Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Panorama( Young families Struggling)

413 replies

dottydodah · 12/04/2022 11:12

Did anyone see this last evening? A lady with 2 small DC and a husband working as a Research Scientist was struggling with bills .Another young Mum in tears as her energy bill was so high.A third lady (working as a Nurse) not able to run a car. How will they manage to keep going? Surely Govt could do more?

OP posts:
mydogisthebest · 14/04/2022 11:52

[quote Angelswithflirtyfaces]@mydogisthebest Not sure you are reading the room here
People are desperate you twittering on about M&S ( you probably have shares in them the way you are banging on)
All the branches of that establishment are in town centres which a lot of people here simply cannot access or pay fuel parking charges.
Perhaps they could fuel up on cauliflower and lentils and fart their way there super speedy like. After all there is no fart like an M&S fart[/quote]
For a start not all M&S branches are in town centres. I was trying to make the point that if you buy things like a large cauliflower you can make at least a couple of meals out of it.

I DID NOT say that everyone should shop at M&S. I don't shop there all the time. I shop at Tesco, Lidl, Sainsburys, Morrisons, Asda, Home Bargains, B&M, M&S and, rarely, Waitrose. The only shop I don't use is Aldi because every single one I have ever tried to shop in has had the most disgusting display of fruit and veg and would be a complete waste of money.

mydogisthebest · 14/04/2022 11:47

@CharSiu

I had a year of being vegetarian not by choice as I was hard up, it was about 30 years ago and it was bloody miserable.

I hope the Father of the 3 three children whose Mum is a nurse saw that and felt thoroughly ashamed of himself.

DH started his career as a research fellow in science like the guy who lived in Wales. 25 years ago DH was on 19k. Those positions are now in the low 30k area. We rented a small but lovely house then and it was £100 per week. I have checked and a comparable house on the small estate is up for rent at £200 per week. DS nursery 20 years ago was £25 per day, my friend pays £50 now. The biggest expenses have doubled.

Housing crisis is out of control.

Not sure why being vegetarian was miserable. By far the majority of the meals are tastier than any meals with meat or fish.

Far more interesting and better for you

mydogisthebest · 14/04/2022 11:46

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

I would bet I spend less on food for me and DH than most people and we eat well. We just don't eat meat or fish people are allowed to want to give their children meat and fish ffs
When did I say people can't eat meat or fish? Stop reading things into my posts.

I said I bet we spend a lot less on food than most people. People can go without meat or fish for some meals surely?

OberthursGrizzledSkipper · 14/04/2022 11:44

@Eviebeans

The government should make tackling the situation regarding absent fathers a priority. I don't think that is the only situation where people are struggling though. Two people working full time should mean having a reasonable standard of living for themselves and their family.
Yes, I agree. The point is though on this programme not one of the families had 2 parents working full time.
mydogisthebest · 14/04/2022 11:42

@howtomoveforwards

House insurance is not very expensive. Mine is £10 a month for buildings and contents insurance

The cost of insurance depends on complex risk assessing by the insurance companies - living near the sea, close to a flood plain, in a high crime area, size of the property, age of the property etc all make a huge difference.

If you are down to £10 a month, I would hazard a guess you have no accident coverage and your contents insurance is at a bare minimum. I bet your excess is high as well which is great if you have the money to cover it but that’s not for everyone. You may well find there are huge restrictions on your policy - I pay considerably more but at the cheaper end of the range for my property but made careful calculations to ensure that if it burns down, it gets rebuilt and everything inside is replaced. But I was involved in a major flood as a child and from my parents perspective, have a clear understanding of what happens when you need to really claim on your insurance. I would hazard a guess a £120 a year policy just won’t cut it. Please have a very careful look at your policy.

I do have accident coverage and my contents insurance is far from a bare minimum. I actually think it is too high which I worry about as years ago when we were burgled the insurance company were funny about our cover being too high.

The excess is not high either. I certainly don't have the money to cover it.

I know exactly what my policy covers and I spent a long time making sure I got a good deal. Plus I got cashback on it

CharSiu · 14/04/2022 11:30

I had a year of being vegetarian not by choice as I was hard up, it was about 30 years ago and it was bloody miserable.

I hope the Father of the 3 three children whose Mum is a nurse saw that and felt thoroughly ashamed of himself.

DH started his career as a research fellow in science like the guy who lived in Wales. 25 years ago DH was on 19k. Those positions are now in the low 30k area. We rented a small but lovely house then and it was £100 per week. I have checked and a comparable house on the small estate is up for rent at £200 per week. DS nursery 20 years ago was £25 per day, my friend pays £50 now. The biggest expenses have doubled.

