Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you vote Tory now…

740 replies

Joanna1988124 · 12/04/2022 21:48

You’re effectively propping up this absolute shit show of a government and have no empathy.

I’ll be honest, I’ve voted conservative before as a middle class family their (taxation) policies have suited me more than Labour. I honestly feel ashamed of this and I wish I could’ve seen that the conservatives agenda of ‘levelling up’ is BS.

Regardless of your personal situation, enough is enough now right? People are reliant on food banks, they’re choosing between heating and eating. Austerity has been a total nightmare for society causing the rich to get richer and the poor to get poorer.

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 13/04/2022 22:29

A week after KS fucked up on "What is a woman?", PM Johnson refused to say that only women have a cervix. www.google.com/amp/s/www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1501654/Boris-Johnson-GB-News-latest-Conservative-Party-speech-woke-cancel-culture-woman-cervix-vn/amp

DownNative · 13/04/2022 22:28

[quote Blossomtoes]Here you go @DownNative, it’s a bit more pertinent.

www.theguardian.com/business/2022/jan/31/as-uk-households-feel-pressure-how-are-other-european-countries-tackling-energy-crisis[/quote]
No, your article is actually quite selective. Note how it only includes a few of the major economies in Europe. It's selective for a reason.

While the Guardian asserted the UK Treasury remains "tight-lipped" on further measures to help, it includes Denmark.

But notes that "The Danish government remains in talks to decide how much support it can offer towards household bills." Nothing has actually been agreed in Denmark which means they're in a similar position to the UK. Contradictory of the Guardian, really.

Unfortunately for you, Oxford Economics whom I quoted is NOT selective like the Guardian. Why do you think Eastern European economies were blatantly ignored by the Guardian, for example? Same for countries outside the European continent?

Over a quarter of Bulgarians struggle to heat their homes. Yet only 10 per cent of Bulgarians had a positive view of the measures being taken by the government to support businesses and households, according to a poll for the public broadcaster Bulgarian National Television.

No mention by Guardian?

Answers on a postcard, please!

"It’s not that the UK is necessarily the miser of Europe. There are more generous countries – yes, there are few that are as generous as what has been done in France – but then you look at places like Germany and we look comparatively better off than many German households."

  • Josie Dent, managing economist at the Centre for Economics and Business Research.

That puts Germany into perspective too.

mrshoho · 13/04/2022 22:27

thank you @FOJN for an excellent post.

FOJN · 13/04/2022 22:17

A government policy is a positive act by politicians. The Tories own this stuff, to their prison policy, schools policy and health policies for trans. All theirs.

The conservative government haven't developed policies for prisons or schools, they have been written by the prison service and individual schools. Those organisations have written policy in accordance with Stonewall guidance rather than the law. This includes the College of Policing introducing a policy on recording non-crime hate incidents which could show on a DBS check without the person being aware of this record and without an investigation taking place. It seems to have been used almost exclusively to silence anyone who campaigns against self ID. This has been challenged by judicial review. See link below.

www.faircop.org.uk/

The government have committed to providing more money for trans healthcare but the treatment protocols are devised by clinicians. It took a whistle blower from the Tavistock to raise the alarm about how much influence lobby groups had at the clinic. The Tavistock is now under enhanced oversight.

Many of the changes we've seen have been years in the making, quite a few pre-dating the Tory/LibDem coalition but that doesn't make them a problem of Labours (or the SNP) making either. Trans lobby groups have had a long term strategy, getting Stonewall on board was part of that. Stonewall took on the campaign for self ID in 2015 and things have accelerated since then. Developments in the Scottish Prison Service are a good example of how long this has been in the works. The "consultation" to introduce a policy of self ID for Scottish prisoners started back in 2007. The link below details how difficult it has been to get any transparency about the process.

murrayblackburnmackenzie.org/2022/04/06/the-sps-review-on-trans-prisoners-a-chance-to-get-policy-making-in-scottish-prisons-back-on-track/

There has been a concerted effort by lobbying groups to keep their activities under the radar in the hope that they could bring about so much change that self ID would simply be a matter of getting parliament to rubber stamp it. Explained in link below.

www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-document-that-reveals-the-remarkable-tactics-of-trans-lobbyists

The Conservatives realise they have made a big mistake by proposing self ID. Labour and the SNP are doubling down on their committment despite very reasonable concerns being raised.

MangyInseam · 13/04/2022 22:14

[quote LexMitior]@MangyInseam - well, I share optimism, but I don't share your opinion on political speed. If its a priority, things happen very quickly. Two months is pretty quick, but its not fast enough for the local elections.

If the Conservatives actually change their policies between now and the next election I will seriously consider voting for them because this affects women now, not in two years.

