Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope this very sad case stops them giving out abortion medication without scanning

306 replies

Greenmascara · 12/04/2022 18:05

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10711221/Baby-died-doctors-gave-30-week-pregnant-mother-abortion-pill-thinking-12-weeks.html

Extremely sad for mother and baby, mother is likely completely traumatised by this.

This isn't an anti abortion thread. Whilst never desirable, abortion needs to remain a safe, legal, NHS funded option so women aren't forced into buying illeagal/ dangerous pills online or having dangerous/ unsanitary abortions from backsttreet "doctors."

But I have been really, really concerned how at the start of covid, any safeguarding/ care in abortion went out the window. Pills posted out with no safeguarding concerns, and no scans to confirm pregnancy is within the legal limit.

Am I right in saying tragic, traumatic cases like this happen when you don't scan to check the gestation of pregnancy before handing out this medication ?

OP posts:
jampim · 12/04/2022 20:56

@CavernousScream

I can’t see how this has anything to do with telemedicine, when the entire incident happened in a hospital. She was terminating for medical reasons, she may have been eligible for abortion even if they’d known she was 30 weeks. There were obvious failings in care at the hospital, but that is not an argument against telemedicine which reduces the amount of people needing care in a hospital.
I agree.
whumpthereitis · 12/04/2022 20:55

Well we can never completely eliminate the risk of abusers getting hold of these pills, pills by post makes it a lot easier.

So make women who need this service jump through hoops/prevent them from accessing it legally at all, to prevent men from…getting hold of something they can get hold of with a quick google and a few clicks of a mouse.

What of the women that will, in absence of telemedical abortion being an option, turn to those sites that sell abortion pills? Who will take these pills with exactly zero oversight and safeguarding (and isn’t safeguarding your motivator?). I guess it’s fuck them too, along with the majority of women this already helps.

Infallible reasoning.

Booboobagins · 12/04/2022 20:50

Really sad case, can't quite ever get my head around why women don't know they're pregnant - it's a big mistake thinking you're 12 weeks when your actually a further 18 weeks along.

During a crisis these things happen though - it's like thinking a woman going into labour on a sinking ship or a building on fire is going to have a standard delivery, she isn't.

This issue is no different to sending covid infected OAPs to nursing homes to infect staff and other vulnerable people.

I'm afraid loads of decisions like this were taken early on in the pandemic and when hospitals became over ran. Have to admit I'm not sure why the nhs is funding abortions unless we're talking a vulnerable woman.

Of course these events are nothing like sending contracts for ABC supplies to your mates and wasting billions on a track and trace system that didn't work. Who knows how many people died because people in government made decisions like this and withheld PPE from nhs employees too.

Greenmascara · 12/04/2022 20:42

@HardyBuckette

To use the example you used - abortion pills are available to purchase online, without any safeguarding. Without any oversight. If someone wanted to sneakily obtain medication to slip to their wife/girlfriend, they easily could without going through the correct channels.

Yeah, the reality is that now this medication exists, abusers can get hold of it and unconsensually administer it to a woman. The NHS not offering telemedical abortion won't prevent that. There isn't an option available to us that will.

Well we can never completely eliminate the risk of abusers getting hold of these pills, pills by post makes it a lot easier.
OP posts:
1forAll74 · 12/04/2022 20:20

I would imagine, that this woman would desperately want an abortion for her own reasons, whatever they were, as at 30 weeks, she surely would have known how far into the pregnancy she was, as in her size and body shape and all other signs of a late on pregnancy.. And normally wouldn't risk taking any medication at all, unless she was so very desperate not to birth a baby. A truly awful situation to read about.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 12/04/2022 20:17

So in the first Daily Mail article you shared, it isn’t at all clear that the telemedical abortion service had anything to do with it. It’s unclear but it reads to me like she had the medicine in hospital, and received negligent care.

Similarly, with the second Daily Mail link, there’s no confirmation that the telemedical abortion service was involved there either. It simply says that a woman took the abortion pills at home at 28 weeks pregnant, four weeks past the legal limit, and the police are investigating. The DM has added all that stuff about the rules around abortion pills being relaxed to suggest that the two are linked - because DM readers are often anti-abortion. But the woman could have obtained the pills illegally online. She could have been forced to take them by an abusive man who sourced them illegally online. We just don’t know.

