Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you vote Tory now…

740 replies

Joanna1988124 · 12/04/2022 21:48

You’re effectively propping up this absolute shit show of a government and have no empathy.

I’ll be honest, I’ve voted conservative before as a middle class family their (taxation) policies have suited me more than Labour. I honestly feel ashamed of this and I wish I could’ve seen that the conservatives agenda of ‘levelling up’ is BS.

Regardless of your personal situation, enough is enough now right? People are reliant on food banks, they’re choosing between heating and eating. Austerity has been a total nightmare for society causing the rich to get richer and the poor to get poorer.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 18/04/2022 17:54

Thinking that they switched purely out of being anti immigration and being patriotic is part of the problem

If that isn’t true why did the Tories win so many red wall seats with the inane “Get Brexit Done” slogan?

HRTQueen · 18/04/2022 17:52

Many Labour voters have been saying for years that Labour is no longer the party that listens to them

It’s not new and started in the later years of Blair’s leadership

And this was said time and time again when Corbyn led the party.

Thinking that they switched purely out of being anti immigration and being patriotic is part of the problem

Narcoanonymoose · 18/04/2022 17:47

@Xenia this old chestnut keeps on getting trotted out that labour doesn’t like its core voters. Where is the evidence for this ? Who are its core voters anyway ? Many W/C northern voters have gone down the culturally conservative road (anti immigration, patriotic ) but still want state interventionist policies (better public services, well funded NHS) which they will never get with the Tory party. If anything the Conservative party has an even bigger ideological bridge to cross if they want to retain those voters.

Parker231 · 18/04/2022 17:21

www.politico.eu/europe-poll-of-polls/united-kingdom/

This is good for following voting trends - the Tories and Boris are both on the way down which isn’t surprising when the NHS and post lockdown education difficulties haven’t been addressed, Boris’s ongoing lies regarding Partygate and now the Rwanda proposal.

HRTQueen · 18/04/2022 16:58

Really that is good Labour are ahead by 5 points

That is a drop from a few months ago

And given the last year Labour should be a clear 10 points ahead Labour need to look at why this is

Blossomtoes · 18/04/2022 16:37

@Xenia

Labour seems to dislike its traditional core voters and does not like their ideas eg ideas about who is a woman. Stamer pretending he is patriotic or supports the army or loves our country is not really going very well.
It’s going well enough for Labour to be five points ahead in the polls.
Xenia · 18/04/2022 15:41

Labour seems to dislike its traditional core voters and does not like their ideas eg ideas about who is a woman. Stamer pretending he is patriotic or supports the army or loves our country is not really going very well.

DownNative · 17/04/2022 20:56

Whoever said this:

"The flag shagging, bungalow bigot blue collar idiots voted for them"

Starmer has been trying to wrap Labour in the Union Jack for a while. He absolutely knows he needs to appear patriotic in England and Scotland.

Especially Scotland where Labour has been appallingly bad on the Constitutional debate and the Union.

If Starmer is serious about Labour being patriotic and Unionist, he needs to boot the Irish Nationalist SDLP away. Something he's failed to do.

Labour will continue to lose votes to the SNP and Conservatives on many issues, including patriotism, until it gets its act together.

As long as Labour and their activists take an England centric approach....they'll keep failing. Starmer, at least, recognises that.

It would do a few in this thread good to donthe same.

DdraigGoch · 17/04/2022 20:39

The flag shagging, bungalow bigot blue collar idiots voted for them

Hmm Labour's project to win the hearts and minds of voters is still going well then...

Blossomtoes · 17/04/2022 20:31

Whatever the Tory party thinks of them as a group, they know what the LP thinks - that they are stupid racists

That appears to be the Tory party’s opinion of them, hence the Rwanda debacle which appears to be going down a storm.

MangyInseam · 17/04/2022 20:01

@Blossomtoes

Do you think it might just be possible that the "left" now actually represents policies that are good for and represent the values of it's members, mc people, and this is why wc people are not so keen?

I think a lot of people for whom life is pretty hopeless have bought into the “levelling up” promise they were sold at the last election, somehow forgetting that the problems in many of the red wall towns were caused by austerity, ie a Tory government. Whether they’ll do so again remains to be seen since very little has changed there since 2019.