Labour are just stupid - really stupid, and its incredibly dumb that a party with a very poor history of party discipline (ie nearly anyone could say what they liked) chose trans policy as the thing that united them and where there was no debate (except it alienated a lot of women). It seems deeply misogynist to me that they did so - may be there's a story on that hasn't come out yet. But I'm not pro Labour either and I won't be voting for them currently.[/quote]
I think though that the things that are problems are not really things that the government has direct control over in a lot of cases. It's not the government who ever directly said, put transwomen in women's prisons, or said, schools, make your toilets gender neutral. Even if they want to make announcements about these things it will involve some behind the scenes negotiating first. It would be the same if Labour tried to do the same thing.

I think the problem for Labour is they took it at face value as a basic rights issue. In the mind of many MPS and others with influence, saying wait, lots of people have concerns about this was the same as saying, wait, I have concerns about black kids on the school bus. They'd already been well captured by identity politics. And they tend to be suffer at times - this seems to be a thing among progressives generally - of accepting an ideological position and being unwilling to consider whether concrete instantiations are actually effective. Not the better thinkers obviously but for some reason many of the ones that have influence.

Blossomtoes · 13/04/2022 22:06

It doesn’t matter why manifesto promises were broken @DownNative. The fact remains that they’re not worth the paper they’re written on.

DownNative · 13/04/2022 22:02

@Blossomtoes

I would rather read the parties ' manifestos than vote along tribal lines

The Tories have broken at least two of their manifesto promises - they’ve raised tax when they said they wouldn’t and removed the triple lock which they promised to retain. Manifestos mean nothing.

Those manifesto pledges were made in 2019.

Who had a clue a global pandemic was going to occur in 2020 and change everything globally?

No one.

I'm afraid you're being highly selective there. Tax had to be raised due to the serious economic climate caused by covid, tanker blockage in Suez, refineries shutting down globally, lockdown lifted caused intense pressure in the global just in time delivery process, war in Ukraine and even eco-warriors blocking fuel distribution all contributed to an increase in cost of living which led to increased taxation.

The situation globally isn't great according to Oxfam:

"The combined impact of COVID-19, inequality and food price hikes could result in 263 million more people living in extreme poverty this year, resulting in a total of 860 million people living below the $1.90 (Rs 144.7) a day extreme poverty line. This would be an extraordinarily damaging rise that reverses decades of progress in the fight against poverty."

Note the causes they cite. Manifestos will not be able to be implemented worldwide as a result.

The world is in an unprecedented situation right now.

Blossomtoes · 13/04/2022 22:00

Here you go @DownNative, it’s a bit more pertinent.

www.theguardian.com/business/2022/jan/31/as-uk-households-feel-pressure-how-are-other-european-countries-tackling-energy-crisis

jgw1 · 13/04/2022 21:53

[quote DownNative]@Blossomtoes said:

"Other countries don’t seem to be inflicting the same economic damage on their citizens. The French haven’t seen their energy bills double."

How many countries are there in the world?

Hint: a lot more than just the French!

If you want a dire situation economically, here's a BBC News report on Sri Lanka from 4 days ago:

Now, THATS a fuel crisis.

And this from 8 days ago:

And THAT'S a governmental crisis.

Other countries in Europe ARE experiencing very, very serious economic issues too, especially the four Eastern European economies of Poland, Czechia, Hungary and Slovakia, according to Oxford Economics.

"Russia's invasion of Ukraine is being felt throughout the global economy, but few places are as exposed to its impact as the Central and Eastern European (CEE) countries. In addition to surging energy prices, CEE economies will be hurt by renewed supply shortages in manufacturing, loss of access to Russian markets, currency depreciation, and the refugee crisis. As a result, we have cut our growth forecast by around 1ppt this year and 0.5ppt in 2023. But the situation remains very volatile, and given the CEE's exposure, the risks are tilted heavily to the downside."

Ukraine's economy will be halved due to the war which represents a loss of $600 billion.

Middle income countries such as Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Egypt have all had to negotiate financial help from the IMF.

According to the UNCTAD Division on Globalization and Development Strategies (United Nations), it is developing countries who will be bearing the brunt.

Not those of us in high income countries such as the UK, France, Germany, USA, etc.

"The brunt is being carried by the developing countriesbecause of the rise in prices of food, of energy and fertilisers that is very steep and also the financial stretch under which the developing countries are already under.

Butthe European Union will see a fairly significant downgrade in its growth performance this year…so will parts of central and southern Asiaas well."

So, it is far from true that other countries aren't experiencing very serious economic damage that's being felt by their citizens. EU countries still have more to come, including France and Germany.

We in the UK are still far more fortunate than many, many people in the world.[/quote]
I thought were an Asian nation so why the comparison to Sri Lanka which as far as I remember my geography is in the Indian Ocean.

