Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not buy their house out of principle?

142 replies

ReeMee · 12/04/2022 12:18

Help me decide what to do?!

In Jan we had an offer accepted on a house. Estate agent told us there was loads of competition and as we’d lost houses in best and final before we ended up bidding 20k over asking. We got it but only because apparently we had sold to first time buyers and the other bidders had longer chains.

House survey was shocking but I know surveys read like horror scripts and we knew from viewing that there would be work needed. When I liaised with estate agent about getting specialists in to quote for work they told me, the vendor has other cash buyers lined up, she will not be taking money off (it’s a probate sale for her parents). Thinking that was our plan. It genuinely wasn’t, we just needed to know the extent of any issues and costs, the house is 500k so not cheap!!

Then on the day of exchange our buyers pulled out. Estate agent/vendor would not wait for us to resell, they put it back on the market that afternoon and have since redone the photos so some of the issues we had been looking at (damp, some cracks) have been covered up with mirrors and pictures (in an empty house!)

2 weeks later we have now resold and the house we were buying is still on the market. I actually rang the estate agents to enquire about it (not telling them who I was) and they said the vendor had had some offers but was looking for close to asking price!! WTF? Now she will accept an offer 20k lower than what we were paying. The cash buyers were clearly a tool to get us paying more and not renegotiating.

I do still love the house (damp and cracks aside) although I think we were overpaying a bit but had come to terms with it not being ours and come to terms with the financial loss (£900ish). I am waiting for the estate agent to phone me once they see our house is SSTC again but I don’t know what to do.

I want to tell them where to go tbh but is that a mistake?

OP posts:
MandyLHarkness · 13/04/2022 18:00

Don’t cut your nose off if you love the house. We were (IMO) used by estate agents to chivvy a developer who’d been delaying completing on a house. We put an offer in but the seller didn’t want to upset the developer (!) & gave them one more chance which of course they took🙄We ended up paying the developer an extra £35k for him to sell directly to us. Yes it stuck in our throats but we had 11 very happy years there & made a huge profit when we sold up.

middleeasternpromise · 12/04/2022 18:40

I think you are focusing too much on the estate agents, you cannot rectify that problem - they will not be impacted at all by your decision its not how they work. Perhaps try to see it as a unavoidable part of the extremely unhelpful home buying system we have - the vendors have chosen to use them so the buyer must do so if they want to buy. If you want to confront them about their ethical shortcomings, do so after you have bought although I doubt they will take your feedback on board - its an industry that needs improvement. I can understand the vendor moving on swiftly if they are in a probate situation - the property is probably empty and vulnerable whilst it waits to sell. Had they been in the property and you had a chance to meet them things might have gone differently but you are where you are. I think you've had a few suggestions thrown your way, barter to get some money off, buy it if you think the house is what you want. If you get caught up in the negative emotions of what has happened it will impact on everything you are doing including how to you see alternative properties and choices.

ReeMee · 12/04/2022 18:39

I presume probate is sorted. The owners died over a year ago now. We were at the point of exchange when our buyers changed their mind. I didn’t know about council tax being double after 6m.

I’m surprised how many people are so horrified by the damp and crack, IME (& that’s maybe because I’ve always brought old houses) surveys are generally worst case scenario and cracks (apart from subsidence obviously) are part and parcel of an older house. Unless it’s covered in thick wallpaper, which many are. It is priced accordingly if the damp, which I feel is mainly due to the property being empty and not heated for a good while, is what it looks to be and nothing more sinister. It could be a money pit but we felt that by having specialists and builders to look we were doing what we could to negate the risk.

That said, I think we loved the location a bit too much and that made us get a carried away when bidding.

We think the sensible thing, given we have no need for a 4 bed now, would be to go for something smaller and not in need of loads of remedial work. The location won’t be as good but there is only a very small area where it would be. I just hope something comes up that we like and we can compete with the others who want it. Every property seems to have cash buyers or first time buyers lined up if you speak to the estate agents.

Thanks for the advice Smile

OP posts:
LittleOwl153 · 12/04/2022 18:21

You have all the information in front of you. Look at the surveys take into account what needs doing and the costs, and look at perhaps the worst case scenario of those costs.

Think about whether you really want the house long term... 10 years time?

If the answer is yes then make a fresh offer. Asking price less survey results issues, buyer can take it or leave it. Circumstances change - as the estate agent hasn't sold yours they do not know whether you have accepted less to sell. You can proceed quickly given you have all the paperwork.

Bear in mind that in my area once probate is granted there is only a 6 month period before the council charge double council tax as it is an empty property.... they would have had to have probate granted to exchange I believe...

Threetulips · 12/04/2022 18:03

Offer under the asking price - say it’s best and final offer.

unname · 12/04/2022 17:49

I don't now why I quoted you BonnyAndPoppy!
Sorry.

dewl · 12/04/2022 17:41

Haven't read the replies but can't you say you've accepted a lower offer on your house, therefore have to offer less on theirs? You could offer £496 or something definite like that.