Because basically it sounds here like you think of them as children who should listen to their betters who know what is really best for them

I’m sorry that’s the impression I’ve given as it wasn’t my intention. I think that’s how the Tory government sees them. I do think a lot of people will be hurting financially over the coming months and the next election will be won or lost on the economy, this government has a poor record with the least well off. They’ll be looking at the free school meals debacle and the £20 UC cut and wondering why they would vote for a government that appears to be oblivious to their concerns.

Maybe I'm being a little unclear.

What I am suggesting is that maybe working class people have a better idea where their interests lie than a bunch of mc people do. And if they are voting Tory in large numbers, it's not because they are suffering from false consciousness or short-sightedness - and that is a paternalistic idea no matter how you cut it - it's because they do not see the Labour party as representing their interests or values.

Whatever the Tory party thinks of them as a group, they know what the LP thinks - that they are stupid racists.

Blossomtoes · 17/04/2022 18:58

Do you think it might just be possible that the "left" now actually represents policies that are good for and represent the values of it's members, mc people, and this is why wc people are not so keen?

I think a lot of people for whom life is pretty hopeless have bought into the “levelling up” promise they were sold at the last election, somehow forgetting that the problems in many of the red wall towns were caused by austerity, ie a Tory government. Whether they’ll do so again remains to be seen since very little has changed there since 2019.

Because basically it sounds here like you think of them as children who should listen to their betters who know what is really best for them

I’m sorry that’s the impression I’ve given as it wasn’t my intention. I think that’s how the Tory government sees them. I do think a lot of people will be hurting financially over the coming months and the next election will be won or lost on the economy, this government has a poor record with the least well off. They’ll be looking at the free school meals debacle and the £20 UC cut and wondering why they would vote for a government that appears to be oblivious to their concerns.

MangyInseam · 17/04/2022 18:43

I mean, it's not "ironic" that university educated people are turning left when the policies of the left are now the policies of the middle classes. It's exactly what you would expect.

MangyInseam · 17/04/2022 18:41

@Blossomtoes

Isn't it funny that Labour has now become a party dominated by middle and even upper middle class, university educated, urban people, and somehow the working classes increasingly are abandoning them because they don't recognize that the policies these people come up with are what's really good for them?

The “working class” started to abandon the left 40 years ago when the Tories pretended to share their toys with them. Home ownership through RTB, the offer to buy shares in nationalised industries, all those “aspirational” goodies in exchange for their votes.

Ironically it’s the university educated children of those new middle class people who are now turning left.

Do you think it might just be possible that the "left" now actually represents policies that are good for and represent the values of it's members, mc people, and this is why wc people are not so keen?

And this idea that somehow these mc individuals are representing the working classes is in fact the false consciousness here?

Because basically it sounds here like you think of them as children who should listen to their betters who know what is really best for them.

DownNative · 17/04/2022 18:36

@Blossomtoes

Isn't it funny that Labour has now become a party dominated by middle and even upper middle class, university educated, urban people, and somehow the working classes increasingly are abandoning them because they don't recognize that the policies these people come up with are what's really good for them?

The “working class” started to abandon the left 40 years ago when the Tories pretended to share their toys with them. Home ownership through RTB, the offer to buy shares in nationalised industries, all those “aspirational” goodies in exchange for their votes.

Ironically it’s the university educated children of those new middle class people who are now turning left.

Labour's Red Wall didn't collapse until 2019. In Scotland, Labour collapsed because Jack McConnell's Scottish Labour made a mess and took voters for granted. SNP saw an opportunity and smacked Labour ever since.

Conservatives only became Scotland's second biggest party under Ruth Davidson precisely because Labour failed to present itself as a Unionist party.

You cannot keep blaming the working class population for Labour's failure to attract or hold voters.

That's down to Labour's mismanagement which was worsened by Corbyn and his Momentum group.

Labour should own their own mess and failures.

Xenia · 17/04/2022 18:19

Yes, I remember the campaign socialists under Blair as we used to call them. They seemed to be the richer people at work who could afford to vote labour as they had loads of spare money to spend on extra tax. They were not the traditional labour working class vote.
I did my local council vote today (postal) and voted Conservative. One of my student sons did his - one green and 2 liberal democrat (we get 3 votes).

