Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surely there's benefits for people like me

265 replies

Bpdqueen · 12/04/2022 13:44

I'm a single adult, kids moved out I work 30 hrs a week my take home pay after tax and NI is around £1000 4 weekly. My mortgage payments are £450 a month. Leaving £550 a month for all bills food petrol the only benefit I get is 25% of council tax which brings ct down to £100ish a month. I used to get working tax credit but I apparently earn to much I have lots of medical conditions but I don't think anything enough to claim pip as I'm Mobile and capable of looking after myself and working. Am I missing something or am I expected to be able to live on this.
Aibu - yes that's more than enough to live on.
Yanbu - no you should be entitled to help on such a low income

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 19/04/2022 19:48

[quote Innocenta]**@Rosscameasdoody* Yes, it is incorrect and irresponsible because people who see only* this advice sometimes interpret it as "fill in the form as if your worst day is every day", which can lead to being accused of fraud. I never said anyone should ignore their worst days; that's a bad faith reading of my response and I think you know it. [/quote]
I’ve been assisting with PIP applications for nine years and not once have I seen anyone try to fill in the form as if every day is their worst day. At no point did I say this is what you should do - and at no point did I misread your post or say you were advising people to ignore their worst days. I’m simply saying that the advice is to factor in your worst days because they do matter - especially if you have a condition which fluctuates because if that condition severely restricts your ability to carry out the assessed activities for more than 50% of the time, you will qualify. In my experience people tend to downplay the effects of their disability, not exaggerate them - especially with the more intimate and embarrassing details. Honesty is the best policy with PIP because it’s a very harsh assessment - attempts at exaggeration will usually be detected. No two people will be affected in exactly the same way even by the same disability and the very nature of the PIP assessment forces you to think more about the things you can’t do. A lot of people find that very difficult, when they’re trying to focus on the positive just to get through the day, so I’m more concerned with people who under report. I’m sorry if you took offence at my reply, it wasn’t intentional.

Innocenta · 19/04/2022 19:32

@Rosscameasdoody Yes, it is incorrect and irresponsible because people who see only this advice sometimes interpret it as "fill in the form as if your worst day is every day", which can lead to being accused of fraud. I never said anyone should ignore their worst days; that's a bad faith reading of my response and I think you know it.

Rosscameasdoody · 19/04/2022 19:31

@Babyroobs

For goodness sake - how many more people are going to tell op to fill out the form on a worst day?? You do not do this. You can describe a worst day but if you say you cannot walk 50m because you can't on a worst day ( which could happen twice a year) bu then on the day of the assessment they observe you walking 100m or more down the road to the assessment centre ( and yes they do watch people ) then quite honestly you are going to look like you have exaggerated from the start. It is really really poor advice to tell someone to fill out the form based on a worst day. By all means describe a worst day but explain how your conditions vary, how often a bad day is etc.
Mobility and care awards of PIP are not just based on how far you can walk or any other singular aspect. For each activity the assessor takes into account how well you can carry out the activity, how much pain you are in before, during and afterwards, whether you have to take pain killers in order to carry it out or afterwards, whether you need help or use an aid, etc. They have to consider whether doing any activity would make your condition worse - usually based on medical evidence - and whether you can do it repeatedly, reliably and in a timely manner. You are likely to be observed once you step onto DWP property and this will include how you walk from the waiting area to the assessment room (usually in excess of 20 metres) how you sit and stand and whether you move around easily or with difficulty - it’s called informal observation and will appear on the report, as will demeanour and any other relevant body language. It IS important to consider bad days and worst days because there is something called the 50% rule. If on bad days you are unable to carry out an activity and this applies for more than 50% of the time (usually 4 days a week or more) then you are considered unable to carry out that activity.
Rosscameasdoody · 19/04/2022 19:08

[quote Innocenta]**@jkrfan* No, you do not* fill it out based on your worst day. This is totally incorrect and irresponsible advice! [/quote]
Not incorrect and not irresponsible. And not meant to convey the fact that every day is your worst day . I have advised on PIP for a disability charity since 2013 when it was introduced and have had a lot of success with applications, reconsiderations and appeals. You need to consider how you feel on your worst days and think about how often they occur. With PIP, it’s not about the fact that you have a particular disability - it’s about how it affects you on a daily basis and whether/how much it fluctuates, and that’s why you need to consider how you are on the days when you’re most affected. For every activity assessed you need to consider how much pain you are in before, during and afterwards, whether you could do the activity repeatedly as often as needed throughout the day and whether doing a particular activity would affect your ability to do something else. You need to consider whether you feel fatigued, whether you need to take painkillers before, during or afterwards, and whether you need an aid or appliance, or help from someone else to complete an activity. Your safety and regard to not worsening your condition is also into account. PIP is a very difficult benefit to claim successfully. Head over to the benefits and pensions forum on GN as I’ve posted a comprehensive guide to claiming several disability benefits, based on my experience.

Innocenta · 15/04/2022 14:42

@jkrfan No, you do not fill it out based on your worst day. This is totally incorrect and irresponsible advice!

Babyroobs · 15/04/2022 11:49

For goodness sake - how many more people are going to tell op to fill out the form on a worst day?? You do not do this. You can describe a worst day but if you say you cannot walk 50m because you can't on a worst day ( which could happen twice a year) bu then on the day of the assessment they observe you walking 100m or more down the road to the assessment centre ( and yes they do watch people ) then quite honestly you are going to look like you have exaggerated from the start. It is really really poor advice to tell someone to fill out the form based on a worst day. By all means describe a worst day but explain how your conditions vary, how often a bad day is etc.

jkrfan · 15/04/2022 11:27

@Bpdqueen

I have borderline personality disorder, pots, hypothyroidism and cardiovascular disease so 30hrs is a struggle as it is I wouldn't be able to do more but when I looked into pip the questions where can you dress yourself and feed yourself ect which I can
You have to fill out the PIP questionnaire based on your worst day. PIP is awarded on how the condition affects you, not the condition you have. Citizens Advice could help you fill out the application to ensure you are not 'minimising' the effects on you. It is a normal human instinct to deny the true impact of your medical conditions. It's a survival mechanism.
Babyroobs · 15/04/2022 11:16

@HammerToFall

Can you not get working tax credits
No -one has been able to make a new claim for tax credits for around the past 3 years or longer.
HammerToFall · 15/04/2022 10:14

Can you not get working tax credits

Username1951 · 15/04/2022 10:03

Increasing hours is fine IF YOU CAN
You can't be managing your money properly, everyday we get told by the Troy MP's that they done really well in "helping" the low paid into a world of plenty......they certainly have for their mates.
For gods sake make your choice on your MP not on lies and promises of he future, (NI increase to pay for adult care in years to come and Brexit will give us hundreds of millions a day - from someone who has made a career of lying )make it on what they have done to you when in office. Sorry to hear of your plight, l really do feel for you, and all others at food banks (there's more food banks n the UK than McDonalds) and trying to get help from the six largest economy in the world. A disgrace

SommerTen · 14/04/2022 19:49

Hi @Bpdqueen I have a similar problem.
I'm single & sadly childless at 45, live alone in my small 2 bedroom home which I bought when I was well and had a good career so luckily the mortgage is low just £350 a month.
But I can now only work part time (22.5 hours / 3 days a week) as I have Schizoaffective disorder and epilepsy; my medications make me drowsy & I get paranoid easily despite the anti psychotics which makes my working life difficult.

I work too many hours to get ESA / UC of any kind but I really get a lot of self worth from my job and don't want to cut any more hours. I earn approx £1k a month.
I currently don't have a lodger as I'm not well enough.

So with assistance from a local charity I've applied for a PIP renewal.
I originally got PiP for Mobility for the epilepsy since 2018ish on mandatory reconsideration which gave me an extra £250 a month but now my Renewal is due my psychiatrist & occupational therapist have said that I should see if I can get more PIP points for other activities which I do struggle with - mainly due to the negative symptoms of Schizoaffective disorder.

I do think you should apply for PIP - there are probably local disability charities who you can pay to help with the form, just like I found.
Just make sure you get plenty of evidence (as in reports about how you meet the criteria rather than descriptions of your illnesses).

You can also try applying separately for council tax benefit I believe.

Innocenta · 14/04/2022 16:06

@SilverHairedCat Thank you for your reply Thanks I was really upset by the other person saying I don't know what PIP is, when it's my main income and of course, in order to receive it I did have to go into detail about my health (or lack thereof). I just found that such a nasty thing to say to a claimant who obviously must be very unwell, you know? But I really appreciate the way you responded and I totally agree with you that I haven't personally experienced that awful treatment from the DWP. I did have assessments in the past (one for DLA, one for ESA), but was lucky to have only home visits, and assessors who were comparatively respectful of me.

Ironically I do have MH problems but we left them out of the PIP application because of knowing (in theory) how useless the DWP is with all MH stuff. So I'm not ignorant about it (and certainly not about MH struggles, I've been in treatment for 15 years Sad) but I fully take your point that people have a much harder time applying for mental health conditions. For what it's worth, I think the descriptors are awful, that many more people should get awards, and I support UBI anyway, so I'm definitely not coming to it from a POV of 'fewer people should get benefits' or anything like that.

I've known people who had problems with their applications relating to taking the 'worst day' approach, and I think that makes me particularly cautious and pessimistic.

SilverHairedCat · 14/04/2022 15:48

@Innocenta I think it sounds like you have an extraordinary case with clearly very severe circumstances and its absolutely brilliant and amazing that they have accepted your application and given an indefinite award. That's truly wonderful for you.

As such though, you've no idea how hard it is for people with different conditions, especially mental health conditions, who are forced to renew every 2yrs which is more like every 12 months after they have had to go through the process of interview, mandatory reconsideration and tribunal to get the award they refused you in the first place. You've obviously not had to deal with the lies, deceit, underhand tactics they use to undermine people applying for PIP.

I'm pleased for you, but your experience is far and away the exception and not the rule.

Innocenta · 14/04/2022 14:07

@MarriedThreeChildren I think you haven't read my posts if you imagine I don't know what PIP is. I literally said that I have an indefinite award of both components at the higher rate, and was given that award without an assessment (ie based on just the form and evidence). That really sounds to you like someone who doesn't know what it is...? Hmm

Haus1234 · 14/04/2022 14:06

Apologies if someone’s already mentioned this but could you remortgage over a slightly longer period to reduce the costs a bit since it currently finishes in your mid 50s? Obviously it’s not ideal as being mortgage free will be a big help for you at that point - but perhaps the saving would be better for you now?

MarriedThreeChildren · 14/04/2022 13:59

I think one of the big issue is that the government has made extremely hard to get anything lie this.

It has also done so on the back of ‘tackling fraud and people claiming when they shouldn’t ’ So now most people don’t even bother to claim because they think they aren’t unwell enough for it. And that’s even though they ARE filling all the right boxes in the first place!

Basically lots of disinformation and making people like shit because they want or need to claim, which reduces claims in the first place. :(

MarriedThreeChildren · 14/04/2022 13:56

@Innocenta

It's quite unlikely OP would meet the criteria for PIP, and posters shouldn't encourage her to exaggerate. Hmm
@Innocenta I think you don’t know what PIP is.

The OP has several conditions that is affecting her daily life.
It IS worth for her to try.
He fact she might be rejected at the first go doesn’t mean she is not entitled to it either. Most claims (around 70~75%) are accorded at appeal.

worriedaboutmoney2022 · 14/04/2022 13:43

@Bpdqueen

My neighbour is in a similar predicament she phoned up her GP who got her a referral to a support worker/ social worker who did an assessment sorted out lots of stuff

Assistance with utilities - capping gas/electric and water
Access to a community larder
Some UC but gave her free prescriptions etc and
she got a bus pass (like the over 60's) which really helps
Some cognitive therapy to help her mental health
She owns her home and loves it hence not wanting to move as everyone is nice on our street

I'd reach out to your GP or phone your local councils adult social care
I really hope they can help

Innocenta · 14/04/2022 13:35

@Babyroobs I have an unlimited award of the higher rate of both components, without having had an assessment, so I know how the process works! It's certainly not impossible OP could qualify, and I wasn't trying to say that, but I do think people are pushing her to present her issues in a way that may verge on falsification, which is a bit concerning. The descriptors are too strict, no question about it, but the answer isn't to massage the truth. Sad

Babyroobs · 14/04/2022 13:32

@Innocenta

It's quite unlikely OP would meet the criteria for PIP, and posters shouldn't encourage her to exaggerate. Hmm
Totally agree that people should not be encouraging her to exaggerate but I think she may qualify. PIP doesn't just look at whether you can do an activity but how it affects you. So if you can shower yourself but it causes pain or it takes you ages or you need to rest afterwards then you may score points. It's always worth a try I guess especially if conditions are chronic and likely to get worse in the future. To be honest I've been in the line of work for some years of helping people with PIP forms and I'm very surprised at the awards some people do get. Then there are others when you think no way will they be refused it and they are. I agree with others that half the battle is knowing how to complete the forms without exaggerating the truth, to adequately show the difficulties you have. You only need 8 points to get standard rates.
usernamealreadytaken · 14/04/2022 13:28

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Innocenta · 14/04/2022 13:28

@Bpdqueen Is your POTS optimally managed and treated? It sounds like it probably isn't from what you've said.

DownNative · 14/04/2022 13:17

@Bpdqueen

"I have lots of medical conditions but I don't think anything enough to claim pip as I'm Mobile and capable of looking after myself and working."

Many, many people on PIP are mobile, capable of looking after themselves AND working!

I'm one due to lifelong hearing loss and, since it's not means tested, there's no restrictions on how many hours a week I can work.

Apply and see what they say. You've nothing to lose.

Innocenta · 14/04/2022 13:14

@tkwal

If you have a lot of medical conditions you should apply for PIP as I know prescriptions can be expensive. Even if you were to be awarded the minimum amount it would still help and you may also get some help with the mortgage interest
PIP isn't awarded to help with prescription costs.
Swipe left for the next trending thread