Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope this very sad case stops them giving out abortion medication without scanning

306 replies

Greenmascara · 12/04/2022 18:05

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10711221/Baby-died-doctors-gave-30-week-pregnant-mother-abortion-pill-thinking-12-weeks.html

Extremely sad for mother and baby, mother is likely completely traumatised by this.

This isn't an anti abortion thread. Whilst never desirable, abortion needs to remain a safe, legal, NHS funded option so women aren't forced into buying illeagal/ dangerous pills online or having dangerous/ unsanitary abortions from backsttreet "doctors."

But I have been really, really concerned how at the start of covid, any safeguarding/ care in abortion went out the window. Pills posted out with no safeguarding concerns, and no scans to confirm pregnancy is within the legal limit.

Am I right in saying tragic, traumatic cases like this happen when you don't scan to check the gestation of pregnancy before handing out this medication ?

OP posts:
bibibug · 14/04/2022 21:03

NC for this.

I went through this. They didn't scan me.

I ended up losing 4 litres of blood and nearly dead, apparently the periods I thought I was having was in fact bleeding from a sub chronic hematoma. (Blood clot attached to placenta)

Baby was 16 weeks and they said he was absolutely fine.

5 weeks later I gave birth to a 21 week old baby that was severely deformed and I passed away in theatre for 6 minutes.
The misoprostal can cause deformities.

They would have picked this up at the anomaly scan scheduled the day after he was born and it would have ended in termination anyway.

It's so sad Sad

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 21:00

Exactly @onreee. I had a 12 week scan recently, the sonographer said to me she wasn't going to turn the viewing screen on until she had found the heartbeatt/ baby was well. Presumably in the case of a termination scan, they wouldn't turn this on at all, ( unless the patient requested it).

There's a difference between thinking the pregnancy needs to b dated via ultrasound before medication is given out, and the women should be forced to view images she doesn't want to.

OP posts:
onreee · 14/04/2022 21:00

@Wannakisstheteacher

Because you are making it sound like she lost a much longed for child. She wanted an abortion. She took the tablets and the foetus died - normally that happens pre birth, but not actually always - but you are trying to make out that the resulting dead baby would have been a shock.

They named the baby, so I think it's fair to say this isn't the outcome the parents wanted.

Wannakisstheteacher · 14/04/2022 20:57

Because you are making it sound like she lost a much longed for child. She wanted an abortion. She took the tablets and the foetus died - normally that happens pre birth, but not actually always - but you are trying to make out that the resulting dead baby would have been a shock.

onreee · 14/04/2022 20:52

@Stompythedinosaur

No, women should not be forced to have a scan in order to exercise their right of body autonomy.
A scan is used to date the pregnancy and prescribe the right treatment for an abortion.

I went to a consultation but didn't go through with an abortion for other reasons. The monitor is absolutely not shown to you. Yes, fpr your own sake, your HCP needs to know the gestation.

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 20:49

Because @Wannakisstheteacher, it was born and lived for four days, (unsurprisingly, as 90% of babies born at this gestation survive), and I'm not sure what else I can refer to it as ? I cannot refer to it as a foetus, as it lived for four days independently. Genuinely, what should I refer to it as ? And I am normally the first to agree that referring to embryos/ foetus as "babies," in the context of termination is rude and hurtful.

As it stands, I believe the women is telling the truth.

But, even if she wasn't, how is giving birth alone in a hospital toilet, watching hospital staff rush in and attempt resuscitation and watching the baby live for four days considered to be the best, least trauma inducing outcome for the mother ?

OP posts:
Wannakisstheteacher · 14/04/2022 20:41

Why are you calling it “her baby”, she didn’t want a baby, she wanted an abortion. To me, it seems likely that she wanted the abortion in hospital because she knows she was over 12 weeks and the risk to her health.

The chances of getting to 30 weeks without knowing are incredibly small.

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 20:37

@Wannakisstheteacher

I don’t really believe she didn’t know she was 30 weeks. But at the end of the day she wanted an abortion and she had one.
I would believe that.

If she wanted to hide a 30 week abortion, ( which is illegal), she would have said she was 7/8/9 weeks and been given the pills to take at home.

The fact she said she was 12 weeks, ( knowing it would take place in a hospital setting and be unable to cover it up), suggests she very much did think it was 12 weeks. This sounds like a very traumatic experience for the woman and she was failed by a negligent termination provider. Consenting to a 12 week termination does not mean she would have consented to a 30 week labour in a hospital toilet, with her baby being resuscitated in front of her and spending four days in NICU.

And many women struggle to date a pregnancy. Some have irregular periods, on/off bleeding, ( those who got pregnant using hormonal contraception might not have had regular periods for years). Not everyone experiences sickness, symptoms etc and if this was a first pregnancy movements could have been confused for indigestion etc . This is why a scan to date a pregnancy accurately pre termination is vital .

OP posts:
Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 20:31

Furthermore, @SW1amp, a 12 week foetus measures approx. 5.7 cm, and a 30 week foetus measures approx. 38 cm; so I think we can be pretty sure a scan wasn't carried out in this particular case, as that's well, quite a big difference for a sonographer to miss.

OP posts:
Wannakisstheteacher · 14/04/2022 20:31

I don’t really believe she didn’t know she was 30 weeks. But at the end of the day she wanted an abortion and she had one.

Mummyme87 · 14/04/2022 20:22

I booked a TOP during covid, I called at 5weeks pregnant, but they wanted to scan me first, not sure what the criteria was, I had two prev children, x1 prev CS, bled 1litre and 2.5L with babies requiring blood. Ended up with a ruptured ectopic a week before appt. not sure what would have happened had I not been put in for a scan

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 20:15

Erm @SW1amp, the link is very clear that a scan may not have been given. Highly unlikely it was, given that even a non medical person could tell the difference between a 12 week and 30 week pregnancy on a scan.