HardyBuckette · 12/04/2022 20:15

To use the example you used - abortion pills are available to purchase online, without any safeguarding. Without any oversight. If someone wanted to sneakily obtain medication to slip to their wife/girlfriend, they easily could without going through the correct channels.

Yeah, the reality is that now this medication exists, abusers can get hold of it and unconsensually administer it to a woman. The NHS not offering telemedical abortion won't prevent that. There isn't an option available to us that will.

ButtockUp · 12/04/2022 20:11

It's not clear , from the article, what situation the woman was in.

It's really difficult to make assumptions but , ideally, this shouldn't have happened.

Many women, particularly young women, find it hard to approach their GP and it would be great if there was a free-for-all womens clinic that was easily available for every woman.

The reality is that such clinics are only available in bigger towns and cities and, only then, need to be searched... they're often tucked away in quiet and out of the way areas.

Rural communities would not be providing these services.

Really sad but somewhat inevitable.

Namechangehobby · 12/04/2022 20:10

As someone who accessed the pills by collection via the nhs in lockdown, I honestly can say I was grateful and it wasn’t a slap dash agreement with the nurses. It involved lengthy phone calls , offers of in-hospital treatment if necessary. Had I not been 100% confidently certain that I was in early pregnancy they wouldn’t have given me the pills. I was supported so, so well by the team , they regularly checked up on me and afterwards ensured I was safe, and had further follow up for my thoughts on the procedure at home.

This story is , devastating, but indeed rare.

SW1amp · 12/04/2022 20:07

And if you’re going to try and discredit Rape Crisis, at least get the basic facts right

It’s the Edinburgh rape crisis centre (stand alone Centre in erm Edinburgh) which appointed a trans woman as CEO

It’s Rape Crisis, national organisation working at grass roots and policy level which co-signed the letter
But sure, you know more than them on how best to help Rape victims, definitely

whumpthereitis · 12/04/2022 20:06

[quote Greenmascara]@whumpthereitis the experts used to think the world was flat Hmm[/quote]
Yes, because the bar then was exactly the same as it is now. Totally comparable.

We work on the basis of information we have now. Not information that may or may not become available in a future we are incapable of looking into. So yes, funnily enough the educated opinions of experts in the actual field, who have collected a wealth actual evidence in support of said opinions, count for far more than the opinions of a poster on mumsnet who thinks they’re wrong.

Luredbyapomegranate · 12/04/2022 20:06

In terms of safety and accessibility to abortion, it cuts both ways. If a woman has a family or partner who don’t want her to access a termination, a telephone conversation and home procedure is going to be a lot easier for her to access.

So I think women have to be given the choice - scans should be available if people want them, but certainly not mandatory.

It would be extremely rare to mistake an early pregnancy for a 30 week pregnancy, and women in general shouldn’t have open access to abortion limited because of rare cases like this.

I understand that you aren’t entirely anti abortion OP, but I do get the impression you’d like it restricted, which I think is influencing your take on this case, alongside what I’m sure is a genuine concern for women’s well being.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 12/04/2022 20:05

Interesting that both those stories were reported by the Daily Mail

VanGoghsDog · 12/04/2022 20:05

no scans to confirm pregnancy is within the legal limit.

Did that usually happen then? I had a termination thirty three years ago. I didn't have a scan.

Cultureclub · 12/04/2022 20:02

Surely the viability of the foetus at 30 weeks is the real tragedy here not simply the fact that she wanted an abortion and that was what she got.

SW1amp · 12/04/2022 20:02

Of course you can disagree with them, but to be honest, it makes you look pretty bloody stupid when you do

All opinions are not created equal…

In the blue corner, robust scientific evidence, case studies, surveys from women who have used the service, evidence from organisations working with DV victims, immigrants, low income women, rural women, women with MH problems - all in total agreement that the service should continue and lobbying hard to allow it to

In the red corner “oooh I read something in the daily Mail and me no likey cos some scenarios I just made up”

You can see how it looks, right..?

DogsAndGin · 12/04/2022 20:00

It’s negligent. Doesn’t matter how rare it is. Two babies have been illegally and horrifically killed

Masterblasterjammin · 12/04/2022 19:59

I posted this on another thread, but it seems equally as valid here.

Telemedicine abortions are proven to be safe and effective, and the overwhelming majority of women who accessed the service preferred it. There is still discussion with a healthcare professional, and should that professional feel that the woman needs closer monitoring and supervision in person, then that is still the case. But there is still monitoring and supervision.

What it removes is the decades old requirement for a woman to require the permission of two doctors to have an abortion. And the decades old requirement for abortions to take place on licensed premises. These requirements were put into place to redress the problem of ‘backstreet abortions’, which was one of the largest causes of mortality in females of child bearing age. Obviously developments in medicine have rendered these requirements largely redundant.

Telemedicine abortions have also been proven to facilitate earlier abortions, which are proven to be safer for women. Telemedicine abortions have made it easier for women who were previously buying abortion pills illegally online, perhaps due to an inability to visit their doctor due to fear of domestic violence from their partner, to access safe and regulated abortions from home. These women then have access to counselling and safeguarding services, making it even safer for women.

Even without the obvious safety benefits, telemedicine abortions are incredibly cost effective, and are cheaper than the traditional model.

RCOG, Marie Stopes, and BPAS are all calling for telemedicine provision to continue.

To use the example you used - abortion pills are available to purchase online, without any safeguarding. Without any oversight. If someone wanted to sneakily obtain medication to slip to their wife/girlfriend, they easily could without going through the correct channels. In fact, by making telemedicine abortion permissible, legal, accessible, regulated, and safe, you remove the need for these websites to exist in the first place.

Also - the story that you’re posting about, however sad, wasn’t a telemedicine abortion.

FairyCakeWings · 12/04/2022 19:59

The idea that we're going to be able to suddenly fix the system so all women can get access to early scans, in the middle of a pandemic and a colossal NHS staffing crisis, and when there were problems even pre covid is completely and totally fanciful. It's not going to happen.

I can’t argue with that really because you’re right that it’s never going to happen, but I can’t comfortably agree that I’m ok with women being allowed to have abortions at home with nothing but a phone call to support them or check that it’s safe. I can see what everyone’s saying, but it seems so wrong.

Greenmascara · 12/04/2022 19:59

@whumpthereitis the experts used to think the world was flat Hmm

OP posts:
Franklyfrost · 12/04/2022 19:58

You have to assume most people are relatively sane and intelligent and provide adequate services for those who aren’t. The vast majority of people wouldn’t take abortion causing medication at 30 weeks.

Greenmascara · 12/04/2022 19:57

@SW1amp

So *@Greenmascara* what is your experience/involvement with this that makes you more qualified than pretty much every women’s organisation on this topic?

Because when everyone actually working on the frontline is in unified agreement on this, you surely have to question if you’re just wrong..?

Unfortunately @SW1amp, I can disagree with several other decisions the charities supporting pills by post have made.

I disagree with Rape Crisis r.e. pills by post, I also disagree with them appointing a transwoman ceo, ( and I say that as a rape survivor).

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/protests-over-trans-woman-heading-rape-crisis-centre-wp7hwbv09

It's okay to disagree with the organisations backing this on various points.

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 12/04/2022 19:57

@LuluBlakey1

I think the NHS has brought about its own demise with its ridiculously over-drawn response to Covid- after years of underfunding and the Tories will be whooping with delight and making plans to sell it off to American insurance.
You do realise the ‘guidelines’ come from the government and the NHS has to implement them?
NotthesameNotok · 12/04/2022 19:56

@whumpthereitis

“And the other positives are it’s much cheaper for the nhs …….no in person appt…….no scan ….and people are just lapping it up and saying it’s great when it’s just removing care not making things better for women”

Yes, you’re right. All the evidence that supports it being better for women is just wrong. The women themselves who personally benefited from it are wrong too. The RCOG? Wrong. FSRH? Wrong. Rape crisis? Wrong. Hmm

It’s only those criticizing the service, who absolutely have no agenda whatsoever, that are right. Of course.

Interesting first post from a brand new OP that is totally pro choice, by the way.

I have no agenda

I am totally pro choice but it has to be safe

whumpthereitis · 12/04/2022 19:53

@SW1amp

So *@Greenmascara* what is your experience/involvement with this that makes you more qualified than pretty much every women’s organisation on this topic?

Because when everyone actually working on the frontline is in unified agreement on this, you surely have to question if you’re just wrong..?

This thread.
To hope this very sad case stops them giving out abortion medication without scanning