Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope this very sad case stops them giving out abortion medication without scanning

306 replies

Greenmascara · 12/04/2022 18:05

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10711221/Baby-died-doctors-gave-30-week-pregnant-mother-abortion-pill-thinking-12-weeks.html

Extremely sad for mother and baby, mother is likely completely traumatised by this.

This isn't an anti abortion thread. Whilst never desirable, abortion needs to remain a safe, legal, NHS funded option so women aren't forced into buying illeagal/ dangerous pills online or having dangerous/ unsanitary abortions from backsttreet "doctors."

But I have been really, really concerned how at the start of covid, any safeguarding/ care in abortion went out the window. Pills posted out with no safeguarding concerns, and no scans to confirm pregnancy is within the legal limit.

Am I right in saying tragic, traumatic cases like this happen when you don't scan to check the gestation of pregnancy before handing out this medication ?

OP posts:
SW1amp · 14/04/2022 21:42

Haven’t lost the argument but my jaw is quite on the floor at how much weirder you sound with each additional post

Not to mention that you still haven’t addressed why you think you know more than all the experts beyond your sub-teenage answer of ‘experts once thought the Earth was flat’

Either way, I’m tapping out now

As the saying goes, you can’t argue with stupid

LimeSegment · 14/04/2022 21:42

This story has no link to telemedicine. In fact, another way you could interpret this story is - this was a massive screw up by a hospital. So maybe it would be safer if no abortions were done in hospitals. They should only be done at home via telemedicine. That makes as much sense as what you are saying.

Also you are going off the DM article which as usual is like a piece of Swiss cheese. The patient might (?) has been scanned but it was done poorly (?). This makes no sense at all, the real story is obviously completely different.

pointythings · 14/04/2022 21:38

I think people are forgetting the point made so many times that the cases quoted by OP did not involve telemedical abortions and are therefore completely irrelevant to the argument being made.

There's also the old saying that hard cases make bad law.

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 21:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes a deleted post.

SW1amp · 14/04/2022 21:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 21:35

@SW1amp

And as your reading comprehension seems incredibly poor, I’ll repeat it

It’s not about me having expertise in all those areas. But I’m willing to bet the thousands of people working in those fields via all the organisations signed up to tjr various open letters know their stuff

And they all think you are wrong. They all want telemedicine to continue

Im not claiming to be an expert. Im just fully backing them as being right

Which means by default, you are wrong.

Again… in one corner, every Royal College working in sexual health, pregnancy, reproduction
Every charity working with DV and Rape victims, many charities working with immigrants, low income families
All of them ALL of them saying the evidence says telemedicine should continue because it helps women, and especially vulnerable women

In the blue corner - you. Can barely string a coherent sentence together and can’t make a case that doesn’t require a daily Mail article as it’s basis

So yeah, as long as you keep trying to claim your opinion is equal to all those lobbying to keep it, I’ll strongly suspect you are narcissistic or delusional

"Can barely string a coherent sentence together " think that might be an issue with your ( poor) reading and comprehension skills. Now maybe take a break from this thread and go back to getting your posts deleted for saying all women who report being spiked are imagining it Hmm

How you can post such crap and then come on and take the moral high ground r.e. women's rights is shocking.

OP posts:
SW1amp · 14/04/2022 21:30

And as your reading comprehension seems incredibly poor, I’ll repeat it

It’s not about me having expertise in all those areas. But I’m willing to bet the thousands of people working in those fields via all the organisations signed up to tjr various open letters know their stuff

And they all think you are wrong. They all want telemedicine to continue

Im not claiming to be an expert. Im just fully backing them as being right

Which means by default, you are wrong.

Again… in one corner, every Royal College working in sexual health, pregnancy, reproduction
Every charity working with DV and Rape victims, many charities working with immigrants, low income families
All of them ALL of them saying the evidence says telemedicine should continue because it helps women, and especially vulnerable women

In the blue corner - you. Can barely string a coherent sentence together and can’t make a case that doesn’t require a daily Mail article as it’s basis

So yeah, as long as you keep trying to claim your opinion is equal to all those lobbying to keep it, I’ll strongly suspect you are narcissistic or delusional

onreee · 14/04/2022 21:27

[quote Greenmascara]**@onreee* I'm beginning to think @Wannakisstheteacher and @SW1amp* are actively trying to upset people with their posts.[/quote]
Hoping it's a wind-up, because aint no way-

😑

SW1amp · 14/04/2022 21:24

@Greenmascara

In fact *@SW1amp*, here is an example of you disbelieving rape victims. www.mumsnet.com/Talk/feminism/a4377161-Female-students-are-being-injected-now-with-date-rape-drugs-in-nightclubs?msgid=111785303#111785303

So the fact you'd call other women narcissistic for being concerned for rape victims beggers belief.

Oh, those cases that were proven to have not happened and the police acknowledged their investigations showed the alleged incidents hadn’t occurred

Sure, you detail the thread with those…

If anything shows you know you’re in the wrong, but you knock yourself out

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 21:23

@onreee I'm beginning to think @Wannakisstheteacher and @SW1amp are actively trying to upset people with their posts.

OP posts:
Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 21:21

Of course, given your previous posts, I'd be keen to hear how you have so much more expertise to help rape/ DV victims than myself or any other poster that disagrees with you.