Housing crisis is out of control.

MissyB1 · 14/04/2022 11:03

people are allowed to want to give their children meat and fish
Apparently not if they are poor Hmm
Honestly the cheek of these poor people daring to get above themselves.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 14/04/2022 10:47

I would bet I spend less on food for me and DH than most people and we eat well. We just don't eat meat or fish people are allowed to want to give their children meat and fish ffs

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 14/04/2022 10:40

I would bet I spend less on food for me and DH than most people and we eat well. We just don't eat meat or fish.

Neither do I. And I've also used a single cauliflower (Ocado, ner ner) in three meals this week.

...because they were made up to reasonable portions with at least two other vegetables in each of them, plus pulses, plus a carb on the side, and made with a minimum of five spices. Spices which I have in my cupboard but cost around £2 each if you don't have full cupboards like, you know, a lot of people with a minimal shopping budget.

The meals also took at least 30 minutes on the hob and, in one case, a further 30 minutes in the oven. That's a lot of gas.

So stop embarrassing yourself and pipe down.

howtomoveforwards · 14/04/2022 09:59

House insurance is not very expensive. Mine is £10 a month for buildings and contents insurance

The cost of insurance depends on complex risk assessing by the insurance companies - living near the sea, close to a flood plain, in a high crime area, size of the property, age of the property etc all make a huge difference.

If you are down to £10 a month, I would hazard a guess you have no accident coverage and your contents insurance is at a bare minimum. I bet your excess is high as well which is great if you have the money to cover it but that’s not for everyone. You may well find there are huge restrictions on your policy - I pay considerably more but at the cheaper end of the range for my property but made careful calculations to ensure that if it burns down, it gets rebuilt and everything inside is replaced. But I was involved in a major flood as a child and from my parents perspective, have a clear understanding of what happens when you need to really claim on your insurance. I would hazard a guess a £120 a year policy just won’t cut it. Please have a very careful look at your policy.

Eviebeans · 14/04/2022 09:50

People are quite often so busy working/looking after their families that they have no time for traveling around to various shops to pick up bargains/see if there are reductions etc eating according to what is cheap.
I have had my time of doing that years ago (I'm old lol) luckily only for a relatively short time and it is joyless. Sometimes people just want to eat what they fancy and why not ...

Angelswithflirtyfaces · 14/04/2022 09:35

@mydogisthebest Not sure you are reading the room here
People are desperate you twittering on about M&S ( you probably have shares in them the way you are banging on)
All the branches of that establishment are in town centres which a lot of people here simply cannot access or pay fuel parking charges.
Perhaps they could fuel up on cauliflower and lentils and fart their way there super speedy like. After all there is no fart like an M&S fart

desiringonlychild2022 · 14/04/2022 09:23

@tfresh and the government debt. If they increase interest rates to crazy levels, that would affect th government debt which are at record levels.

Blossomtoes · 14/04/2022 09:19

@Blossomtoes

Oh put a sock in it. Your sanctimony and smugness are unbearable. As if having no money wasn’t bad enough without having your nose rubbed in it and being blamed for it.
@mydogisthebest - highly appropriate user name, by the way.
Blossomtoes · 14/04/2022 09:18

Oh put a sock in it. Your sanctimony and smugness are unbearable. As if having no money wasn’t bad enough without having your nose rubbed in it and being blamed for it.

tfresh · 14/04/2022 09:16

The ponzi scheme has gone on for so long, the government is now stuck and unable to do anything.

Inflation is currently 7%, with RPI being 9%.

The UK interest rate is 0.75%.

So we have inflation spinning out of control and rock bottom interest rates, to get inflation under control typically you would increase interest..

However, a large amount of people have large mortgages, cars, sofas, clothes, god knows what else on tic, so if you increase interest rates too much you screw all these people.

So the government can help more, by what? Giving more money out? Inflation is at 7%, if we increase monetary supply inflation will go up further.

The country is in a tough spot with no obvious way out, other than the pain. It's going to get a lot worse over the coming months and years. I'd expect to see huge changes to the benefits system, housing benefits, tax increases everywhere they can.

mydogisthebest · 14/04/2022 09:01

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

So not me being arrogant but you being ignorant in assuming M&S are always expensive someone on a budget- myself included- is not going to wander into M&S for a browse. And yes your weekly food shop will always be more expensive at M&S- if you can buy one item late in the day cheaper than saimsburys it’s completely irrelevant
Not sure what you are going on about with buying one item later in the day.

Do you think the item was reduced? Because it wasn't. M&S prices are not expensive on the whole and when they reduce items they really reduce them unlike Tesco, Morrisons etc that reduce by 20p.

