Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

my brothers contesting my mothers will i have a question

113 replies

masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 13:03

he has claimed that i bullied our mother to leave me the house and claims that there was a previous will saying he was to get half the house and me half but i wasnt told anything about this even if true he claims this will was made in the late 1990s and since then he had no relationship with our mother until two years ago when he became ill due to drinking and needed a liver transplant he was kept informed before this of our mothers and fathers falling healing due to illnessess they both had but didnt bother.

his lawyer is asking for details of gp social work and carers so they can check records and i wondered if this takes weeks or if it takes months as i feel like a nervous wreck being there for our our parents for the last two years of theyre life which was difficuilt and not getting any support from family members now theres money involved theyre interested all of a sudden and im tired of the whole thing it seems to be constant

OP posts:
masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 17:54

Cocomarine whats horrid exactly i see them as her sons which is more than can be said that they do me saying im adopted emplying im not really a member of the family why am i defending myself your clueless

OP posts:
masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 17:52

Cocomarine ill clarify things to put it into perspective this brother whose contesting the will was 30 when he CHOSE to leave the home because of his drinking habits, his behaviour and bringing strangers home he took no responsabillity said that our parents forced him to leave him and CHOSE not to have a relationship with them he was kept informed of our parents health - fathers parkisons and mother having copd and father having a heart attack and mother having a stroke he CHOSE again not to go visit them in hospital after having said he would then lied and claimed that he wasnt told about heart attack or stroke this partner then got in touch a couple of years ago with myself not because of his parents health but because his partner himself had health issues due to drinking which he had been warned about years prior i encouraged our mother to get in touch with brother and thats when they started speaking again yet this same brother has accused me of bullying our parents into leaving the house to myself says a lot i tried doing the right thing and im the jerk im seflish and greedy and entitled yet apparantly theyre all blameless laughable

OP posts:
Cyw2018 · 12/04/2022 17:49

But, they did. It doesn’t sound like you have anything to worry about legally.

This, but for someone who declares that they are not behaving in an entitled way OP seema very inpatient to get their hands on this money, and for someone who declares that the will was 100% above bored they seem very anxious about it being contested.

OP if it has all been done in a transparent and legal way, just sit back and wait for the money to arrive in your account at whatever point the solicitors are ready to transfer it.

Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 17:46

“ those two along with her sons”

That’s a horrid thing to say! Those two? Along with her sons? They are her sons!!!
Even if she decided to drop them like they weren’t.

Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 17:44

Oh come, you can’t really say they haven’t been disinherited!
£27K split 6 ways after fees is hardly comparable to the value of their entire house.
And in any case Scottish law entitles them to share half of that (moveable) anyway, so that part isn’t even left by their mother.
So she’s given you a house and him £2250.
I’d call that disinherited to all intents and purposes even if it’s not the strict legal definition.

You’re coming at this that you’re owed this house as pay back for being the one in their lives and the one to have provided some of their care. Of course, you don’t need to justify being owed it - it was your mother’s to give.

You assume that your brother is motivated by greed. Maybe, maybe not.

6 children. Several off the rails. One an alcoholic. 2 your mother dropped contact with. 3/4 siblings that you share with your father, didn’t want to go to his cremation. I reckon there’s a massive back story here.

Maybe it’s greed motivating him, maybe it’s anger that he wants something from them.

Odd that your parents have used the same solicitor since the 80s yet never made a will until 4 years ago, especially with such a complicated family.

But, they did. It doesn’t sound like you have anything to worry about legally.

masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 17:35

Josette77 i agree my mother had her faults and i dont defend that like i said those two along with her sons were entitled to several thousand pounds each its not like ive sat here demanding everything for myself

OP posts:
masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 17:33

Cyw2018 i dont feel entitled at all ive said in a previous post that i advised my parents to spend as much of theyre money on themselfs as they could before theyre health deteriated as for house i told them not to feel obligated to leave it to me as said theyre choice i wasnt even present when will was written up the only ones who have a sense of entitlement are those who sat back and did nothing

OP posts:
Josette77 · 12/04/2022 17:29

Your mom abandoned two of her kids and disinherited them. That is really awful. No wonder they have issues.

Cyw2018 · 12/04/2022 17:24

@masterofdoomv1

Cyw2018 and that attitude annoys me that its brought up about the rights of other sons they were all informed of theyre mothers ill health yet made the decision to sit back and do nothing where was theyre duty of care for theyre parents yet now theyre mothers passed away shes obliged to give them thousands?
You're demonstrating here that you feel entitled to your parents money.

As I said before you need to separate these two issues. I don't know you or your family, to know whether you were in a better position to easily care for them or if you were treated differently or better than your siblings in childhood, or any other family dynamics.

Many people care for their family with no inheritance on the horizon, parents living in council housing for example, or they care for their parents only for them to need expensive residential care at the end and to spend the majority of assets on that.

The issue of you caring for your parents and the probate of their will are independent issues.

