Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think having kids is brutal

231 replies

Peachypear10 · 12/04/2022 12:16

My impression of raising children is that it's a long, horrible slog where every day for 18+ years is spent sacrificing all your time, energy, money and identity, and being exhausted, stressed, duty bound and miserable. That's generally the impression I get from MN.

I have several friends who have young kids (the kids are mostly all aged around 5 or under). Every single mum is on (or has been on) antidepressants long term, they don't sleep, are frequently ill with bad colds or bugs, are stressed and anxious all the time, and are always struggling financially. They all complain of existing in a non stop, exhausted haze of satisfying their children 24/7, while trying to hold down a job. And also desperately trying to maintain functioning relationships with partners, ex partners, family, friends etc.

I'm mid 30s and quite a way off being stable enough (money and living situation wise) to have a family. Wondering whether to just ditch the idea altogether rather than knocking my pan out over the next few years to set up all the foundations, (affording a home suitable for a family, etc) only in order to have a further soul destroying couple of decades. And especially when children have such a tough time now, need financial support well into adulthood, and the world is basically burning...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Maggie178 · 16/04/2022 06:28

If you can't see any positives you don't have to have children. It really is your choice

SmellyOldOwls · 15/04/2022 23:10

Children are ace. What would I do without mine, sit and watch Netflix all day probably. Anything you want to do, go to the beach, a farm, literally anything you've got a wee friend there who really wants to do it with you. Then you get to cuddle them and love them and watch them grow and help them to learn. My oldest is learning to read and write at the minute and I'm like wow I created him out of nowhere and now he can read and everything. Love it.

Peachypear10 · 15/04/2022 22:42

@ChampagneLassie

New mum age 39, writing during night feed. I was put off motherhood for years by generally only hearing the negative stuff, not least from my own mother and not knowing anyone who gave me a role model that I could aspire to. Fast forward and all my friends have children and I've seen the highs too and now I'm blessed with my own. It's harder than I imagined on a practical level but the love I feel for her and sense of satisfaction is unparalleled and I wish I'd done this years ago.
Yes, it probably doesn't help when you've been raised by parents who are negative about it all. My mum was deeply unhappy as a SAHM and my dad told me constantly throughout my childhood, and still to this day, that if he had his time again, he wouldn't have kids. My parents have never raised the topic of grandkids because they don't really want them! Would hate to regret having kids as much as they seem to.
OP posts:
sjxoxo · 15/04/2022 17:02

@TortugaRumCakeQueen wow you sound like you had a tough time of it. Your first labour sounds a lot like mine. I haven’t had number two but I’d 100% do a C section again to avoid the faff of ‘natural’ birth again.. I found a c sec easier to deal with tbh! Hats off to you for taking the plunge with a second 😅 I’m not there yet!! X

Sponge19 · 15/04/2022 09:59

@TortugaRumCakeQueen had you done much prep beforehand, like hypnobirthing or anything?

macaronipenguinn · 15/04/2022 09:11

@RelativePitch

It is hard work, but so joyful. My DSs are 12 and 10, so I am in the sweet spot years and they make me laugh to the point I can't breathe. They're so funny. My DM only lives a mile up the road and is obsessed with them, she is their third parent. DM has always had them overnight most weeks from the time they were newborns. Just packed them off with bottles of EBM and caught up on sleep. So good support is crucial to take the edge off how hard it can be. I was also lucky enough to be a SAHM for many years so I didn't have the stress of work in the mix.
Sometimes parents die, so their being 'crucial' is a fallacy. You just crack on with it.
macaronipenguinn · 15/04/2022 09:10

@Mjfdrjjbf

It can be hard work and relentless (and adds in a load more admin) but I think my kids are incredible little people. I’m with *@macaronipenguinn* - my kid who has learning disabilities is also bloody brilliant. Nothing brings joy like a child meeting a milestone when you can’t take it for granted that they will, and knowing just how hard they’ve worked to get there. She makes me laugh and love incredibly hard. She’s brought a whole world of amazing people into my life. Even with the things people immediately imagine with disability - we spend more time in hospital than I’d like, I have to advocate for her more loudly than I’d like, I’d love to take more for granted and I know that being financially secure makes things a whole lot easier - she brings way more to my life than she takes.
I would choose my life with my son every single time over whatever alternative life was offered me. He's made me a better person and I am eternally in his debt for that.
TortugaRumCakeQueen · 15/04/2022 09:04

Childbirth shocked me to my core. I had no idea it would be SO painful. First birth, I just couldn't get the baby out. Labour went on for 20+ hours, tried forceps, he just wouldn't budge. Ended up with an emergency C section. Couldn't walk for weeks afterwards without being in agony. The second birth, I was only in labour for 6 hours - no time for any pain relief and I honestly thought I was going to die. I've no idea why something "natural" would be so painful.

RelativePitch · 15/04/2022 09:01

It is hard work, but so joyful. My DSs are 12 and 10, so I am in the sweet spot years and they make me laugh to the point I can't breathe. They're so funny. My DM only lives a mile up the road and is obsessed with them, she is their third parent. DM has always had them overnight most weeks from the time they were newborns. Just packed them off with bottles of EBM and caught up on sleep. So good support is crucial to take the edge off how hard it can be. I was also lucky enough to be a SAHM for many years so I didn't have the stress of work in the mix.

Fairislefandango · 15/04/2022 08:50

'Brutal' doesn't describe my experience of parenthood at all. Childbirth is brutal. Early weeks of having a newborn are pretty tough. Apart from that it's been pretty easy for me. It depends massively on your personal situation, your health and whether your children turn out to have any major health issues or additional needs though.

sjxoxo · 15/04/2022 08:41

I’ll add that I think my opinion is biased as I am in the hardest part where baby can’t communicate yet etc and newborns are so utterly dependent on you - I am sure the load will ease slightly for me in terms of worry when he grows a bit/can move about a bit himself! I long for a 3 year old haha x

sjxoxo · 15/04/2022 08:31

Agree it’s brutal. I’m only a few months in, there are big moments of joy and happiness but it is unrelenting work and unpaid. I would never have one if I thought there was a reasonable chance I’d end up a single parent with young baby/child. Even being able to give the baby to someone else for 30 mins at the end of the day is essential for my mental health!! Doing it all alone would be hell on earth for me and I think I’d have a breakdown. Also having someone else to share ‘The Worry’ with. I couldn’t have a head full of questions and worry as a single parent. Id absolutely recommend being in a solid solid marriage before you take the plunge and having as much security as you can, If you decide to have a bub xo

TortugaRumCakeQueen · 15/04/2022 08:27

I'm mid 30s and quite a way off being stable enough (money and living situation wise) to have a family

Are you male or female? Female fertility decreases drastically at 35.

Whoopsies · 15/04/2022 07:14

I do find that a lot of parent give off this vibe, I'm never sure how true it is of their experience or if they are just talking the talk. But it's not my experience at all. Having 2 children has been the best thing I've ever done. I genuinely enjoy it every day, my kids are my favourite company and its made my marriage so much richer and more fulfilled.

liveforsummer · 15/04/2022 06:40

As I said Brutal means so much more than hard at times, plus OP has no dc so not criticising her experience in anyway and hers is a pre conception not an experience!

interest12 · 15/04/2022 06:37

That messaging was all I heard before I had my baby at 39. It seems some sort of competition between certain mothers over how hard their life is.
When I finally took the plunge I entirely expected a gruelling (yet rewarding) experience. That said, it’s been great. My 7 month old does need my attention but it’s been an entirely positive experience & going through it myself I’m astounded at how so many parents absolutely break down over quite simple tasks. I think it has much to do with your personality. So many parents seem entirely neurotic & those are the ones that can’t core and don’t enjoy it. I don’t say this to shame anyone but rather provide an alternative view to all the negativity that’s dumped on women considering whether to have a child.
However I am one and done and was always going to be. I can see how having more would get harder to find balance.

Dairymilk50 · 15/04/2022 06:37

@liveforsummer

I'm not criticising anything. I'm responding directly to the points in the OP where she said things like everyone has or is on anti depressants. I'd not have mention that if it were not in the OP.
Brutal? Goodness, no. That's incredibly dramatic.

Yes you were. You also continued to question what brutal meant despite knowing what OP meant... then you went on to say OP meant much more than hard. Perhaps some feel differently to you we can't all be a TA it's unrealistic however obtuse you want to be. We are have different valid experiences.

Mjfdrjjbf · 15/04/2022 06:35

It can be hard work and relentless (and adds in a load more admin) but I think my kids are incredible little people. I’m with @macaronipenguinn - my kid who has learning disabilities is also bloody brilliant. Nothing brings joy like a child meeting a milestone when you can’t take it for granted that they will, and knowing just how hard they’ve worked to get there. She makes me laugh and love incredibly hard. She’s brought a whole world of amazing people into my life. Even with the things people immediately imagine with disability - we spend more time in hospital than I’d like, I have to advocate for her more loudly than I’d like, I’d love to take more for granted and I know that being financially secure makes things a whole lot easier - she brings way more to my life than she takes.

liveforsummer · 15/04/2022 06:29

I'm not criticising anything. I'm responding directly to the points in the OP where she said things like everyone has or is on anti depressants. I'd not have mention that if it were not in the OP.

Dairymilk50 · 15/04/2022 06:25

@liveforsummer

Surely sharing experiences is the only way to know if everyone thinks it's brutal? While I'm she didn't mean that it definitely suggests much more than 'hard'. Not that I'd choose hard as the main descriptor either. Hard at times of course but so are parts of child free life too.
Your contradicting yourself you speak upon sharing... yet your being unkind and nit picking on OTHERS experiences. YOU have stated several times you have not found it hard at times and YOU continue to brag how you don't take anti depressants...

Is that really necessary? Nobody said you can't share it's you who is critising here

workingmomlife · 15/04/2022 06:23

It's worth every second

I haven't slept in weeks as my twins are going through sleep depression

I have no money

I have no time

I wouldn't change it for the world.

Pompom2367 · 15/04/2022 06:15

There are brutal moments but they are all worth it most people are likely to complain about the bad things rather than boast about the good bits yes sometimes you are exhausted and want to scream or hide but even on the hard days they are 100% worth it somedays I'm dying for DD and DSS bed time but then when they are in bed I miss them

EdgeOfACoin · 15/04/2022 06:06

@ChampagneLassie

New mum age 39, writing during night feed. I was put off motherhood for years by generally only hearing the negative stuff, not least from my own mother and not knowing anyone who gave me a role model that I could aspire to. Fast forward and all my friends have children and I've seen the highs too and now I'm blessed with my own. It's harder than I imagined on a practical level but the love I feel for her and sense of satisfaction is unparalleled and I wish I'd done this years ago.
Yes, I'm in the same situation.

Only ever seemed to hear the negative stuff.

Six months in I am loving having a child. Genuinely wish I'd started a family sooner.

liveforsummer · 15/04/2022 06:03

Surely sharing experiences is the only way to know if everyone thinks it's brutal? While I'm she didn't mean that it definitely suggests much more than 'hard'. Not that I'd choose hard as the main descriptor either. Hard at times of course but so are parts of child free life too.

Dairymilk50 · 15/04/2022 05:59

@liveforsummer yes I know what brutal means I doubt OP meant violent and cruel do you? That's nice you have shared your experience though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread