Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope this very sad case stops them giving out abortion medication without scanning

306 replies

Greenmascara · 12/04/2022 18:05

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10711221/Baby-died-doctors-gave-30-week-pregnant-mother-abortion-pill-thinking-12-weeks.html

Extremely sad for mother and baby, mother is likely completely traumatised by this.

This isn't an anti abortion thread. Whilst never desirable, abortion needs to remain a safe, legal, NHS funded option so women aren't forced into buying illeagal/ dangerous pills online or having dangerous/ unsanitary abortions from backsttreet "doctors."

But I have been really, really concerned how at the start of covid, any safeguarding/ care in abortion went out the window. Pills posted out with no safeguarding concerns, and no scans to confirm pregnancy is within the legal limit.

Am I right in saying tragic, traumatic cases like this happen when you don't scan to check the gestation of pregnancy before handing out this medication ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 21/04/2022 21:17

No, I’m not trying to shut down debate. Reading @Greenmascara ’s posts, it just came across as disingenuous faux naive ‘pro choice’ text garbed as concern for women. Now I realise that it perhaps was just poorly argued - ie picking on telemedicine for a case that was not about telemedicine etc 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

Greenmascara · 18/04/2022 09:17

@Goldenhairbrush

Very similar actually to how people get ‘anti vaxxer’ thrown at them so easily if they express even a tiny bit if hesitation over vaccination. Often all that’s needed there is discussion/ reassurance/ etc but people jump in to shut the conversation down with cries of ‘anti vaxxer’ when actually an open discussion and education is what’s needed

Same is happening here. Shutting down a discussion saying anyone with a concern is fake .

Women deserve better. I would want access to a scan first but there could be women who don’t realise the importance and could then suffer it’s not good enough to say ‘oh it’s rare ‘ because ‘rare’ is fine till it’s you or your daughter or sister or friend …..

1000% agree.

Not once have I, ( or the majority of any other posters in this thread), said anything to suggest we want abortion in the U.K banned or restricted. I actually said within my posts that I think protestors

It seems a minority of poster's want to shut down people who are concerned for women's health, safety and emotional wellbeing - by saying anyone raising concerns about telemedicine/ termination without scanning "hates women and wants to destroy their rights." Despite the fact that the case studies above show that although rare, the current system can have devastating effects for women.

It is the same "shut down " argument used to say someone saying, "I think transgender people deserve respect but I worry about male prisoners being able to self ID as women and enter women's prison," = " I hate transgender people and think they should be discriminated against in all area's of life."

It is perfectly possible to have concerns about telemedicine / lack of scans without wanting to "ban abortion."

And yes, I imagine complications are rare. But if it is your sister/ niece/ cousin/ aunt / daughter who ended up having a 28 week stillbirth in her bathroom because no one had scanned her to safely check the gestation of the pregnancy, or it was you daughter who was forced, coerced or spiked with this medication; I'm sure you'd be calling for greater safeguards.

OP posts:
Goldenhairbrush · 17/04/2022 14:39

Very similar actually to how people get ‘anti vaxxer’ thrown at them so easily if they express even a tiny bit if hesitation over vaccination. Often all that’s needed there is discussion/ reassurance/ etc but people jump in to shut the conversation down with cries of ‘anti vaxxer’ when actually an open discussion and education is what’s needed

Same is happening here. Shutting down a discussion saying anyone with a concern is fake .

Women deserve better. I would want access to a scan first but there could be women who don’t realise the importance and could then suffer it’s not good enough to say ‘oh it’s rare ‘ because ‘rare’ is fine till it’s you or your daughter or sister or friend …..

Goldenhairbrush · 17/04/2022 14:34

@MyrtlethePurpleTurtle

I think it’s fine to be ‘pro life’ - just as it is to be pro capital,punishment. Neither is my position. However, just own that ‘pro life’ / anti abortion is your position instead of wrapping it up in faux concern afoul DV victims or telemedicine
This is just an attempt to shut down discussion and it’s wrong to say anyone with concerns is just anti abortion.

I’m pro choice but I do have reservations about things like no scan to date a pregnancy to see which abortion method is suitable / identify molar or ectopic pregnancy

It’s not an attempt to hide being pro life at all and i think it’s pretty low to resort to such a tactic labelling anyone who dares to raise a concern as pro life

pointythings · 17/04/2022 10:19

@MyrtlethePurpleTurtle

I think it’s fine to be ‘pro life’ - just as it is to be pro capital,punishment. Neither is my position. However, just own that ‘pro life’ / anti abortion is your position instead of wrapping it up in faux concern afoul DV victims or telemedicine
Very much this. But it's a tactic - posit the false statement that abortion regret is rife and so abortion needs to be made harder. posit the false statement that telemedicine leads to dangerous situations for women and so it needs to be rolled back. Outright saying you are anti abortion doesn't cut it and won't get people following you, so you go with the subtle approach instead. It really is despicable.
MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 17/04/2022 09:51

I think it’s fine to be ‘pro life’ - just as it is to be pro capital,punishment. Neither is my position. However, just own that ‘pro life’ / anti abortion is your position instead of wrapping it up in faux concern afoul DV victims or telemedicine

Angrymum22 · 16/04/2022 12:02

Still 14 days over the legal limit. I hadn’t factored in the pandemic since most areas of urgent NHS medicine have been operating normally throughout the pandemic.
The article does NOT say how she obtained the meds only that the inquest was focused on the lack of care she received while in hospital that contributed to the death of her baby. The article is quick to point out that the hospital has no part in the procurement of the meds.
The article is reporting on the inquest into the death of the baby.
It is very likely that there are ongoing criminal enquiries into the abortion aspect of the case. It’s compl x since the hospital played a part in the babies death but were not involved in the prescription of drugs that induced early labour.
If the woman hadn’t induced the abortion then the baby may have survived, but the hospital failed in its duty of care to fully assess her when she presented.
If she maintained that she was only 12 weeks (for whatever reason ) then her condition would have been completely mismanaged. It’s easy to point the finger at the professionals. But if the patient withholds be information it has a cascading effect.

Angrymum22 · 16/04/2022 11:38

But she was 12 weeks!

iieva94 · 16/04/2022 09:01

I dont think telemedicine service should be stopped. Used it myself and it was absolutely great service during such stressful and sad time. I think people need to take some responsibility for themselves. I know these rare things happen but individual responsibility also plays a role. For example e.g I received Codeine painkillers together with my medicine even though I have informed them I was breastfeeding. But I read the leaflet before taking it. We cannot blame NHS for every single little thing.

pointythings · 16/04/2022 08:53

Therefore it is perfectly possible this poor women legally obtained abortion medication without any physical examination/ scan/ face to face consultation, leading to these very traumatic results.

...leading to these tragic but incredibly rare traumatic results

There, fixed that for you. Context is everything.

Greenmascara · 16/04/2022 07:41

@Angrymum22

I was immediately suspicious of this story. The abortion pill is only licensed for use in pregnancies up to 63 days gestation (7weeks). If the woman had been seen by her GP at 12 weeks the abortion pill would not have been prescribed. However she got hold of the drug was illegal. In this case a full hands on exam would have quickly reviewed that the pregnancy was much more advanced whether 12 weeks or 30weeks and a scan would automatically been prescribed. My take on this is that she sourced the abortion with the aid of a third party. Any medical professional involved in the procurement would be implicit in illegal abortion. However, if the prescription was sought by a third party who was pregnant but under 7 weeks and the drug sold/ given to the woman in the article I don’t think that the medical professional should be blamed. To correctly administer the pill the first pill is taken at the abortion clinics/ surgery so it is witnessed. Again it is possible, with the pandemic, that there has been illegal trading in the abortion pill. So I agree this is likely to come under the umbrella of illegal abortion but not because the drug is available but because it has become a black market drug.
@Angrymum22, abortion pills for home use are licenced up to 10 weeks, ( nine weeks six days), prescription, after a routine telephone call, ( www.msichoices.org.uk/abortion-services/online-medical-abortion/) as opposed to seven weeks, ( link below).

The first pill, ( mifepristone), also does not have to be taken in clinic as, since the covid-19 pandemic started in March 2020, all pills have been licenced to be posted/ taken home. Therefore it is perfectly possible this poor women legally obtained abortion medication without any physical examination/ scan/ face to face consultation, leading to these very traumatic results.

OP posts:
Angrymum22 · 15/04/2022 23:33

I was immediately suspicious of this story. The abortion pill is only licensed for use in pregnancies up to 63 days gestation (7weeks). If the woman had been seen by her GP at 12 weeks the abortion pill would not have been prescribed.
However she got hold of the drug was illegal.
In this case a full hands on exam would have quickly reviewed that the pregnancy was much more advanced whether 12 weeks or 30weeks and a scan would automatically been prescribed.
My take on this is that she sourced the abortion with the aid of a third party.
Any medical professional involved in the procurement would be implicit in illegal abortion. However, if the prescription was sought by a third party who was pregnant but under 7 weeks and the drug sold/ given to the woman in the article I don’t think that the medical professional should be blamed. To correctly administer the pill the first pill is taken at the abortion clinics/ surgery so it is witnessed.
Again it is possible, with the pandemic, that there has been illegal trading in the abortion pill.
So I agree this is likely to come under the umbrella of illegal abortion but not because the drug is available but because it has become a black market drug.

BadNomad · 15/04/2022 23:07

@Monitaurus your daughter had an ectopic pregnancy after taking the morning after pill? Or after taking the at home abortion pill?

Monitaurus · 15/04/2022 22:09

Sparechange. It was a long time ago ...the GP examined me but I was very early I think. Knew immediately because I suppose he had had a lot of experience. Interestingly the locum who saw my daughter said that he had been told when training that if women or girls had a range of symptoms, pregnancy was usually the first reason. Both men, but I owe them a lot. Daughter never received a follow up call, but it was a while ago.

Greenmascara · 15/04/2022 20:03

[quote Sparechange]@Monitaurus

The telemedicine service comes with follow ups as standard. Phone call checks in from a nurse and admission if required

But as an aside… How did you Ob/gyn tell you that you were pregnant before you had any symptoms? Did they do a test, or are you suggesting they are somehow psychic?[/quote]
The telemedicine system does not come with a standard follow up call from a nurse. Read any of the many, many "my medical abortion," experience stories/ threads on here, and not one mentions a standard follow up call from a nurse to check things have progressed medically as they should have done.

OP posts:
Sparechange · 15/04/2022 15:21

@Monitaurus

The telemedicine service comes with follow ups as standard. Phone call checks in from a nurse and admission if required

But as an aside… How did you Ob/gyn tell you that you were pregnant before you had any symptoms? Did they do a test, or are you suggesting they are somehow psychic?

Monitaurus · 15/04/2022 14:41

I absolutely believe that women should be able to access safe methods, but I also think there should be adequate follow up. My daughter nearly lost her life. Got unexpectedly pregnant without knowing as she went for morning after pill. She then arrived at my house with unbearable pain, correctly diagnosed by out of hours locum GP, immediate admission to hospital, delay while tests done, ectopic pregnancy confirmed, suddenly burst , bleeding into abdomen, only just saved her in time. For that reason some medical oversight is surely in the woman’s interests? I am concerned that women who don’t always recognise what is happening in their body will be at risk of considerable harm. Especially as it seems health care in Uk is so compromised. This is why we have specialists. In my own case , my GP ob/gyn could tell I was pregnant before I had symptoms or knew myself.

whumpthereitis · 15/04/2022 12:43

I don't have an agenda. I'm pro women. I don't want termination to be banned, I want us to stop cutting cash on safeguards and invest more in the system so it is safe for women.

Well i can’t trust that, can I? I mean, the RCOG and FSHR claim to be pro woman and support telemedical abortion, but they’re not trustworthy are they? So why are you?

whumpthereitis · 15/04/2022 12:42

Again, at no point have I referenced stonewall as an authority. None of the evidence I have provided has been from Stonewall. As you well know.

Perhaps you can direct your energy to addressing what I’ve actually said, because you’re wasting it in setting up strawmen.

Greenmascara · 15/04/2022 12:40

@whumpthereitis

So what’s your agenda? If those experts can’t be trusted, on what basis should you be? Because you seem to take it for granted that you have superior insight to those that spend their lives working and studying in this field. You say you want to protect women, but of course those bodies you’ve maligned also claim they want to do that, so that’s not good enough reasoning is it?

So go on, WHY are you better informed? WHY should you be trusted?

I don't have an agenda. I'm pro women. I don't want termination to be banned, I want us to stop cutting cash on safeguards and invest more in the system so it is safe for women.
OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 15/04/2022 12:39

[quote Greenmascara]@whumpthereitis you don't think many of the "experts," who have signed that letter, e.g. NUPAS/ BPAS/ MSI / International Planned Parenthood Association might just not have a vested interest in providing cheaper services ?

Stonewall provided a corporate signature to that letter as experts,, What expertise do you think Stonewall have in termination safety, ( or biology at all, frankly).[/quote]
Nice dodge. I haven’t mentioned stonewall at all in this thread, or referred to them having expertise.

Please explain why you are better informed than these medical bodies that have supported telemedical abortion, and on what basis you are trustworthy?

Greenmascara · 15/04/2022 12:38

@whumpthereitis

So what’s your agenda? If those experts can’t be trusted, on what basis should you be? Because you seem to take it for granted that you have superior insight to those that spend their lives working and studying in this field. You say you want to protect women, but of course those bodies you’ve maligned also claim they want to do that, so that’s not good enough reasoning is it?

So go on, WHY are you better informed? WHY should you be trusted?

So you think Stonewall, ( a leading signatory to making telemedicine permanent), have spent their lives studying safe and least harmful termination practices ?
OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 15/04/2022 12:37

So what’s your agenda? If those experts can’t be trusted, on what basis should you be? Because you seem to take it for granted that you have superior insight to those that spend their lives working and studying in this field. You say you want to protect women, but of course those bodies you’ve maligned also claim they want to do that, so that’s not good enough reasoning is it?

So go on, WHY are you better informed? WHY should you be trusted?

Greenmascara · 15/04/2022 12:35

@whumpthereitis you don't think many of the "experts," who have signed that letter, e.g. NUPAS/ BPAS/ MSI / International Planned Parenthood Association might just not have a vested interest in providing cheaper services ?

Stonewall provided a corporate signature to that letter as experts,, What expertise do you think Stonewall have in termination safety, ( or biology at all, frankly).

OP posts:
Greenmascara · 15/04/2022 12:30

@TalkingCat

Of course there is risk for everything, but we don't do away with all safeguarding.

As I previously mentioned, I sadly, no longer trust any of these organisations, because all of them put being 'woke' first regardless of the risk to women. So no, I do not believe these places. If they can ignore safeguarding for women in women's spaces (and these organisations support men in womens spaces), then what else will they approve? They're slowly but inexorably chipping away at the safety and rights as women. I will never, never 'believe the experts' when they advocate removing safe spaces from women, so I am not going to believe them when it comes to this. I don't care how many 'respected' organisations join the list (as they have done with allowing men in womens spaces, sports teams etc), my trust in these organisations has been irretrievably broken. I might be jaded but I no longer believe any of these organisations have womens best interests at heart. If the same organisation says there is 'no risk' to women having men invade their spaces, I sure as shit am not going to believe them on this either.

Sadly, unless things do a 180 and quickly, I don't think I'll ever believe these organisations again. My trust has been irretrievably broken, for good. I don't know what their reasoning is for joining with Stonewall and advocating men in women's spaces, and I don't know what their reasoning is for suggesting we do away with scans. On both, it's nefarious reasoning, imo. On their stance with this, I believe it's cheaper for the NHS. It's cost-cutting. And that's what they push for it. I don't believe for one split second any of them give a shiny shit about women. It's all about cost-cutting, that's all.

100% correct. And NUPAS/ MSI / BPAS are advocating for a system where they spend less money on treating client's, ( they are not clear whether they will require less payment from the NHS despite providing less work), and the public are being gaslit into thinking this is about women's safety.

Oh, and Stonewall are part of the "list of expert organisations," that have signed to say telemedicine/ termination without scans should continue. I don't regard Stonewall as experts in anything. and wonder why on earth they think lesbian and bisexual women, ( who presumably would be a very small minority needing terminations), would be disadvantaged by needing a scan ?

OP posts: