Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope this very sad case stops them giving out abortion medication without scanning

306 replies

Greenmascara · 12/04/2022 18:05

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10711221/Baby-died-doctors-gave-30-week-pregnant-mother-abortion-pill-thinking-12-weeks.html

Extremely sad for mother and baby, mother is likely completely traumatised by this.

This isn't an anti abortion thread. Whilst never desirable, abortion needs to remain a safe, legal, NHS funded option so women aren't forced into buying illeagal/ dangerous pills online or having dangerous/ unsanitary abortions from backsttreet "doctors."

But I have been really, really concerned how at the start of covid, any safeguarding/ care in abortion went out the window. Pills posted out with no safeguarding concerns, and no scans to confirm pregnancy is within the legal limit.

Am I right in saying tragic, traumatic cases like this happen when you don't scan to check the gestation of pregnancy before handing out this medication ?

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 12/04/2022 21:56

I'm not sure why people are so certain that this is such a rare case. I understand that BPAS have been putting a lot of pressure on the media to not report these cases, which have been becoming increasingly common. So this could be why people are so ignorant of the actual situation.

Because the evidence we have demonstrates that it is. A case such as this one is not a common occurrence.‘You understand’… what? Pro life conspiracy theories? Because a quick google on this one took me straight to Christian Concern. They’ve made an allegation, but that in itself is meaningless. What matters is what evidence they have to prove it, and the evidence apparently is a statement from a pro lifer. Said pro lifer happens to be Kevin Duffy, who is politically active in opposing abortion.

You’ve posted raw data. The same raw data that was bought up in the thread about telemedical abortion not too long ago. Raw data tells part of a story, not the whole story. That is why studies need to be done to analyse said data, and why said studies need to undergo the stringent peer review process before they’re published in medical journals. Studies like the one recently in fact, the largest and most comprehensive one ever one conducted on the subject of telemedical abortion, the one that supported the continuation of the service.

Greenmascara · 12/04/2022 21:54

@Glamora

But now pills by post exist, Brian can get his girlfriend Louise, ( whom he also abuses), to ring BPAS and request pills by post for herself.

I think I read this on your last attempt to stop women accessing abortions

I was pregnant by my stepfather at 12 years old. He couldn't access abortion pills so made me drink a bottle of sherry and gave me an abortion with some home made devices. Sadly this isn't an uncommon story. I have spoken to many like me who had abortions forced on them, some of those women are infertile and have health conditions due to it. It's obviously not a great place to be even to have pills forced on you, but given the alternative I would much rather have had them.

So if Brian is intent on aborting Lindas baby, he's going to do it - he doesnt need to get pills over the phone.

Compelling evidence from 52,142 women shows no-test telemedicine abortion is safe, effective and improves care.

So 2 very sad cases against over fifty thousand safe and effective abortions - I still think that this is the right way

I don't want women not to be able to access abortion.

I think abortion should be NHS funded.
I think all U.K women should be able to self-refer for NHS abortion care without any need for a GP referral, ( in the same way you can self-refer for IAPT or STI services).
I don't think the parents of under16's should be informed/ need to consent for their daughter to have an abortion.
I don't think the biological father should need to be informed/ consent.
I think, if necessary, a woman should be able to request a notification of the abortion is not sent to her GP to preserve confidentiality.
I think protestors should be banned from outside clinics.

I'm really not quite sure with how any of that conflicts with wanting to "restrict vulnerable women's access to abortion."

I can hold all those opinions and still think the government favour the current telemedicine / no scan option cos it's significantly cheaper, and that the current system puts vulnerable women at serious risk of abuse, as well as allowing tragic cases like these to happen.

I don't really understand how anything I've said makes it clear I want to restrict access to abortion, rather than ensure the service is adequately funded to prevent the abuse of women and girls.

OP posts:
SW1amp · 12/04/2022 21:52

Well we can never completely eliminate the risk of abusers getting hold of these pills, pills by post makes it a lot easier.

Does it though? In real life, not just in your vivid imagination..?

And if it does, why are DV charities such as Women’s Aid and Refuge not concerned?
Because they are vocal supporters of pills by post which would suggest that her again, you’re making up weird scenarios that don’t exist to justify your very weak argument

Ormally · 12/04/2022 21:49

"The reality is that such clinics are only available in bigger towns and cities and, only then, need to be searched... they're often tucked away in quiet and out of the way areas.

Rural communities would not be providing these services."

To add to this, even the clinics in the larger towns and cities are mostly not held every day so let's say that twice a week could be a generous estimate.

If someone is over a certain number of weeks, beyond what will be acceptable for an abortion by pills, then the default is for a surgical abortion, an operation. If the pill version does not work as it should then this is also where you must end up. This does require a GP (2 GP)/ more specialist route and presumably it is a major undertaking on both the patient and the medical side. The GP element is still very restricted in most areas now.

During the pandemic, you have a pile of factors that meant that the hospital and GP route became much more inaccessible - if you couldn't get cancer treatment or theatre space for other operations, or a GP appointment where you might have been examined while the clock was ticking, then what chance do you have for abortion services? Could you get transport at times when the rule was to 'stay at home?' and rely on being fine to use it to get back too, when you may then be feeling unwell or distressed? Or get childcare for your other child/ren, who would not be permitted to come with you? Or have a reason to be out alone for the afternoon if you were being controlled by someone you lived with and who was there 24/7? I think that you would certainly endanger people's health one way or another if you made them play dice with a short time period in which to access a series of medical appointments or go for a major op further and further into a pregnancy when that system is not reliable.

MangyInseam · 12/04/2022 21:49

This issue has been politicized in a way that means best care practices are being neglected with the excuse that it's better for women. Yes, it goes as expected for many, but that does not make it ok to forgo basic checks. You don't necessarily even need a scan, it's possible to get a general sense of the stage of pregnancy from a manual exam as well.

figtrees · 12/04/2022 21:47

This type of thread only attracts prolifers or people who have strong feelings about abortion, they then masquerade as caring about women but what they really want is to use very unusual cases to cause panic and sway perception.

Jimjamjong · 12/04/2022 21:40

This was in 2016 so way before the pandemic.

Jimjamjong · 12/04/2022 21:40

I gave birth at York hospital, I was 1 week over term, having contractions every few minutes, they tried to get me to go back home but I was in too much pain. My baby was born 20 minutes later. She was nearly born in the corridor while the midwife was shouting "don't push, don't push".
It was not the best experience, they are lacking resources and the care is minimal.

Lemonandlime123 · 12/04/2022 21:38

That's just a completely irrelevant comparison, these two issues are in no way comparable.

Hopspinach · 12/04/2022 21:36

I'm not sure why people are so certain that this is such a rare case. I understand that BPAS have been putting a lot of pressure on the media to not report these cases, which have been becoming increasingly common. So this could be why people are so ignorant of the actual situation.

Kevin Duffy, an independent health consultant and former director at Marie Stopes presented his findings gathered from a number of freedom of information requests on complications resulting from abortion pills taken at home.

Neither the Department of Health and Social Care or abortion providers have successfully captured all the data about events that have taken place after abortion pills have been posted. In the case of the DHSC, data collected on the safety of the policy is based solely on information submitted from HSA4 forms.

Between April and June 2020, out of 23,061 medical abortions, the DHSC recorded just one complication.

So after making freedom of information inquiries to the CQC and the NHS, it became evident that complications were much more common. The foi requests found that 6 hospitals had reported 69 complications following the taking of abortion pills – this is five times higher than the DHSC states!

The requests also found that an average of 36 calls per month were made to 999 emergency services following the taking of abortion pills, with an average of 20 ambulance responses per month.

Also, not that abortion providers do not consider surgical interventions for incomplete abortions a ‘complication’.

Between April and June 2020, 208 women were treated surgically in hospital for the removal of retained products of conception. But by their definition, this isn't a complication.

So no, complications are not rare.

unim · 12/04/2022 21:35

This is terrible, but clearly states that the protocol does require a scan and that either protocol wasn't followed or something went wrong with the scan.

The fact that it has made the news shows how rare and noteworthy something like this is - as it should be.

How terrible for the poor patient.

TyrannosaurusRegina · 12/04/2022 21:33

@NorthSouthcatlady

But she wanted an abortion and she got an abortion? What is tragic about that? The hospital should have been more rigours with their checks
Tragic for the baby. Surely there would have have a more humane way of aborting a 30 week old fetus that this? I would assume that due to gestational age of the fetus, a 30 week old viable baby/fetus would feel pain and distress at this method of abortion therefore I would assume there would have been a different method used had they known how far along the pregnancy was.
Glamora · 12/04/2022 21:27

@Lemonandlime123

Meanwhile a 30 week old foetus, with a 90% chance of survival, has been killed. Surely it is medical negligence and in the interest of the public that this isn't allowed to happen again? 🤷‍♀️
Yes - its hideous and horrific, but one (possibly 2) in over 52 thousand.

In 2019, there were 25,945 seriously injured casualties in reported road traffic accidents so maybe we should ban roads?

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/922717/reported-road-casualties-annual-report-2019.pdf

Hopspinach · 12/04/2022 21:27

Poor, poor baby :(

whumpthereitis · 12/04/2022 21:22

*a service the woman in the article posted wasn’t even using, at that.

whumpthereitis · 12/04/2022 21:22

@Lemonandlime123

Meanwhile a 30 week old foetus, with a 90% chance of survival, has been killed. Surely it is medical negligence and in the interest of the public that this isn't allowed to happen again? 🤷‍♀️
Which is why there’s an inquest happening.

Is this, an incredibly rare case, justification for denying thousands of women access to a service that is beneficial to them? No.

Lemonandlime123 · 12/04/2022 21:19

Meant to quote 'who do you want arrested' above.

PumpkinPie2016 · 12/04/2022 21:18

It is undoubtedly a tragic case. Having read the article though, it isn't clear (to me) that she had obtained the pills by telemedicine/post?
I read it as she had gone to hospital to have a termination and was given the pills there. Went into labour and delivered a live but obviously very poorly baby. Tragically, despite the efforts of medical staff, the baby died as a result Sad

I must say, I find it surprising that she thought she was only 12 weeks? I have only had one pregnancy but there is a massive difference between 12 and 30 weeks. Even if she didn't have a big bump, surely the movement at that stage would be a give away.

I think the issue here was caused by the chronic understaffing in the department. Even without a scan, a simple abdominal examination would have revealed that the pregnancy was beyond 12 weeks.

Lemonandlime123 · 12/04/2022 21:14

Meanwhile a 30 week old foetus, with a 90% chance of survival, has been killed. Surely it is medical negligence and in the interest of the public that this isn't allowed to happen again? 🤷‍♀️

codeVeronica · 12/04/2022 21:09

Have to admit I'm not sure why the nhs is funding abortions unless we're talking a vulnerable woman.

You don't understand why the NHS is funding a medical procedure?

Arianya · 12/04/2022 21:08

How many women get to 30 weeks with no pregnancy symptoms, no movement and no bump?
That’s why I think it’s v unlikely she didn’t know she had an advanced pregnancy. The bigger problem here is that it’s possible for a woman to decide to have an illegal abortion and the hospital will facilitate it without checking it’s within the legal limit. In other words the legal limit isn’t being enforced.

BadNomad · 12/04/2022 21:02

Eh the article you posted has nothing to do with your argument. The woman knew she was more than 10-weeks pregnant, hence why she was having her abortion in hospital. It was the hospitals failure to scan her that caused this. Nothing to do with women being able to access abortion meds at home.

whumpthereitis · 12/04/2022 21:00

Have to admit I'm not sure why the nhs is funding abortions unless we're talking a vulnerable woman.

Because it’s cheaper to fund abortion care than it is to fund pregnancy care. It’s cheaper to fund abortion care than it is to treat women who will be severely, if not fatally, injured as a result of accessing abortions they can’t otherwise afford. It’s cheaper than the state having to pay out to support a sudden surge in unwanted, abused and/or abandoned children.

The medical and social costs of providing safe abortion are far cheaper than the alternatives.

Glamora · 12/04/2022 20:58

But now pills by post exist, Brian can get his girlfriend Louise, ( whom he also abuses), to ring BPAS and request pills by post for herself.

I think I read this on your last attempt to stop women accessing abortions

I was pregnant by my stepfather at 12 years old. He couldn't access abortion pills so made me drink a bottle of sherry and gave me an abortion with some home made devices. Sadly this isn't an uncommon story. I have spoken to many like me who had abortions forced on them, some of those women are infertile and have health conditions due to it. It's obviously not a great place to be even to have pills forced on you, but given the alternative I would much rather have had them.

So if Brian is intent on aborting Lindas baby, he's going to do it - he doesnt need to get pills over the phone.

Compelling evidence from 52,142 women shows no-test telemedicine abortion is safe, effective and improves care.

So 2 very sad cases against over fifty thousand safe and effective abortions - I still think that this is the right way

jampim · 12/04/2022 20:58

@chisanunian

Oh dear. Yet another attempt to erode women's rights and autonomy over their own bodies.

Having the option to take this medication without examination is not ideal, but it is the best the NHS can manage at the moment.

Exactly.