Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Panorama( Young families Struggling)

413 replies

dottydodah · 12/04/2022 11:12

Did anyone see this last evening? A lady with 2 small DC and a husband working as a Research Scientist was struggling with bills .Another young Mum in tears as her energy bill was so high.A third lady (working as a Nurse) not able to run a car. How will they manage to keep going? Surely Govt could do more?

OP posts:
Mookie81 · 13/04/2022 17:39

@sjxoxo

What’s shocking is we still have an elected Tory government. Poverty is a political choice & as many pp’s have said; the Conservative party do not give a f* about normal people. There’s a reason politics isn’t compulsory at school - if everyone understood the system we are all in, they’d never vote conservative. For capitalism to work; you must have poor people. I’m not advocating extreme socialism, but it’s an outrage and un-humanitarian this is the state of the UK in 2022. Please consider alternatives to the Conservative party xo
I 100% agree, children at private school are taught this stuff, children in state schools are not, they are made overcrowded and the curriculum is stuffed with so much crap, and stuff the government should be dealing with, so we have no time to teach the kids any of it. Which leaves a vast amount of people getting their 'knowledge' from right wing rags who make it their business to misinform and divert people from the real problem at hand.
MissyB1 · 13/04/2022 17:38

Ok so these people just weren’t trying hard enough to be successful at being poor - righty ho naughty them 🙄🙄

lemmein · 13/04/2022 17:38

What has happened to this country? I can't even watch the news anymore, it just frustrates me.

The lack of empathy is astonishing, it really is.

I'll accept the excuses of 'global fuel prices' and now the war in Ukraine as reasons for children going hungry when the rich are impacted too - don't tell me nothing can be done when those at the top have become significantly richer in the last 12 years whilst those at the bottom have been crippled with austerity/covid/brexit. Seriously? Fuck off.^^ Poverty is a political choice.

Absolutely shameful that we accept this.

And whilst we're discussing whether the nurse was unreasonable not being able to predict the future when she had her third child - can we remember Boris Johnson abandons his sperm all over the fucking joint? His child-count is at least double that nurses - he's added (at least) two to his brood during the pandemic alone. Then he lectures everyone else about climate change Hmm seriously fuck fuck fuck off!!!

mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 17:34

@RedHelenB my next door neighbour is a nurse and she doesn't work 12 hour shifts so not all nurses do

mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 17:33

[quote MissyB1]@mydogisthebest
No not all people in low incomes or who are struggling get free school meals, that’s a common misconception. You see I was that struggling single parent nurse once. I didn’t tried to get help, I asked for help with my rent and for school dinners, got turned down for both. Got shouted at by ds headteacher because I couldn’t afford the charge for school swimming or day trips. I was told parents like me spoilt it for all the kids because the school might have to cancel those things altogether.
And my kids were dressed in clothes my colleagues donated from their kids. Don’t you think kids might like something new sometimes though? Or do you think that’s cheeky and entitled?
And no you can’t “eat cheaply” if you don’t have the money in the first place. Can I also point out that if you don’t have a car you can’t bulk buy, so you pay more than people who have transport.
It’s easy to blame the poor for being poor.[/quote]
I wasn't sure about school meals but I know my neighbours' children get free meals and both parents work full time.

You can eat cheaply if you eat things like lentils, chickpeas, beans etc. Me and DH are vegetarian and the majority of our meals are made with these. We eat tasty meals which also happen to be pretty cheap.

You can bulk buy if you get your shopping delivered. I quite often get shopping delivered and the most I have ever paid for delivery is £2. Usually it is £1 or even free.

Secondhand clothes are still "new" to a child and you can often get items that look unworn in charity shops. Or, as I said, shops like Asda, Primark, Morrisons have childrens clothes dirt cheap.

I guess older children may not like the idea of secondhand clothes. It's never bothered me - had secondhand clothes as a child and am quite happy to still have them now. Most brand new clothes for adults are silly prices that I am not prepared to pay.

Blossomtoes · 13/04/2022 17:28

@Eviebeans

What very sad, mean little lives we seem happy to think are okay. The cheapest food (not to mention lack of nutritional value) everything 2nd hand. No money to do sport or leisure activities. Cant afford to have friends round for tea. Not able to heat your home. Where's the joy in that? My god I must give myself a good shake - I think I'm going soft in my old age.
Amen to that. I don’t think I’m going soft in my old age. Having struggled in the late 70s as a single parent I’ve always hated seeing other people go through it.

That poor nurse who has £80 a week had to spend 35% of it on new school shoes. I bet there was a lot of beans on toast that week. It’s shocking.

RedHelenB · 13/04/2022 17:22

@Smileyaxolotl1

I don’t doubt that it is going to be very difficult for people with rising fuel and food prices but the nurse worked 3 days a week. It’s not surprising that she couldn’t run a household on that few hours and as usual no sign of a man anywhere to support the three kids.

