Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you vote Tory now…

740 replies

Joanna1988124 · 12/04/2022 21:48

You’re effectively propping up this absolute shit show of a government and have no empathy.

I’ll be honest, I’ve voted conservative before as a middle class family their (taxation) policies have suited me more than Labour. I honestly feel ashamed of this and I wish I could’ve seen that the conservatives agenda of ‘levelling up’ is BS.

Regardless of your personal situation, enough is enough now right? People are reliant on food banks, they’re choosing between heating and eating. Austerity has been a total nightmare for society causing the rich to get richer and the poor to get poorer.

OP posts:
Xenia · 13/04/2022 20:44

I was crtainly against all the lockdowns but Labour and the Tories were veyr much in favour, Labour even more so than the Tories. Only 100 Tory Mps ultimately rebelled against some of the latter ones, so hardly anyone at all. This is a middle ground big state, high spending Tory party, unfortunately, not the policies I want but heaps better than Labour.

LexMitior · 13/04/2022 20:42

@MangyInseamYes I've seen many opinions but not much policy - which suggests that whatever MPs or the PM say now, its not worth very much.

They actually have the power to do something now - politicians who just speak without a proposal when they are in government are getting something cheap from voters.

You say the statement was decisive, but its a statement. Nothing else.

Next week maybe Keir S says something - who cares? He needs some actual policies, and so do the Conservatives. Both of them are hopeless on this until they show some results.

MarshaBradyo · 13/04/2022 20:40

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

Up to you if you feel that way about people who vote differently to you. Especially since the last election had the result it did that’s a fair amount of people you hold hate in your mind for.

I don't feel that way about everyone who votes differently from me, just those who vote Tory.

I’d say you were wrong of course but angry intolerant people exist in all walks of life and the level of intolerance from the left is apparent.

Your right I am angry at and I am intolerant of the tories and those that keep them in power. It's hard not to be when you see the real impact on people on the receiving end of their policies. Such as the 15 year old girl with complex needs, who regularly soils herself in class, but because of cuts is kept in the mainstream (despite the desperate pleas from teachers and family). Or the 12 year old boy, who's behaviour has deteriorated massively over the last two years because he eventuall reveals (after a breaksdown in school) thag his mum has been pimping him out since the first lockdown. Or not being able to speak to one friend every again because they hung themselves when they fell through the furlough cracks and couldn't support their family. Or another because their potentially life saving cancer treatment was postponed again and again until it was too late, leaving behind two devastated u10s.

I'm sure you'll come back with something like "there were issues under labour" and there of course were issues, but everyone I speak to and see says the same. It's far worse now than they ever remember it and that's from people with 20, 30, 40+ years experience.

The aggression and abuse is mostly from your direction.

Yes, those in ivory towers don't tend to show much aggression towards those they consider below them, the don't tend to think of them at all actually. On the odd occasion they do enter their minds they tend to throw contempt and pity their way instead

It is true lockdowns caused a lot of harm. Something I’ve posted a fair bit about. Unfortunately Labour were even more for restrictions and lockdowns and the left generally were ok with thinking about the risk from Covid but not the damage from lockdowns. Which is a huge pity as many were vulnerable to the risks from lockdown.

I hope it never happens again but Labour have been keener to neglect those hurt by them so I’m not seeing much opposition there.

MangyInseam · 13/04/2022 20:39

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

Up to you if you feel that way about people who vote differently to you. Especially since the last election had the result it did that’s a fair amount of people you hold hate in your mind for.

I don't feel that way about everyone who votes differently from me, just those who vote Tory.

I’d say you were wrong of course but angry intolerant people exist in all walks of life and the level of intolerance from the left is apparent.

Your right I am angry at and I am intolerant of the tories and those that keep them in power. It's hard not to be when you see the real impact on people on the receiving end of their policies. Such as the 15 year old girl with complex needs, who regularly soils herself in class, but because of cuts is kept in the mainstream (despite the desperate pleas from teachers and family). Or the 12 year old boy, who's behaviour has deteriorated massively over the last two years because he eventuall reveals (after a breaksdown in school) thag his mum has been pimping him out since the first lockdown. Or not being able to speak to one friend every again because they hung themselves when they fell through the furlough cracks and couldn't support their family. Or another because their potentially life saving cancer treatment was postponed again and again until it was too late, leaving behind two devastated u10s.

I'm sure you'll come back with something like "there were issues under labour" and there of course were issues, but everyone I speak to and see says the same. It's far worse now than they ever remember it and that's from people with 20, 30, 40+ years experience.

The aggression and abuse is mostly from your direction.

Yes, those in ivory towers don't tend to show much aggression towards those they consider below them, the don't tend to think of them at all actually. On the odd occasion they do enter their minds they tend to throw contempt and pity their way instead

Do you really think Labour would have kept things more open during covid? That hasn't been the pattern of progressive governments in other countries at all, quite the opposite.
MangyInseam · 13/04/2022 20:35

[quote LexMitior]@MangyInseam - they are in power. Now why have the Conservatives not changed or removed some of the policies they implemented or permitted during the last ten years?

You are really giving the Government a huge benefit by ignoring that they made this mess in the first place and have not actually done anything yet to sort it out.[/quote]
Have you been following this particular issue? It's been changing constantly.

Initially most people supported a lot of the thinking around gender, and then there was a long time when even very mild criticisms or even questions were suppressed.

Most MPs seem to have been in much the same situation as the rest of the public, really unaware of what activists were saying or doing, and in many cases completely unaware that there was any disagreement. And that was very deliberate, activists deliberatly acted in such a way as to avoid that kind of attention by flying under the radar and getting at various government, non-governmental, and arms length institutions. Like prisons. Like the police. Like schools.

Contrary to what some seem to believe, these kinds of institutions are not directly controlled in these kinds of details by ministers or even by the senior civil servants that advise the ministers. Schools trying to update their curricula or choosing books for their libraries or updating their equalities policies are not asking MPs or the ministers for education how to go about it. They have their own employers or advisory groups or are asking for groups like SW to advise them.

It's only in the past two years that there has been more and more public discussion apparent, and in the last year that it's become really open, and in the last few months that it has begun to be addressed at the highest levels politically. And really only in the week that the Tories have finally made a fairly decisive statement after the UN judgement came back. There's been no time to sort it out yet and I daresay it will be at least a year before a lot of it is untangled. But we are beginning to see some action.

There are several posters on this thread who keep saying again and again that the Conservatives should have done something years ago, and they know darn well what the timeline is because every time it is pointed out to them. Up until now it's been Labour like a bulldog on gender issues, with the Conservatives at first for it and later somewhat on the fence with a variety of opinions (unlike Labour who didn't really allow that.) It's only now that there has been a decisive statement.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 13/04/2022 20:34

Up to you if you feel that way about people who vote differently to you. Especially since the last election had the result it did that’s a fair amount of people you hold hate in your mind for.

I don't feel that way about everyone who votes differently from me, just those who vote Tory.

I’d say you were wrong of course but angry intolerant people exist in all walks of life and the level of intolerance from the left is apparent.

Your right I am angry at and I am intolerant of the tories and those that keep them in power. It's hard not to be when you see the real impact on people on the receiving end of their policies. Such as the 15 year old girl with complex needs, who regularly soils herself in class, but because of cuts is kept in the mainstream (despite the desperate pleas from teachers and family). Or the 12 year old boy, who's behaviour has deteriorated massively over the last two years because he eventuall reveals (after a breaksdown in school) thag his mum has been pimping him out since the first lockdown. Or not being able to speak to one friend every again because they hung themselves when they fell through the furlough cracks and couldn't support their family. Or another because their potentially life saving cancer treatment was postponed again and again until it was too late, leaving behind two devastated u10s.

I'm sure you'll come back with something like "there were issues under labour" and there of course were issues, but everyone I speak to and see says the same. It's far worse now than they ever remember it and that's from people with 20, 30, 40+ years experience.

The aggression and abuse is mostly from your direction.

Yes, those in ivory towers don't tend to show much aggression towards those they consider below them, the don't tend to think of them at all actually. On the odd occasion they do enter their minds they tend to throw contempt and pity their way instead

Moppincraxy · 13/04/2022 20:33

@TeenPlusCat

I think anyone who makes generalisations about people based on who they vote for is doing a disservice to open debate.

Politics is nuanced. People look at parties and policies and make decisions based on the balance and how important individual aspects are to them personally.

People can dislike Boris and think he is a self serving opportunist, but still think that the Conservatives will be better because xyz.
Just like people can think that Labour policies are on average better but still choose not to vote for them because of abc.

I would imagine pretty much everyone agrees that the Downing Street lockdown parties were a total disgrace. But that on its own is not necessarily a reason to not vote Conservative.

Balance. Nuance. Weighing up priorities. Not name calling.

@TeenPlusCat this is most intelligent and sensible post on this entire thread.
Cornettoninja · 13/04/2022 20:28

Yes the energy bills are going up - there is no magic money tree

Yes there is, it’s us.

For example take a look at the percentage of tax paid on fuel and then maybe a look at the profits of the fuel companies.

BasiliskStare · 13/04/2022 20:28

@Cornettoninja - agree - a spoilt ballot I reckon you might as well stay at home

BasiliskStare · 13/04/2022 20:26

& yes a spoilt ballot is like pissing against the wall - doesn't make a blind bit of difference. Vote for someone or not. Your spoiled ballot will go straight into the bin .

Cornettoninja · 13/04/2022 20:26

@Blossomtoes

A spoiled ballot makes more of a point

It makes no point at all. Particularly in a stronghold - of either colour.

Agreed. No more than a cursory glance is given to most reasons recorded and your basically leaving the interpretation of your reason for abstaining up to politicians.
BasiliskStare · 13/04/2022 20:23

I have looked at stuff & in truth I would prefer Boris not being PM - but on the other hand I have seen the conservatives giving people 80% salary on furlough . - surely that was a good thing. ?