If your brother wants it investigated now, then surely this is better than them popping up at a later date when you have already spent the money and accusing you of fraud.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 12/04/2022 17:15

Get a solicitor to act for you immediately or ask the Executor to do it ( I am pretty sure that the legal fees can be deducted from the estate before it is paid out) Probate etc takes some time so don't expect it to be cleared up early.
Put all your info clearly with a timeline if you can... the consultation will reveal what your situation is.
The solicitor will write to your Bro and tell him all communication must go through him ( this will save you from upsetting contact) Plus the solicitor will know whether you are obliged to answer any of these questions. And if your Bro is talking rubbish, the solicitor will know how to respond. Plus he is more likely to take the solicitor's word for it than you and the solicitor will make sure that all the handling of the will is watertight and can be proved to be in compliance with the law. Best of luck.

masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 17:13

coc my brothers made theyre choices as well lets not pretend theyre saints or faultless they knew where there mother was sat back chose not to get in touch and not help when advised of ill health yet now theyre gone they have all these rights regarding money and house laughable

OP posts:
masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 17:11

Cocomarine theres six sons including myself the other 5 werent disinherated ive stated that that theres £30000 and after lawyers fees were paid for helping deal with estate that would have left several thousand to be split dont forget this was parents money theyre choice what they did with it why should they be forced to give it to adults theyve had no relationship for decades yet thats what this brother is claiming whose contesting will that ive forced them to leave me the house go figure the one thats been there looked after the parents is greedy and selfish the ones who sat back and did nothing are victims these same brothers have claimed i did nothing as there were carers involved and reminded me im adopted inferring that im not a real member of the family go figure huh

OP posts:
Xpologog · 12/04/2022 17:11

I would say your brother is hoping to wear you down, or bully you into handing him money.
Leave him to pay a solicitor, it’ll cost him thousands. It is very difficult to contest a will successfully but a solicitor will tell him otherwise at it’s money for them.

Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 17:08

I don’t think you can talk about duty of care towards parents, when your mother didn’t keep in touch with two them!
There’s a lot going on with your family.

Which doesn’t change the situation on
inheritance, as the will was drawn up years ago correctly.

masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 17:05

Cyw2018 and that attitude annoys me that its brought up about the rights of other sons they were all informed of theyre mothers ill health yet made the decision to sit back and do nothing where was theyre duty of care for theyre parents yet now theyre mothers passed away shes obliged to give them thousands?

OP posts:
masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 17:01

there were different issues coc one got into a lot of trouble when he was younger mugging an old woman stealing cars etc another lied a lot still does the one whose disputing the will drank a lot had to get a liver transplant because of that was bringing strangers home he would be so drunk hed come home 3 or 4 in morning making noise so drunk hed go into my room or my parents room instead of his own there were arguments and the brother chose to leave but took no responsabillity said parents were forcing him to leave as for other two that was my mothers doing they were half brothers same mother different fathers they stayed with theyre father when my mother and theyre father seperated my mother didnt keep in touch which i dont defend so fault on both sides

OP posts:
masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 16:56

fulmire although i lived with my parents when the solicitor came with independant witnessess for the will to be made i made a point of not being present to give them privacy they could have written will however they wanted i even advised them to spend as much money as they could before they passed away while they could and as for house they were under no obligation to leave it to me id appreciate it if they did but i didnt want them feeling they had too

OP posts:
Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 16:56

@masterofdoomv1

thirdelephant all my mothers sons (six including myself) were to get an equal share of our mothers savings (£30000) after lawyers fees were paid - the lawyer helping me with sorting out estate so its not like they were getting nothing and theres only one who took issue with this
That’ll teach me to assume MNers are female! That’s why I was confused whether there were 6 or 7 of you!

Did your father also disinherit the other 5?

Why did none of them have a good relationship with your parents?

masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 16:52

blanc in scotland

OP posts:
masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 16:51

thirdelephant all my mothers sons (six including myself) were to get an equal share of our mothers savings (£30000) after lawyers fees were paid - the lawyer helping me with sorting out estate so its not like they were getting nothing and theres only one who took issue with this

OP posts:
sammylady37 · 12/04/2022 16:26

I think tbh he probably is entitled to something

Unless he is in Scotland, he is entitled to whatever the parent wished him to have, which in this case is nothing.

The sense of entitlement people have about other people’s money never ceases to amaze me.

HazelBite · 12/04/2022 16:25

I used to work in the Chancery Division of the High Court, the very fact that sucessfull contestion of wills appears in the press is because sucess is very rare.
It is eye wateringly expensive to undertake this with the prospect of little sucess and no "no win no fee" companies will take on this work.
You really do have to have very clear evidence of coercian, very difficult to prove without witnesses and medical evidence,
A lot in this case depends of the opinions/attitudes of the rest of the family concerned.

Heronatemygoldfish · 12/04/2022 16:05

Sorry I didn't finish what I was going to say earlier. Wills are a nightmare even if they're straightforward. I lost my Dad 6 weeks ago and I'm mid-probate now with an uncontested will - stressful enough! Sorry for your loss and all the hassle, OP.

AbbieLexie · 12/04/2022 15:53

Please follow the advice given and see preferable the lawyer who drew up your mum's will and follow their advice.

I would also ask if brother can be responsible for paying any costs incurred.

Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 15:48

@dumdumduuuummmmm it’s on another of OP’s threads - she’s posted several times recently about claims. That’s not a criticism of posting again, as this post is a specific question.

I searched not to trip anyone up, just because I don’t find the OP clear, and because it’s one of those situations where a little detail goes a long way - a will written with a lawyer and two independent witnesses 4 years before death, for example, which is the case here.

I find it odd that the will wrote all 6 brothers - the OP describes one (maybe two, it’s confusing) who sounds awful. But… we’re only hearing one side and if you write out 6/7 children then the alcoholic son isn’t the common dominator in that situation!

But, if the will was written whilst in sound mind and the two independent witnesses didn’t think the OP’s mother was under duress, then ultimately it was her decision.

I’m curious whether (as this was decided well before OP’s father died) her father’s will also - had it been mother who died first - favoured 1 child over 6 others.

I have a sister in a large family who lives in parents’ home and cares for them - though it’s not personal care level. Her opinion is that though it’s her home, she’s benefited from that (free accommodation in her) and she feels she has no more claim on the house morally than any other sibling.