Blossomtoes · 17/04/2022 18:19

Isn't it funny that Labour has now become a party dominated by middle and even upper middle class, university educated, urban people, and somehow the working classes increasingly are abandoning them because they don't recognize that the policies these people come up with are what's really good for them?

The “working class” started to abandon the left 40 years ago when the Tories pretended to share their toys with them. Home ownership through RTB, the offer to buy shares in nationalised industries, all those “aspirational” goodies in exchange for their votes.

Ironically it’s the university educated children of those new middle class people who are now turning left.

MangyInseam · 17/04/2022 18:01

@Blossomtoes

And your comment about the working class being "fooled" is what's known as false consciousness

And your point is? Marx and Engels were entirely correct in this instance.

False conciousness is a double aged sword, rhetorically.

Isn't it funny that Labour has now become a party dominated by middle and even upper middle class, university educated, urban people, and somehow the working classes increasingly are abandoning them because they don't recognize that the policies these people come up with are what's really good for them?

So who is it that is suffering from false consciousness?

MangyInseam · 17/04/2022 17:45

@HRTQueen

Well we had Labour taken back to the left and it don’t go down well with voters

Also returned to being the party intrenched in ideology it’s past politics it’s doesn’t apply any longer to kee banging on about being the party for the working class

The Tories have realised they are the party for both sides at present

Labour need to work out where they stand and further to the left will not get them in power

I disagree that Labour were taken back to the left. To a left maybe.

But Momentum leftism is not traditional British leftism, no matter what they would like to believe. As I said, look how they sneered at people who were Leavers and EU skeptics. Not just sneering either, but really not even understanding how it was a leftist position, and looking down consistently on the people they claim to represent.

Ursula4007 · 17/04/2022 17:39

@Narcoanonymoose

Oh yeah the pile on by m/c lefty feminists in their little bubble. Not a shit given about how poor w/c women have suffered under tory policies...
Precisely this.

If you think labour are falling short when it comes to womens rights then absolutely address this. When the time is right, and the tories are out. Stopping the damage they are doing to the most disadvantaged in our society needs to take priority over your principles. No other party is going to see the tories off, right now that’s all that matters, the rest can be addressed later.

DownNative · 17/04/2022 16:45

@Blossomtoes

You appear to be under the impression that you’re setting essay questions or teaching a recalcitrant pupil *@DownNative*. Here’s some news, this is a discussion not a lesson. I’m happy to engage when you stop this nonsense.
In a discussion, any claim you make IS going to be faced with "Well, what evidence have you got?".

Especially if you will persist in making sweeping statements.

It's very telling you chose to deflect there instead of trying to support your own claim that Marx was somehow right.

Marxism has long since lost credibility as can be seen in the real world.

So, I'm not surprised you simply cannot support your claim.

Blossomtoes · 17/04/2022 16:40

You appear to be under the impression that you’re setting essay questions or teaching a recalcitrant pupil @DownNative. Here’s some news, this is a discussion not a lesson. I’m happy to engage when you stop this nonsense.

DownNative · 17/04/2022 16:34

@Blossomtoes

And your comment about the working class being "fooled" is what's known as false consciousness

And your point is? Marx and Engels were entirely correct in this instance.

Right.....please demonstrate with empirical evidence then that the working classes are the victims of false consciousness.

Bear in mind that Marxist theory of false consciousness is part of a group of logical fallacies.

Blossomtoes · 17/04/2022 16:15

And your comment about the working class being "fooled" is what's known as false consciousness

And your point is? Marx and Engels were entirely correct in this instance.

DownNative · 17/04/2022 16:10

@Itisasecret

Tories always do this. Part of the reason we are so they rely on the middle/upper class to vote them in. The working class got really fooled, turkeys voted for Christmas. Everyone who voted for them is accountable.

Six figure household income, typical Tory target here and hell would freeze over before I’d vote for them.

And your comment about the working class being "fooled" is what's known as false consciousness.

I'm far away from being on six figures, but I've had more money in my pocket under the Conservatives than I did under Labour. And I also would vote Conservative based on the Constitutional debate which Labour is also a no-no for.