Their fruit and veg is good quality unlike Aldi so false economy to buy at Aldi.

You can wander into M&S or not, I don't care. I also budget for food but when I am near M&S food I go in to see if there are reduced items and what they have on offer.

I would bet I spend less on food for me and DH than most people and we eat well. We just don't eat meat or fish.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 14/04/2022 08:51

So not me being arrogant but you being ignorant in assuming M&S are always expensive someone on a budget- myself included- is not going to wander into M&S for a browse. And yes your weekly food shop will always be more expensive at M&S- if you can buy one item late in the day cheaper than saimsburys it’s completely irrelevant

mydogisthebest · 14/04/2022 08:44

I also meant to say that food in this country has been very cheap for years. Far cheaper than most, if not all, of Europe.

mydogisthebest · 14/04/2022 08:43

[quote ringlightisnotflattering]@mydogisthebest Milk has went up in price. It used to be 98p for 4 pints in Asda pre pandemic. It's now £1.25 for 4 pints.

When you are disabled and living on benefits that have risen 3% this year total, whilst inflation is nearing 10% and gas and electric is up a staggering 54%, the you'll notice these increases.

These increases cause misery for a lot of people. In previous years I've saved £2 a week (yes, a week), to have a couple days camping once a year. That is now gone for this year. Sad Sad.

But I guess I'm lucky, some people will starve or freeze. At least as a female I have the option of selling my body if things get that bad. Sad Sad.

The race to the bottom is really alive and well on here!!

It would be telling if some on here had to actually try to live on the UC the Tories have brought in and the cuts and freezes. £70 a week for EVERYTHING after rent (and even worse if in private rent). Every bill. Even less if you have debts. My gas and electric and council tax is 60% of that alone. I spend £10 a week on food. I cannot even get a bus to visit my family 15 miles away. EVER.[/quote]
I think the gas, electric and fuel prices are awful. I have oil heating and the price has doubled.

Food though has to go up whether people like it or not. Farmers also need to earn and living and their rent, gas, electric have all gone up along with fuel for their tractors, feed for their livestock.

Farmers far too often get badly treated by the big supermarkets. It's about time they actually made money from milk instead of losing money

mydogisthebest · 14/04/2022 08:37

@OnlyFoolsnMothers It really is- the M&S part tops off the ignorance too. These people aren’t struggling to cut back on the lobster and caviar- they already eat basic cheap food from the cheapest supermarket.

I was pointing out (and thought it pretty obvious) that if I could get a very large cauliflower in M&S for 85p presumably you can get them at other supposedly cheaper supermarkets for less.

Although not sure that is true. A large one in Asda (a supposedly cheap shop) is £1.50. In Tesco they are £1.90. They might be cheaper in Lidl or Aldi although every Aldi I have ever been to has disgusting fruit and veg so a complete waste of money.

M&S is not always more expensive. A lot of their prices are the same as the main supermarkets and some are cheaper.

So not me being arrogant but you being ignorant in assuming M&S are always expensive

Cosmos123 · 14/04/2022 07:44

Terrible times ahead for too many.

While the top 1% encourage us to go to food banks and eat lentils.

Cosmos123 · 14/04/2022 07:39

[quote QueenCamilla]@Crikeyalmighty Spot on!

My rent is £760 pcm for a small 2 bed flat.
UC only covers £600 of that.

After paying just the rent, me and DC have £440 left for the bills, council tax, food...

I don't have Netflix. Haven't ordered a takeaway, well.. Never! I don't have a car (wouldn't be able to afford that), I don't go out for entertainment anywhere, I don't have a TV so I don't pay the TV licence, I don't have a broadband, my Internet comes from my phone but someone else pays the bill. I have no memberships, no insurances, no hobbies. I shop secondhand nearly exclusively (less so for DS, it's much more difficult to find charity shop clothes for him!). I don't have nail appointments and my hair gets trimmed for a tenner.
My family are abroad and I can't see how I'll be able to visit them any time soon (haven't for 3.5 years already).

It makes me very sad that with the recent increases I won't be able to afford the little treats either - some pumpkin seeds to add to my oatmeal, some smoked salmon to go with eggs, fresh berries, or even a long, hot bath just to relax in!

Hopefully I get top marks for trying to be poor!![/quote]
Top marks.
Reality for mostnow. Sadly.

SquirrelG · 14/04/2022 07:09

@mydogisthebest - oh give it a rest, please! Not everyone is as perfect as you are when it comes to having children, but you keep labouring the point and it is getting very boring. Maybe try and show some empathy instead of judging.

QueenCamilla · 14/04/2022 03:47

@ringlightisnotflattering I feel for you! It really is frighteningly crap, isn't it!