Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you vote Tory now…

740 replies

Joanna1988124 · 12/04/2022 21:48

You’re effectively propping up this absolute shit show of a government and have no empathy.

I’ll be honest, I’ve voted conservative before as a middle class family their (taxation) policies have suited me more than Labour. I honestly feel ashamed of this and I wish I could’ve seen that the conservatives agenda of ‘levelling up’ is BS.

Regardless of your personal situation, enough is enough now right? People are reliant on food banks, they’re choosing between heating and eating. Austerity has been a total nightmare for society causing the rich to get richer and the poor to get poorer.

OP posts:
MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 14/04/2022 11:35

@AlexaShutUp how is calling Tory voters lacking in empathy helpful? I've never voted tory before but unless there is a big change in how Labour approach the concerns of women about the destruction of their rights in the name of being trans friendly then I might.
I won't be bullied into feeling ashamed for not voting for a party that has behaved like Labour have around womens rights issues.

There's just a long long litany of offensive remarks and contempt, from David Lammy saying that gender critical feminists are "rights hoarding dinasours" to Rebecca Long-Bailey and Lisa Nandy signing a pledge to expel "transphobes" from the party if they won the leadership contest. And then you've got the appalling way Rosie Duffield has been treated.

Why are women the only group of people who are not allowed to prioritize their rights?

DownNative · 14/04/2022 11:22

@DdraigGoch

Considering Macron is feeling the heat from Le Pen this time round, I agree it's pretty doubtful France would have gone as far as they did.

The last few years under Macron suggests they wouldn't have.

bubblegumunicorn · 14/04/2022 11:20

It takes a while for people to have a social awakening a lot will after this but a lot won't they have a surprising number of working class seats in the north east after the last election when people saw the vote as a second brexit. Then those same people I know voted for them are struggling to afford food and energy at the moment because of the failing benefit system this government designed. I've always thought voting conservative is a sign of privilege and forgets about the hard workers on low- middle incomes!

lifeturnsonadime · 14/04/2022 11:03

reesewithoutaspoon

Totally agree with you.

For me it does Trump everything.

Labour, if you have any advisors reading these threads, will you listen to how women feel about this please and stop calling us bigots for having genuine concerns about women and children?

Stop condescending us by telling us we need to 'take the heat out of the debate', and consider where the heat is coming from. Hint, it's not women with reasonable concerns.

A great start would be condemning the hate, death and rape threats that Rosie Duffield has encountered for being the internal voice for women with reasonable concerns.

There is time for the Labour Party to win back our votes. They need to act though.

FOJN · 14/04/2022 11:01

Of course we can. We share them but we don’t think they don’t trump everything else.

Our fundamental difference is that you prioritise the urgent need for walls and a roof now and I think securing the foundations is more important for women's long term interests.

I have not accused people who prioritise the way you do of being stupid and short termist whilst many who agree with you are happy to characterise people who share my views as stupid, selfish and morally bankrupt. Many of your allies are happy to preach about stopping hate without a trace of irony.

reesewithoutaspoon · 14/04/2022 10:46

@Blossomtoes

but they either can't or won't acknowledge there is legitimacy to the concern s you, I and many other women share

Of course we can. We share them but we don’t think they don’t trump everything else. We’ve seen what the Tories think about the least wealthy. They showed their colours with austerity - ideological in relatively prosperous times. The next few years will be austerity on steroids if they’re re-elected.

I get that. I dislike the Tories with a passion, so they won't get my vote either. I,m either going to vote for an independent candidate who knows biology or I will spoil my ballot with a big double X. I know not voting is a cop-out. I live in a strong Labour region that has never had a tory voted in so my vote won't count anyway. But I will show them that I was prepared to get out and go to the ballot box, but they lost my vote for a reason. It's all I can do, but I won't vote to sell women down the river. I just couldn't live with that.
Blossomtoes · 14/04/2022 10:41

We don’t think they trump everything else - no idea where the extraneous don’t came from.

Blossomtoes · 14/04/2022 10:39

but they either can't or won't acknowledge there is legitimacy to the concern s you, I and many other women share

Of course we can. We share them but we don’t think they don’t trump everything else. We’ve seen what the Tories think about the least wealthy. They showed their colours with austerity - ideological in relatively prosperous times. The next few years will be austerity on steroids if they’re re-elected.

FOJN · 14/04/2022 10:22

reesewithoutaspoon

Thanks for your post, your reading of the situation is much the same as mine. It's interesting that I see, understand and agree with posters who are worried about what other Tory policies will mean for women but they either can't or won't acknowledge there is legitimacy to the concern s you, I and many other women share.

Its like having a conversation about which bricks to use to build a house. You can't have a house without walls so there's no point in pretending they're not vitally important but equally a house build without foundations will lack durable structural integrity. Legal recognition and protection of females as a sex class are the foundations. Labour are happy to discuss our brick requirements but would like to give away our foundations. The conservatives think should sort out our own bricks but will maintain the foundations.

leotardrock · 14/04/2022 10:17

So my meme about the performance of this Govt & it only being fucking Tuesday, we'll now it's fucking Thursday & they announce their plans to ship Asylum Seekers to Rwanda for processing - never to return!

I am GC, I don't think anyone with a penis should be in a female space but my god, we can't let them win another Election! I should imagine another 10 years of Tories & we won't care what we're called!

What sort of Country are we living in! 😡

SleeplessInEngland · 14/04/2022 10:06

I suspect neither Starmer nor Johnson give a shit about the 'what is a woman' issue one way or another, Johnson was just canny enough to have a prepared line on it. Anytime's Starmer's asked he always seems surprised and jumbles his words.

(Not saying that gets him off the hook, in fact it's a bit off this late in the day, but I wouldnt infer any massive ideological gap between the two men.)

reesewithoutaspoon · 14/04/2022 09:58

While Labour insists that it will 100% bring in the GRA I cannot vote for them ever, even if the rest of their policies were fantastic. Because I would be selling women and future generations down the river. Once a policy is in its incredibly hard to reverse and seen as this one majorly affects women only, it will be bloody impossible too, because men still hold most of the power and it wont affect them so they wont be in a rush to reverse it.

Without the ability to differentiate between men and women in law you get what you have now where women are referred to as cervix havers, bleeders, menstruaters.
News reports of men having babies, of men, reported as women committing violent and sexual crimes and this being recorded as female crimes. It affects everything.
When the data you have on who requires what sex-based services is useless then you cant target funding.
Women will be attacked in places that should be single-sex, because you will no longer be able to challenge male bodied people for fear that that person identifies as female.
Women will be housed in prison with intact males. 2 women just recently got pregnant in prison to a male bodied inmate in the women prison.
Women won't be able to sue for sex-based discrimination, because it affects males too , there's already been a case where a breastfeeding woman lost an industrial tribunal because 'men can breastfeed too, so it wasn't discrimination. Sounds fucking crazy, but the female penis also sounds crazy, but we are still seeing news reports of attackers using their female penis.
We currently have sex-based legislation that offers women some protection from being paid less, being sacked when pregnant, etc. But soon as the law recognises that men also suffer from these (transmen getting pregnant etc ) then they can claim there is no discrimination because its happening to men too.
We have to retain the ability to recognise women as a sex class in law or we lose all the rights we have fought for to alleviate the discrimination we face based on out ability to reproduce.

DdraigGoch · 14/04/2022 09:56

[quote DownNative]@DdraigGoch

People forget that France are able to do what they've done with EDF because energy is still nationalised there.

Most European economies cannot do what the French have done.[/quote]
Would he have even done it if he wasn't in an election year? It's going to be a massive bailout after the election.

jgw1 · 14/04/2022 09:39

@lifeturnsonadime

What this shows to me isn't so much that it's terrible that lots of people in Labour were taken in. That was the same all over. What was a shocking revelation was that they would not admit any discussion, even by their own party members, even by their own MPs. If the Tories had done that they too would be in the same position on this issue. That should just never happen, it's toxic and it suggests you could have the same problem with other issues.

Women's rights aside. This bothers me a lot. If you don't toe the party line you might be expelled and if you are not bullying will be condoned (Rosie Duffield).

This is a problem also in the Tory Party where my own excellent MP was one of those expelled for the Brexit Rebellion.

In truth I think the whole political system is a complete mess.

I don't think it is true of the Tory party currently. You have Michael Fabricant openly campaigning for the Labour party and being their most successful vote winner and he is still a Tory MP.
lifeturnsonadime · 14/04/2022 09:32

What this shows to me isn't so much that it's terrible that lots of people in Labour were taken in. That was the same all over. What was a shocking revelation was that they would not admit any discussion, even by their own party members, even by their own MPs. If the Tories had done that they too would be in the same position on this issue. That should just never happen, it's toxic and it suggests you could have the same problem with other issues.

Women's rights aside. This bothers me a lot. If you don't toe the party line you might be expelled and if you are not bullying will be condoned (Rosie Duffield).

This is a problem also in the Tory Party where my own excellent MP was one of those expelled for the Brexit Rebellion.

In truth I think the whole political system is a complete mess.

DownNative · 14/04/2022 09:31

@DdraigGoch

People forget that France are able to do what they've done with EDF because energy is still nationalised there.

Most European economies cannot do what the French have done.

jgw1 · 14/04/2022 09:29

*Wrong as what happens to the four Central European economies WILL have a serious impact on the biggest European economies.