OP posts:
Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 20:13

@EmeraldShamrock1

The poor woman must have had a horrendous time.
Exactly. It must have been horrendous for her and highlights why the government shouldn't be cutting back on safeguards and doing away with basic necessities such as scans in this situation.
OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 14/04/2022 20:01

The poor woman must have had a horrendous time.

SW1amp · 14/04/2022 20:00

@Greenmascara

And I find the forced birther insults particularly bizarre. The woman was forced to undergo a 30 week stillbirth in a hospital toilet as pre abortion scans weren't thought to be essential. A scan would have completely avoided this forced stillbirth experience.
The actual link you posted says the scan may have been done erroneously

So that’s some bold fucking statement from you to say ‘a scan would have completely avoided this’

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 19:56

And I find the forced birther insults particularly bizarre. The woman was forced to undergo a 30 week stillbirth in a hospital toilet as pre abortion scans weren't thought to be essential. A scan would have completely avoided this forced stillbirth experience.

OP posts:
MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 14/04/2022 15:32

@Hopspinach

Interesting that the majority of voters agree with you, but the comments are dominated by people attacking any skepticts as being "forced-birthers" and anti-woman.

Clearly the subject has become so politicised and partisan it's impossible to have a nuanced and reasonable discussion around it. Plenty of people agree with you, OP. But people are scared to voice their opinion because they see how they will be attacked. This makes the debate more and more one-sided and means we increasingly only hear one opinion. It's basically another, more insidious form of cancel culture.

I suspect the majority of posters agrees with the OP as her opening post was based on a false premise - ie that the tragic incident reported was a result of telemedicine - which it was not

< OP’s assertion: Pills posted out with no safeguarding concerns, and no scans to confirm pregnancy is within the legal limit

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 14/04/2022 14:47

@SW1amp

The problem with your hypothetical arguments is that none NONE of the charities and organisations dealing with the people who would be victims in these cases agree with you.

Take a look at the list of charities that signed the letter to government to maintain the pills by post services
It’s Womens Aid, Refuge, countless medical Royal colleges, Rape crisis centres

They all deal with the actual reality of victims of coercion and abuse and all the other what-abouteries that you listed

And if they all think pills by post are a good idea, I’m more inclined to agree with them than someone who can only find a couple of Daily Mail articles to back up their case…

Yes, yes & yes
IDontHaveAnOutingHobby · 14/04/2022 00:15

I think it is symptomatic of a dysfunctional hospital
Sadly it is the hospital which has probably killed my DH due to incompetence .

I could write a book about York hospital and it wouldn't be good
My advice- avoid at all costs

HedgehogToes · 13/04/2022 18:04

I'm really confused as to how this woman fell through the cracks for a scan.

I've been pregnant four times in the last 18m. One chemical, one MMC and 2 second trimester TFMRs. With the MMC I had to be scanned at a two week interval to make sure the pregnancy hadn't progressed before I could be given the medication.

The TFMRs, I had to be in hospital to give birth, but I had to go through scans, confirmations and multiple signing of documents. They had to be sure I absolutely wasn't past 22 weeks as after that, feticide is used to stop the heart.

Something has gone very badly wrong in this woman's care and needs investigation.

SevenWaystoLeave · 13/04/2022 10:37

@Whatalovelydaffodil

I really see no contradiction between believing it's best to check there's no risk of pregnancy before a medical procedure and also believing women should be able to have an abortion if they want one Well, no but that's not what I said.
Then why have you even brought the first scenario up?
Whatalovelydaffodil · 13/04/2022 10:31

I really see no contradiction between believing it's best to check there's no risk of pregnancy before a medical procedure and also believing women should be able to have an abortion if they want one
Well, no but that's not what I said.

SevenWaystoLeave · 13/04/2022 10:28

@Whatalovelydaffodil

There isn't a contradiction here. Abortion should always be an informed choice. If someone has an x-ray not realising they are pregnant and the foetus is harmed, that is not an informed choice

How is it not an "informed choice" if you know you can't be pregnant because you haven't had sex for five years or you have had a hysterectomy? Shouldn't we trust women?
If someone takes an abortion pill when they are 30 weeks pregnant, but they thought they were 12 weeks because they haven't been able to have a scan how is that an "informed choice"?.

I've had a hysterectomy and if I'm asked before a medical procedure if there's a chance I could be pregnant, I simply reply "no, I've had a hysterectomy" and that's that. But if I hadn't, and they didn't check, and it turned out I was pregnant, but that foetus was then killed by x-rays, clearly I have not been able to make an informed choice about that pregnancy. This is a vastly different situation to someone who wants an abortion and I'm honestly baffled as to why the two situations have been compared. Routinely checking if a woman might be pregnant before a medical procedure and having an elective abortion are two very different situations. I really see no contradiction between believing it's best to check there's no risk of pregnancy before a medical procedure and also believing women should be able to have an abortion if they want one.
HardyBuckette · 13/04/2022 10:18

This is going to turn into a TAAT...

Whatalovelydaffodil · 13/04/2022 10:05

There isn't a contradiction here. Abortion should always be an informed choice. If someone has an x-ray not realising they are pregnant and the foetus is harmed, that is not an informed choice

How is it not an "informed choice" if you know you can't be pregnant because you haven't had sex for five years or you have had a hysterectomy? Shouldn't we trust women?
If someone takes an abortion pill when they are 30 weeks pregnant, but they thought they were 12 weeks because they haven't been able to have a scan how is that an "informed choice"?.