Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Panorama( Young families Struggling)

413 replies

dottydodah · 12/04/2022 11:12

Did anyone see this last evening? A lady with 2 small DC and a husband working as a Research Scientist was struggling with bills .Another young Mum in tears as her energy bill was so high.A third lady (working as a Nurse) not able to run a car. How will they manage to keep going? Surely Govt could do more?

OP posts:
QueenCamilla · 14/04/2022 03:45

@Crikeyalmighty Spot on!

My rent is £760 pcm for a small 2 bed flat.
UC only covers £600 of that.

After paying just the rent, me and DC have £440 left for the bills, council tax, food...

I don't have Netflix. Haven't ordered a takeaway, well.. Never! I don't have a car (wouldn't be able to afford that), I don't go out for entertainment anywhere, I don't have a TV so I don't pay the TV licence, I don't have a broadband, my Internet comes from my phone but someone else pays the bill. I have no memberships, no insurances, no hobbies. I shop secondhand nearly exclusively (less so for DS, it's much more difficult to find charity shop clothes for him!). I don't have nail appointments and my hair gets trimmed for a tenner.
My family are abroad and I can't see how I'll be able to visit them any time soon (haven't for 3.5 years already).

It makes me very sad that with the recent increases I won't be able to afford the little treats either - some pumpkin seeds to add to my oatmeal, some smoked salmon to go with eggs, fresh berries, or even a long, hot bath just to relax in!

Hopefully I get top marks for trying to be poor!!

ringlightisnotflattering · 14/04/2022 00:27

@mydogisthebest Milk has went up in price. It used to be 98p for 4 pints in Asda pre pandemic. It's now £1.25 for 4 pints.

When you are disabled and living on benefits that have risen 3% this year total, whilst inflation is nearing 10% and gas and electric is up a staggering 54%, the you'll notice these increases.

These increases cause misery for a lot of people. In previous years I've saved £2 a week (yes, a week), to have a couple days camping once a year. That is now gone for this year. Sad Sad.

But I guess I'm lucky, some people will starve or freeze. At least as a female I have the option of selling my body if things get that bad. Sad Sad.

The race to the bottom is really alive and well on here!!

It would be telling if some on here had to actually try to live on the UC the Tories have brought in and the cuts and freezes. £70 a week for EVERYTHING after rent (and even worse if in private rent). Every bill. Even less if you have debts. My gas and electric and council tax is 60% of that alone. I spend £10 a week on food. I cannot even get a bus to visit my family 15 miles away. EVER.

Nospringchix · 13/04/2022 23:41

@lemmein

What a depressing thread. The biggest cost of living crisis in a generation and some posters are falling over themselves to blame these families for their shit circumstances.

This is why we'll never be rid of the Tories.

Yes, I find it depressing too. I despair at the lack of empathy some folk show.
Angelswithflirtyfaces · 13/04/2022 23:14

@Keepitonthedownlow yes I can truly see that. With that, hope goes and then it really is a slow sad spiral.
Bordering on discrimination really, as where is the equality, opportunities and chance to improve your lot in life?
We are developing an underclass by default, steathily. Very poor people will soon have no one to advocate for them. They will be too tired to protest themselves and the kids born into an underclass will never know any different.

Keepitonthedownlow · 13/04/2022 22:57

@Angelswithflirtyfaces

So much justification on this thread that this woman has brought it on herself. People here suggesting lentils and the like how do you know that this is already part of her diet? So poor people = junk food. What an absolute generalisation of her circumstances and others in the same difficult position. When you live in poverty, it is very hard to come out of that. It can become a life of payday loans and cardboard in shoes. The belt gets tighter, so the internet goes ( along with the lovely delivery of lentils and cauluflowers) No phone = harder for jobs, contact with other humans and opportunities to climb out of the misery inducing existence your life has become. You become tired, depressed, more likely to lose your job and your aspirations. What example are we even setting kids if despite working , a trip to the park watching other kids eat icecream while the mum tries to work out how 2 kids can share an ice cream cone. The kids start to think well mum works and look at our life, so there goes the motivation. Gang culture will explode. No one here thinks of the ramifications of a truly meagre existence longer term. Its not make do and mend, its make do then die. Watch mental health and suicides explode too.
Good description.