UltimateIrritant · 12/04/2022 17:39

The probate issue may well hold up the sale for several months even if they accept your offer, which may be an issue for you or others In the chain.

unname · 12/04/2022 17:38

@BonnyandPoppy

I would offer 20k under the asking price and be prepared to maybe go up to just under asking. If yoy still like the house and it's in a good location I would go for it.
I understand completely. But your actions here are not going to fix the fact that some people are corrupt and dishonest. You can get the house or you can leave it. You don't have to allow them to take advantage of you since you already know their character.

I chose to get my house, because I loved it and was not going to let them stand in my way. In the end, I am pretty sure they didn't make much, and they definitely didn't pull anything over on me.

Why2why · 12/04/2022 17:16

That house sounds like a den and f regrets. Use your head and put aside your emotions. You may have a lifetime of regrets if you don’t.

PollyPollyPollyPolly · 12/04/2022 17:02

@ExplodingElephants good point- it’s possible they’d already hidden a lot when OP offered the first time.

ExplodingElephants · 12/04/2022 16:59

You already know it’s not great and now they’re hiding things with mirrors (admittedly you know about these faults too). It just makes them come across as deceitful and I’d wonder whether there was anything else that might be found further down the line, how comprehensive was your survey? Be that as it may, if you’re very set on the house then I say go for it. However, I’m not sure that I would personally.

maddiemookins16mum · 12/04/2022 16:39

Personally I’d not want that house, it just sounds as if there could be problems galore.

worriedaboutmoney2022 · 12/04/2022 16:21

@ReeMee

What a nightmare!

£20k is a lot of money isn't it?

I'd get yours sold and go into a rental and start again my best friend did that then they weren't in a chain x

LadyMacduff · 12/04/2022 16:18

I really think you need to decide if the house is the house for you, at the right price, now that you're armed with the survey information. Only you can know that. Maybe another house would be better. Maybe this is the one.

Though you're in the thick of it now, the buying process and crap estate agents will one day just be an anecdote. Flouncing from a house you love only affects you. It'll sell eventually to someone.

IncompleteSenten · 12/04/2022 16:16

I'd put in a lower offer and tell them you know about the issues and this is what you are willing to pay.

GreenLunchBox · 12/04/2022 16:12

House survey was shocking but I know surveys read like horror scripts

This isn't true. Your house sounds like a nightmare and it sounds like you had a lucky escape

rainingsnoring · 12/04/2022 16:11

@ReeMee

Once my DH comes home we will sit down and weigh it all up this evening. If we offer it will be asking price and it will be our best and final.

Our circumstances have changed since we were buying in that DH has gone back to the office after being told he wouldn’t be so we don’t need a home office anymore, this house is 4 bed and we may start looking for a 3 bed instead. We could get a lovely one without work needing doing for 500k.

That said, I still love the house. It is in the best location we could hope for.

Sounds sensible to have a proper discussion and weigh up the pros and cons before replying to the agent. I see from your later posts that two previous sales have fallen through. That already makes one suspicious!

Do whatever suits your family but definitely at a discount if you decide to go ahead. Clearly other people don't feel this house is worth the price even in a busy market or they are put off because it is back on the market for the nth time.

GatoradeMeBitch · 12/04/2022 16:10

*morals not orals...

GatoradeMeBitch · 12/04/2022 16:09

Why offer asking price if the estate agents are saying they'd accept "close to"? They have dicked you around so don't worry about orals at this point. Offer at least £10k under. Emphasize that the damp will be a problem to fix and your lower bid reflects that.

Hadjab · 12/04/2022 16:08

I haven’t bought or sold a house for over 20 years, so I’m probably missing something, but if you actually want the house, surely you’d put in an offer, slightly below the asking price. If they accept it, then job done?

AntarcticTern · 12/04/2022 15:58

I would offer £20k (or more!) lower than your previous offer and refuse to budge. If it's a great location and your eyes are open about the potential issues, then it would be silly to let your dislike of the vendors/EA get in the way.

BonnyandPoppy · 12/04/2022 15:52

I would offer 20k under the asking price and be prepared to maybe go up to just under asking. If yoy still like the house and it's in a good location I would go for it.

ReeMee · 12/04/2022 15:50

What pisses me off is estate agents shouldn’t be able to get away with lying.

I asked why previous sales had fallen through and was told ‘we’re not sure, changing financial circumstances.’ I asked if it was due to something found on the survey ‘oh no, we are not aware of any issues on the survey’ they acted completely surprised when I said we had been told we needed a specialist damp survey by the mortgage company. The damp was obvious and if two previous buyers had surveys it would have come up and I’m sure they knew about it!

The change to the law a few years back saying buyers/agents needed to disclose known issues is utterly pointless when they can just say whatever they want.

OP posts:
unname · 12/04/2022 15:50

@ReeMee

Once my DH comes home we will sit down and weigh it all up this evening. If we offer it will be asking price and it will be our best and final.

Our circumstances have changed since we were buying in that DH has gone back to the office after being told he wouldn’t be so we don’t need a home office anymore, this house is 4 bed and we may start looking for a 3 bed instead. We could get a lovely one without work needing doing for 500k.

That said, I still love the house. It is in the best location we could hope for.

I bought a house that had been poorly renovated years ago from shady investors. I loved the house and never regretted it.

If you love it and it suits you, it's worth the extra annoyance. You already know the issues so you won't be fleeced.

Swipe left for the next trending thread