Yes the energy bills are going up - there is no magic money tree. I wish we could have one. Personally I wish we could tax the likes of Amazon / the coffee shops a great deal more I think the slight problem is that these companies employ people . I have read that shutting down CFC ( because Abramovich ) has lost many poeple their jobs even though his bank is frozen

Blossomtoes · 13/04/2022 20:21

A spoiled ballot makes more of a point

It makes no point at all. Particularly in a stronghold - of either colour.

EngTech · 13/04/2022 20:18

Come the Local Elections and the GE, people will vote accordingly 👍👍

lifeturnsonadime · 13/04/2022 20:17

@Blossomtoes

I may in the future vote conservative

Yet you objected to being described as a Tory voter. 🤷‍♀️

Well i'm not a Tory voter! I've voted in every election in the last 30 years and have never voted Tory.

I may vote Tory on this single issue in the future because this single issue is important.

In reality I live in a Tory area anyway so it makes no odds. A spoiled ballot makes more of a point.

LexMitior · 13/04/2022 20:13

@MangyInseam - they are in power. Now why have the Conservatives not changed or removed some of the policies they implemented or permitted during the last ten years?

You are really giving the Government a huge benefit by ignoring that they made this mess in the first place and have not actually done anything yet to sort it out.

Blossomtoes · 13/04/2022 20:12

What are you trying to accomplish by posting this stuff?

What stuff? Facts that don’t suit your narrative?

MangyInseam · 13/04/2022 20:07

[quote TooBigForMyBoots]A reminder for those who have forgotten what Penny Mordaunt said last year: www.spectator.co.uk/article/penny-mordaunt-is-wrong-to-repeat-the-trans-allies-mantra[/quote]
What are you trying to accomplish by posting this stuff? Everyone knows there are Conservatives with a variety of opinions on this, and have changed the majority view over the last years too.

The issue is that Labour has only one allowable position right now, and wants to change it in a particular direction right now, and has a leader who can't make a straight statement right now.

LexMitior · 13/04/2022 20:04

[quote TooBigForMyBoots]A reminder for those who have forgotten what Penny Mordaunt said last year: www.spectator.co.uk/article/penny-mordaunt-is-wrong-to-repeat-the-trans-allies-mantra[/quote]
Thats a good point - basically I saw one statement from Johnson on this and its certainly not enough to undo the mess that his party created, implemented and supported. There's nothing he's said or shown so far to undo that. Given he's the first PM ever to break the law in office, I don't really take what he says seriously since this is someone who lies to Parliament. Its not a serious thing to him.

However the Labour Party need to wonder why, given they were in opposition, where they needed to have a mainstream policy and appeal to a large demographic, why trans rights were the thing that they thought were significant. Because frankly its a massive vote loser and any decent political adviser would have known that. It suggests that they are really, really political out of it.

BobbyeinArkansas · 13/04/2022 20:01

very much doubt things would be any different if the Labour Party were in power.

I would never judge people for how they vote. Why is it always Labour Voters trying to dictate who people vote for?

Quite frankly they're all awful at the moment.

Blossomtoes · 13/04/2022 20:00

I may in the future vote conservative

Yet you objected to being described as a Tory voter. 🤷‍♀️

lifeturnsonadime · 13/04/2022 19:59

@TooBigForMyBoots

Yet the Labour Equality Law is what helped women and protected them from the Tory proposed GRA Reform and Self ID.
Say what? No it hasn't the same lobby group that almost enforced the government to bring in Self ID made sure that the Equality Act has been misrepresented with support from the Labour Party.
TooBigForMyBoots · 13/04/2022 19:59

A reminder for those who have forgotten what Penny Mordaunt said last year: www.spectator.co.uk/article/penny-mordaunt-is-wrong-to-repeat-the-trans-allies-mantra

lifeturnsonadime · 13/04/2022 19:57

That's because the title of this thread is AIBU to think that if you vote Tory.... Support and opposition to self ID is cross bench.

Well, kind of, but I'm yet to see members of the Tory Party be expelled for believing that women exist.

There may be some conservative support for Self ID but it is not as vociferous as that coming from the front benches of the Labour Party.

I may in the future vote conservative simply to block self ID as women's rights to be classed separately to men and the protection of children from harm is too important to me to ignore.

Once women lose our current legal right to name ourselves and to safe spaces we won't get them back. 'Stonewall Law' has indicated very clearly what the implications of self ID means for vulnerable women No Thank You. It implicates everything not just the vulnerable. Equal Pay, crime stats, funding for women's issues, women's health. If women can't be named they can't have carved out policies for women. That very clearly will suit some factions of society who don't think women matter much.

And as for what it does to children. I've been there already on this thread. I just can't vote for a party that will endorse physically harming children.

BasiliskStare · 13/04/2022 19:56

@BorisJohnsonsHair - I respectfully disagree. unless you have a little more backup to your points. I don't think I am selfish or stupid but have once voted tory. I may vote Labour next time if Keir Starmer were not such a wimp/ with no ideas & indeed against women's rights.

@DragonOverTheMoon Flowers