Remember lockdown? Imagine it's forever, because that's what poverty is like. Food shortages, no days out, no holidays, no meals out, no coffee shops, just relentless work and agonising claustrophobia.

Constantly juggling small financial transactions with no hope of improvement, living in fear of something breaking down or needing replaced, feeling shame and self recrimination because if you were more able in some way you could have been better off. Chastising yourself for your upbringing or health conditions that set you up for a more difficult path.

It's relentless.

Crikeyalmighty · 13/04/2022 22:34

I don’t actually think food is the issue, it’s possible to eat reasonably well for not ridiculous cost provided you have an idea of cooking and nutrition however a big issue is utilities and rent as these are fixed and can’t be varied. We need as a country to sort out the lack of proper affordable social housing relative to wages. To give an example when we lived in Bath- if you needed to claim housing benefit and were say a single mum with 2 very small kids or even 1 - the ‘allowable’ on a 2 bed house/flat is around £780 — the actual price in private rented is around £1100 to £1500 .—even if you moved somewhere a bit cheaper like Radstock around 5 miles away - allowable allowance goes down but the price is £860 to £1100 — whereas 2 bed housing association is around £640 and would be covered. We have so many people trying to supplement rent out of money that’s intended for food and bills. And if you work then in many cases you get no help at all so could easily end up with £1200 rent and £1800 income . It’s all very well saying move somewhere cheaper— itsnit that straight forward , requires up front money in quite hefty chunks and depends where your job is based— not all jobs are home based!!!

Cactuslove · 13/04/2022 22:17

[quote Angelswithflirtyfaces]@Cactuslove well when you start work please try not to better your station. Make sure you justify your netflix account with some handwringing while doffing your cap at the same time.
No fun for you either missus, make up any form of fashion will be severly frowned upon.
Practice squashing your face ( teaching your DC to do the same) against the windows of fancy shops like a Dickensian orphan sighing at all the things you used to afford.
In fact we all need to start learning how to look up with reverance to the richer and better as after all we brought it on ourselves didnt we?[/quote]
🤣🤣🤣 haha just snorted into my cup of water and bowl of lentils.

Also for other posters mentioning UC and that they pay 85% towards childcare. I only just qualify for UC. But they make it beyond difficult to get the money back which you have to pay up front to the child care provider. So on 31st March I paid nursery fees... UC pay me on the 14th April and they have given me nothing towards it... I've messaged them etc and now need to wait until 14th of May. So 6 weeks of that money gone... money that would have been used for groceries and petrol.

So it really is easy to judge... but you don't have all the answers- even when it looks like there's options often these are very difficult to access.

Angelswithflirtyfaces · 13/04/2022 22:06

@Cactuslove well when you start work please try not to better your station. Make sure you justify your netflix account with some handwringing while doffing your cap at the same time.
No fun for you either missus, make up any form of fashion will be severly frowned upon.
Practice squashing your face ( teaching your DC to do the same) against the windows of fancy shops like a Dickensian orphan sighing at all the things you used to afford.
In fact we all need to start learning how to look up with reverance to the richer and better as after all we brought it on ourselves didnt we?

Nospringchix · 13/04/2022 22:03

@Mojoj

Here's an idea. Stop bloody voting Tory. Whatever you think (or maybe you don't give it a thought), as a Scot, I'm sick to the back teeth of our vote (where the Tories will never succeed) meaning so little when the rest of the UK keeps voting in these useless eejits who exist on an entirely different plane from the rest of us.
I live in the North East of England and I feel the same. I really despair, and I'm ashamed to call myself English. My whole family feel the same.
Cactuslove · 13/04/2022 21:58

Some of the replies about the nurse is so annoying- it's just not as simple as working more hours and these posts highlight how the Tory Government get voted for. When my son starts school I will have to work my 24 hrs over 5 days... you know so that I can actually drop him off and pick him up. I can't afford after school clubs. I'm a professional woman, 2 degrees, paying a mortgage... my ex pays what is calculated he should. I have looked at this every which way and there is no way to earn more, to work more. But I know some posters will not like this as it is so much easier to blame the individual.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 13/04/2022 21:55

@Angelswithflirtyfaces

So much justification on this thread that this woman has brought it on herself. People here suggesting lentils and the like how do you know that this is already part of her diet? So poor people = junk food. What an absolute generalisation of her circumstances and others in the same difficult position. When you live in poverty, it is very hard to come out of that. It can become a life of payday loans and cardboard in shoes. The belt gets tighter, so the internet goes ( along with the lovely delivery of lentils and cauluflowers) No phone = harder for jobs, contact with other humans and opportunities to climb out of the misery inducing existence your life has become. You become tired, depressed, more likely to lose your job and your aspirations. What example are we even setting kids if despite working , a trip to the park watching other kids eat icecream while the mum tries to work out how 2 kids can share an ice cream cone. The kids start to think well mum works and look at our life, so there goes the motivation. Gang culture will explode. No one here thinks of the ramifications of a truly meagre existence longer term. Its not make do and mend, its make do then die. Watch mental health and suicides explode too.
So true!!! Well she’s only a nurse not an investment banker so why should she be able to take her child to a restaurant, or go on a day trip, she should work more hours!!!!
Angelswithflirtyfaces · 13/04/2022 21:33

So much justification on this thread that this woman has brought it on herself.
People here suggesting lentils and the like how do you know that this is already part of her diet?
So poor people = junk food. What an absolute generalisation of her circumstances and others in the same difficult position.
When you live in poverty, it is very hard to come out of that. It can become a life of payday loans and cardboard in shoes.
The belt gets tighter, so the internet goes ( along with the lovely delivery of lentils and cauluflowers)
No phone = harder for jobs, contact with other humans and opportunities to climb out of the misery inducing existence your life has become.
You become tired, depressed, more likely to lose your job and your aspirations.
What example are we even setting kids if despite working , a trip to the park watching other kids eat icecream while the mum tries to work out how 2 kids can share an ice cream cone.
The kids start to think well mum works and look at our life, so there goes the motivation. Gang culture will explode.
No one here thinks of the ramifications of a truly meagre existence longer term.
Its not make do and mend, its make do then die.
Watch mental health and suicides explode too.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 13/04/2022 18:26

@Blossomtoes

Bloody hell, that cauliflower’s like the MN chicken.
It really is- the M&S part tops off the ignorance too. These people aren’t struggling to cut back on the lobster and caviar- they already eat basic cheap food from the cheapest supermarket.
mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 18:13

@Blossomtoes

Bloody hell, that cauliflower’s like the MN chicken.
So a large cauliflower can't do 3 meals. I was stressing how big it was and only 85p to dispel the fallacy that all food is expensive
mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 18:12

[quote RedWingBoots]@mydogisthebest how much was the cheese and milk? How much did cost to cook the cauliflower cheese in the oven? How much did it cost to cook the dried lentils and dried chickpeas?

It's not just buying the food any more due to the rise in energy prices it is the cost of cooking it when you only have a few pounds left on your pre-payment meter.[/quote]
The cheese was not expensive. I never buy expensive cheese, only buy it when on offer. It was strong cheese so didn't need to use too much either.

Milk is dirt cheap, far too cheap in fact but then the farmers just get ripped off.

I didn't cook the cauliflower cheese in the oven - not sure why you would. I cooked the cauliflower, made a sauce and poured it over the cauliflower and then just browned it under the grill. Didn't take long at all.

The mother is obviously feeding her children some food so why not cheaper more nutritional food? She was using the oven so it doesn't seem like she can't afford to.

I soak chickpeas in bulk, cook and freeze. Lentils don't take long to cook especially red ones

mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 18:08

[quote RedWingBoots]@lemmein those having three children balance out those of us who only have one.

Even then there isn't enough young people to balance the old people who are living longer than before.

Oh and they probably had their children too young which is why they had three and I had mine too old which is why I had one Hmm[/quote]
Oh the rubbish about some having 3 children to balance out others. Why not trot out the garbage about how it's ok to have as many as you want because of more women choosing not to have any?

We need less people in this country not more - a hell of a lot less

Blossomtoes · 13/04/2022 18:07

Bloody hell, that cauliflower’s like the MN chicken.

mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 18:06

@lemmein

What has happened to this country? I can't even watch the news anymore, it just frustrates me.

The lack of empathy is astonishing, it really is.

I'll accept the excuses of 'global fuel prices' and now the war in Ukraine as reasons for children going hungry when the rich are impacted too - don't tell me nothing can be done when those at the top have become significantly richer in the last 12 years whilst those at the bottom have been crippled with austerity/covid/brexit. Seriously? Fuck off.^^ Poverty is a political choice.

Absolutely shameful that we accept this.

And whilst we're discussing whether the nurse was unreasonable not being able to predict the future when she had her third child - can we remember Boris Johnson abandons his sperm all over the fucking joint? His child-count is at least double that nurses - he's added (at least) two to his brood during the pandemic alone. Then he lectures everyone else about climate change Hmm seriously fuck fuck fuck off!!!

It's absolutely disgusting that Boris Johnson has so many children but what has he got to do with this?

It's not a matter of being able to predict the future when you decide how many children you have. Why not stop at 1 or 2? Just why not?

No one, absolutely no one know what the future hold and it is bloody obvious that the more children you have the harder it will be if something bad does happen.

RedWingBoots · 13/04/2022 18:05

@mydogisthebest how much was the cheese and milk? How much did cost to cook the cauliflower cheese in the oven? How much did it cost to cook the dried lentils and dried chickpeas?

It's not just buying the food any more due to the rise in energy prices it is the cost of cooking it when you only have a few pounds left on your pre-payment meter.

RedWingBoots · 13/04/2022 18:03

@lemmein those having three children balance out those of us who only have one.

Even then there isn't enough young people to balance the old people who are living longer than before.

Oh and they probably had their children too young which is why they had three and I had mine too old which is why I had one Hmm

mydogisthebest · 13/04/2022 18:01

@Eviebeans

What very sad, mean little lives we seem happy to think are okay. The cheapest food (not to mention lack of nutritional value) everything 2nd hand. No money to do sport or leisure activities. Cant afford to have friends round for tea. Not able to heat your home. Where's the joy in that? My god I must give myself a good shake - I think I'm going soft in my old age.
Some of the cheapest foods are things like lentils, chickpeas etc. Good for you and no way lacking in nutritional value.

There are tons of cheap meals you can make using those and they are all delicious. Far more delicious than most meat based meals.

Potatoes are cheap. A jacket potato with a 3 bean chilli or a lentil bolognaise is cheap, tasty and filling.

Veg is pretty cheap in most supermarkets. I got a very large cauliflower in M&S (of all places) for 85p last week. It wasn't reduced, that was the price. I have made cauliflower cheese with it, a cauliflower and spinach curry and still have some of it left.

RedWingBoots · 13/04/2022 17:59

[quote mydogisthebest]**@RedHelenB my next door neighbour is a nurse and she doesn't work 12 hour shifts so not all nurses do[/quote]
The fact this nurse can only work PT to afford childcare indicates she very likely does some form of shift work.

One of my SILs use to do shift work until her children got to secondary age simply because only then in her speciality were there jobs in the community that were basically 9-5.

In my SILs case she relied on her husband (my brother), paid for childcare and a friend who lived around the corner for regular childcare. In an emergency more people helped out including me.

desiringonlychild2022 · 13/04/2022 17:49

@mydogisthebest my MIL bulks buys without a car (uses a trolley) and managed to feed 4 kids despite earning below minimum wage on a single income. But she wouldn't be able to do it today in 2022 and would probably struggle to feed herself if she had to pay full market rent on even a studio apartment. Her mortgage on a
3 bed house in London is £300 (only reason why she has a mortgage is due to a divorce which meant she had to give 100k of the equity to her ex who never worked) and a big part of it is because she bought it in 1997 for 100k.. no young family can pay rent of only £300.

Blossomtoes · 13/04/2022 17:41

@lemmein

These threads are always took over by sanctimonious nobbers who preach to the poor how they should do poverty better.
Ain’t that the truth.
lemmein · 13/04/2022 17:40

These threads are always took over by sanctimonious nobbers who preach to the poor how they should do poverty better.