Ukraine, bread basket of Europe, has already affected them with more coming.

Even so, you blatantly ignored a comparison between the UK and Germany:

"It’s not that the UK is necessarily the miser of Europe. There are more generous countries – yes, there are few that are as generous as what has been done in France – but then you look at places like Germany and we look comparatively better off than many German households."

  • Josie Dent, managing economist at the Centre for Economics and Business Research.

That puts Germany into perspective too.*

Is one of Germany's biggest electricity companies owned by the French government?

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/04/2022 09:29

@knowinglesseveryday

The notion that the Tories stand for woman's right is utterly farcical.
Look, people are not stupid. They know Johnson is an opportunist who knows a vote winner when he sees one. They also know politicians lie (nothing unique to see here). They are very often remainers, who were ardently anti-Brexit and probably couldn't have contemplated voting Tory as recently as a year ago. It would have taken something pretty serious to make those people grit their teeth and vote Tory.

But if you have the slightest degree of insight into the slow march of assault on women's rights, this is too important to ignore. At present it's a choice between hoping Boris holds the line or voting for Labour, in which case you WILL get the GRA reform, which is tantamount to a permanent signing away of women's rights. And once they are gone, they're never coming back.

It's a no-brainer. Turkeys voting for Christmas only just begins to cover it.

The Tories haven't won my vote. The supposed 'left' (who haven't been the left in three generations) have lost it, and until they start showing respect for the well-being and safeguarding of half the population, they are never getting it back.

DownNative · 14/04/2022 09:25

[quote Blossomtoes]The only comparisons pertinent are major European economies. It’s pointless comparing apples and pears. Here are details of Denmark’s strategy for supporting its citizens.

www.thelocal.dk/20220408/danish-taxpayers-to-receive-19-9-billion-kroner-in-rebates/[/quote]
Wrong as what happens to the four Central European economies WILL have a serious impact on the biggest European economies.

Ukraine, bread basket of Europe, has already affected them with more coming.

Even so, you blatantly ignored a comparison between the UK and Germany:

"It’s not that the UK is necessarily the miser of Europe. There are more generous countries – yes, there are few that are as generous as what has been done in France – but then you look at places like Germany and we look comparatively better off than many German households."

  • Josie Dent, managing economist at the Centre for Economics and Business Research.

That puts Germany into perspective too.

SleeplessInEngland · 14/04/2022 09:21

"Labour would be just as shit as the tories. Vote tory!"

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/04/2022 09:19

[quote toconclude]@FrankLeeSpeaking

Yup. And the number of people here falling for it is indicative of the toxic levels of transphobia on MN[/quote]
Advocating for women's rights, for fair competition in sport ('exclusion' is a lie, trans people are still eligible to compete just not entirely on the terms they dictate) and objecting to being referred to as a 'bleeder', are not transphobia.

Transphobic content is not allowed on this site. Those posts are likely be deleted before they've had three readers.

HTH

FOJN · 14/04/2022 09:14

I don't think we need to worry about Crispin Blunt after his comments this week.

mrshoho · 14/04/2022 09:04

@Wintersonata

Why no one said, males in women's prisons, that's crazy, stop right now, I don;t know

Mangy because those who are in favour of males in women’s prisons have a powerful network of supporters who makes the lives of those opposing it absolute hell.

And wrongly accused of not upholding the Equality Act. Stonewall misinterpreted and everyone was taken in or too scared to question for fear of being accused of bigotry.
DdraigGoch · 14/04/2022 09:03

I am trying to accomplish women's rights. Penny Mordaunt is a full on TRA, she hasn't and wont change on this. And she is being tipped as a possible party leader.shock I am opposing Crispin Blunt, Jamie Wallis (and his supporters) and I am utterly disgusted by that mendacious cunt PM Johnson, pretending he is on the side of women. He's not.

There's no chance of Mordaunt becoming the next party leader. No chance at all. The front runners (now that Sunak's brand is tarnished) are Liz Truss and Sajid Javid. Both of whom have been clear that biology matters.

Mordaunt and Blunt are just a couple of MPs. All I've heard about Wallis is that he's got dysphoria, I've not seen any suggestion from him (as he still wishes to be known) that he's up for invading women's spaces or cheating at sport (if I've missed anything, please enlighten me).

TRAs are a tiny minority on the Conservative benches, just like Rosie Duffield is in a minority of one on the opposition benches (yes, some others have privately sent their support but none are prepared to go public).

Wintersonata · 14/04/2022 08:52

Why no one said, males in women's prisons, that's crazy, stop right now, I don;t know

Mangy because those who are in favour of males in women’s prisons have a powerful network of supporters who makes the lives of those opposing it absolute hell.