OP posts:
onreee · 14/04/2022 21:21

[quote Wannakisstheteacher]@Greenmascara. Sigh. Yes, the actual experience was (possibly) different to expectations. But ultimately she didn’t want a baby and got the outcome she wanted. I’m not going to get incredibly worked up about the death of an unwanted baby. I really hope the baby didn’t suffer too much, but fundamentally if a woman isn’t sure the difference between being 12 weeks and 30 weeks pregnant when having an abortion done responsibly needs to lie with her.[/quote]
Wow. Again, she probably didn't expect to give birth to a 30 weeker, and probably wanted him survive after realising (even if she still didn't want him). It's s possible to support the right to choose and still have compassion for what ended up being a baby who was born early and died.

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 21:20

In fact @SW1amp, here is an example of you disbelieving rape victims.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/feminism/a4377161-Female-students-are-being-injected-now-with-date-rape-drugs-in-nightclubs?msgid=111785303#111785303

So the fact you'd call other women narcissistic for being concerned for rape victims beggers belief.

OP posts:
Wannakisstheteacher · 14/04/2022 21:16

@Greenmascara. Sigh. Yes, the actual experience was (possibly) different to expectations. But ultimately she didn’t want a baby and got the outcome she wanted. I’m not going to get incredibly worked up about the death of an unwanted baby. I really hope the baby didn’t suffer too much, but fundamentally if a woman isn’t sure the difference between being 12 weeks and 30 weeks pregnant when having an abortion done responsibly needs to lie with her.

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 21:15

@SW1amp I assume you then are an expert in DV, Rape victim support ? You work in the field, ( I bloody hope not !) Oh wait.....maybe you don't have any more expertise than anyone else posting on this thread. No, not everyone who disagrees with you has narcissistic personality disorder Hmm

OP posts:
BadNomad · 14/04/2022 21:13

I don't think women should be forced to have a scan before being allowed to abort. But for any women with unreliable cycles, or those just wanting to check, then a scan should be an option. But most women know their bodies and their cycles well. They should be believed. There is no need to put additional hurdles in front of every woman because a tiny few either lie or guess wrong.

SW1amp · 14/04/2022 21:11

[quote Greenmascara]@SW1amp the fact you are calling me narcissist for not wanting women to suffer as in the above case is hilarious. Try investing in a dictionary. And I must have missed the bit where you were given a copy of the coroner's report.[/quote]
You are a self appointed expert of everything

And have come out with some light-bendingly stupid reasons why we should discount the views of actual experts (“didn’t they once think the Earth was flat” being my particular favourite for showing how erm un-expert you are)

A very very overblown opinion of your own expertise is a very common indicator of narcissism. I’m probably not the only person on this thread putting 2 and 2 together…

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 21:09

[quote Wannakisstheteacher]@onreee what do you imagine they thought happened with an abortion? You don’t have an abortion with the expectation of bringing home a live baby surely?[/quote]
And for the last time @Wannakisstheteacher, most people don't have a 12 week termination and expect the baby to be born at 30 weeks, resuscitated on the toilet floor in front of them and sent to NICU for four days whilst doctor' try to save it Hmm That would have been traumatic for the women, and avoided if a scan had been given . How many women seeking a 12 week termination expect this to be the outcome ?

OP posts:
onreee · 14/04/2022 21:08

[quote Wannakisstheteacher]@onreee what do you imagine they thought happened with an abortion? You don’t have an abortion with the expectation of bringing home a live baby surely?[/quote]

You really don't get it? I find it hard to believe.

She thought she was 12 weeks and getting a standard procedure, instead she birthed a fully formed 30 week fetus, who she and her partner then named. It doesn't sound like that's what she wanted. Most people - even if they didn't want a baby- would rather keep than abort a 3rd trimester fetus

SW1amp · 14/04/2022 21:08

@onreee

Any baby born after 24 weeks, including terminations, have to have a death certificate and that requires a name

So the parents would have had to provide a name, it doesn’t automatically mean this was a longed for baby
Of course it probably wasn’t the way they wished the pregnancy to end, potentially including needing to name him

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 21:07

@SW1amp the fact you are calling me narcissist for not wanting women to suffer as in the above case is hilarious. Try investing in a dictionary. And I must have missed the bit where you were given a copy of the coroner's report.

OP posts:
Wannakisstheteacher · 14/04/2022 21:05

@onreee what do you imagine they thought happened with an abortion? You don’t have an abortion with the expectation of bringing home a live baby surely?

SW1amp · 14/04/2022 21:03

@Greenmascara

Furthermore, *@SW1amp*, a 12 week foetus measures approx. 5.7 cm, and a 30 week foetus measures approx. 38 cm; so I think we can be pretty sure a scan wasn't carried out in this particular case, as that's well, quite a big difference for a sonographer to miss.
Oh well if you can be sure, maybe you should speak to the coroner doing the inquest, who has said no such thing

But brilliant that we can now add ‘coroner’ and ‘sonographer’ to the list of things you are an expert at, along with DV support worker, obstetrician, Rape crisis support worker, psychologist, GP, nurse…

Apropos nothing, have you looked at the definition of narcissist at all..?

onreee · 14/04/2022 21:03

Precisely!

Greenmascara · 14/04/2022 21:03

@Wannakisstheteacher

Because you are making it sound like she lost a much longed for child. She wanted an abortion. She took the tablets and the foetus died - normally that happens pre birth, but not actually always - but you are trying to make out that the resulting dead baby would have been a shock.
I have to say, @Wannakisstheteacher, you don't exactly sound dripping with compassion for the mother in this case.

You think the baby being resuscitated on the toilet floor in front of her snd living in NICU for four days when she was expecting the termination of a 12 week pregnancy might not have come as a shock to her ?

OP posts: