 16:07

The agency needs to get in cover, then. Either they provide the services you require, or you go elsewhere. If they’re allowing him to go to all the appointments, they need to provide someone to step in and cover the visits etc. The agency are the ones you need to take this up with, not the bloke, but again, I’d be horrified as his wife to think he’d shared the details of why he is absent.

UnexpectedItemInShaggingArea · 13/04/2022 15:38

I had ICSI and apart from the initial consultation, the egg harvesting and embryo transfer I went to all my appointments alone. DH had his own appointment for sperm retrieval which I had to drive him home from but it would have been madness to drag him away from work for every single appointment, especially in the days leading up to egg harvesting when I went in frequently.

YANBU OP. People need a bit of resilience in life.

ForeverSingle881 · 13/04/2022 15:38

YABU for bringing IVF into this. This is not about IVF, it doesn't matter what his excuse is. You are paying for a service and it's not being delivered. That's the issue you should be addressing. You are trying to present yourself like a tough business woman but by bringing personal judgment into it you are making this too personal. Even if he is using IVF as an excuse, that's not what you should focus on.