LexMitior · 13/04/2022 21:48

@MangyInseam - well, I share optimism, but I don't share your opinion on political speed. If its a priority, things happen very quickly. Two months is pretty quick, but its not fast enough for the local elections.

If the Conservatives actually change their policies between now and the next election I will seriously consider voting for them because this affects women now, not in two years.

Labour are just stupid - really stupid, and its incredibly dumb that a party with a very poor history of party discipline (ie nearly anyone could say what they liked) chose trans policy as the thing that united them and where there was no debate (except it alienated a lot of women). It seems deeply misogynist to me that they did so - may be there's a story on that hasn't come out yet. But I'm not pro Labour either and I won't be voting for them currently.

DownNative · 13/04/2022 21:42

@Blossomtoes said:

"Other countries don’t seem to be inflicting the same economic damage on their citizens. The French haven’t seen their energy bills double."

How many countries are there in the world?

Hint: a lot more than just the French!

If you want a dire situation economically, here's a BBC News report on Sri Lanka from 4 days ago:

Now, THATS a fuel crisis.

And this from 8 days ago:

And THAT'S a governmental crisis.

Other countries in Europe ARE experiencing very, very serious economic issues too, especially the four Eastern European economies of Poland, Czechia, Hungary and Slovakia, according to Oxford Economics.

"Russia's invasion of Ukraine is being felt throughout the global economy, but few places are as exposed to its impact as the Central and Eastern European (CEE) countries. In addition to surging energy prices, CEE economies will be hurt by renewed supply shortages in manufacturing, loss of access to Russian markets, currency depreciation, and the refugee crisis. As a result, we have cut our growth forecast by around 1ppt this year and 0.5ppt in 2023. But the situation remains very volatile, and given the CEE's exposure, the risks are tilted heavily to the downside."

Ukraine's economy will be halved due to the war which represents a loss of $600 billion.

Middle income countries such as Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Egypt have all had to negotiate financial help from the IMF.

According to the UNCTAD Division on Globalization and Development Strategies (United Nations), it is developing countries who will be bearing the brunt.

Not those of us in high income countries such as the UK, France, Germany, USA, etc.

"The brunt is being carried by the developing countriesbecause of the rise in prices of food, of energy and fertilisers that is very steep and also the financial stretch under which the developing countries are already under.

Butthe European Union will see a fairly significant downgrade in its growth performance this year…so will parts of central and southern Asiaas well."

So, it is far from true that other countries aren't experiencing very serious economic damage that's being felt by their citizens. EU countries still have more to come, including France and Germany.

We in the UK are still far more fortunate than many, many people in the world.

StormzyinaTCup · 13/04/2022 21:31

I almost voted Tory once. I thank the heavens DH literally talked me out of it. I was almost won over by that twat David Cameron. I was so grateful, even though labour lost, that I hadn't been one of the fools people who got them into power.

I actually did vote Labour once. Unfortunately, I was won over by that twat Tony Blair and I wish someone had talked me out of it. I was a fool and lesson learnt.

britneyisfree · 13/04/2022 21:27

I almost voted Tory once. I thank the heavens DH literally talked me out of it. I was almost won over by that twat David Cameron. I was so grateful, even though labour lost, that I hadn't been one of the fools people who got them into power.

My excuse is that I was quite young and it was my first time voting. I voted for Gordon in the end. Now that I know more about politics I would never ever ever vote Tory. There are members of my family to whom I wouldn't even want to them to know I'd ever considered it!!!

That being said, I'm not sure I could vote labour at the moment. I think Kier is trying to acknowledge women exist at the moment but they seem to be wrapped up in trans ideology so that can fuck off too.

MangyInseam · 13/04/2022 21:26

@DragonOverTheMoon

No it's not. It's world wide ideology from TRAs that have changed womens lives all over. Canada, US, Europe, Iran just to name a few. It's just as global as the financial crash and has real impact to vulnerable women and girls. It has been a tidle wave that engulfed lots of us and it's not just been our country. We don't exist in a vacuum.
The conversion therapy bill is a good example, there have been pretty identical projects, all of which passed I believe, in Australia, Canada, and NZ, and I think in some states in the US.

Which is kind of amazing when you think about it.

The UK was the only place where there was enough public discussion to have any serious push back at all.

MangyInseam · 13/04/2022 21:21

[quote LexMitior]@MangyInseamYes I've seen many opinions but not much policy - which suggests that whatever MPs or the PM say now, its not worth very much.

They actually have the power to do something now - politicians who just speak without a proposal when they are in government are getting something cheap from voters.

You say the statement was decisive, but its a statement. Nothing else.

