Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Panorama( Young families Struggling)

413 replies

dottydodah · 12/04/2022 11:12

Did anyone see this last evening? A lady with 2 small DC and a husband working as a Research Scientist was struggling with bills .Another young Mum in tears as her energy bill was so high.A third lady (working as a Nurse) not able to run a car. How will they manage to keep going? Surely Govt could do more?

OP posts:
DesidaCrick · 16/04/2022 12:10

Was not organic, just cheap. And they also sold treats such as dolly mixtures by weight as well!

krazykatzlady · 16/04/2022 12:09

Tofaen where the ecofood business was is one of the poorest areas of Wales. No surprise she gets no business... very bad idea to place her shop there. Free school meals are amongst the highest rate there, as is unemployment and poverty rates 🤦🏽‍♀️.
Research is everything.
I date say people locally are living out of the food bank nearby, not socking up on plastic free rice/pasta 😥.

DesidaCrick · 16/04/2022 12:09

I’m asking myself whether there’s a way she can at least minimize her losses. If she sold ordinary rice, lentils, nuts etc at affordable prices loose, would people go for it and would it make more money? We had a zero waste shop in our poverty stricken town in the 80s and it was extremely popular because people could buy just a small amount of an ingredient for one meal and it helped with budgeting.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 16/04/2022 12:04

Oops pressed send by accident.😬🙈🙄

It wasn't feasible to open that type of venture right now...

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 16/04/2022 12:03

@DesidaCrick

The zero waste shop business model might have made more sense financially a year ago when people had more money and the wholesale costs of basic foods were lower. She is probably signed up to a premises lease of a year or more so is just struggling along hoping to just cover costs until things improve. As for the commute, I suspect that the scientist works in Bristol or Bath and he commutes in from Wales, where property is much cheaper to buy.

I feel for all the people in the film. It’s hard to just work more, or just get a better job, or whatever, particularly if you’re not properly nourished and your mental health is fragile.

I agree but surely the business idea was foolish. Most businesses go bust within 1
DesidaCrick · 16/04/2022 11:37

The zero waste shop business model might have made more sense financially a year ago when people had more money and the wholesale costs of basic foods were lower.
She is probably signed up to a premises lease of a year or more so is just struggling along hoping to just cover costs until things improve. As for the commute, I suspect that the scientist works in Bristol or Bath and he commutes in from Wales, where property is much cheaper to buy.

I feel for all the people in the film. It’s hard to just work more, or just get a better job, or whatever, particularly if you’re not properly nourished and your mental health is fragile.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 16/04/2022 11:27

It's not a fault but a person needs to figure out a way to generate more income. That normally means overtime or a secondary income.

This idea that part time or a niche business set up in an area with no footfall or customers is nonsense.

Grantanow · 16/04/2022 11:17

Brexit - done! Pandemic - done and don't mention it. Energy bills - couldn't care less! Inflation - ha ha!

Blossomtoes · 16/04/2022 11:14

@Hrpuffnstuff1

NHS shift patterns can be brutal on family life. However I'm not sure about radiologists... They need an extended support network.
She’s not a radiologist, she’s a nurse who works in radiology. The Tory government has really done a number on some people over the last 12 years. It used to be that people who claimed out of work benefits got slated at every opportunity, now it’s escalated to people with jobs who can’t manage on a pittance but should just work more/harder because it’s all their fault they haven’t got enough money.

Some of you should really be ashamed of yourselves.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 16/04/2022 11:09

NHS shift patterns can be brutal on family life.
However I'm not sure about radiologists...
They need an extended support network.

Blossomtoes · 16/04/2022 11:04

@Blossomtoes

people who benefit most from conservatism would lose loads of money if the alternatives gained popular support

I’m not sure how you work that one out. Can you explain why?

Sorry - got it now. I need coffee!
Blossomtoes · 16/04/2022 11:04

people who benefit most from conservatism would lose loads of money if the alternatives gained popular support

I’m not sure how you work that one out. Can you explain why?

bumblingbovine49 · 16/04/2022 10:54

[quote RedWingBoots]@Babyroobs she said she couldn't afford childcare.

Even working 7-8 hours that are office hours doesn't cover school hours.[/quote]
Nurses usually have to work shifts, unless they work in very specific areas like district nursing or GP/ day surgery work. You often can't just way you won't work weekends or nightshifts and in any case those are the best paid shifts so if you can only work days your pay is lower

I've never understood how single parents of very young children can be nurses unless they have family to help with childcare on night shifts etc. I imagine paid overnight care must be astronomically expensive and way beyond the pay level of most nurses

DesidaCrick · 16/04/2022 10:51

@GreenNewDealNow

Conservatism doesn't seem to have solutions. I am confused as growing up, Conservatives promised that you will be OK if you work hard. It is very strange.
Yes, except it is not very strange, it is a con because people who benefit most from conservatism would lose loads of money if the alternatives gained popular support.
HotCrossTum · 16/04/2022 10:48

I've watched this and it's been stuck in my mind for a while. Normally we are more familiar with families on benefits that are struggling or when something happens and the benefits doesn't come through quickly enough but these were families with two working parents struggling except the nurse. Normally, the art gallery worker and the niche shop owner would use their money to pay for holidays, their own expenses/children's day trip expenses as just an extra income as this is what we are used to. We are literally f over for many reasons:

  1. we are f'd because one full time job isn't enough to cover shelter, food and heating and now even having a second job doesn't help.

  2. childcare is extortionate in this country and they want us to have a second job okay but provide nothing for childcare for the second parent to go into work until the child turns 2 and even that, the childcare hours doesn't cover full time work and when you are part time, you are still f'd over.

  3. No real crackdown over child maintenance. So many absent fathers who don't contribute to their offspring leaving the woman in a vulnerable position-unable to work due to point 2 and even if they do work, it goes on to point 1 where it's still not enough.

We are lacking shortage in skilled work and what kind of message are these leaders sending to the younger generation where a uni degree that costs thousands of pounds will only graduate you into a miserable life counting pennies.

That saying, we only have jobs that are a available in the service sector. I have friends who take part time jobs during the day and a few hours in the evening when the oh arrives to takeover bath time and bedtime for the kids. So part time receptionist job in the day until 1pm and from 6pm-10pm working at a local restaurant. Of course this isn't possible for single parents which goes back to how f'd up this whole thing is.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 16/04/2022 10:36

She's very very very frugal.
We've spent £90 this week to host us 4 and 7 other family members.🤣🤣

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 16/04/2022 10:17

@Hrpuffnstuff1

We're family of 4, we spend 50 on food. We have good incomes, but Dp is frugal to the nth degree. We shop at Aldi. She works a second job, sometimes we don't finish till 11pm...
We’re a family of 4- aldi shoppers, used to spend £70-£80 now £100 a wk- how the hell do you do £50 a wk I don’t buy alcohol- shampoos aren’t included-???
Hrpuffnstuff1 · 16/04/2022 10:10

We're family of 4, we spend 50 on food.
We have good incomes, but Dp is frugal to the nth degree.
We shop at Aldi.
She works a second job, sometimes we don't finish till 11pm...

Blondeshavemorefun · 16/04/2022 09:51

True about debts

Would have been helpful to see what she earnt

What bills she was paying out for do how much for water ct g&e internet phones food etx

And any debts or credit cards etx

I didn’t notice branded food

I understand some parents can’t afford to eat and their child 🥲 but equally a loaf of bread 50p and 4 tins of beans 89p so boring but equally filling beans on toast as a meal or 5

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 16/04/2022 09:39

@Lennybenny

I've just watched this... a few things struck me as I'm a single parent with kids. Firstly....one of the kids was eating Branded food before eating a meal, a nurse is on good money and she could work more hours but chooses to use a childminder. The self employed woman with her shop...she opened it 6 months ago in a time of financial uncertainty. If she's that stressed....work another job. Who works in an art gallery? Seriously if you're struggling get a full time job or work more hours. £75 a month going to £240....they weren't paying enough to start off with so that wasn't just the increases. There are a lot of options to help and I do think this show didn't really represent the right people.
Nail in the head. All the jobs apart from the radiologist were crap. The basic are, the families needed more income, arsing about in a niche shop and farting about in an art gallery aren't going to cut it. They all need either better paid jobs or extra income from secondary jobs.

The RS also needed to swap his car to a more fuel efficient one for his long commute. I also think some people need to learn how to cook properly. The teen-ager needs to look after the other two.
The boomers scoff because they've walked this path and there's no answer other than to work.

As for the food banks, charity, take it, it's free.

I have a friend single mum, during covid her business revenue fell, so she started as a health care, now covid has settled she's doing both as her clients have returned.

AutumnColours9 · 16/04/2022 09:24

[quote gogohm]@Blondeshavemorefun

I'm always left with more questions on these sorts of things - normally why isn't the father paying for the kids (and why have so many kids in some cases if your income is marginal) why they need x, y &z as essentials (when my kids never got these), why don't they work full time but the biggest elephant in the room is normally that the person has significant debts, I was watching a thing on channel 4 and they had a £390 a month debt repayment, I couldn't cope with that on our much higher income - I save up/buy second hand/go without and never borrow except the mortgage hence driving an older car, sitting on a 6 year old sofa from Ikea, even our sheets are old ones from Dp's ex wife, she gave him a pile when he moved out.

I'm a debt counsellor and never say anything to clients but spend sessions biting my lip especially session 2 when they admit to spending x between the sessions which are completely frivolous. I'm more and more convinced easy credit and feckless men not paying child support are the main reasons for poverty not wages per se [/quote]
I'm not sure I agree or that a few people coming to a debt service are representative. Poor people are often forced onto expensive credit. If life feels hopeless I certainly wouldn't begrudge someone buying something, even 'frivolous' which is subjective.

We seem to be back to the logic of deserving and undeserving poor (almost always the later). But surely these days everybody should be able to have a comfortable life and not just a meagre existence of basic survival without being judged.

AutumnColours9 · 16/04/2022 09:18

The Tories also don't seem to believe in relative poverty. This has many psychological effects especially on young people and life opportunities.

gogohm · 16/04/2022 07:39

@Blondeshavemorefun

I'm always left with more questions on these sorts of things - normally why isn't the father paying for the kids (and why have so many kids in some cases if your income is marginal) why they need x, y &z as essentials (when my kids never got these), why don't they work full time but the biggest elephant in the room is normally that the person has significant debts, I was watching a thing on channel 4 and they had a £390 a month debt repayment, I couldn't cope with that on our much higher income - I save up/buy second hand/go without and never borrow except the mortgage hence driving an older car, sitting on a 6 year old sofa from Ikea, even our sheets are old ones from Dp's ex wife, she gave him a pile when he moved out.

I'm a debt counsellor and never say anything to clients but spend sessions biting my lip especially session 2 when they admit to spending x between the sessions which are completely frivolous. I'm more and more convinced easy credit and feckless men not paying child support are the main reasons for poverty not wages per se

moimichme · 16/04/2022 07:29

This article is depressing and looks at the higher level effects rather than individual cases...thanks Tories:

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/apr/08/health-inequalities-uk-poverty-life-death

Dairymilk50 · 16/04/2022 07:07

For FSM you need to be on an extremely low income. Something like 600 a month maximum.*
Correct I googled this I was shocked that your salary had to be low to qualify.

If I was the nurse I would sell the house.. it's ridiculous because she's probably going to have to sell it in her old age to fund her care. The way she's struggling is extreme and its not fair on her kids.