Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

my brothers contesting my mothers will i have a question

113 replies

masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 13:03

he has claimed that i bullied our mother to leave me the house and claims that there was a previous will saying he was to get half the house and me half but i wasnt told anything about this even if true he claims this will was made in the late 1990s and since then he had no relationship with our mother until two years ago when he became ill due to drinking and needed a liver transplant he was kept informed before this of our mothers and fathers falling healing due to illnessess they both had but didnt bother.

his lawyer is asking for details of gp social work and carers so they can check records and i wondered if this takes weeks or if it takes months as i feel like a nervous wreck being there for our our parents for the last two years of theyre life which was difficuilt and not getting any support from family members now theres money involved theyre interested all of a sudden and im tired of the whole thing it seems to be constant

OP posts:
Cocomarine · 14/04/2022 08:29

@Itsbackagain but OP has already explained about the money and the jewellery, and not complained that he’s getting that? Her complaint is about the house. So I don’t know why you copy & pasted it?

Itsbackagain · 13/04/2022 20:28

[quote Cocomarine]**@Itsbackagain* you’ve copy and pasted from the internet and you’ve literally* copy pasted the bit that explains that property is excluded 🤣🤣[/quote]
Yes I know, OP mentions money and jewellery also.

Daleksatemyshed · 12/04/2022 21:58

Please don't be offended @Masterofdoomv1, it's always a difficult thing balancing a parent passing, everyone's expectations and doing the right thing. I do understand that as the one child who stepped up and did the right thing and looked after your parents you feel upset and let down.
I can say from experience that time will take away some of the pain and give you some peace, family can be a blessing and a pain at the same time. Take some time and remember that you did your best, I hope you find peace and you can akways be proud that you did your best for your DPs

Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 21:23

@Itsbackagain you’ve copy and pasted from the internet and you’ve literally copy pasted the bit that explains that property is excluded 🤣🤣

Itsbackagain · 12/04/2022 20:27

Legal rights are a distinctive feature of Scottish law and only apply if the deceased died domiciled in Scotland. Legal rights:
can be claimed by the deceased’s surviving spouse or civil partner and the children of the deceased
are claimed from the deceased's worldwide ‘moveable estate’ (IE. not property or land) after all moveable debts have been deducted
are automatic, so you won’t need to make an application to the court
are considered a debt on the deceased’s estate in relation to beneficiaries (the person(s) inheriting assets from the estate) and will take priority over any legacies, included in the deceased’s will

Itsbackagain · 12/04/2022 20:25

Scottish law is the right of succession so yes he'll be entitled to a share.

Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 20:15

I haven’t said you’re an arsehole.
I’ve just said that the information you’ve given suggests that your alcoholic brother isn’t just an arsehole.
There’s a reason that he’s one of 5 children with a problematic or absent relationship with both parents.
Like I said, backstory here. That’s not bullshit, and it’s not messed up, but I expect your aggression towards the idea that it’s not all his fault means that you also have some issues to resolve over family dynamics.
I wish you luck with that, and hope the will is sorted quickly.

masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 20:06

anyways im done with this bs so messed up stuff on here

OP posts:
masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 20:02

no coro ive started multipile threads as im excausted with the whole situation those last two years where my parents were alive were tough i lost father december before last then just a few weeks later in january me and mother were told she didnt have long to live there were times where i had to confort her as she cried that she didnt want to die i was with her 24/7 i had to wipe her backside i had to get up 3 or 4 times a night to see to her at times and guess what in january when mother was told she didnt have long to live this brother whose contesting the will was told and his response was what do u expect me to do about it ive just lost my father no effing joke so dont sit there and make me an a hole ive done nothing wrong my concience is clear which is more than can be said for others

OP posts:
masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 19:54

Daleksatemyshed ive given this brother whose contesting will photos to share of theyre mother since hes claimed the rest didnt want any contact as well her jewellery so again all ive done is try and do the right thing and all ive got is crap for it

OP posts:
masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 19:51

LadyMary50 i paid dig money which was of an equal ammount that my brother was expected to and he worked and thats how its always been im not a freedloader my parents benefited a lot more by me being at home than i did it meant they didnt have to go into a nursing home or sheltered housing which they were always scared of because theyd lose theyre independance this is really shity that the one that was there is being made to feel like the a hole in all this for what being there and looking after parents whatever happened between parents and siblings was between them i played no part in it other than to get mother to contact the one whose now contesting the will because of his ill health i dont get people

OP posts:
LakieLady · 12/04/2022 19:26

@Cocomarine

Disinheriting 6 out of 7 of your kids though… bloody hell!
I knew someone who was one of 8 children and was disinherited. 6 of the other 7 felt this was very unfair and each gave her a 1/7 share of their inheritance to make it more equal, but the 7th, who had been their mother's favourite, refused to do so.

She found it strangely liberating, she told me. She had always felt that her mother didn't like or love her, and that she was treated far less favourably than her siblings, and it made her realise that those feelings weren't wrong or based on something imaginary. And she realised that it didn't matter, and that her mother couldn't hurt her any more.

Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 19:10

Absolutely agree with you!
I think though, where the snapshot given is only the adopted child left having a relationship with the parents and five not, then to me that snapshot suggests the OP is being unfair to call the alcoholic just “greedy”.

Doesn’t mean the alcoholic has any right to the money.
Doesn’t mean the alcoholic isn’t just a total shit.

But I think OP recognises that his parents were not good and fair… and perhaps that’s why he’s started multiple threads about the threat to his inheritance, despite already being in touch with the self same lawyer that arranged the will.

Daleksatemyshed · 12/04/2022 18:55

@Cocomarine, I understand your point of view that morally it would have been kind to try and make up to her two oldest sons by leaving them something extra in her will. I think the problem here is, as always, we only get to read a snapshot of someone's life- we have no idea why their DM felt the need to leave her sons, things were very different years ago and women could have very few options.
My DF had a DD from his first marriage who he had no contact with for years, since his death I've been in contact with her and met up and given her some of our DF's personal items which she wanted, not his money, she wanted to feel connected. It would be a lovely idea for the Op to do something similar

Unsure33 · 12/04/2022 18:44

As long as the will was drawn up properly and witnessed I would think he would be wasting his money . The illness’s you have mentioned does not mean that there was any reason why your parents were not capable of making a will .

LadyMary50 · 12/04/2022 18:42

@masterofdoomv1

Cyw2018 and that attitude annoys me that its brought up about the rights of other sons they were all informed of theyre mothers ill health yet made the decision to sit back and do nothing where was theyre duty of care for theyre parents yet now theyre mothers passed away shes obliged to give them thousands?
Call me cynical but having read some of your other posts I find it hard to believe everything you say about your parents situation. You say you have lived with them for 20yrs,presumably rent free as you are on benefits.Methinks you doth protest too much about doing all the care work for them.I wonder what all your brothers stories about the situation would be!!!
Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 18:30

@Daleksatemyshed literally no-one on this thread has said that all 6 children should inherit equally, morally. Some have opined that he might have some claim, most of us have said it sounds like he’s pissing in the wind.

But morally? I’d say the two older sons that the mother didn’t bother with after she left them with their father on divorce have just as much right to the same value share as OP. In recompense, perhaps. That’s not a legal position though.

SScoobiedoo · 12/04/2022 18:25

Hang on in master - honestly in years to come when your life is good and the property you inherited has made you secure with savings and a good future it will be worth the horrible hassle now.
Don't give way to them.

Perhaps write down all the help you gave DPs, and all the lies DB is making up. Once it's written down it won't go round and round in your head. So less stressful.

Daleksatemyshed · 12/04/2022 18:16

@masterofdoomv1, I think you're being given a bit of a hard time here and you don't deserve it. It's easy for pp to say all the DC should inherit equally but why should they? Until the moment they died, that house and money was your DP's and they were intitled to spend every last penny- they made it, they get to deceide who inherits it.

SirGawain · 12/04/2022 18:10

Tell your brother to read the story of Jarndice V Jarndice in Charles Dickens Bleak House.

masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 18:08

Cocomarine as i am her son too bad they dont see it that way that theyve accused me of bullying not doing anything for theyre mother by saying it was carers that did the work and that im not really a member of the family as im adopted anyways i wanted advice im not going to sit here and be made out to be the bad guy in all this and defend myself bye all

OP posts:
Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 18:04

@masterofdoomv1

Cocomarine whats horrid exactly i see them as her sons which is more than can be said that they do me saying im adopted emplying im not really a member of the family why am i defending myself your clueless
Is isn’t your place to “see” them as her sons. They are her sons!!!

What I think is horrid is your language - saying “those two” and then “along with her sons” reads that you don’t consider them her sons, really.

That said, I do find some of your phrasing hard to follow, so perhaps it was innocently said that way. The language we choose does say a lot.

How old were your half brothers when she lost touch with them?

masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 18:04

Cocomarine one was cut off because of his actions as an adult doing things such as mugging an old woman breaking into houses stealing cars etc and no this wasnt my mothers fault as hes the only one who got in bother with police and the other was a compulsive liar you couldnt believe a word he said the two sons that stayed with theyre father mums first husband and she chose not to have a relationship with that was on our mother and in no way at all do i defend her but as for the rest theyre not saints they made theyre own poor choises theyre responsible for them

OP posts:
Cocomarine · 12/04/2022 18:00

You’re very angry with your brother.
I understand that.
Frankly, he sounds like a total arsehole, and alcoholics are no fun.

If this was just you and your brother, I’d have just thought, “yeah - what a selfish dick!”

But there are 6 adult children here.
2/6 were dropped by their mother.
3/4 of the father’s children didn’t want to go to his cremation.
4/5 who are not the arsehole alcoholic have been similarly cut out of the will
5/6 (I think?) did not see their sick parents

And the 1 that did is adopted, which can bring in a different dynamic in their relationship with their parents.

This isn’t one rogue selfish arsehole. Yes, only one is contesting it. But 5/6 have serious issues with their parents.

Which is why I think it’s possible that the alcoholic’s motivation isn’t simply greed. Could be recognition, or wanting pay back.

Like I said, clearly a massive backstory.

masterofdoomv1 · 12/04/2022 17:57

Cyw2018 im not impatient at all just think its a slap in the face by family members that did bugger all

OP posts: