Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you vote Tory now…

740 replies

Joanna1988124 · 12/04/2022 21:48

You’re effectively propping up this absolute shit show of a government and have no empathy.

I’ll be honest, I’ve voted conservative before as a middle class family their (taxation) policies have suited me more than Labour. I honestly feel ashamed of this and I wish I could’ve seen that the conservatives agenda of ‘levelling up’ is BS.

Regardless of your personal situation, enough is enough now right? People are reliant on food banks, they’re choosing between heating and eating. Austerity has been a total nightmare for society causing the rich to get richer and the poor to get poorer.

OP posts:
DownNative · 17/04/2022 16:08

@Itisasecret

Tories always do this. Part of the reason we are so they rely on the middle/upper class to vote them in. The working class got really fooled, turkeys voted for Christmas. Everyone who voted for them is accountable.

Six figure household income, typical Tory target here and hell would freeze over before I’d vote for them.

This is very much an England centric view when that's not the entirety of the UK itself. It'd be one thing if England was sovereign, but its not.

The UK is sovereign.

People in Scotland vote Conservative largely based on the Constitutional debate. That IS perfectly reasonable, acceptable and democratic.

An all or nothing view really does not help the UK. Neither does demonising others.

Anothersatellite · 17/04/2022 14:57

Eighties = righty

Anothersatellite · 17/04/2022 14:56

It's gone way past Tory/Labour leftie/eighties now. You either believe in a fair society or you don't. The flag shagging, bungalow bigot blue collar idiots voted for them and nearly nothing can dislodge them now. Too many favours for mates will keep them there. I honestly believe Boris could give the Queen a knee trembler and get away with it.

Itisasecret · 17/04/2022 14:53

Tories always do this. Part of the reason we are so they rely on the middle/upper class to vote them in. The working class got really fooled, turkeys voted for Christmas. Everyone who voted for them is accountable.

Six figure household income, typical Tory target here and hell would freeze over before I’d vote for them.

DragonOverTheMoon · 17/04/2022 14:45

I don't agree at all with @Brieandcamembert I think we should have lovely, well made, affordable council housing that anyone can rent. It shouldn't be - you're on benefits you get a shit house in a shit area with shit neighbours. If you look at social housing before RTB it wasn't housing ghettos, normal WC people with jobs and trades lived in them. Now we have an underclass (don't shoot me for saying it, you know it's true) and social housing looks like social housing. The LAs (that still have council stock, quite a few tendered or sold those contracts out long ago) would have more revenue and people would have secure housing. If you look at Europe most long term rent, in a home that is theirs that they are not forced to move from.

I think new towns should be built with infrastructure to complete it rather than pilling houses on any available land and using their infrastructure. Yes it would cost more but the outcome would be less crowding and more community.

If you put people in ghettos their children will grow up acting that way. There won't be hope for them, we'll end up like america with more violence and crime. Put people in nice houses with nice neighbours and nice communities their children will grow up nice. Put them in shit hole areas they will grow up acting like shits.

Crikeyalmighty · 17/04/2022 14:12

@Brieandcamembert. That’s what social housing is like here in Copenhagen— all are bigger than Uk that I’ve seen plus some nice 3 bed town houses with lounges on 1st floor. They have actually pulled down quite a bit of retail in secondary areas to do this and sites of any size that come available are rarely offered first to the private housebuilders, so we see very few new large sprawling private estates .

Brieandcamembert · 17/04/2022 14:03

Not sarcasm at all. I feel so sad when I see these big sprawling estates being built.

Housing stock being sold off is an illogical arguement as it doesn't matter who owns a house the same number exist.

So many factors to address. There are a lot of houses that sit empty that we need to redevelop.

We need to address the social issues around so many people having multiple families thus requiring more homes.

Social housing should be flats (not high rise, the ones 3 stories or so) with a communal playground, recreation area and allotment area.

Council and housing association properties should be time limited i.e. when your kids leave home you get moved into a 1 bed apartment. Not keep your 3 bed semi.

Blossomtoes · 17/04/2022 13:00

@Brieandcamembert

consistently failed to build more housing to replace stock sold.

Gosh no no no. My heart breaks at the amount of new houses being built. It's awful. We can't just keep building all over the countryside.

Where are people supposed to live then?
mrshoho · 17/04/2022 13:00

is that sarcasm @Brieandcamembert? I can't tell but hope it is. Where are people supposed to live in that case? Would you rather a return to the inner city overcrowded slums? When so much of our social housing stock was sold off where did you think people were going to live?

Brieandcamembert · 17/04/2022 12:54

consistently failed to build more housing to replace stock sold.

Gosh no no no. My heart breaks at the amount of new houses being built. It's awful. We can't just keep building all over the countryside.

HRTQueen · 17/04/2022 12:46

Be interesting to see how voting goes on May 5th

Though not to be relied on for the next GE

I think a shift to the left but not a substantial shift

DownNative · 17/04/2022 12:44

@mrshoho

It depends whether you believe that the RTB scheme was ever a sustainable long term policy. I absolutely believe that both Thatcher and Blair's policies are relevant.
Fair enough if you truly believe both are relevant to mention. The previous commenter was implying otherwise which is why their point was cancelled out with the Thatcher example. Precisely the point here.
Blossomtoes · 17/04/2022 12:37

@mrshoho

It depends whether you believe that the RTB scheme was ever a sustainable long term policy. I absolutely believe that both Thatcher and Blair's policies are relevant.
Of course they are. And RTB is a major cause of the current housing crisis. Thatcher takes the blame for introducing it and not allowing the properties lost through it to be replaced. Blair and successive governments take the blame for not reversing it and not replenishing the stock of social housing.

Thatcher also completely changed the landscape of the UK economy by decimating its manufacturing base and programme of mine closures, privatisation of basic services and contracting out public services. Her shadow is a very long one.

mrshoho · 17/04/2022 11:55

It depends whether you believe that the RTB scheme was ever a sustainable long term policy. I absolutely believe that both Thatcher and Blair's policies are relevant.

DownNative · 17/04/2022 11:45

@mrshoho

Thatcher's policies, although a long time ago, very much still reverberate today. The RTB scheme took millions of social housing stock into private hands. The receipts of these sales ended up in Central government funds instead of being given to LAs to subsidise and improve local housing.
RTB is a red herring as the problem is that successive Labour and Conservative governments have consistently failed to build more housing to replace stock sold.

It really begs the question as to why Labour dithered until 2009 to introduce changes regarding housing. This was completed in 2012 since then councils do get a proportion of money from RTB.

So, no, it's not as straightforward as just Thatcher's policies in isolation. The truth is both Labour and the Conservatives have failed in this area.

It does not detract from the argument, then, that it's more ludicrous to bring up Thatcher than Blair.

mrshoho · 17/04/2022 08:43

Thatcher's policies, although a long time ago, very much still reverberate today. The RTB scheme took millions of social housing stock into private hands. The receipts of these sales ended up in Central government funds instead of being given to LAs to subsidise and improve local housing.

DownNative · 17/04/2022 03:34

@Blossomtoes

No whoosh at all. Neither is worse than the other, incidentally, both are ludicrous.
There is such a thing as degrees of things and it's clearly considerably more ludicrous for folk to mention Thatcher in regards to the Conservative Party than it is to mention Blair in regards to Labour.

He's much more recent and his policies still reverberate today. We're still paying for his PFI failure, for example - 2049 is when we stop paying for it. Then, there's the impact of his distortion in order to start an invasion too.

Thatcher was a very long time ago in contrast.

HRTQueen · 16/04/2022 23:55

Well we had Labour taken back to the left and it don’t go down well with voters

Also returned to being the party intrenched in ideology it’s past politics it’s doesn’t apply any longer to kee banging on about being the party for the working class

The Tories have realised they are the party for both sides at present

Labour need to work out where they stand and further to the left will not get them in power

MangyInseam · 16/04/2022 23:24

@Blossomtoes

Blair’s been gone for 15 years, you might as well say you wouldn’t vote Labour because you didn’t like Attlee.
You could make an argument that Blair permanently changed the policy direction of the LP, in the same way that Thatcher changed the very definition of conservative politics in the CP. When people think today of Conservatives being for deregulation, or Labour being very pro-EU, those are both new. Just as examples.

Anyone who was a traditional Labour or Tory voter isn't really represented politically these days in any comprehensive way.

Blossomtoes · 16/04/2022 22:33

No whoosh at all. Neither is worse than the other, incidentally, both are ludicrous.

DownNative · 16/04/2022 22:19

@Blossomtoes

Thatcher’s dead? Fucks sake, why did nobody tell me?
Point being that it's worse for people to reference Thatcher than Blair as a reason not to vote for Labour.

Whoosh.....Hmm

MangyInseam · 16/04/2022 22:13

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

Do you really think Labour would have kept things more open during covid? That hasn't been the pattern of progressive governments in other countries at all, quite the opposite.

It is true lockdowns caused a lot of harm. Something I’ve posted a fair bit about. Unfortunately Labour were even more for restrictions and lockdowns and the left generally were ok with thinking about the risk from Covid but not the damage from lockdowns. Which is a huge pity as many were vulnerable to the risks from lockdown.

I hope it never happens again but Labour have been keener to neglect those hurt by them so I’m not seeing much opposition there

The above posts really sum up why it's pointless speaking with the remaining tory voters.

The post they are replying to was one that detailed the real life impacts of over 10 years of tory cuts, highlighting just what their failure to invest in education, social services, health, communities, public services, etc, etc has led too. Their response, as you can see, is to skip over all that nasty stuff and simply say "Well Labour might have been as bad".

I genuinely can't get my head around that thought process. You have insurmountable evidence that the tories have and are having a horrific impact on the most vulnerable in society, have overseen widening inequality, unseen since the Victorian era, and a reduction in living standards across the board and STILL you ignore it all "cause someone else might have done worse".

Labour might have been worse if they'd been in power, they might not have been, it's irrelevant. The tories were and are in power, their failures are their's alone. Yet the tory faithful refuse to hold them accountable. When that's the level of denial/willful ignorance you're dealing with there really is no point.

That was my comment, and you are projecting. And FWIW I have voted across the spectrum.

I didn't have anything to say about the other points in the post, so I didn't.

I was surprised to see the individual suggest that somehow lockdowns would have been lesser or better under Labour, so I asked about why she thought that.

That being said, you are making a very simplistic point I think. We can say all kinds of things about the success of the various Tory policies. At the same time, some social problems are outside of that - the idea that current rising prices are due to the Tories is pretty ignorant, they are based on global problems.

On the other hand if we are talking about voting for Labour, or any of the other parties, one would like to think the policies would actually be better, rather than worse or the same. Otherwise there isn't much to recommend them as an alternative.

Peopel's views on that may vary, personally I tend to think that fundamentally neoliberal policies and the kind of policies Labour tends to prefer are both rather inadaquate.

Blossomtoes · 16/04/2022 21:57

Thatcher’s dead? Fucks sake, why did nobody tell me?

DownNative · 16/04/2022 21:53

@Blossomtoes

Blair’s been gone for 15 years, you might as well say you wouldn’t vote Labour because you didn’t like Attlee.
And many Labour voters have gone on about Thatcher long after too. Even this year on this forum too.

And she's dead.

Blossomtoes · 16/04/2022 21:33

I just couldn't bring myself to vote in someone who has the likes of Rayner, Philips and Abbott on their front benches

Abbott and Philips are backbenchers.