Next week maybe Keir S says something - who cares? He needs some actual policies, and so do the Conservatives. Both of them are hopeless on this until they show some results.[/quote]
Maybe it will come to nothing, but actual political action is usually not quick. It takes time for wheels to turn. The UN decision was a big deal, and the PMs statement coming right after suggests that was what they were waiting for - they are now in a position to start taking action on captured institutions. But it's going to take time to actually do it, and what it will probably look like is guidance coming out from various government bodies, I'd expect to see things over the next two months.

But what has been very clear and has already happened is that Tory MPs were allowed to have a variety of views and hash it out in the party, and Labour MPs weren't. And that's a really serious fault on the part of Labour that goes beyond just this issue.

BasiliskStare · 13/04/2022 21:18

@Blossomtoes - I speak of Blair . So yes - old.

Blossomtoes · 13/04/2022 21:12

[quote BasiliskStare]@Blossomtoes - I do get your point but both of the larger parties have broken promises[/quote]
How can Labour break manifesto promises when they haven’t won an election for 16 years?

BasiliskStare · 13/04/2022 21:08

@Blossomtoes - I do get your point but both of the larger parties have broken promises

StormzyinaTCup · 13/04/2022 21:07

It is true lockdowns caused a lot of harm. Something I’ve posted a fair bit about. Unfortunately Labour were even more for restrictions and lockdowns and the left generally were ok with thinking about the risk from Covid but not the damage from lockdowns. Which is a huge pity as many were vulnerable to the risks from lockdown.

I hope it never happens again but Labour have been keener to neglect those hurt by them so I’m not seeing much opposition there.

I agree.

With Labour I’m imagining there would have been more lockdowns and even more money handed out because, hey, it’s all good as the average Joe won’t be required to pay anything back, it would all be paid for by higher earners and businesses when they are clobbered with increased tax rates - happy days!

Wouldn’t take a genius to spot the problem there.

LexMitior · 13/04/2022 21:06

@DragonOverTheMoon

No it's not. It's world wide ideology from TRAs that have changed womens lives all over. Canada, US, Europe, Iran just to name a few. It's just as global as the financial crash and has real impact to vulnerable women and girls. It has been a tidle wave that engulfed lots of us and it's not just been our country. We don't exist in a vacuum.
I'm not saying it doesn't have impact. But I also know that trans policy in the UK is not just coming from nowhere. I expect politicians to have critical thinking skills and given that the policies I have mentioned above have been in place for some time, I would imagine it would be quite easy for a party in power, who has been in power for 10 years, to actually do something.

Or you can be satisfied with a Daily Mail headline, which looks to be all that can happen between now and the next election.

Given no policy change or proposal, do you think its a fair assumption that the PMs statement will lead to a change. Or will global forces prevent that happening?

Blossomtoes · 13/04/2022 21:02

I would rather read the parties ' manifestos than vote along tribal lines

The Tories have broken at least two of their manifesto promises - they’ve raised tax when they said they wouldn’t and removed the triple lock which they promised to retain. Manifestos mean nothing.

BasiliskStare · 13/04/2022 20:58

@Xenia - I think that was my point also - the Conservatives have spent a whole load of money to keep people jobs afloat. - Are they really dreadful people. The No 10 party is surely just a diversion

Well as I say I would rather read the parties ' manifestos than vote along tribal lines. & Flowers to @TeenPlusCat

DragonOverTheMoon · 13/04/2022 20:58

No it's not. It's world wide ideology from TRAs that have changed womens lives all over. Canada, US, Europe, Iran just to name a few. It's just as global as the financial crash and has real impact to vulnerable women and girls. It has been a tidle wave that engulfed lots of us and it's not just been our country. We don't exist in a vacuum.

LexMitior · 13/04/2022 20:53

@DragonOverTheMoon

Also - banging on about the gender issues - saying that it's been under a Conservative gov. is just like saying the economy crashed under labour. These things happened and are happening world wide.

Lots of countries are struggling with the TRAs and reassignment surgery for children. Just like lots of countries struggled with the banking crisis.

Not a fair comparison. Trans policy is a choice made by politicians based on their thinking.

A government policy is a positive act by politicians. The Tories own this stuff, to their prison policy, schools policy and health policies for trans. All theirs.

It takes officials and Ministers to agree, debate and put them forward. That isn't quite the same as an economic crash where the people who manage the economy are not in government. Ministers react to that, but they don't write proactive policies for their management, or they do, they certainly aren't conservatives.

DragonOverTheMoon · 13/04/2022 20:48

Also - banging on about the gender issues - saying that it's been under a Conservative gov. is just like saying the economy crashed under labour. These things happened and are happening world wide.

Lots of countries are struggling with the TRAs and reassignment surgery for children. Just like lots of countries struggled with the banking crisis.

Swipe left for the next trending thread