Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not buy their house out of principle?

142 replies

ReeMee · 12/04/2022 12:18

Help me decide what to do?!

In Jan we had an offer accepted on a house. Estate agent told us there was loads of competition and as we’d lost houses in best and final before we ended up bidding 20k over asking. We got it but only because apparently we had sold to first time buyers and the other bidders had longer chains.

House survey was shocking but I know surveys read like horror scripts and we knew from viewing that there would be work needed. When I liaised with estate agent about getting specialists in to quote for work they told me, the vendor has other cash buyers lined up, she will not be taking money off (it’s a probate sale for her parents). Thinking that was our plan. It genuinely wasn’t, we just needed to know the extent of any issues and costs, the house is 500k so not cheap!!

Then on the day of exchange our buyers pulled out. Estate agent/vendor would not wait for us to resell, they put it back on the market that afternoon and have since redone the photos so some of the issues we had been looking at (damp, some cracks) have been covered up with mirrors and pictures (in an empty house!)

2 weeks later we have now resold and the house we were buying is still on the market. I actually rang the estate agents to enquire about it (not telling them who I was) and they said the vendor had had some offers but was looking for close to asking price!! WTF? Now she will accept an offer 20k lower than what we were paying. The cash buyers were clearly a tool to get us paying more and not renegotiating.

I do still love the house (damp and cracks aside) although I think we were overpaying a bit but had come to terms with it not being ours and come to terms with the financial loss (£900ish). I am waiting for the estate agent to phone me once they see our house is SSTC again but I don’t know what to do.

I want to tell them where to go tbh but is that a mistake?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Heythere13 · 15/04/2022 10:19

Principles? House buying?

Every property I have brought or sold - it’s been about two things

  1. Securing the absolute maximum I possibly can given demand for my property. So on one occasion accepting a £10k higher offer the day after accepting an offer.
  1. Securing the best property for the best price. And that has involved negotiation, hard, post survey, to get a reduction in price.

In the world of mumsnet - the above behaviour is criminal!

KarmaStar · 15/04/2022 10:13

Go with your instincts

Username1951 · 15/04/2022 09:57

Get a list of works needed, have them costed and out in an offer with that taken off the asking price. I did that but the offer went to the vendor not the agent, and l got a better house! The only way to do it.
I had a local estate agent tell me that my offer on a probate house was too high! She wanted me to reduce mine - and then a local buddy builder gets it for a steal.

Low lifes most of them, failed used car salesman. NEVER be pressured into buying with that sort of crap. Good luck

masterblaster · 14/04/2022 23:30

@E17Stowmum

The estate agents do not work for you. They work for the vendor.
Lol. The estate agents work for the estate agents.
Mandyjack · 14/04/2022 18:34

Depends how much you like or want it and if anything better has come up. Don't always believe what agents tell you. If you are in a good position again and still really like it going in with an offer close to asking price based on the fact your legal work and survey have more or less been done. Give them a take it or leave it offer

clpsmum · 14/04/2022 12:59

I would offer lower tbh, a considerable amount lower at that

mangipops · 14/04/2022 12:42

Selling a house is a business for many and quick sales are what is preferred. Buyers make an offer, which is then sometimes counter- offered or last bid left on the table. You pulled out - you cannot expect anyone to put their house selling on hold because of that. Don't offer more than what the going price is (which can go down if taking a long time to sell). You are lucky the price has gone down, if you love the house so much, to not go ahead at this point is just cutting your nose to spite your face and will affect you more than the seller who will, no doubt, get an offer sooner or later.

Holdinghnds · 14/04/2022 11:26

I’m not sure why you would need to be concerned about being mucked about later down the line because you had got to the point of exchange with them already. You’ve got an opportunity here to get the house you wanted for a lot less money and without the major emotional energy/stress you had invested in it previously. You are considering cutting your nose off to spite your face and I really think principles don’t come into this. Show me a person who hasn’t had a cross word to say about an estate agent or a vendor (or buyer for that matter). When the house purchase is completed the vendor and estate agent disappear from your view and mean nothing to you so why should they now?!

Frazzled2207 · 14/04/2022 10:43

I wouldn't want to do business with the agent or the vendor.
Even if they accept a lower price there is still potential for mucking about further down the line.

That said if you still like the house you could end up with a good deal here .

Recently bought and sold myself and it's horrid I sympathise. I am pleased that I dealt with reasonable pleasant people on both sides of our chain and we had direct contact with them as the agents were useless. That helped a lot. But I appreciate others might want to deal with it entirely transactionally.

007Stocko · 14/04/2022 10:31

Offer £12k below the asking price, prepared to go to £10k below. If they don't accept it then walk away.

whynotwhatknot · 14/04/2022 10:08

The ea would have wanted it back on straight away all they want is their comission on the sale i doubt it was the vendors choice not to wait

Icantfindmykeys · 14/04/2022 09:07

I was in a similar position stick a low offer in and don’t be pressured. You’ve nearly lost it before so you can now do it without the fear of loss - mentally if that makes sense?
Tell the estate agent you know the issues with the house, you have now got new buyers, had your survey, finance in place you are ready to roll and move quickly. No other buyer will be in such a good position. Tell them you had to drop your price if you want so they can justify to the seller.
Then sit back and wait … it took 3 months and the seller came back to me!
Do you know you can now treat this house purchase in a more ruthless manner!
Do let us know what happens.

Heythere13 · 14/04/2022 08:55

@Brambieblue

House selling & buying generally is a brutal business. It sounds like you want that house. My advice is go for it at its new price. Estate agents don’t care they just want a sale. Just see it as a business transaction. At the same time I would hedge my bets just in case the sale of the property you want does not go through.
Us that’s what happens in RL

But on mumsnet, the biggest purchase of yourself is all about being moral and not negotiating and whatever you offer in the first instance is basically like scrawling in blood.

Brambieblue · 14/04/2022 08:18

House selling & buying generally is a brutal business. It sounds like you want that house. My advice is go for it at its new price. Estate agents don’t care they just want a sale. Just see it as a business transaction. At the same time I would hedge my bets just in case the sale of the property you want does not go through.

nettie434 · 14/04/2022 05:14

I saw that you are going to go for a 3 bed, ReeMee but just wanted to comment on your sentence:

I presume probate is sorted. The owners died over a year ago now.

Actually there have been media reports of long delays in sorting out probate because of Covid. Between the estate agent and the vendor, I think you've had a lucky escape. Not because of the work needed - as you say, damp can be treated and most cracks are not serious - but because either the estate agent and/or vendor seem to be a bit sneaky.

E17Stowmum · 14/04/2022 02:34

The estate agents do not work for you. They work for the vendor.

HouseMoveHell2021 · 13/04/2022 22:23

If its a house uou live, and uouve seen nothing else that ticks your boxes then go for it... but at the lower offer for now...
I paid slightly over the idea for a house that needed a lot if work, but pulled on my heart strings when nothing else did (and tbh, nothing else compares still...) the end goal is a home you love... chance those other buyers never existed (but that would be the estate agents agents anyway.. not the seller) and as it was in probate there may have been multiple people making the call hence the remarket instead if waiting out (I remember the pelarva when my grandmothers house was being sold.... )

Holdinghnds · 13/04/2022 21:11

You wanted that house, you were about to exchange on it. See the positive side of this, you are potentially now going to get it for a lot less!
Think about how much it’s going to cost to do it up, how much you would be comfortable paying for it and also keep in mind that they are clearly marketing it covering up issues which would down value it….ie it isn’t worth £500k, no one has offered near that since it has been re-marketed and they are already telling you they are looking for something less than £500k! I would personally go back to the estate agent with an offer under asking, at least £20k under asking price but if it were me it would be 10% below and see where you get. You are literally ready to buy it, it’s all done. Every house I have known have a sale fall through has sold for less.

Last year I was about to buy a house, my builder uncovered some issues so I reduced my original asking price offer by 4%, they countered with less than 3% off. I felt uncomfortable (1% was a lot of money and there were other reasons) and they put it straight back on the market, sold it straight away…looked it up on the land registry a couple of months ago and they had resold it for 10% below asking. Half of me was glad they paid for being greedy, they knew they’d covered issues up, and half of me was so cross I hadn’t got the house for that lower price.

munner · 13/04/2022 19:57

This is all an negotiation. They played you before, do not let them get away with again. Offer £40k below asking price and demand the right to survey as a starting point.

WotsitsMadeIn1927 · 13/04/2022 19:43

I’ve voted YABU as I think the sellers are greedy and the EA are impatient and rigid. Im on your side and think you could get better and more reasonable for your money

masterblaster · 13/04/2022 19:33

I’d put in an offer 30k cheaper if you aren’t desperate for the house. You are now starting negotiations again and you have no moral compunction to offer the same amount. However, I wouldn’t lose the house if you really want it.

LookingforMaryPoppins · 13/04/2022 19:30

I found myself in exactly the same position that you describe, I too was annoyed that the sellers of the property we were buying put it straight back on the market rather than giving us some time. We actually received another offer within a day or two of going back on the market - I made a new and lower offer on the house we were buying (but had been put back on the market) on the basis that our new buyers had offered less (they hadn't) - lower offer was accepted and sale went through.

Had the sellers have given us some time to find a new buyer I would have paid the original offer - as they didn't, I felt no guilt in offering less.

You have nothing to lose doing the same.... If they accept you get the house cheaper, if they don't you can find a smaller house as planned.

Good luck

CrankyFrankie · 13/04/2022 19:24

I know you’ve pretty much settled on your plan of action but all I would say is don’t be put off by the EA. By definition, EAs have no soul. The only way they can sleep at night? On a bed of money. Chances are, wherever you end up buying, you will be dealing with a weasel for an EA. On the other hand, you could enjoy your relative position of power now and enjoy teaching them a lesson! But only if it were the right house for you, which, tbf sounds like maybe it’s not anymore.

Yayhelen · 13/04/2022 18:46

If you really like the house re-offer at asking now you have sold, if they query just say it’s because they didn’t show any goodwill in allowing you in to assess required work or give you a grace period to get a new buyer. If they reject then your in the same position as now. If they accept then the delay has saved you £20k that sounds like it will come in handy.

DonaPatrizia · 13/04/2022 18:31

You obviously don't feel comfortable doing this major transaction with them, so don't. There are plenty of other houses.

(If it really is your dream home, then go for it though because you would soon forget all this. But I think if this were the case, you wouldn't be on here asking.)

Swipe left for the next trending thread