Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surely there's benefits for people like me

265 replies

Bpdqueen · 12/04/2022 13:44

I'm a single adult, kids moved out I work 30 hrs a week my take home pay after tax and NI is around £1000 4 weekly. My mortgage payments are £450 a month. Leaving £550 a month for all bills food petrol the only benefit I get is 25% of council tax which brings ct down to £100ish a month. I used to get working tax credit but I apparently earn to much I have lots of medical conditions but I don't think anything enough to claim pip as I'm Mobile and capable of looking after myself and working. Am I missing something or am I expected to be able to live on this.
Aibu - yes that's more than enough to live on.
Yanbu - no you should be entitled to help on such a low income

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 12/04/2022 17:24

@MarriedThreeChildren

But *@Babyroobs* the case of your guy needing a full time carer is very different isn’t it?

I’m reading all this and thinking ‘well stuff this. I need to apply to PIP and I ought to get too’.
I mean I have a chronic illness, bad enough that apart from a few hours of work p, I can’t do anything, not even cooking for myself.
But somehow I also know I’m very unlikely I won’t get it. Like the many other with a similar condition than me.

A friend of mine was receiving PIP. Her GP finally diagnosed her with fibromyalgia so she had to tell PIP. They then decided she wasn’t entitled to anything at all, despite the fact none of her symptoms changed. But she is exhausted, some times so exhausted she struggles to feed herself. So she won’t go to appeal.

I think it’s disgraceful

Yes the guy in the wheelchair he obviously had a lot of care needs and wanted to and was able to work with support which is great, but I agree with some people it is hard to see how they qualify, which is what I meant about my ex colleague but I guess I don't know exactly how she qualifies, she must have put forward medical evidence which they accepted to be awarded the points for an award. Yes you should definitely apply for PIP - get some help with the forms. Good luck.
AnotherEmma · 12/04/2022 17:22

@SophieSoSo

I earn more than that and get UC as a single parent, I get £625 a month with the housing element.

I’m sure you would be entitled!

You are a single parent which presumably means you have at least one dependent child. So you are entitled to the child element and the housing element (you must rent), and the OP is entitled to neither.

People really do give bollocks "advice" on here sometimes.

MarriedThreeChildren · 12/04/2022 17:22

@MissMaple82

Yes you are expected to live off this, and sounds more than manageable for 1 person !
Have you tried to do it yourself @MissMaple82 or is it just a ‘feeling’?
SophieSoSo · 12/04/2022 17:21

@Babyroobs you’re absolutely right - that will teach me to skim read I never usually do that!

MissMaple82 · 12/04/2022 17:20

Yes you are expected to live off this, and sounds more than manageable for 1 person !

MarriedThreeChildren · 12/04/2022 17:20

Sorry Xpost @Babyroobs.

I think we are in the same lines really

whywhythough · 12/04/2022 17:19

@SophieSoSo

I earn more than that and get UC as a single parent, I get £625 a month with the housing element.

I’m sure you would be entitled!

OP is not a single parent who is renting a house Confused

MarriedThreeChildren · 12/04/2022 17:19

But @Babyroobs the case of your guy needing a full time carer is very different isn’t it?

I’m reading all this and thinking ‘well stuff this. I need to apply to PIP and I ought to get too’.
I mean I have a chronic illness, bad enough that apart from a few hours of work p, I can’t do anything, not even cooking for myself.
But somehow I also know I’m very unlikely I won’t get it. Like the many other with a similar condition than me.

A friend of mine was receiving PIP. Her GP finally diagnosed her with fibromyalgia so she had to tell PIP. They then decided she wasn’t entitled to anything at all, despite the fact none of her symptoms changed. But she is exhausted, some times so exhausted she struggles to feed herself. So she won’t go to appeal.

I think it’s disgraceful

Babyroobs · 12/04/2022 17:18

@SophieSoSo

I earn more than that and get UC as a single parent, I get £625 a month with the housing element.

I’m sure you would be entitled!

Yes you get it because you have a rent elment on your claim which op does not as she has a mortgage and you have a child element on your claim which op does not because she has no dependent children and you get a generous work allowance on your claim because you have a child which op does not get. So really your situation and hers are in no way comparable. She would not currently qualify for Uc unless she gets PIP awarded and then applies for UC and applies to be assessed for limited capability for workl.
Babyroobs · 12/04/2022 17:16

Married with children - I do know what you mean though. I do sometimes find myself thinking that if working full time, what exactly are you scoring points on PIP for ? I guess it depends what work you do though. Obviously if you were awarded PIP for having difficulties with washing and dressing yourself yet were working as a carer then that is going to be contradictory. They do ask at these PIP assessments what people do for a job sometimes as part of getting an idea of what daily life looks like for them.

Babyroobs · 12/04/2022 17:13

PIP is not an earnings replacement benefit, it is a disability benefit. It is extra money to help with the additional costs that a disability brings, so for example if you can't walk far and need taxis to get you to work, or you need to pay for a carer, or you maybe need to pay for therapy or whatever or an electric wheelchair. No-one checks up what PIP is used for. I used to work with a young guy who was paralysed- he worked full time from his wheelchair but had a carer with him at all times to help with toileting etc.

SophieSoSo · 12/04/2022 17:12

I earn more than that and get UC as a single parent, I get £625 a month with the housing element.

I’m sure you would be entitled!

Ballcactus · 12/04/2022 17:11

If you go for PIP try and get someone supporting f you to do the application, with experience. Makes a big diff

MarriedThreeChildren · 12/04/2022 17:10

@Babyroobs

Married with children ; PIP is not an earnings replacement benefit. If you cannot work at all because of disability then there are various other benefits you may be able to claim - Universal credit, or if you don't qualify for that due to savings or partners income then there is potentially contributions based ESA if you have paid enough NI contributions.
If PIP isn’t an income replacement benefit, what is it?

Because I genuinely have always seen people using their PIP as their income. Not let’s say as a way to help them to go to work or make adaptation to their house etc…

I did know you could work whilst receiving PIP. I’m just really surprised that you could get enough points if you are working full time, don’t need a carer with you etc…

Or maybe the issue here is that you need to know how to use the system and give the ‘right answer’. Which is crap btw because some people, like people with severe MH issues, will never be able to play that game. It’s too stressful/demanding for them to do that.

Babyroobs · 12/04/2022 17:07

@Femalewoman

Friends daughter has PIP after a battle. She was on full DLA and mobility and is sever learning disabled and sever end of autistic spectrum (non verbal, unable to function without 24 hour care). Basically, needs full care, no communication, meltdowns, aggression, unable to be left alone, cannot wash/shower/dress without help. Very, very fixed routines etc and struggled to get the higher award. Crazy.

For someone who is mobile and able to work and needs no care to function then I wouldn't expect PIP to be paid.

On a separate point, if more hours are out of the question or a struggle then a lodger (tax free) might help?

My ex colleague was awarded it. She worked full time, and actually increased her working hours after applying for PIP. Could type all day long in her job , walk across town, communicate with clients, wash and dress herself. Has currently managed to travel to south america alone and unaided. I never quite understood how she got an award but I guess there must have bene something ?? I suppose we never know the difficulties others have.
bringincrazyback · 12/04/2022 17:06

@HulaTallulah

You need to work full time, take a lodger or downsize your home. Not sure why the state should pick up the tab if you're not willing to do any of these things.
Ermm... because the benefits system is supposed to work in such a way that people pay in (which the OP as an employed person has been doing) and are then entitled to claim support if they need it. It's not freebies. Sheesh.
Shortbreadselection · 12/04/2022 17:05

@whywhythough
Examples:
Needing prompting/encouragement to eat (or cook).
Same again for showering/hairwashing when depressed.
Help with communication due to Autism.
Impulsive spending.

Westegg · 12/04/2022 17:04

I would also contact your Council Tax department as well, you may qualify for Council Tax support to reduce Council tax - I just checked my local council website and a single person earning up £250pw would get 50% reduction in council tax - each Council is different for support available so may be different in your area.

Thenose · 12/04/2022 17:04

It sounds like it will be worthwhile for you to apply for PIP. Some non-profits can help you fill in the forms effectively, like fightback4justice. If you have no experience advocating for this sort of help, specialist support is likely to make a big difference to you.

Viviennemary · 12/04/2022 17:00

Unfortunately unless you can claim some sorrt of disability benefits you don't qualify for help. I would try to find a way of earning extra money.

Femalewoman · 12/04/2022 16:59

"you see I’m happy for you.
But also gutted when I think about the m ay people who have been rejected from PIP and can’t work AT ALL.

Why is one person who is working full time receiving support for disability when one that can’t isn’t ???

(NOTE: again not an attack on you!! But in the system that is so unfair)"

Wow I agree. Someone working getting PIP benefit and can care for themselves and work and is mobile and yet some disabled people get rejected and unable to do a fraction of what a person with epilepsy does! Crazy system. Needs looking at.

Femalewoman · 12/04/2022 16:56

Friends daughter has PIP after a battle. She was on full DLA and mobility and is sever learning disabled and sever end of autistic spectrum (non verbal, unable to function without 24 hour care). Basically, needs full care, no communication, meltdowns, aggression, unable to be left alone, cannot wash/shower/dress without help. Very, very fixed routines etc and struggled to get the higher award. Crazy.

For someone who is mobile and able to work and needs no care to function then I wouldn't expect PIP to be paid.

On a separate point, if more hours are out of the question or a struggle then a lodger (tax free) might help?

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 12/04/2022 16:55

Why is one person who is working full time receiving support for disability when one that can’t isn’t ???

Because the PIP allows them to work with any advantages that this brings for them? Financially, socially, and/or emotionally?

There do seem to be substantial injustices within the PIP awards that are made. I'm aware of somebody who was blind, a wheelchair user, had cognitive issues and a couple of progressive conditions who was initially awarded zero points. That was appealed successfully (unlike in the case that you report) so it seems that the inter-rater reliability is very poor.

Babyroobs · 12/04/2022 16:54

Married with children ; PIP is not an earnings replacement benefit. If you cannot work at all because of disability then there are various other benefits you may be able to claim - Universal credit, or if you don't qualify for that due to savings or partners income then there is potentially contributions based ESA if you have paid enough NI contributions.

seekingasimplelife · 12/04/2022 16:48

How much tax are you paying each month?

Invest any income over your income tax allowance threshold into a pension. It will be deducted from your gross pay and you will reduce/eliminate your income tax payments with possibly little impact on your overall take home pay at your current monthly rate.
Your pension contributions will also receive a 20% uplift from the government into your pension pot.... It might not seem like much of benefit now, but your future-self will thank you for it in years to come!!
You might even be able to build enough in your pot to pay your mortgage off early.

Also you are likely to stop being liable to pay NI contributions at all in July, if your annual income is below £12,570.

Swipe left for the next trending thread