Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

my brothers contesting my mothers will i have a question

113 replies

masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 13:03

he has claimed that i bullied our mother to leave me the house and claims that there was a previous will saying he was to get half the house and me half but i wasnt told anything about this even if true he claims this will was made in the late 1990s and since then he had no relationship with our mother until two years ago when he became ill due to drinking and needed a liver transplant he was kept informed before this of our mothers and fathers falling healing due to illnessess they both had but didnt bother.

his lawyer is asking for details of gp social work and carers so they can check records and i wondered if this takes weeks or if it takes months as i feel like a nervous wreck being there for our our parents for the last two years of theyre life which was difficuilt and not getting any support from family members now theres money involved theyre interested all of a sudden and im tired of the whole thing it seems to be constant

OP posts:
MaryGubbins · 12/04/2022 15:36

And actually if ops parents were in Scotland this would have happened when the father died if he had cash etc over an amount even if everything was left to his wife.

Cyw2018 · 12/04/2022 15:35

YABU

He has every right to contest it, especially if what he says about previous Wills is true , and if it involves a significant sum of money it could be a pivotal moment in his life (or he could drink it all away).

Just because he contests it doesn't mean he will win.

You need to seperate out the time and care you CHOSE to give to your parents, from the dividing up of assets now happening. He was there son too afterall. You should not have cared for them with the anticipation of financial gain as inheritence is never guaranteed, and even when you do get it probate can be a long drawn out procedure.

MaryGubbins · 12/04/2022 15:34

Moveable assets in Scottish wills are 1/3 of cash etc. this is then divided equally between the children who can choose to claim it or relinquish it or choose to retain a claim for 10 years. If they don’t take it it goes back to the main estate and divided as per the will. When my dad died I got a letter from the solicitor telling me what I could to claim and those three options.

NotthesameNotok · 12/04/2022 15:32

Inheritance isn’t dependent on how much help a person gives their parent/s??

Yes there’s a moral obligation but it’s not a legal obligation in order to then inherit. I think tbh he probably is entitled to something .

It maybe cheaper for you to actually accept that and see if you can come to an agreement which will save you both legal expenses

dumdumduuuummmmm · 12/04/2022 15:28

@Cocomarine

Disinheriting 6 out of 7 of your kids though… bloody hell!
How many kids were there? I can't make it out. Where does it say 7?
WhatTheWhoTheWhatThe · 12/04/2022 15:27

Did they leave him anything at all. In my experience (well observed others experience) if the person contesting was left nothing and is likely to need state help/benefits now or in the future then there’s a strong chance they could be successful. The state doesn’t want to pay out benefits to someone if there is a potential for family money instead. Anecdotal I know but I would expect this to be long and drawn out and potentially costly both sides.

Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 15:14

Disinheriting 6 out of 7 of your kids though… bloody hell!

Fulmine · 12/04/2022 15:08

Glad to see that this will was drawn up by a solicitor with the signature being independently witnessed. That will be good evidence on your behalf, as solicitors have a duty to satisfy themselves that the person making the will knows what she's doing and wants to do it. If there was any sign that your mother was scared of you or unhappy about what she was doing, they should have picked that up.

ratspeaker · 12/04/2022 15:00

In Scotland children are automatically entitled to a share in moveable estate ( cash, bank accounts etc), as I recall it's an equal share in half the moveable estate if there's no surviving spouse.
So it's half the bank accounts divided amongst children that can't be willed to anyone else. So if it's only £1 in the bank 50p goes between all children by law. The other 50 p is the deceased to will to anyone they want. This is as I recall from our solicitor explaining as we made our wills.
Heritable assets such as house etc can be willed as the person sees fit

BlancmanegeBunny · 12/04/2022 14:57

Where did your mother make the will.........England or Scotland?

How long ago was the will made?

Heronatemygoldfish · 12/04/2022 14:53

@Onlyhuman123

sorry, no advice and it's horrible that you're in this situation but why is it that these family members bugger off during the years preceding death and then all of a sudden come out the woodwork when parents die and EXPECT their fair share of any estate proceeds?! it beggars belief. If I had NC with my parents, I wouldn't expect a single penny from their estate or dream of enquiring as to whether I was a beneficiary because I imagine I would have had a reason to go NC ergo, lost entitlement to anything?!
Pam Ayres wrote a hilarious and cutting poem in the 70s about that called "Where there's a will... there's a sobbing relation"
florentina1 · 12/04/2022 14:48

You are not obliged to answer the Solicitor’s letter or give any details. If your brother really wants this, then he will have to get his solicitor to apply to the Court. This is even more expensive.

I would do nothing.

Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 14:41

@steff13

I believe if your parents lived in Scotland, they can't disinherit one of their children. But that's just based on what I've read on MN and some googling. So if they lived in Scotland, I would imagine whether he was left anything at all is going to be key.
That’s wrong. I think a PP even mentioned “moveable” assets. You can’t disinherit those (which is why the 6 way split on the £30K cash isn’t just mum trying to be fair and equal!) but the rules for property are different.
SockFluffInTheBath · 12/04/2022 14:40

Wills and a sniff of money bring out people’s true colours like nothing else. Hold fast OP, let him waste his time, energy and money.

steff13 · 12/04/2022 14:36

I believe if your parents lived in Scotland, they can't disinherit one of their children. But that's just based on what I've read on MN and some googling. So if they lived in Scotland, I would imagine whether he was left anything at all is going to be key.

Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 14:36

I find your posts confusing, so I name searched to see if I could answer my own questions.

So, it is a proper will. Drawn up by a lawyer. 4 years old so far from last minute. Same lawyer you’ve engaged now. And that lawyer brought 2 independent witnesses at the time of signing, to confirm she was in sound mind.

Given all that, I don’t think anyone on here can reassure your any more than your professional can. And it sounds pretty reassuring!

And none of your other 5 brothers are contesting this?

PizzaPizza56 · 12/04/2022 14:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Zilla1 · 12/04/2022 14:18

Will they need the executor's assistance or explicit permission before securing any information from the GP/hospital/SW so they will need more than details. Might be an idea to take a breath and have a chat with the lawyer and see what's best rather than have the executor do more than the minimum required in advance of any proceedings.

Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 14:13

His lack of care for your parents and whether he can afford to go travelling now aren’t relevant.
How old is the will that you’ve got, was it drawn up by a solicitor / will writer, and was your mum of sound mind when she wrote it?

I daresay the 1990s will could be true. Afterall, before you’d provided extensive care, why wouldn’t they have split it equally? But it doesn’t matter if the newer will is valid.

namechangeranonymouse · 12/04/2022 14:13

We are currently in the position of challenging a will and coming up to mediation. Provided your mother was in her right mind when she wrote the Will and it is legal (signature witnessed by 2 other people), preferably drawn up by a solicitor, you brother can just do one. He hasn't a cat in hells chance of contesting this will. He is self sufficient and is not/was not financially dependent on your mother.

Your mother's wishes top his claim.

SolasAnla · 12/04/2022 14:11

@Justcallmebebes

Hi OP. This is my area of work. GP/hospital/medical notes have to be supplied within 40 days of the request for them (not all Trusts keep to this deadline, but that's the legal deadline).

If you make a Will it automatically revokes any previous Will made so unless it's a mirror Will made in the past with say a deceased spouse, the new Will stands regardless.

Contesting Wills is very expensive and has a very low success rate. Your brother would have to prove that he was financially dependant on your mother or she provided other services that are quantifiable.

Who has the authority to obtain the deceased's records?

I presume the Trust is not going to be sending out multiple copies of the file to all family members who request a copy?

If I were the OP I would buy a file and hole punch, stick the correspondence on it and ignore it.

Hope90x · 12/04/2022 14:08

Hi OP, if you are asking how long the GP/SW will take to process this - it won't be painstakingly long. For access to the written notes/files there is a set amount of time to respond however if the solicitor wished to make contact with the SW by telephone, he could be provided with a verbal overview of the circumstances there and then.

The only difficulty you may run into is if your parents had any memory problems/cognitive decline before re-writing the will. Makes it a little trickier if their mental capacity at time of making will can be brought into question.
This information would be recorded by both SW and GP.

StooOrangeyForCrows · 12/04/2022 14:05

Try not to worry OP. Overturning a will is very very difficult indeed and rightly so. It would cost him an eyewatering sum to do so too. He is probably truing to bully you into handing over half - don't and don't provide him with any documentation unless forced to.

I had all this with my sister. My Dad left her a sum of money though so although the will was unbalanced, it wasn't totally so. She hadn't been near him in fifteen years and expected half of a house I had paid to keep up together!

chisanunian · 12/04/2022 14:02

His lawyer is presumably looking for evidence to prove that she no longer had the capacity to understand what she was doing when she named you as beneficiary. Either that or she was vulnerable enough to be coerced or browbeaten into it by you.

You need legal advice as soon as possible, and don't hand over any information until you have proper advice.

Justcallmebebes · 12/04/2022 13:54

Oh - yes this is English law, not Scottish. That's very different for probate matters