Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Panorama( Young families Struggling)

413 replies

dottydodah · 12/04/2022 11:12

Did anyone see this last evening? A lady with 2 small DC and a husband working as a Research Scientist was struggling with bills .Another young Mum in tears as her energy bill was so high.A third lady (working as a Nurse) not able to run a car. How will they manage to keep going? Surely Govt could do more?

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 13/04/2022 12:19

@MissyB1

£80 a week is not bad if all bills are paid for

Right so that will cover
Petrol to get to work
Car maintenance
Car insurance
House insurance
General house maintenance
Kids school uniforms/clothes
Kids shoes
School lunches
School expenses (day trips, swimming, mufti days etc)
All groceries
Mums clothes / shoes
Emergencies like washing machine breaking down

Really you think so?

I felt so bad for the poor bloke who had filled his car up and it cost £80 and he said well that's a days wages gone.
MissyB1 · 13/04/2022 12:01

£80 a week is not bad if all bills are paid for

Right so that will cover
Petrol to get to work
Car maintenance
Car insurance
House insurance
General house maintenance
Kids school uniforms/clothes
Kids shoes
School lunches
School expenses (day trips, swimming, mufti days etc)
All groceries
Mums clothes / shoes
Emergencies like washing machine breaking down

Really you think so?

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 13/04/2022 11:53

Also the nurse has a mortgage and they said "after paying her mortgage and bills she has £80 a week left". £80 a week may not be masses but it is not that bad if all bills are paid what planet are you living on £80 for a family to eat from- what if a child needs something for school or has a birthday. Seriously this isn’t £80 left after putting savings aside.

mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 11:49

I have just watched the programme and did feel very sorry for the young mum whose partner we did not see.

I can understand that although they get just over £2,000 a month they are struggling, mainly because they are renting. Rents are just so expensive.

The couple in Wales have a mortgage though and houses are pretty cheap in Wales so doubt their mortgage can be that much. We weren't told what else they are spending their money on apart from fuel for the motorbike and car.

Also the nurse has a mortgage and they said "after paying her mortgage and bills she has £80 a week left". £80 a week may not be masses but it is not that bad if all bills are paid.

These sorts of programmes never tell us what actual outgoings the people have. Have they got debts? Are they paying a lot each month for a phone, full Sky package or what?

desiringonlychild2022 · 13/04/2022 11:32

@mydogisthebest food and charity shop clothes don't cost very much... If you are struggling with that, you would be struggling either way.. they account for maybe 10% of my outgoings and we are not high earners at all (6% of our combined income with DH's new job). Even if you doubled it, it would be 20% and you shouldn't spend more than 30% of income on housing (sadly not the case for many people).

If you struggle with food now, it's appalling unless you are feeding an army. It's why it makes the news because food is not expensive. but yet people are struggling. Housing in cities and the SE is expensive esp family sized housing. Eating out is expensive. Holidays can be expensive. But not supermarket food from Lidl and Aldi. Even if inflation hits 10%. I feel so sad that people are struggling.

mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 10:26

@desiringonlychild2022 absolute rubbish to say "if you can't afford to feed 3 kids, you can't afford to feed 1". Of course 3 cost more than 1. Not just in food but also in clothes. Only so many clothes can be handed down, particularly if all the children are not the same sex.

Also child care will cost more for 3 than 1.

desiringonlychild2022 · 13/04/2022 10:05

@Porcupineintherough why not just have 1 then.you fulfil your biological instinct and it's the cheapest option.

Worth noting it's not just China who was trying to control population size. Many Asian countries were trying to encourage parents to stop at 2, but weren't so heavy-handed. But it was when average families ranged from 4-7 kids. Having 3 kids as opposed to 2 kids isn't really going to make a huge difference.

desiringonlychild2022 · 13/04/2022 10:00

@Angelswithflirtyfaces well said.

Sorry peeps, no matter how rich you are, you are likely to end up in diapers at some point. If there isn't enough staff to change your diapers because they can't afford to get to work or it doesn't pay to work or they don't have childcare that enables them to work, you are going to be demented, sitting there in your crap and there is little anyone can do about it. The only way you can get out of it is maybe moving abroad to a place with cheaper labour (but probably away from your kids).

Ditto with any medical treatment you need. And no private healthcare is not a get out of jail free card. I have private healthcare and they will refer to NHS if they don't think they can deal with it.

Porcupineintherough · 13/04/2022 09:59

its not like it costs triple to feed 3 kids than to feed 1

No but it more than doubles it. It's a mumsnet myth that a third child makes no difference, you'll manage somehow, bullshit, bullshit. 3 children is a really expensive life choice.

Angelswithflirtyfaces · 13/04/2022 09:52

Stories like this poor nurse will affect us all over time.
If this is happening all over the UK we will be left with more health problems and even more strain on the NHS.
Warm well fed people are healthy people.
Physical and mental health as a nation will decline, malnourishment, hypothermia, infections. Sickness from work, school it all has a domino effect.
These families are older peoples workers, carers etc in years to come and its awful.
None of us have asked to be plunged into poverty. This woman ( who a lot of you were clapping for like seals on your doorsteps) has risked her health, risked getting long covid to stay in work and now is in poverty.
How easily you all forget when she is seen as a burden.
She could be getting universal credit to work in Tescos and prop up a huge profit making organisation, would that be preferable?
The smug ones on here will be affected very soon when they need medical treatment, but the system is so over burdened with sick poor people it will take months.
It will affect them when crimes if all kinds soar and their band D council tax trebles to cope with the costs associated with policing and law and order.
It will affect them when we descend into a totally divided society of awful human beings with zero empathy that think its ok for a celeb to spend 3 million on a wedding when kids starve.
A sexist government where women are punished for having kids having to juggle working with unafforable childcare that leaves them poor.
This corrupt sleazy government has done this and the smug ones stand shoulder to shoulder with them.

desiringonlychild2022 · 13/04/2022 09:51

Why have 2- people struggle with 2 kids.

People struggle with 1 kid..honestly for people in poverty, if you can't afford to feed 3 kids, you can't afford to feed 1 and probably yourselves as well. It's not like it costs triple to feed 3 kids as opposed to 1 kid, there is economies of scale. It's why some singles' weekly shop is £40 but a small family can be £60-70. If you are short because of extra £20, you are going to struggle either way.

People who choose to stop at one (like me) do so because they want to give each child their own room (which in London can add 200-300k to the price of a flat/house, or the cost of loft conversion), cost of holidays i.e. long haul flight tickets, cost of activities, cost of funding university/private school as well as perhaps wanting more free time and other reasons unrelated to finances (for example wanting to start a family later). None of these are that material to low income households. With the exception of childcare but low income families get support with childcare and free hours at an earlier age. Plus if there is any sort of age gap, it wouldn't be 3 on full childcare as at least 1 would be in school full time..

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 13/04/2022 09:20

[quote mydogisthebest]**@Cosmos123 But if she only had 2 children she would only have to pay for childcare for 2 which, obviously, would be less than for 3.

In the picture in the paper one of the children (probably the eldest) didn't look that young so not sure they need child care.

Yes she likely was in a relationship when she had the children but, I ask again, why have 3?

Everyone with a brain knows circumstances can change so don't take on more than you are likely to be able to cope with.

My circumstances did change in that I was unable to work but we coped because we were sensible.[/quote]
Why have 2- people struggle with 2 kids. People judge having 3 because they don’t want 3, because with 2 your children have a sibling

mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 09:13

@Cosmos123 But if she only had 2 children she would only have to pay for childcare for 2 which, obviously, would be less than for 3.

In the picture in the paper one of the children (probably the eldest) didn't look that young so not sure they need child care.

Yes she likely was in a relationship when she had the children but, I ask again, why have 3?

Everyone with a brain knows circumstances can change so don't take on more than you are likely to be able to cope with.

My circumstances did change in that I was unable to work but we coped because we were sensible.

Eviebeans · 13/04/2022 09:08

The government should make tackling the situation regarding absent fathers a priority. I don't think that is the only situation where people are struggling though. Two people working full time should mean having a reasonable standard of living for themselves and their family.

PopOfNothing · 13/04/2022 09:03

@MsDataPotata

When my lot were little I'd do anything for extra cash. Sit up all night packing cards into cellophane sleeves, other peoples ironing, online surveys, literally anything so I didn't have to choose between buying nappies & food. It was the lowest point of my life, I remember the feelings of desperation & exhaustion really vividly. The thought that 20 years later, mothers are still having the same struggle, makes my blood boil.
Same here, I was a single mum for many years after my DH died and DD was very much a breadline child. I was lucky in that I had a degree in accounting which meant I was able to audit / tax refunds for local clubs / organisations books a few times a year in exchange for food vouchers. I would always leave the food voucher for a rainy day. I worked all day and the last thing I wanted to do in the evening was more work but my god it was a godsend when I had unexpected bills. This was 10-20 years ago too. I really feel for those families, it wasnt easy back then but it was survivable, no way would I have made ends meet today.

I did it tough financially but I was lucky enough in that my parents which relatively wealthy, I never relied on them for money but my parents bailed me out a couple of times when I was truly desperate and they spoilt my DD at birthdays / christmasses.

My best wishes are going out to everyone who is struggling.

SandysMam · 13/04/2022 08:57

I think the young mum did have a partner, he was a warehouse manager, I imagine he just didn’t want to appear on film.

Porcupineintherough · 13/04/2022 08:53

@Eviebeans maybe the government should tackle it first rather than jumping in to fill the gap with benefits, just so some man somewhere can dodge his responsibilities. Other countries take a far harder line on this and we should too.

LauriePartridge4Eva · 13/04/2022 08:51

@ExplodingElephants

This was so sad. I assumed that the two single mum’s weren’t getting maintenance either as it was never mentioned. If so, that’s shameful that ‘men’ are leaving their exes high and dry like that. I remember as a kid seeing my mum missing meals and the cupboards being bare and it’s bloody awful for kids. I felt so sad for the kids knowing how dire things were. The nurse mum looked so thin.

It leaves scars that can never be healed. I grew up in poverty and have a fear of empty cupboards. My fridge has got to have food in it at all times. I horde toiletries as well, because we never had any and my hygiene as a child was terrible. I will probably never not be like this,

LauriePartridge4Eva · 13/04/2022 08:47

@mathanxiety

With choices come responsibilities...

Except if you're a man. If you're a man you can walk away from your responsibilities. Nobody will mind. Boys will be boys after all.

Everyone will tut tut the woman for having children though (virgin births apparently) and expect her to work as many 12 hour shifts as she can pick up to pay for them.

Fecking well said!

Eviebeans · 13/04/2022 08:37

I absolutely agree about absent fathers needing to pay their fair contribution. A contribution that takes account of what it takes to properly take care of a child. However in the meantime there are children who are growing ip in less than ideal circumstances. The nurse and her family struck me as a situation where a little help (from government) would go a long way and make a big difference.

Porcupineintherough · 13/04/2022 08:29

@ExplodingElephants that's kind of the point (or at least a point) though. Why wasnt the lack of a paternal contribution mentioned? I mean, maybe the children's fathers are dead but more likely theyve left. Are they contributing to theirupkerp, and if do, how much?. Most maintenance payments are woefully low. We should be talking about this.

Binjob118 · 13/04/2022 08:25

@Mumofsend

The tory government simply do not care. Only solution is to vote them out in 2024
Unfortunately it looks like Labour would do very little to help. Shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves was asked if she would increase pay for nurses etc, she said no.
ExplodingElephants · 13/04/2022 08:23

@Mumofsend

The tory government simply do not care. Only solution is to vote them out in 2024
Second post in and already Tory bashing. What did Labour do that was so amazing?
ExplodingElephants · 13/04/2022 08:22

This was so sad. I assumed that the two single mum’s weren’t getting maintenance either as it was never mentioned. If so, that’s shameful that ‘men’ are leaving their exes high and dry like that. I remember as a kid seeing my mum missing meals and the cupboards being bare and it’s bloody awful for kids. I felt so sad for the kids knowing how dire things were. The nurse mum looked so thin.

ChiswickFlo · 13/04/2022 08:13

@Fluffyslippersohyes

Re the phone/Internet thing. I think modern life is tailored to having an Internet connection. It is nigh on impossible to apply for a job, benefit, do research for homework or bank without the Internet. Yes there's libraries but so much more convenient to have a smart phone or tablet. I find it annoying when people think a smartphone is a luxury. Yes 20 years ago they were, yes top of the range ones every year are but not a low tariff or an old phone. I think you need it to carry out even simple tasks.
No library where I live! Public transport not reliable Very few shops and only grocery store is a co op (expensive) Please don't assume everyone lives with was access to libraries, good transport links and choice of shops