And the idea that the people are worse off than miners in the 20s? Do you realise how dumb you sound? I’m sure if miners had been spending money on cars, internet, trainers, take aways etc then they would have been hungry too rather than on a couple of bits of coal and some meat and vegetables.
Unfortunately there are far more things that we all see as essential now which take up large parts of our income and the difference is that we don’t expect to have to live frugally like they accepted then. Things like internet and phones have become essentials.

Exactly, essentials now are different. Very hard to cope without a mobile phone and InternetA nurse working 3 days would be 36 hours as they work 12 hour shifts, so actually that's nearly full time.
desiringonlychild2022 · 13/04/2022 17:11

Our household income ranks in the top 9-15% of the country according to IFS. We have no car and no children. We live in London but our mortgage is 23% of after tax income so that is well within parameters suggested by most financial advisors.. we are cutting back i.e. always bringing lunch to work and having small bites in restaurants rather than full blown meals (which we used to do twice a week). Buying the majority of groceries at Lidl with only a few purchases at Waitrose. I buy more of my clothes second hand these days.

So yes while 10% of the country has more money than me, they also probably have larger homes to maintain (I am in a 2 bed flat), cars and kids so would have larger outgoings so I think most people would be cutting back even if in top 5%. Of course a large percentage of wealth is derived from assets rather than traditional income and maybe older people may have savings and investments that fund their lifestyles (and zero mortgage) so they are in a better position. This is not reflected in the IFS figures. Which may explain all the shopping and holidays that people seem to be indulging in despite the cost of living crisis.

But for people who derive their income solely from work and small business owners, I do things will get harder

Ireolu · 13/04/2022 15:52

Our energy bills have gone up by 200/month. I am not surprised ppl are struggling. We earn well but will need to look very closely at all our outgoings in the coming months and will need to save less to cover the bills. Its a mess.

mathanxiety · 13/04/2022 15:31

Are they paying a lot each month for a phone...?

The basic assumption behind that comment is that the poor are both stupid and feckless.

I am right that society has not progressed or become in any way enlightened since the days of the workhouse.

AnneElliott · 13/04/2022 15:10

I felt for all of those families. But I did wonder where the father was of the single parent. I think we as a country should properly clamp down on men (and yes it's usually men) who don't provide for their children.

How many kids could we lift out of poverty if we actually made those blokes find their children?

MissyB1 · 13/04/2022 14:49

@Eviebeans

What very sad, mean little lives we seem happy to think are okay. The cheapest food (not to mention lack of nutritional value) everything 2nd hand. No money to do sport or leisure activities. Cant afford to have friends round for tea. Not able to heat your home. Where's the joy in that? My god I must give myself a good shake - I think I'm going soft in my old age.
Yes it totally depresses me the amount of people saying that kind of basic existence should be all poor people should want. They should be absolutely fine with that, and if they aren’t - well how very dare they the cheeky feckers!!

God forbid we should demand any better for those who are struggling in our society. Oh no! They might forget their place!

Eviebeans · 13/04/2022 14:37

What very sad, mean little lives we seem happy to think are okay.
The cheapest food (not to mention lack of nutritional value) everything 2nd hand. No money to do sport or leisure activities. Cant afford to have friends round for tea. Not able to heat your home.
Where's the joy in that?
My god I must give myself a good shake - I think I'm going soft in my old age.

SickAndTiredAgain · 13/04/2022 14:20

These sorts of programmes never tell us what actual outgoings the people have. Have they got debts? Are they paying a lot each month for a phone, full Sky package or what?

Actually, right at the start it showed a spreadsheet with the Welsh family’s outgoings. I didn’t examine it but you could see it had pretty cheap phone contracts, and it looked like just Netflix and bt internet for entertainment stuff (but it only came up very quickly, but you could pause it if so inclined).

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 13/04/2022 14:06

Mum would not need to buy clothes or shoes very often. I rarely buy clothes or shoes and when I do I buy in charity shops or from ebay so very cheap.Childrens clothes are cheap in places like Asda, Primary, charity shops this is fine for young children- my 14yr old nephew is in Medium mens and has a size 11 shoe.
As for free school dinners - the threshold is ridiculously low

vivainsomnia · 13/04/2022 14:02

The whole conversation is so pointless. 'Bills' mean nothing, everyone has different definition of what bills are.

For me it's everything that NEEDS to be paid, so of course that includes food, even essential clothes, insurance, clubs etc....

In this case, £80 a week to have at leisure is very reasonable. I certainly had less than that.

If the £80 left is only after mortgage and gas and electricity, then yes, it's clearly a problem.

Then there's everything in between.

Hortensiateapot · 13/04/2022 14:01

Money was tight for coal miners post war (filling up on homegrown potatoes, second hand clothes, no holidays, no sick pay etc) but my grandparents had a council house in walking distance of the pit and free coal from the colliery so that’s three big inflationary costs they didn’t need to worry about. The cost squeeze on housing and fuel/energy is the real kicker these days, however much people try to cut back on discretionary spending.

LakieLady · 13/04/2022 13:48

@dottydodah

Blossomtoes I know .it just smacks of them and us situation .We are not wealthy but managing OK with a sensible budget . Thing is one ladies bill was going up by £50 pm! how is this even possible?
My MIL's monthly payment for her electricity (all-electric house) has gone up from £120 pcm to £260 pcm.

She's a pensioner, in her early 80s and on pension credit. Luckily, 2 of her children are very well off and will help her out, but that payment is around a third of her monthly income.

Angelswithflirtyfaces · 13/04/2022 13:42

@mydogisthebest I earn the equivilant of a nurses salary. For full time now with fuel, NI hikes, pension and tax I lose a day and a halfs wages. I dont have childcare thank goodness. If she was given a better pay rise ( same as our wonderful, hard working non partying M.Ps got) didnt have to pay for parking at work or prohibitally expensive childcare maybe she could actually afford to go full time?
Its very easy to make everything so black and white behind a keyboard but she is a person, with a life and I am guessing she matters very much to some people.
She could of course go on benefits altogether, not use her skills, get her rent paid etc. Is that preferable to a life of working poverty?

MissyB1 · 13/04/2022 13:41

@mydogisthebest
No not all people in low incomes or who are struggling get free school meals, that’s a common misconception. You see I was that struggling single parent nurse once. I didn’t tried to get help, I asked for help with my rent and for school dinners, got turned down for both. Got shouted at by ds headteacher because I couldn’t afford the charge for school swimming or day trips. I was told parents like me spoilt it for all the kids because the school might have to cancel those things altogether.
And my kids were dressed in clothes my colleagues donated from their kids. Don’t you think kids might like something new sometimes though? Or do you think that’s cheeky and entitled?
And no you can’t “eat cheaply” if you don’t have the money in the first place. Can I also point out that if you don’t have a car you can’t bulk buy, so you pay more than people who have transport.
It’s easy to blame the poor for being poor.

mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 13:14

@DuvetHugger

houses are pretty cheap in Wales so doubt their mortgage can be that much

you are wrong

Really? So how much do you reckon their house cost and how much would that mortgage be?

Houses are, on the whole, much cheaper in Wales than in other parts of the country.

I know people who live in houses in Kent, Essex and St. Albans. None of their mortgages are very expensive because of the low interest rates

mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 13:11

@Angelswithflirtyfaces

Lovely to see people condemning her in case she has any luxuries or god forbid a basic sky package. Maybe she should go to work come home and huddle under a blanket with candle? Since when did we all sign up to live in Dickensian Britain again. She is a professional working woman I am pretty sure this is not the life she envisaged for herself having undergone years of training? No one knows when our circumstances could change but people quibbling over a few treats is just shite.
What I *@actually* said was that we were not told what other spending they were making.

There is a pretty big difference in price between the basic Sky package and the full film, sport etc package although even the basic one is a rip off.

If she can't manage she needs to work full time and not part time. 3 days a week is a luxury most cannot afford

mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 13:05

@MissyB1

£80 a week is not bad if all bills are paid for

Right so that will cover
Petrol to get to work
Car maintenance
Car insurance
House insurance
General house maintenance
Kids school uniforms/clothes
Kids shoes
School lunches
School expenses (day trips, swimming, mufti days etc)
All groceries
Mums clothes / shoes
Emergencies like washing machine breaking down

Really you think so?

She didn't have a car. She said that, only a bike.

So no petrol, no car maintenance, no car insurance.

Mum would not need to buy clothes or shoes very often. I rarely buy clothes or shoes and when I do I buy in charity shops or from ebay so very cheap.

Childrens clothes are cheap in places like Asda, Primark, charity shops.

House insurance is not very expensive. Mine is £10 a month for buildings and contents insurance.

People on low income get help with the cost of school lunches don't they? My neighbours do.

If there is no spare money the children can't go on day trips etc. Not great but many children do not go as their parents cannot afford it.

Food is one of the most expensive things but you can eat pretty well cheaply if you plan, don't waste food, shop in markets or cheaper shops.

DuvetHugger · 13/04/2022 12:33

houses are pretty cheap in Wales so doubt their mortgage can be that much

you are wrong

Angelswithflirtyfaces · 13/04/2022 12:27

Lovely to see people condemning her in case she has any luxuries or god forbid a basic sky package.
Maybe she should go to work come home and huddle under a blanket with candle?
Since when did we all sign up to live in Dickensian Britain again. She is a professional working woman I am pretty sure this is not the life she envisaged for herself having undergone years of training?
No one knows when our circumstances could change but people quibbling over a few treats is just shite.